Skip to main content
Loading video...

Messina 1347 Review - Chairman of the Board

Transcript 22:10

hey everyone today i'm taking a look at messina 13 47 which is a one to four player euro strategy board game designed by vladimir suki and published by delicious games this one takes around an hour to two hours to play on average before i get into my review of messina 1347 i want to give a shout out to the show's sponsor kianda dot co dot uk who are my go-to online retailer in the uk so be sure to check out their great website and use my discount code in the show notes to get five percent off your first order okay so once set up messina is going to look like this where you have this main board here which is used to hold a lot of the different components so you've got three different types of workshops which you can acquire throughout the game the same applies to these upgraded quarantine houses and you've got two different wagons on display at all times as well on top of that you've got these three tracks which are going to be climbing throughout the game to give you upgrades and victory points as you go additionally the person at the end of the game with the most or the highest up on each of these tracks is gonna get 10 points second place seven points and third place three points this little part here shows the turn order each round and you've got a little round structure breakdown here as well where the game is going to play over six rounds and in some of those rounds the game rules are going to change very slightly you've also got the main map here of messina and this is completely modular and the layout does change depending on the player count where essentially you have these hexes and which are essentially your um worker placement spots to collect resources money and

climb tracks and things like that and you've also got these four docking stations put on these spots like this um additionally each player is going to have their own personal player board i think this main part is probably worth ignoring for now and i'll explain it later because it might look a little bit overwhelming we've also got these quarantine houses here which can come into play and you've also got this scroll track here where you have three different tracks you can climb up which will give you points based on different things you do throughout the games and then you've got the generic resources such as these flame tokens you've got wood and play cubes and these rat tokens as well and you also have money and you have all these different civilians that can come into play okay so each round of messina is going to follow quite a rigid structure but the first round works slightly differently i'm however normally starting from the second round the first player will be determined based on a certain criteria i.e in the second round the first play will be the person to climb the highest on this track here but once turnover is decided you're going to go to these boat tokens here and you're going to reveal the top one like so you can see this one is the one with the build icon and the double flame icon and then you're going to put the first boat on this stack here on that docking station which is going to be this one here and that's going to sail into port like this and it's also going to have one of these play cubes on them now one of the ideas of this game is that you're trying to basically completely eradicate these black play cubes because you are trying to fight the black death in this game and you're going to get rewarded for

doing so also in future rounds you may be adding tiles onto the map to expand your options however in the first round you do not do that so after you've done those two things you are going to use this little wheel here which is essentially a randomizer to determine how things are going to affect the main map of messina so you can see here that it's going to have a certain rat token on it or right icon this one showing the one who's um on his all fours and looking to the left and then a play cube is going to go on each of those matching symbols you can see here i've already put a black play cube on all the rats facing to the left now this is important because again you want to try and eradicate those um those black play cubes but additionally they can end up killing these civilians so after you've done that you're going to have a look at all the three different types of civilians and you're going to place one on each of the matching colors you can see here all these nun icons want to go on the orange spaces so again you can see i've done that here so all the nuns are on the orange spaces i've got all these nobles on these bluish spaces and all these workers on the white spaces so once you've done that bit of admin you're going to go into the main bulk of the game where you are going to be deploying your little workers on to the map so the first turn you can place your worker absolutely anywhere so let's just say i wanted to place it here like so now when you do that you are first going to have a look if there are any of these um tokens on them and you can see there is one here so i'll end up taking this

noble and i'll place it somewhere on my player board now when i do that i can put on any of these noble spaces again which i'll talk about the relevance of later but let's say i put it there like that now if i wanted to put a spot or collect a um token where there is a play cube then i have the option to basically eliminate that play queue by spending one of these fire tokens which is a a resource you can collect throughout the game and whenever you do that you are going to spend that fire token you're going to eliminate that play cube and then you're going to climb up on this reputation track so again another incentive for you to eliminate those black cubes because you can collect bonuses as you go such as money i'm climbing up the other tracks i'm guessing one of these overseer actions which i'll talk about later i'm getting victory points resources and the like additionally whenever you end up rescuing one of these civilians from a spot with a play keep on them they have to go into quarantine which is one of these spots on your player boards you have four of these spots and then you'll put that token onto the first bottom what this means is that they'll essentially stay in quarantine for two rounds so you go one round here and then the second round before you can get to utilize them so let's talk about what some of these spots offer so the first one here lets you flip over one of your already collected civilians to the other side like so to make it an upgraded version and what that means is that these are like an improved version which can go into better buildings which i'll explain shortly but also they'll start

