Rising Sun: Discussion
Transcript
viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome to the discussion for Rising Sun whoo okay this is a very stressful game I gotta say that no no no no it's not if you make it to the joke well I can see how it could no one betrays you like whenever you whenever you have in your mind that you're gonna win and then you're so that's why it's like man I'm doing really well right now so no one betrayed me because I'm doing really well you know Devin hates it yeah he did kind of get [ __ ] I think it [ __ ] you game tomorrow [ __ ] this round I did my own [ __ ] this game so man it's kind of hard - okay so we'll just we'll just safety net uh well start with things we don't like about the game the only thing I really don't like anything I really I really don't dislike anything about these games I uh I think maybe the only thing that I dislike is the fact like the hostage you can take a monster that just kind of doesn't like because it's like why have such a badass like dragon that's worth five force whenever someone can just take it as a hostage that doesn't really thumb Attica Lee make any or you wounded it so much to the point yes but I don't
know like what are you gonna do tying up in and give it you give it back oh I'm like acid Danny what oh no it's just that's probably like my only thematic dislike about this game other than that I I have no I have no complaints yeah I I could see a couple of mechanics that I may have like if I was a game designer done a little bit differently but other than that what are you watching you done like the harvest I I feel like just putting your people there to block somebody else from harvesting isn't really enough of a reward to do that I don't know how many points is like yet I got right you got probably got like half my points strictly from artisan well not right almost half I probably got like 27 some points from that it would be nice that a harvest was a global check to see who has control over a territory and who gets that resource I see where you're coming from but again that's such a minor thing it's I like the way the game plays I like everything about the game but I know that like I said I was the designer what do you think yeah I don't know I I like the fact that it gives more weight to the places you want to go to like it definitely adds more strategy and like the there is a game that we play called cry havoc where I was a race that spread out really quick so everyone bought me the entire time and I was like man it seems really weird
you guys were only going after me and then my friend was like yeah you played like that you spread out to where we only could fight you like oh yeah and that's kind of what I did here was that it felt like it was almost always a fight against me but that's because I was in the two spots and I gave victory points yeah for a harvest and look at hearing for different reasons alone what hearing for different reasons alone three of them at war so right right and that's that's just one of those things that it's not as prominent like I'm not gonna win a lot of battles because I'm only trying to stay here and harvest and hope that I get a harvest because that's the thing is like these aren't as prominent unless I get to harvest if anyone if no one halides with me I'd have to hope I got to play the tile to be able to even get the points other than that yeah it's a block I see where you're coming from though to be like well check and see if anyone has the highest but then that kind of takes away an ability of being allied with someone right yeah I understand that too so I mean Devin you seem to have the most gummy cat no I guess you're boiling up more worth would you not like about it so I the only thing that I don't like because I do like this game is I just don't want to play it so often cuz it's so stressful no just because there's only so many strategies that I'm gonna want to do and it's gonna be you know like I wouldn't play it next Thursday like I would see and that's fine it's just I'm
going through that yeah no that's that's actually fair um I would agree we I would agree with that for a different reason I would say that it's too stressful of a game to play all the time especially because it's so heavily negotiation you know now I have a dress like yeah you have to trust people and you have to be like even whenever you do Li with someone who has done nothing on game it's like [ __ ] you even if you're like hey please we do this action I really want to what the [ __ ] why well why be a lie then yeah um and then so you're trying to work with them but then at the end of the game in at the end of the day there's only one winner so at some point you're gonna be like you don't have to betray them but you can bug no I'm not gonna you know play the action that you need there's definitely a lot of yeah tension and I would say I mean yeah there's firm it's gonna be your same really route of strategy is I mean cap did something that I didn't even think of doing was just kill your people just for the short term yeah yeah yeah but I knew I wasn't gonna win and so I wasn't go see it's like it was a still like eat for them for the entire game up until like that last bit you had the lead and it's like oh my god cuz that's even then I didn't even realize the Imperial poets even though it's in bold says every figure killed I mean you can kill all your people with seppuku
