Witch's Brew: My Favorite Mechanism
Transcript
Hey, I'm Jamie from Stonemaier Games and today I'm going to talk about my favorite mechanism in Witches Brew, which as I understand is a 2008 game from Alexander Pfister, which is a as I understand a precursor to Broom Service. If you played Broom Service, it's been a while since I've last played Broom Service. Um but it was neat to play this and and kind of remember some of those elements from Broom Service. So the idea in this game is that each player has I think 12 to 15 cards, character cards. They're all the same. Um all all unique cards, but each player character has the same hand of cards. You're going to choose five of them and simultaneously and secretly. And then one by one you are going to reveal those cards. So the the leading player might say, "I am playing the This is the German version you can see on the screen here, so I need to remember the names. I'm playing the Cutpurse. I'm playing the Cutpurse right now. I am the Cutpurse." And the next player, if they have the Cutpurse in their selection of five cards, they will put it into the play and then they will decide to say, "Actually no, I am the Cutpurse." Or they will say, Um oh, what is the exact term they said?
"So be it." I think you say, "So be it." And by doing so be it, they get kind of a lesser benefit. By declaring that they are actually the Cutpurse, um they will get that the the big ability for the Cutpurse unless someone follows them by saying, "Actually no, I am the Cutpurse." And so it leads to players really kind of paying attention to what other players are doing and how much they need and how many remaining cards they have in hand as you try to guess, "Am I the last Cutpurse? Or is there another player who has the Cutpurse? They must play it if they have it." And then they're going to probably declare that I'm the Cutpurse that they are the Cutpurse instead and I'm not going to get anything as a result. Because if you declare that I am the Cutpurse and someone else follows and says the same thing, uh you don't get anything. Now, this leads to some really interesting choices, both in terms of what you actually say when you play a card, so be it versus I am the blank.
But, it also leads to an interesting choice in terms of the player, even the last player who knows that no one is following, because if they say so be it, they get a benefit. They don't get maybe the biggest benefit, but they still get a benefit, and they don't lead. And if you're not leading, you have a much higher chance of getting exactly what you want on the card, whether it's so be it or whether it's the bigger benefit. Uh we kind of realized that the more we played in this We played in a five-player game, that uh that there were opportunities where you might say so be it, even if you know no one will follow with the name of the card. I thought that was really, really interesting. Um this also impacts, in interesting ways in my opinion, the idea of which card that you lead with. If you are the leader, you have a chance that everyone will follow and say so be it, and they'll be so worried that someone else uh will will say the name of the card, or maybe no one will have the card. Um and so you might just get to have the card. You If you If you were leading with the card, you don't get a choice. You have to say I am the cut person.
But, because there is a chance, especially early in the round, there's a very good chance that other players will have the card and will be declaring that they are that character when they play it, you might lead with a card that you don't really care about all that much. Yes, you selected it for your hand of five for that current round, but maybe you just don't need that benefit all that much. Um so, you're making that choice of which card to lead with, knowing that it you might be essentially ditching that card. You're not getting anything from it because other players are going to get something from it, versus saving cards for later in the round that you real really need, where you don't want to be leading, or you want to play it when other players have run out of cards, things like that. So, as you can tell from this fairly simple mechanism, um that is also found in the slightly different form in Broom Service, there's a lot of choices that you you make. It was one of those games where we were layering on these decisions, these choices the more we played. And the game also didn't outstay its welcome. It played I think in around 45 minutes for five players and that was almost exactly the right length for this this game. So yeah, Witch's Brew, really neat mechanism. I I had a great time with it and I'd love to hear your thoughts on the comments for this game and this mechanism or if you want to talk about Broom Service as well, either the differences or what makes that one stand out over Witch's Brew. I think it's much more popular than this game. Feel free to talk about that in the comments as well.
Thanks.