generating you victory points at the end of each round you've also got these pretty obvious spots here which will give you flame tokens and wood tokens money tokens let you climb the relevant tracks um a double wood token there and you've also got one that looks like this which is a building spot now when you go to a building spot you have the option to build a different building so you've got these um workshops here which are going to cost you the resources listed on the left hand side so this one's going to cost you a coin and a wood token so let's just say i built that one by spending those resources and then i can add them to my personal player board like so however they are not occupied yet because you can see in order for me to occupy this building i need to have a noble or if i have an upgraded noble i am going to get the better reward and what this is going to do is going to generate the victory points at the end of each round so you can see if i got a normal one i'm going to get one point if i have an upgraded one i'm going to get one plus two points and these two different things such as getting you victory points getting you um resources getting you coins even getting you flame tokens another type of building you can buy is one of these upgraded quarantine houses so again just like normal you're going to spend the resources this one being a wood token and then you're going to put it on your personal playboard and overlap one of your existing buildings now this is a really cool mechanism where now your person who's in quarantine who would normally be completely unproductive is going to start working for you and i'm giving you resources just passively so this one's going to get generated a coin and a point at the end of each production

phase and the final type of building you can build are these wagons where again you'll pay the resources get the chunk of victory points on them and these will come into play later when you want to start repopulating the city of messina you can also see that this port here has a double flame token now these are really great to get rid of these play cubes because if you spend a flame cube let's say i went here and you can actually not only kill or destroy the play keep on this one but also one on an adjacent tile to climb two up that track and the final one we haven't touched on are these overseer markers so this one here is like a wild overseer you can see all the different ports have a different type of overseer markup on them as well and when you use that action you are going to choose the corresponding marker here and you're going to slide it down one of these pathways so this isn't a great example of doing it because i've only got one noble on this spot but i could move this one to here like so and activate one of the civilians on one of these spots connected to it so you can see here this one is going to allow me to flip over another civilian so maybe i'd want to upgrade this one like this and these offer a bunch of different bonuses such as giving you building actions letting you climb tracks get coins um let you climb up the scroll track to again invest in certain things at the end of the game and things like that so you've got a lot of options there also normally you cannot share a spot with someone else so the blue player could not go here um however the exception to that are these dock spots where any number of people can go there and when you do that you are going to have the option to

interact with one of these boats and get the reward on them such as these coins and as usual you can spend a flame to eradicate one of those cubes however if you ever choose not to eradicate one of those cubes you will acquire one of these rat tokens and the more rat tokens you acquire throughout the game is going to score you a hell of a lot of victory points based on a sliding scale now obviously in future rounds you are going to start populating this board here and from that point you cannot just choose and pick up things anywhere on the map you have to move to adjacent spaces so this one here this all this meeple here could essentially go to here if he wanted to for free but you could even go further than that by paying coins so for every additional hex you want to move you can pay a coin for let's also take a quick look at all these different tracks here and what they offer so this one here basically lets you take an overseer action of your choice can let you climb the tracks um of the other two and get you coins i'm getting you scroll actions this one here lets you unlock new meeple so you have more workers to work with um and these overseer tokens here let you flip your overseer markers to the other side to give you an upgraded action so you actually get two oversea actions when you activate that one so when you slide down these tracks here instead of activating just one from this region you can activate two and you can also see that when you meet certain spots like this from here it kind of encroaches on both areas of your you know your nuns and your nobles and you can choose either of them but if you have this double one you can choose two of one and one of the other you can also see here from this round structure that later in the game and you