and but can you still have to kill all of them but in some other place just try and win through Imperial poets it doesn't matter if you win the province yeah she could have put one figure in here play one coin on the periods and everyone who dies she gets the points for right I didn't even I I did that like once maybe yeah so that's a very good strategy that I didn't even realize was even a strategy it was more oh go for these yeah yeah what oh yeah no just me it's not a bad game I just don't think it's my type um you know see here there are you control strategy it's ever been let's do you guys I feel like your clan never came in to play yeah I did not like I was like meat son right is this 420 praise it that it seems like alright with the ones we played last time and then the Fox clan and the right plan and we say this and those are all part of the core correct Fox clan is not okay Fox nine came from the danio pledge which came from the Kickstarter but everyone else the Cloyd clan its koi a bonsai dragonfly turtle and I think that's it I think it's just those four and I just noticed that just at least with the Rising Sun dynasty invasion is that's
all looking moon and saying yeah it seems like they didn't care too much about balance of the abilities gotcha until dynasty invasion because his very much has a pretty rough balance to it mine is a little overpowered in this start but I found it to be a pretty big limiting factor waiting and you have eight provinces I do that you won almost every every battle you were in but at the same time this is self-controlling again only no matter what have a maximum of four with the exception of maybe like having Daniel bonuses or something like right I will never have more than four force in a single territory and it's definitely beatable but I had to really try and do a goiden strategy to make that work to my advantage and widget which I think it does I think that's more balanced than that one right and so yeah I do I think they didn't really care too much about balance until they did this expansion yeah because there's no limiting factor on your guyses it's harder to get like characters out it is really difficult and is that when so many years I couldn't contest you at all without my eyes and I can't summon monsters I had opportunities but I was looking for a lair victory right but I mean you can't win right I mean I didn't strong early game but then past that right this one was me mine was I mean Mike my strategy
was pretty much turtle was yeah was turtle and then hold up two spots and then harvest as much as possible and get my allies to harvest as much as possible and that's probably why I was the most stress this entire game because I was the one in the spots that don't [ __ ] take it for me and it's very nerve-wracking whenever it's like because I probably I got a lot of points because occasionally this one was like a war province once and this one was twice but it's like one time it's like you moved out you're like it's not a war province I don't care and I'm like oh I care harvest as much as possible right yeah leave me alone that's funny I did turtle uh and I'm and I'm the turtle clan I don't know I would I would disagree with the balance except for the Sun clan because how much you get you get steal wait I get extra cash yeah that's for every time I wonder like the Moon clan really [ __ ] me on that one right right I want to say that the Sun clan is also very good only if you get up high honor real quick it was until the very end whenever you skyrocketed because even then but yeah it is it is whenever each time you win a tie by honor that one yeah I wouldn't like that clan either cuz I think we then tie as often because the Moon clan came in yeah and I was and you haven't even walk you drew you happen to only at fight him so it's like if you had done for anyone else you die more
often I was hoping you all would get all distracted like hunting for those mid points I was hoping they'd give you a little more trouble yeah but and then that I could just kind of grab the flags on the edges right well cat did earlier like I was definitely hold up way over here like oh well [ __ ] cuz she killed herself and I was like man I could have used them somewhere else I know the real strangler was there that's true so exactly it was it was very good whereas in Kyoto and Kansai now what most people fought me for this one not for this one and so I would say that every single clan doesn't really have a drawback like yes you have a limit but I just know anything more of a limit on the stuff that came out of it at some point though everyone's ability you know has its limits though because my liner only my strongholds right there so count as one force half a time they didn't [ __ ] matter I just got to move them yeah that's that's really cool him will forget the Sun let's talk about the Fox clan he got to spread out anywhere he didn't have force so that's like three places and if you tie that in with harvesting is that but she runs out of bushi nobility and they're all spread oh yeah cat is hers is really good but only when she's when it's our turn to pick and then you're pretty much good almost anywhere because you put your Shinto just one Shinto up there yeah and you took it I pissed me off I think if you
