Skip to main content
Loading video...

Jessica's Gloom of Kilforth Solo Review

Transcript 13:33

Hey everyone, I'm Jessica and today I want to talk about another one of my favorite solo games and that is Gloom of Kilforth. I think the subtitle is a fantasy quest game. Sounds about right. And the reason I like this one so much is that this is one about creating these sweeping tales of traveling across a land and sort of fighting back the gloom and having this ultimate storyline that sort of follows your character through this saga where they go through these different chapters and sort of explore everything leading up to this final battle with an ancient enemy. Now, I will note that this is not a cozy sort of adventure. There are some really nice sort of um moments I will say that are kind of like, oh, I got to see a wedding over here or I saved this kid um who was lost in the woods and I did that, but then there are also these really scary images of these demons and a lot of other things. So, just a note that this one does not feel cozy at all, but I enjoy the depth of storytelling that comes with it because a lot of what's going on is you're picking up these cards as rumors. So, in a lot of games, you will draw a card or you'll gain it in some form and that becomes part of your deck or you can use it immediately. this one, it's more like, hey, I heard about this quest over there, or I heard about this item that I can do in, you know, wherever, uh, and I

have to go actually travel to track it down, which sort of adds that storytelling element to it and creates this narrative where you sort of have those memories along the way of, oh yeah, I found it way up there in the Northwest or whatever, and I had to travel south across the mountains and the plains, and I finally found it here after this big battle. And that's why that item or that card has this memory or this little storyline attached to it that travels with my character through the game. This one is also fairly quick to play for me. Uh it's probably around an hour if I'm really pushing it, an hour and a half. And by pushing it, I mean taking it really slowly and creating stories as I go. The one thing that sometimes works, sometimes doesn't are dice rolls. This is very much based on rolling a bunch of dice and trying to get successes on them. You can have some cards that change that up, but that part of it I sort of weave into my storyline where failures sort of are part of whatever happened to my character. And it's a really really nice experience for me because I have these big sweeping tales and I get to remember what happened with each of my characters and hopefully they make it to the end and kind of get to save the world. It's a It's a nice thing to do and I love the adventures along the way and that whole idea of traveling through a character's personal saga and their own chapters to have that going on leading up to that big battle. Over the years, Kilforth has

expanded, so there's a whole family of them now. There's Gloom of Kilforth, which is this one. There's Shadows of Kilforth, and there is Call of Killforth. All of which I own. and I started playing those more often and found that I was not enjoying the system as much. Couple of reasons why. Gloom Killfor remains my favorite. I returned to that after not playing for a few years thinking that the newer ones were sort of that's what I remembered as the experience and that's not quite the case. Gloom of Kilforth is the simplest one in the series in terms of mechanics. There's not a lot going on in terms of other things you have to track. You're very focused on your character and there's a few things that affect the world. Obviously, you're going to put cards out that stay at some locations, but for the most part, there's not all this other tracking and you got to, you know, look at this and that and whatever. Shadows of Killfor added a few mechanics that I liked. Uh, namely that on all the cards, they typically have something at the bottom. Let's see if I can actually draw one. I have all my cards over here. I'm just trying to find out one that. So, here's one for instance. This is an ally card.

Normally, you will have a location that's just stated at the very bottom, and that's where that rumor came from. And going there, you can find the card, but it's always tied to the same one. With Shadows of Kilforth, you now have these random tokens that get assigned. So rather than having this specific location, it's the location on the board that is, you know, in row one, column 3 or whatever. There's a little indicator for it. So that adds a lot more variety, and I like that a lot. Shadows of Kilforth also added in some things where you're keeping track of allegiances and what's going on with a few other things. It didn't change things that much for me. Um, so it's not like I disliked Shadows of Kilworth. That one I think is it sort of works if you like the setting a little bit more. Um, but I found that the the original stays true to being simple and allowing for deep storytelling without all this other stuff going on and it looks really, really nice. Shadows of Kilforth also has a similar art style, but it starts to veer a little bit away from what you'll see in the original and I'll show you an example of this in a second.

So, between Gloom of Killilforth and Shadows of Kilforth, I think they're they're similar enough that, you know, you may prefer one over the other. And I don't think there's, you know, there's you're going to prefer what you prefer. I prefer Gloom of Kilforth. Um, but then if we take a step further to Call of Killforth, this one adds an ocean and it kind of adds more pirates and it actually adds ships that you add and you kind of have additional enemies that you can go after and everything and it it adds a lot more in terms of overhead. Um, and I I say this because I'm I'm coming up to the reason why I don't like Call of Killforth. It does make it more complicated, but and this is extremely subjective, I'm aware, the art style just did not work for me. Um, if it had stayed closer to Gloom of Kilforth, I think I would have liked it better. So, let me show what I what I mean here. And again, artwork and illustrations are very subjective. And this is nothing against any artists or decisions or art direction. Um, this is just to kind of explain why this one doesn't resonate with me as much as the original Gloom of Killilforth, which I love. Um, and that's a a hard that's a very hard bar to to reach. Um, but these are from So, these are a couple cards from the original uh original Gloom of Kilfor.

