Skip to main content
Loading video...

Sprawlopolis Review | Pocket Board Games Series - Part One

Transcript 15:12

hi i'm not kate mckinnon and these are the best board games that fit in your pocket where are they where are the board games they're in my pocket so i read the news this morning and you're not going to believe it there's been a pandemic for the last six months anyway turns out i can't go out and sell the games that turn out to be what's the word larabee and i've already filled up not one but two calyxes in our new house first i thought let's use science to shrink down games but that just turned out to be a scam by some person called paula deming and then you thought why not have elaine write a song about it i mean how would that even help

them sometimes to the charity shop but they're growing and i wish i had more room for games there in my hand

i wish you know we could just buy less games the advantages of a board game that fits into your pocket are obvious first of all it fits in your pocket and that already makes me feel like a giant who has an entire universe tucked away in her waistcoat with tiny little people going about their day doing their laundry murdering each other it's great but the trick isn't just to find games that fit into your pocket because it's entirely possible that those games are a bit poo no what we want to do is not only find games that fit in your pocket but are also just as good if not better than some of the greatest games ever made when we originally planned this video it was just one video you know like a list but then we realized that we have so much to say about some of these that they easily deserve a video of their own and thus we welcome you to the very first episode of the pocket series a collection of six videos released over the course of six weeks all here to tell you how to fill the holes in your clothes with games audios that's welsh for board games let's start with some of the best the tiny board games have to

offer city building games are one of the most popular genres in board games in fact currently board game geek lists a whopping 1622 games in the city building category even though some of these listings are a little bit suspect and some fantastic games like suburbia quadropolis between two cities and le have stand amongst the representatives so if i told you that sprawl opposite a game composed entirely out of 18 cards a tiny rule book and a wallet to hold it all in is as good as any of those that would be tremendous right well it's not as good as any of those it's better than all of them i know what you're all thinking of course it's better than all of them but afka i hear you say can this game really fit into your pocket well let me demonstrate by tastefully cropping out my crotch that's the pocket part covered but now you say efka why is this game your favorite city building game well here's the thing all the other ones suburbia and so on they're perfectly fine games not just fine some of the greats but after i played sprolopolis i realized that none of them really carry the spirit of building a city but before we get into the poetics of this genre let's have elaine tell you the rules in

sprawl opolis one player will be dealt three cards and each other player will be dealt one card the player who has three cards goes first and plays one card which can only be laid horizontally then they pass the other two cards to a player on their left and draw a new card play continues until all cards have been played and that's the rules to sprawl opolis

alright there's a few more rules each card features four different types of neighborhoods factories businesses parks and houses in this cooperative game you're all building one city and you'll win if you reach the target score after all cards have been played building bigger neighborhoods is what scores you points the largest neighborhood of each type will score you one point per block in that neighborhood which is where you might ask me where's the game in that since each card always has four blocks and all four block types the maximum neighborhood size you can achieve is four that is until i tell you one final rule you can lay new cards on top of old cards demolishing entire neighborhoods and springing up new ones like an architecture wizard say hello to a city that you thought you knew because you built it but now it keeps changing all of the time and you have no idea what the hell is going on and that's cool but elaine you might say where's the challenge in that i can just lay cards on top of one another and build the biggest neighborhood ever and score all the points that's true until i tell you one final rule in this game each new road that you build will score you a negative point hey look at this park it's a big park sure would be nice if i could get it a little bit bigger more trees maybe a diseased pigeon i'll just add this card and now i'll score another point but i created two extra roads so in fact i'm scoring a negative point all of this might

already seem clever but elaine you might say what is the point of all these points how do we win how do we point well there's one final rule i need to tell you about at the start of the game before you dish out any of the cards you put the first three cards face down onto the table each of the game's 18 cards has a unique backside and a unique scoring condition for example this card will give you one point for each commercial block on the edge of your map and two points if that block is in a corner this card will count your longest row and longest column and give you one point for each block in that row and column but also each of these cards has a point total add your three point totals together and you get the score you need to beat to win the game i know i know you can tell that i'm hiding something else up my sleeve so i'll let you in on one final rule and that final rule is that friendship can overcome all adversity okay there is really one final rule and that is that you can't show your cards to any other players and you cannot place a card so it fully overlaps any other card but they don't really make the game much more interesting sprolopolis is a game of hubris it seems so simple for example if i place this card here i will create a single continuous road and that's only a single negative point at the end of the game which is great except there's still all these other cards i need to place and no matter