put it in the region but you almost did you put them I couldn't ever be counted for two or no no he counted from what you could have asked but when you move to Merrill's I got [ __ ] because then I'd have to you know try hope I can recruit and put one up there which is less resources so the fact that they're worth to force and there are not a lot of places where you're gonna have high force for is a lot so if you could just stack one Eric 115 uh the only the only detriment on yours I would I would say is a lot more limits and easy you only have two figures in all the shrines like you couldn't but then again to force you just put one in region he doesn't get it unless he wants to put a Shinto up there and you do I excessive honor exactly pissed so so well no you would have won the time oh yeah see that's because it's worth - it's funny I think the only reason Europe clan I mean you know virtually sucked the entire time was because he fought him he broke every single tide just by placing one figure in an area you were at so I think they're still pretty good the koi clan [ __ ] hey I'm gonna get all the Rona oh it's also coins that I can use anywhere else oh no no yeah dragons what I'm saying I didn't really notice the balance concepts until right this right even though that it's not much balanced yeah there's a little bit of a balanced effort yeah BRR and a lot of balance effort there right that didn't really need the balance effort
yeah Dragonfly plan gets to move wherever when they marshal Banzai clan well their ability only matters when they're buying upgrades yeah so but I mean something like that with reijin and oh yeah you can easily you know I think I think with the commies they're very situational and they the way the commies layout they could be a lot of like very beneficial for certain plans and that's like because there was a like the bushi plan which he which he tried to get or the one that allowed you to play a bushi that's really good I mean you place it anywhere that's also really good for you because now you're no longer limited by your stronghold areas you're you can put them anywhere right I don't know I think that this game is extremely balanced but it's gonna be one of those things and here's another negative I have about it we've played this game with us for each time when you betray someone one time in one game yes it's a new game but you're not gonna trust them again like I tried thought I would trust Devin and you think betray immediately and I was like trying to freak out because I'm a cat don't you [ __ ] do it don't you [ __ ] betray me don't you do it did you pull you did the Devin man cry I was talking some mean I wasn't gonna betray you and I had this just like if it was me now I'm with you damn it so that's that is a negative is that the more you play this game with someone the negotiation kind of almost flies out the window because they who wants to a like
[ __ ] you who we all saw what you did to us but open-minded because no one ever we never traded coins we never made any promises it was just hey you want to ally okay it is but it's like good if you really want someone to to ally with you you've got a hey hey will you please ally with me so I can get the benefits for every action you take yeah what are you gonna give me you're in my [ __ ] territory move them out and it's like nothing's binding but it's like if you want to be honorable you don't want to betray too early but the game isn't that long either yeah so okay the second is when I did my first ya know a second round and now it's action Devon was begging her to do something and she's like I'm gonna try oh well okay but it was the best you can cry you should send me out you been this is mad I think every action of its you need to [ __ ] harvest in our reality that only helped me like I know in all reality should have been like [ __ ] you I know I mean I believe this Martin would have been know after the game I was fine I would have like packed it up or even like but it was been a really good move um so mechanic wise here's things that I love about this game this is this is not a long game either like for everything that comes in the box and you're engaged
the entire time you never like you [ __ ] it's been eight hours thing like I feel like is the very very strong area control game negotiation political area control game and you only play for what happened hour and a half
doesn't protect it to 90 minutes I thought so so oh no it was 90 I remember I remember that now 90 to 120 yeah so but I know like normally it's like a hundred twenty get ready for a three hour game exact so I think that it's very intense from the tea ceremony of being like who wants to ally then it's already pitting people against each other but I realized that the allies that we made we didn't keep like the for the game we play we were allied until like the very end we never do finally run with him and in cat and I allied this time it was me and you know me and Devin than me and you and me and cat right and then you stayed out of it here is a negative though I kind of wish that there was more of a benefit if you didn't have I was someone I guess for there don't my bet is that you a magic play betray and replace two figures that is true and you that's true yeah yeah I love the card drafting mechanic of this game it's different because it's it it is it is card drafting because it's like it's of me grabbing a hand like blood rage does this at the beginning of you trying you get a hand of cards you pick one for your clan you pass it it'll s so you're thinking I mean that has a different level of strategy because you're like what do I want Oh what don't I want you to get this one doesn't really do that but it is still drafting of like okay [ __ ] I was scared someone's gonna take away of the moneylender I was scared someone's gonna take the path of a server which was my shipping route which is the only reason I got as many provinces as I did because you guys moved a lot and and you move through