So, here's a noble woman. Kind of see like, you know, the the details of how how that artwork looks. And then just as another as a location, here's the unseen bridge. and you can kind of see the the scope of that and everything that's going on. Also, the other nice thing that I didn't mention before is all these cards, the ones you encounter, have little pieces of flavor text at the bottom that don't take a lot. You can ignore them, but they also kind of add to the story in some ways. You get like names of places or names of people and then you can kind of be like, "Oh, I wonder if I'll see that again." And every now and then you do get to connect those cards. So again, original Gloom of Kilforth, Call of Kilforth sort of has more of a I would say like realistic not ter in terms of you know there's it's very smooth sort of the the characters and then even the bigger um the bigger like locations or enemies or quests. This let me see if I can get that on the screen. It it feels flatter to me. It doesn't feel you know if I if we compare these two which are supposed to be like you know two big sort of areas and again it's hard to compare uh understandably. So, um, but then if we want to compare, you know, close-up characters, we have this one in Call of Kilforth and then again going back to her, just the I get it that this is

conveying a very different type of character, but just the way he looks is kind of and then let's just there's this one which we just saw, isn't Isn't that the same? I saw that and I was like, "Wait a second. What?" Um, and I I get it. I get it. There's There's neat cards. This again is all Call of Killforth, but the characters just look very flat to me and too perfect. Like here's here's another one. um you know just just the the face the facial expressions and everything are just kind of that I want this that that feels more like there there's a a character there. Um so again not trying to complain about art because everybody has their own preferences but that was just an example to show how the Kilforth games do not all have the same art style. And Gloom of Kilforth is my favorite remains my favorite. I played Call of Killforth for a bit and I I really struggled because I felt like I was taken out of my storytelling a bit because the art just wasn't quite working for me. Um, and I know it's really the mechanics, the that's what holds a game together. How it looks plays a role, but it's really how it, you know, the the mechanics of picking up cards and creating the stories that

way. But it was it was difficult for me. So, I have returned to just playing with Gloom of Kilforth with a couple of those elements that I mentioned from Shadows of Kilforth, especially adding some variety and randomness onto what cards are tied to different locations. That adds a lot without creating overhead. It's basically I just draw a token each time I draw a card and that is the location it's tied to. That has worked very well, very simple to implement without adding on all this overhead. And there's a ton of variety in this. That's what I love about Gloom of Killforth 2 is that even if you focus on one of these locations, you're not going to see all of those cards. And every now and then, I see a card I've never seen before. Partially because there's been a few expansions that have come out over the years, the smaller ones that sort of just add variety. Um, the other note that I will say is part of the reason why I continued to pick up additional Killforth titles was that I thought that I would be able to just mix all of the cards together. So, of course, yeah, let let's just mix all of Gloom of Killilforth and all of Shadows of Killforth together. The problem is that this is a keyword focused game. So, for your saga and the different chapters for your character, you're typically looking to collect a set of specific keywords, usually around three or four, to actually advance your character and go to the next chapter, which I enjoy. I like that you do have to sometimes sift

through a deck and mill through it a little bit and find ways to sort of hang out in some areas um to find them, but if you mix these decks together, it does not work. Um, it will, you know, you sort of get two different, excuse me, two different styles of how Gloom of Kilfor is sort of this high fantasy setting. Um, and Shadows of Kilforth is more of, how do I describe the setting? I don't even know what the setting. I don't even know exactly what the setting is, but it's very different. Um, while Call of Killforth is more pirates and ocean related. So, mixing all those together sometimes doesn't quite um match up with the story line. you get things that don't really match and don't really go together. Whereas each game on its own, those sets of cards do match up. You can create compelling storylines and narratives for your character based on what you're seeing. And you don't have to sort of reconcile in your mind, wait a second, why is this happening?

What? Hold on. That doesn't that that doesn't it doesn't fit in this setting. Um, so I continued to enjoy Gloom of Killforth. And I will say I actually thought that I was done with the Killforth series after I stuck with the newer ones for a while because those were not really working for me. So I kept giving them a chance thinking they're going to turn out. It's going to be like Gloom of Killilforth, isn't it? They did not turn out like that. But Gloom of Kilforth when I played that again, loved it. So, that one continues to be a favorite of mine. And just telling those stories and having my character sort of go through these different sagas and, you know, make it to the end and hopefully be able to defeat this big bad ancient is is a nice sort of experience. So, I will continue to play with the original. Call of Kilforth can just sit on its own in my collection.

So, that again is Gloom of Kilforth. Thanks so much for watching and I hope you get some great solo games to your table soon. Take care. Bye.

Progress saved