War Chest: Discussion
Transcript
thank you some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome back to board games unlocked and Brad and I are doing the discussion of War chest now this is specifically the base game of war chest I know there's a few expansions out and there's currently one at this point in time on Kickstarter uh not sure what those bring I'm sure more factions and more units um but this is game that I've I've always seen at like Barnes and Noble and stuff and I always hear good things about but I was like War chess like like what is that and with aeg's Kickstarter thing about expansions it's on there with all of them and I'm like okay well let's see what it's about so I eventually looked it up and I'm like oh it's a chess like but it's not chess well I like that in other games when it's not chess uh like I mean onitama and then just other kind of asymmetric uh games um there are things of this game I like but there's other stuff I don't like and I think I think you and I completely agree on the stuff and probably we agree on the stuff that we don't like right and I don't know if you really like this game all that much uh so let's talk about um the positives because I feel like there's gonna be less of those uh my favorite thing about a lot of kind of
skirmish games that I do enjoy are the ones of tons of different powers like that are specific to you and in this game you're given quite a bit the game comes with a bunch of different chips of varying numbers you know five or four really uh and those go into your bag so it's not necessarily bad Builder I guess kind of yeah you are recruiting from your cards yeah so yeah uh but and they all have different abilities like the light Calvary when you use their token they can move two spaces The Swordsman he can attack and then move normally you can only do one or the other uh the the Marshall he can choose a friendly unit that is within two spaces of them then choose that unit to attack uh and there's um 16 no one two three four twenty sixteen or eighteen I can't remember exactly how many people were complaining online that the Berserker is overpowered I don't know what the Berserker does but yeah there's 16 but Berserker after the Berserker Maneuvers he may maneuver It Again by discarding a bolstered coin from the Berserker unit you may do this multiple times but you may not remove the final coin so essentially you could stack them up in this one massive unit moving around but yeah so that's that's something I really enjoy I like I I mean this game has little things of
from like I mean it has like memoir44 in the sense that you can only activate specific units the biggest thing that this gives me a reminder of which is not even close to the same vein a game but is Mythic battles Mythic battles is a massive miniature Skirmish game but you can activate units based off the cards you have in your hand instead of cards you have chips foreign that's the main positive I have that's like the variety the the replay like if you like this game there's a lot of replayability in this yeah box and then with all the expansions of course too you're gonna have tons of units and tons of stuff to do with it exactly and it's well produced it looks nice it's yeah it's easy to learn because it's pretty simple easy to learn very succinct in terms of just yeah whether it's very minimalistic uh I wouldn't I would never say this is thematic I think what your units do is kind of thematic like the Lancer or Marshall or stuff like that but and this game does have a pretty good kind of tactical head-to-head however it feels like it can come to a screeching halt it builds and it does well for the first half yeah and then it just slams yeah it just drops off to the point where the last several rounds of the game I was just pass pass yeah I'll use my boo my Bowman once pass yeah I'll take initiative anyway I hope you killed my
my unit the only unit I can activate Okay well that's pretty much the game uh and I know chess can have that obviously like if you use a lose enough important units and chess you're kind of like yo all right the one thing in chess and that is still a good player that you're playing against isn't going to let you do this but you can still with one Pawn get down to their end true and get a something back and get something back and I can't stop the tide you're right right I mean that the biggest thing with this game and we both said it was this this the Royal ship needs to be able to be a universal activation yeah I mean that that would be a big fix yeah because then I I mean you didn't you know if I had when I had this hand instead of just going initiative pass and play my Bowman I could move my Bowman attack with my Bowman yeah until the thing is actually gone yeah because when you have one chip for a unit they're they're useless it's a dead and that's what every one of these were just dead yeah dead units because but technically you still have a gym yeah but you can't do anything with it especially after you've recruited everything I'm okay yeah no exactly and I think that's really dumb because it's like whenever you attack and your units get attacked it's a game they're removed but there's no way to get them back and I find that extremely frustrating whenever it's like I mean yeah sure I make a dumb dumbass move I I bolster my
Cavalry of [ __ ] and then run into the middle of the battlefield and you just fire on them it's like well I deserve that uh but yeah just having one chip one light Cavalry chip being in my bag just every time it's basically like oh right that's cool well it's like these numbers of chips it's like I understand the number of chip but it's actually like you only have three of those units you only have three you only have four It's like because once you get down to that one there's nothing because all it does is oh okay now that's there just and I just puppy guarding and it's like I don't want a puppy guard I'd like to use my cool unit that has an ability but yeah the Royal coin being just a [ __ ] useless whatever because there's no way to like undeploy like there's nothing like hmm I don't like the positioning of my Calvary I don't want them to die like let's say I had two light Cavalry left uh one on the board one in my thing it's like huh I really don't want him to die I'll use my Royal coin to be like okay I'm pulling him back you know I mean pulling back could be like I'm gonna move him but you can't do that because all this thing does is face down actions which is gain initiative which you can only do if it's not yours recruit recruit eventually or pass or pass that's your three options it's mind-boggling why this isn't because it's only one like make it to where it's those things and activate a random unit whether to take control to attack or to