how i do it i'm i'm making more roads and with every card you play you realize that your simple plan becomes well sprawling each layer of a card is a layer of convolution you're juggling sizes of different neighborhoods you're connecting roads you're disconnecting roads you find the perfect spot to play a card for example look right here if i place this here i still only have a single road but now i realized that i just demolished another scoring objective and as you and your friends get lost in this urban landscaping nightmare you watch this thing you've created become an actual pulsating undulating monster that threatens to overtake every single neuron in your brain and that's before you even begin to consider the two cards you'll be passing over to the next player it's all well and good finding the perfect spot to lay a card but more often than not that perfect spot will turn out to be a death trap for someone else but hey you don't have to worry about that you've done your part and you can just sit there and pretend you're not noticing the murder daggers in their eyes but what pushes sprawlopolis over its city building siblings is that it does something that most games in this genre regretfully emit here we have glasgow an otherwise excellent representative of city builders that follows all the standard tropes you have a bunch of tiles representing different neighborhood types each score points for either being adjacent to another type or being in a certain place on the grid

or simply racking up numbers in the same type if you want to hear more about glasgow you should tune into our podcast where we cover that game but honestly just saying those mechanisms out loud make me realize how formulaic this genre is once a tile is placed it's set in stone which is just not what cities are like i remember trying to refilm the intro to the uk version of the office for a sketch and realizing that it's impossible because it's been 10 years since that intro was shot and not a single location looked even remotely similar that is why sprawlopolis is the only one of these games that makes me experience what a kick in the groin city planning is nothing is where you put it people keep messing with your grand vision and the entire thing feels like it's about to tilt 45 degrees and slide off into the ether all of that and just 18 cards and no compromise as the french say oof except of course there is a compromise let me tread very carefully here because i don't want to give you the impression that sprolopolis is somehow worse than big boy board games it's not it's just different once you shrink down to the pocket realm things get a little bit abstract the crunch we're used to in games takes on a more nebulous shape you're in a flat field of math that is at the same time pure but also hazy like a white fluffy cloud sometimes you think you'll have an obvious path for example if you get a scoring objective like the one we

mentioned before where you get one point for each block in your longest row and your longest column that's easy right just keep building cards like that and hope that you also match other scoring objectives but as the sprawl grows you realize that a you're creating a generally unpleasant amount of roads and b just stacking cards next to each other means you'll never score much for your largest zones because you pull out three random scoring objectives from a set of 18 there is enough variable puzzle here for you to play a game of sprolopolis every morning with your cup of coffee for a year and never run into the same situation it plays equally well if you're playing by yourself with a partner or a multitude of people and you don't have to perform any arcane rituals just to set the game up just break it out and go but with that absence of clear direction without the component ritual without setting yourself up to feel like you're about to play it's easy to remain unmoved by the challenge to enjoy sprolopolis you have to buy into sprolopolis and that's not a criticism that's just an observation for many of the games that we're going to cover in this series pocket games aren't magic they're not an infinite cake you can have and eat but it's a pretty good cake if you embrace it don't cuddle cake cool wasn't that good just the first video and we've already found a triumphant leader of an entire genre what next next we cover one

of the best party games that's built its marketing campaign on the premise of fitting into a pocket what could be more pocket board games than that a board game that was an actual pocket but that is a step too far the pocket series will return next week and i know i know you have to wait a whole week but don't worry because wait a minute what's that in your pocket oh that that skillshare the sponsor of this video skillshare offers thousands of inspiring classes on various topics like illustration photography cooking interior design or even board game design for less than ten dollars a month you can find helpful guides on almost any subject delivered to you by industry professionals my favorite part about skillshare is that classes are structured in an easy to follow plan so when i want to pick up a new skill like for example mastering the arcane arts of adobe after effects or finally being able to strum along when ellen plays guitar i don't have to dig through the annals of the internet the information is clearly laid out in a step-by-step process and look at me now that's a g no it's not oh joking aside ever since i went to vancouver two years ago and couldn't sleep because of jet lag wanted the pier at night and snapped this picture i wanted to get better at sunrise photography the outdoor photography class by chris burkhart helped me understand why that picture

worked why it didn't and what i could do to get better for a limited time you can use the link in the description of this video for a free trial to unlock your potential for just about anything you want to do all notepad included videos are only possible because of our patreon supporters they keep our lights on and make sure that we don't have to worry we can dig through the masses and masses of board games to highlight the best ones for you if you value our work and would like to support it we very much encourage you to become a patreon backer and there's a lot of rewards for you to choose from like exclusive monthly newsletters exclusive monthly audio logs this lovely print that backers already received and maybe even a personal shout out like jonathan foster whom i had a chance to talk to and had a delightful time learning more about him we'll see you again in a week's time for more board games that fit in your pocket wait a minute i don't have any pockets

Progress saved