[ __ ] well I had to move one at a time I couldn't just put [ __ ] where I wanted it because I had to adhere to my lemon right right so it definitely benefit been gave you like six coins by myself yeah it gave me a lot and the fact is yeah you did die was like you totally through each fight and I'm like [ __ ] and you won the last one so I really like the cards I like how each of them are something different yeah if you want to be really good in battle if you want your clan to be upgraded if you want monsters or if you want end game scoring they're all none of them is like I don't really want that one right even then I have a lot I had nine cards and I mean I didn't feel like I was broken they don't that that felt broken was just cuz you guys happen to move a lot you guys could have been like oh we don't need to move and I'm like [ __ ] getting any money what do you thing about the card system I I do like it as well okay I'm just gonna quit asking you stuff you didn't like it you're gonna give it a zero out of ten I so the other thing that I want to talk about was the monsters obviously the monsters and the and also the lucky gods because they came in this game what you guys think of the monsters or sorry whether the cat what are you and don't think of the monsters cool I like them a lot mm-hmm I think they're very impactful yep yep I
don't think they're broken though no she only counts us to my console did a meal and a daimyo yeah and she didn't even really hate my turtle Canada's a Damian - yeah no I just felt that they were like a perfect amount of impact there was some that were maybe a little bit more impactful than others but only situational I think as well like but because before I had come I know only counts as a Shinto all right one thing I did notice though which is something I guess might be as a negative is they're impactful enough that if you don't have them you're most like you're here hurting and I mean because I have this game here she doesn't have any Danielle monsters monsters and I mean her point value is hurting because of it and then same with yeah I think yeah that's true they are most of them were all about adding force into an area exactly the the lucky gods lucky God right nothing about force they were a little bit more the turtle one yeah yeah so yeah I think if you're not gonna get any it's gonna be kind of painful but you can still do well without them right especially if you go for end games like hey get more points for you know virtues or for strongholds or or something like that also with the
cards is that what's really cool is that you're gonna get a different variety each time you play because there are different types we played with the like the horse back one last time you played it was the arch comes and that brings in different types there are six I think different sets of cards you're gonna have the same basic one same eight basic ones but you're gonna have like five more thrown in and if you want the my Kickstarter anyway it came with extra monsters for extra monsters that can be thrown in um another expansion that we haven't done is the call me it actually has call me miniatures that come in effect areas not go up there and pray I think you so go up there and pray but then they're they're miniature will go to an area and alternate the area con what the gods did in blunder age okay I didn't really care for that a whole lot in blood rage I thought that they were just kind of weird and more annoying but I haven't try them here so I can't but that is another possibility and it's another incentive to conflict to an area which might be really correct yeah there are probably some you place them there hey get five honor if you win this area or something like that I don't know right but it's like oh okay that put in if someone goes there you can put it in my Kyoto and make it [ __ ] it now everyone's gonna swarm there and rake it so people can't really turtle I don't know if that's the case but those are there as well um I really man ok combat that's another thing what you guys think of the combat I didn't like it's you know one good okay oh yeah weird to me
it's still a wallet like weird the first game and it still was the second game okay yeah it do you think gotcha okay so it doesn't we'll play on what cryotic does as well where it's not there's no dice rolling it's just you pick an action you want to do everyone has the same type of action and you can kind of like power like whoever has the most power on that action really right he wins it I think that's a completely different element of strategy which I really really like yeah because it's it's a mind game it's Who am I fighting oh that's number one well the one blow all my coins cuz I have I'm in 30 other fights right that's a crap if I do win I'm giving out my coins which is completely interesting then the losers if they lose still get compensation which weakens the person winning right I I don't know I think that's brilliant I would tend to agree with you it was definitely like it was a little bit easier having less resources coin wise but you know spending it elsewhere try see what the strategy was I guess it's a tendency for most people to play better on the defense and the offense right so like last game where I had just an ungodly amount of coins I had no idea what to do I probably lost a lot more right right it's it's very interesting I like the coin system as well because it counts you know you need money to be