move or you use a tactic this needs to be like a universal like awesome coin because I mean let's say you don't have a lot of you that's getting attacked that's I mean I had uh 19. that's a lot of chips to cycle through eventually to get this back right uh yeah this is this is such a missed opportunity because the thing is also this game takes way too long because you have to get all your control markers out and when you're just piddly going yeah oh don't have any more crossbow men guess I can't take that from you until time to redraw okay I got it back now I get to take control oh you shot him okay I guess that's that even if it was bolstered and it's like uh and you kill him then it's like okay well I guess I can't do anything with him but if he had the Royal coin it's like okay I can still take control I think that's the thing I like about Chess over this it's just like I said when we were playing was that everything's on the board you know there's none of nothing to do with the bag yeah there's no activation craft you know what everything does you do it you know this one is trying to do that but then you still have the randomness of this and then there's that you know
there's the you know when you get to this point yeah you know like there's you're you're you have five chips in your bag and every single one of them does nothing except for getting initiative yeah that's so true and it's like if you have a rook upon a bishop and queen's all right your King's still out there you could you're still you can still do stuff yeah you know instead of it being happier yeah and I'm mind-boggling because I've been I was like I was Triple checking the rules I'm like you know this game is super simple like what are we missing why is this a 7.9 or an eight hi in a skirmish game because even in even in onitama you can have one [ __ ] unit and it's like he can do all of this right I can still win I'm not going to right right but I can still potentially win in this and that's perfect knowledge as well because in an asymmetric game like this you want to have perfect knowledge and if you're not going to have perfect knowledge to the needs to be I mean you can kind of be like oh what unit has a have they used because the face of actions are very limiting they eventually go away so then it's going to be a lot of face up so I can count and be like okay he has one Archer on the board he has two over there oh he has two chips left can he activate that Archer again no I killed one so he's out and that's the part I like but you never want to have dead turns
that's kind of why I moved to my Archer and into the fire zone at the end to get him killed because I thought I was hoping you had two chips because I was counting and I was like okay if you have two chips you'll kill it finish the game because I was just I mean yeah no I mean I couldn't move him at that I mean I was just I mean and I will say that like I don't think the abilities are unbalanced or anything because like I the the the uh team that I had I was like I went all in on light Cavalry and then they just got picked apart and I was like I might be [ __ ] and it wasn't until the very end of the game that I started using swordsman and then I started whittling down your units to kill and be like okay I'm gonna take it over so it does have you know the attack tactful nature it could have been just as easily this happening to you I mean it did yeah you know I mean I I have a feeling and I know none there can be people that are gonna that have played this game probably 500 times sleep with it and stuff but it's like I see this happening more times than not every game yeah before the locations get taken yeah that was the thing is I was also like oh yeah that's right you have to take you have to control all this you have to lose all your tokens it's not like it's gonna be like oh this is an anomaly like I feel like this is how it's gonna be you know like every like every game is going to end up being several dead turns just waiting for the
inevitable to happen yeah I mean unless we're some somehow missing a very crucial rule I I mean because again it's like chess in the sense that for the most part you lose a you lose your Bishop you're down one bishop and you lose both your Bishops they're all gone right but it's not like in chess where and I'm not even an advocate for chess I do not like chess because typically I feel like I'm not bad and then I play someone who has played for years and then they're like ah you're I've moved like my Pawn like two spaces and you're like oh you're doing the [ __ ] sock maneuver and I'm like what how do you know that like and it's like I'm gonna win in 30 turns cool you get you do you you do that you win I'm done uh but at least it's not like in chess where if you lose I killed one of your Bishops it's like sorry that one Bishop he can't do anything right you need the other Bishop to get the bishop to do something yeah it just felt weird that you have units in your bag but not anymore there's no mitigation there's no like oh you can spend two chips as a wild you know like Mythic battles I it's been a little bit but I believe it has something like that where it's like you can use three of one type of card as another card so yeah it's been years or two of another type of card I there are ways that it's like even if you don't draw and you're like I really would like to activate my God [ __ ] I didn't draw okay oh but I can use these to activate
him it burns my hand and I'm only getting two actions out of this but instead of four but yeah having just drawing and being like nothing nothing cool like it's kind of like what what are we doing like why why even bother and who knows maybe the expansions yeah they do uh I would love because I I want to like this game uh it has the makings of a game that would be up my alley a skirmish type type game where it's where what you're like your opponents can't really dick with you on like like you don't move your units and then hope you can do something you're drawing and then you're like these are the three I got [ __ ] I really wanted my pikemen get him what can I do with the two crossbowmen and The Swordsman I got I like that type of thing and that puzzle be like okay now what does he have what have I killed whether he had done face up was done face down uh enough of perfect information that clearly doesn't have it so I want to like it but I can't if if this is a lie if your unit number is is actually a lie uh because you're right it is theoretically just one less if you're if all of them happen to be killed so if those if there's any of the expansions that they're like oh no it actually gives you like the Grande