might start putting two boats down on the docking stations and you might even put double play cubes down in one round and on top of that the play becomes even more potent in the fifth and sixth round where you have to spend two flame markers to destroy a single cube however when you do that you are going to get two victory points and in the last round um you do not put any play cubes down whatsoever and the final mechanism that i haven't talked about is to repopulate the city so if you've spent the resources to acquire one of these wagons you are going to have the option to repopulate the city so when you do that you as normal would go onto the spot um collect any civilians if they're maybe fight a plague but instead of taking this action you can forsake it in order to take this part up here where you will spend these resources i.e in this example a coin a nun and an upgraded worker in order to get this many victory points and when you do that you're going to flip your wagon over because you're going to have to spend one for each time you do this and you're also going to put one of your markers on that spot here to show that you played a part in kind of restoring that part of the city now that does mean that you secured these victory points at the end of the game but it also means if somebody else ends up going to your spot later in the game by going here you will generate two victory points and additionally if there is ever a play cube on that you're going to automatically generate one of these wrap tokens so it is a bit of a risk to do that so once everybody has exhausted all of their workers you're going to generate all your income from your upgraded quarantine houses from your upgraded

civilians and from your workshops in order to get all your different resources points etc and after that you're going to lay down all your workers to show that they are inactive and ready to be used again and additionally any civilian still alive with one of these play cubes on them is going to be removed from the game as they have been killed by the black death and that is essentially how you play messina 1347 after six rounds the person with the most picture points will be the winner okay so let's get into my thoughts on messina so i really enjoy this kind of worker movement system and i much prefer to a standard worker placement game i think this game would lose a lot of strategy if it was just the um you know the process of placing the worker wherever you wanted i love this degree of foresight and for planning and strategy that you need to bear in mind where you know this round i am going to go here with the idea of next round getting a free movement to go to here like so but you know if you do find yourself in a bit of a corner you can end up spending your money to skip further along the board but of course that's going to be quite efficient because you might want to use your money to do other things additionally you want to be quite careful about what you prioritize because the board is relatively tight and people are going to be competing for the same spaces so you want to prioritize what you think your opponent might go for so yeah a very nice tight board there with some good degree of player interaction and a big part of this game is the ability to chain actions together to get these kind of domino effect um actions

as is the case with a lot of vladimir suki game so i love this idea of maybe going to um you know or maybe using your flame to put out you know to put out a cube and then using that one to climb up this track here that that won't let you climb another track which let you climb this one here which will let you upgrade one of your overseer tokens and flipping it to the other side and then in a future turn you might want to move down here like this and actually all your different um civilians as a single action to get lots of bang for your buck so i love that kind of efficiency and timing puzzle where you want to make sure you have the resources in your kitty to make sure that when you do trigger these things um deliberately or not you have the option to fully utilize it so yeah there certainly is a lot of tinkering here and the ability to play out these big satisfying turns i also think this quarantine mechanism is absolutely genius you know if you end up rescuing one of these civilians from a you know from a safe spot here then you can use it straight away and put it straight on your board you know ready to utilize but if they had a cube on them you're gonna have to shove them in one of these houses which is annoying because it just it's just a waste of time however i love the way you can spend these resources to get these upgraded buildings to make sure they're productive when they're sat there doing nothing um really good idea thematic and it just works well for the game i also really enjoyed the variety of ways you can score points here because a lot of these work houses and upgraded civilians will give you kind of ticking points to generate you a slow trickle of points each round but that can really build up if you get these down on the board early but alternatively if you fall back on something like this and you you fall behind you might have to divert

your strategy and focus on maybe repopulating the city to get these big bursts of points rather than that slow and steady income so yeah i love the balance between the two and also this repopulation mechanism is great because you can get a huge chunk of points for doing so however you do have to give up the resources in the first place and i love that kind of tension of the turning point of when are you going to start repopulating uh the city because if you go too early then there's a good chance that more tokens are going to come out and you're going to start generating these rat tokens which are going to score you negative points um but additionally you want to go early to beat other people to the punch because there's some really chunky points available here such as this 19 spot here and you want to be the first to get that because that could be a huge swing of points so you might be you know you might be lured in to do that early or maybe earlier than you should do especially as some of these even require you to give up workers for the rest of the game so that's going to be quite a hefty decision and you might want to make sure that you're focusing on climbing this track to get backups for that i also think a great decision has been made here to introduce these level two workshops when it comes towards the end of the game and these level two buildings give you an instant reward rather than that steady income because the desire to take a slow income towards the end of the game is going to be pretty much non-existent whereas these are still really worth having such give you a big chunk of points giving you coins and we'll even let you climb up tracks really quickly now i will say something that seems to be a pattern in each of the games of messina that i've played is that these boat tokens get completely neglected and