able to upgrade your clan and get people but you also need money to win fights which is gonna get you points um yeah I I think this game is fantastic I highly highly recommend it I'm trying to think of really yeah I can't really think of anything else quality Oh quality of components it's it's C Mon games they've done a ton of other ones that their quality is always amazing their miniatures are fantastic paper it used to be cool mini or not I thought it was come on it's I mean it can be I think they go by C Mon that was come on hey come on come on buy this game yeah I'm back our Kickstarter hey get better stuff than everyone else yeah the art is fantastic they did you throw blood for Bashar yeah it's real good for training so no the art board just I don't know someone was like dis Luger was drawing in crayon oh no it looks like it was Japanese are you ignorant [ __ ] crown like just someone who is uncultured swine online Oh though I really like the art I think it's the Matic to the era I think it pops there's nothing like it what's that say you're like wait what what area am i in I don't know I could play this game I guess that that actually might be the only I guess other criticism that I'd have is that maybe the figures are just here to make you think it's a little hard to read sometimes I stand out whenever there's a lot of thinkers in an area and that's to be expected in
a way right but even let's say having just a single day me oh right here I can't write any of that right here but I mean you don't really need to because it's like that's the green area oh look there's the green area right here and there's the two and it's on - well is it being a little bit bigger that is true there's a I didn't get it but with the kicks are they came with a neoprene mat which you roll out and it's I think it's like 20% bigger but apparently it smells like ass someone was huh because it's me yeah someone was like what does it smell like fish another man I don't know anymore that harbored this is not like a generalization but like if I guess or whatever it's coming overseas yes I think it I think they do it a lot of like printing and stuff overseas so I know I think it's like a sweatshop travel - yeah I mean I bought a sweater one's a really cheap doesn't like factory and Jorge poster from and I sections the first thing I did was smell it to make sure it didn't smell right hidden under our couch oh I don't know I guess the one less thing I could say is the the action selection the way the turn orders work is based off honor I
really like the honor system too because it's very important a lot of the time there are a lot of times where I was looking and I was like oh yes two figures are [ __ ] I have four because higher honor than me so good yay you're not you're not you're not limited [ __ ] you you are but even then it's like high honor like gets you a lot but then you can betray a lot of people and be like hey all right that's fine I'm all discreet a lot of people over I don't know I think the honor system is really cool the action selection how it passes on from person to person and it broken up with commie so that's another thing we want to do is you want to go there to get those bonuses that's probably also what I did so well is I only went for reuse in this entire game it was to get I have a [ __ ] ton of upgrade I did that the very first round and I think you had them from everywhere yes yeah so it's just it's just really real everything just connects there's nothing that's like why the [ __ ] is that there right all the actions I think are extremely balanced and and then the Allies are what's gonna you know help you in this game so that's all I got anyone stuff anything scale one to ten I'm sorry you didn't just [ __ ] won here's a bad game you just didn't think it was for fun I think you were like blood rates a lot better it's strict combat don't worry land upgrade there's no negotiation if I like it don't worry
yeah imagine just fighting and big monsters that's it so 7.57 I would actually imma give it like a 9.5 yeah okay you and I preserve 10 for like the perfect game and this is it is really close like it could easily be a 10 if not for kind of something you said that I think if you play it a lot the strategy might get stale but even then the only thing that keeps it from being 10 is I know I can't run out and buy this because I that's a good point yeah it's a retail but here you're not gonna get these you're gonna get tokens right not gonna metal coins you'll have plastic you're gonna have token you know cardboard you're gonna have cardboard for these yeah that's actually a really good point the fact that this is Kickstarter the same game it works the exact same way but you're gonna feel like you're missing sites ready so that's that's a really good point actually for that reason I will drop it onto an island because even though I have it and it kick-starts for other people it's a big [ __ ] you hey cuz I that happen with blood rage like oh yeah I had the retail version and I was playing someone kept bringing it up oh you don't have this monster you don't yell like no I have the Kickstarter version now but yeah it's like you feel like you're missing something even though it's just extras it ain't working yeah yeah I have all you like all those monsters like it's like that this will eventually come out but you're gonna get tokens you're not
gonna get it just your it won't be as aesthetically pleasing right like right right so yeah so nine nine seven point five and seven fantastic game I let us know what you think in the comments below other than that like oh my chair and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you hey everyone thank you for watching and I really hope that you enjoyed the video if you want to support us you can go ahead and click that link to go to my patreon account if you have any suggestions you can go ahead and click the link in the show notes below the girl of my BoardGameGeek list other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful with every time of data is for you