worker in video course oh no there is a token in the in the Nightfall expansion it astounds me that I because I looked through several pages of the forums before we start recording this there was no no complaining about anything like this so I don't know if maybe I'm maybe we're just dumb but I mean I feel like I play enough of these kinds of games that I'm I'm not bad at them so it's like am I just missing something no no because all the face up actions have to be you have to activate the the thing that you put face up otherwise it would just be cheating it would just be caught no man I'd swear I got my crossbowmen again and again yeah and again yep yeah so I mean please let me know in the comments like be like oh actually no you can do that it's not in the rules or if there's an updated rule book or if there's a variant I mean I guess theoretically you could easily just house rule this [ __ ] coin to be like a while yeah uh I can't imagine that would be too busted because because still even if I had when I had that out there if I was able to do that you'd still be able to activate extra stuff too I mean yeah and this would only come out of course when you get down to this bag you're able to you know you'll be pulling this one yeah not when you get down to the that's true but then it actually makes me like you put out your last Archer hoping to use them then it's like okay well I know I
need to kill him right exactly actually remove the entire unit from the board it'd be cool if I could deploy my light Cavalry even though he's my last one and hope you can't kill him and then use that to tactic and then run over here and and hope you still can't kill him for me to draw this back to be like okay now I'm gonna act you know control again so that's pretty much it that's all I got on on this game I mean the biggest positive like I said is the sheer amount of variety of units uh and a subsequent positive is it does have a kind of back and forth it felt close uh for a while but yeah once you start losing a lot of units and it just does become that move King back oh didn't Checkmate me move back it's like what are you doing you're gonna lose stop nope you have to Checkmate me I know you only have a pawn and you're Queen So eventually you'll get me but I'm just gonna drag this [ __ ] game out and I obviously don't do that um it this I guess this game when it comes through screeching halt you could just be like let's call it yeah all right but you never know I guess until really it becomes a pass pass pass oh okay you can't do anything and that's stupid that is that's really dumb uh yeah on a scale of one to ten what would you give War chest um I was one I was leaning towards you know the first half of the game because I
made the comment when we were playing that I still prefer chess yeah over this having all the units and they they are thematic and everything like that I probably would have went with like a six at that point yeah than the way the game ended and the way I feel like that's how the game is going to end every single freaking time yeah I can't go above five yeah I mean that I would be and that's pushing it yeah you know I I'd say five just to be generous yeah that's um that's honestly where I'm at too like I even though it's like I won this game that we we played but I'm like I mean that's not fun again whenever I win it especially a head-to-head game I wouldn't feel like I earned it and it's like there was a point where I switched tactics and that started working I was like oh okay now I now I feel like I'm starting to gain ground but it was like cool I have my pikemen puppy guarding yay that's not exciting in any way he's just there to get him out of my [ __ ] bag yeah and I wish this guy was a little more because like some some of the units I don't know what the other units do yeah but like some of these have a limit where you can't just I don't want to hear about your archers no and that one's not one I'm necessarily complaining yeah that makes sense but my Lancer you would think would be able to attack and do a basic attack too and his Advantage being the moving and attacking yeah because he can't do a basic attack at all he can only that was his restriction right he can only attack by moving one or two and then attack
instead of just right next to him but that's the thing it's like I like that these some of these have passives I don't like that some of them have tactics and and uh detriments to him right no I agree but then but this unit in particular like I had you know there's four chips so I could have I had a bolstered one so then I had two chips to activate so one I have to move away yeah and then be able to do the other one to attack but as soon as you did enough damage it was like I couldn't even attack with the guy yeah exactly you know because he he had to be moved I mean this game like yeah it does have good like you kind of pick what your what your opponent yeah favors um so I know this I was like okay where your archers are disgusting so I need to find some way to get up close to them and same with your Lancers like I I my units were meant to be up close except for one so I had to kind of just be up on your ass and be like yeah okay you you gotta move to attack you can't get you can't do it yeah uh and then your archers it was like uh you just pop them out and I had to run up to them and just buddy up to them and then you pop a scout down to kill the units I got a Jason it's like oh okay now I gotta get rid of your Scouts first and that's what war chess can bring that kind of like hmm how do I deal with your [ __ ] units because my units seem like they're dog [ __ ] but it's like honestly this is probably one of the most disparaging rankings that I could give it because I'm agreeing with you I'm giving it a five but if if someone comments and says you
missed a crucial rule oh yeah uh yada yada you can't have dead tokens that's one or if an expansion does do that wild kind of thing this could bump up to a seven or an eight oh I I would agree it would definitely go up higher yeah like like I mean maybe the six out of half because I still was hesitant on it to start with yeah but yeah that ending just yeah cemented it you know yeah no I mean I totally get it uh so as of right now it's a five but please prove me wrong I want to like this game I want to get the expansions and have a bunch of units and just shuffle them up and be like oh okay everyone get you know you get four or let's draft right uh but yeah nah nah not not enough not enough for me to be like yeah I'll play this over onitama I'll play this over Summoner Wars I'll play this over I don't know how to make the battles yet eventually hopefully I'll play this over Mythic battles um so yeah that's that's it everyone that's our thoughts on war chest let us know we think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful with every time of day that's true hey everyone thank you for watching and I really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever I upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other
run throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever I feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you