just ignored now i'm not sure if that's just the kind of game as we are and it's um something that we're missing out on um i just didn't really feel the massive incentive or the urge to spend so many resources and time to come right to these extremities of the board in order to do these things now i understand that maybe if you invest your whole game in trying to collect those boat tokens and fully investing on this scroll track here then that might pay pretty huge dividends but that's just something i haven't really explored and it seems to be a again an ongoing pattern each time i play this i've also found that avoiding these rat tokens is actually pretty easy um yeah each time i've played this i've not collected a single rat token now maybe that is because i'm a really cautious player um and i would rather just you know completely not worry about that and have a concrete decision that i'm not going to take any rat tokens and maybe i'm missing a trick with that because taking one or two rap tokens is absolutely fine you're only going to lose a couple of points but having a whole chunk of them at the end is going to be pretty um catastrophic but i would have liked it to be a little bit tougher to get around um you know avoiding these rap tokens i also feel like the game has a fantastic game arc it's one of those games where for the first three rounds um it feels like you're not really getting much done and all of a sudden when you get to that halfway point it feels like things really start ramping up you're getting way much more done than you had before you've got more workshops down you've maybe got upgraded quarantined houses you've lined up a big move for your overseers so yeah things really do crescendo in this game and that also ties into the time investment and the game length for

mecena so i think if you are playing this at three or four players and you have you know people who want to min max everything and maybe take a bit longer to ponder over their turns rather than being instantly decisive then it does have the potential to run towards that two-hour game length however if you do have players who are relatively snappy and taking their turns and if you're playing two players this game is remarkably quick so i actually played this the other get of the day with only two players and we got this completed from start to finish in about 65 minutes which i thought was pretty damn impressive of a game of this magnitude there's a good degree of player interaction here as of course you are standing on each other's toes trying to get to the best spots and jumping there before your opponents get there i'm climbing the tracks to get the majorities here for the end game scoring um and even like winning in the different categories to be first player in all of the rounds i think the game scales well in general because you know the actual map is going to expand or contract based on the player count to keep things feeling tight um but yeah i think probably the best spot here is probably two or three players for me two players because it is so quick to resolve and three players because it adds a little bit more competition for the spots and adds a bit more life into the track climbing production wise the game is more than adequate i like the way everything looks nice clear precise symbology um no reason to go look in the rulebook to see what anything means or anything like that so yeah i'm very impressed with the symbology and the way everything's been produced and graphically designed and the physical production is absolutely

fine as you'd expect you know relatively um high quality tiles there they're not flimsy or anything like that and all your standard traditional euro components such as these wooden disks which which you do have to sticker up at the start and you've got your wooden cubes and all the different resources and things are absolutely fine um maybe these civilian tokens are a little bit small and fiddly but that is a bit of a nitpick okay so let's get in some final thoughts for messina 1347 and i have to say this is another big hit from vladimir suki for me um you know these last recent years i've really been diving into suki's games and they've all been kind of one hit after another just unanimously good and this is certainly another example of that i think this is certainly of that pedigree and quality of his other games and there's just so much to enjoy here i love the ability to pull off these big moves and you know this timing exercise to line things up just perfectly to get those big payoffs and just the tension of grabbing the spots that you want before the other people do and you know prioritizing things um accordingly so yeah and actually works surprisingly intuitively as well you know it's not a terribly complex game and i think you can tie things back to the theme quite you know quite organically so yeah a lot of fun to be had here if you have pretty players who don't mull over the decisions too much you can actually get this done and played pretty quickly as well and there's just lots of different routes you can go down points galore um i suppose one of the small issues i have with the game is the potential to have a runaway leader um especially if they end

up getting a lot of these ticking points early in the game and generating points before you have the chance to do so it can be quite difficult to make up ground for that um at least that's what i found and but i do understand that you can potentially get around that by being a bit more risky by repopulating these cities and getting those big chunks of points but again lots to explore here good track climbing um just good choices and consequences to your actions and it's a hell of a lot of fun with a theme that's relics bob which is a really interesting time um in history so yeah a big hit for me um i was really toying with how to grade this one um and i think i'm gonna give it pretty much the strongest shield of quality that i possibly can without giving it an elite shield but i definitely think there's room for improvement on this one i think it could climb even higher because it is that solid and it's up there with the best of suki games so that is messina 1347 certainly one of the best games of 2021.

Progress saved