Skip to main content
Loading video...

Etherstone - First Play Review

Transcript 10:52

Hi there. I'm Jonathan with Getting Games and these are my first play opinions for Etherstone. Now, what you're going to watch here was recorded live as an exclusive perk for the Patreon supporters of the channel and you can learn more about that as well as get access to the hundreds of other opinion segments that I've made by going to gettingames.com/support. Now, if you have thoughts about this game, then please leave those as comments down below. Also, if you enjoyed this video, then please click the like and subscribe buttons. Okay, let's jump into the game. Etherstone. This is a brand new game. It came out from Thundergri Games. It was a Kickstarter. It just um was fulfilled recently and I actually backed this game so I paid for it. Although I am super biased about this game. Uh first of all, I made a sponsored video for it. So I was paid to make a video uh for a prototype version of the game. And second of all, I wrote the rule book for this game and I did a bunch of proofing passes on this game. So keep that in mind as I now talk about the game and why I had fun playing it. Spoilers. So this is a game where you start off with drafting and then you play cards from your hand. So what that means is during setup you're going to be dealing out a hand of seven cards to each player from this big deck of cards and then you pull one card, pass it to the left, then get the next one, pull one card, pass it to the left. After this uh after you do it seven times, everyone has seven cards and those are the only cards you have for the entire game. Then you start playing the game and it's kind of a hand managementish put units out onto a map and fight sort of a thing, but you don't fight specific

people. So, we played a four-player game of this one. And let's talk about the actions that you do on your turn to start things off. When it's your turn, you choose one action from a bunch of options. And one of them is simple. You take a die from the middle of the table and you get two ether stones in that color. So, if I took this white dye, I'd get two ether stone tokens and take them from the supply and put them in front of me. And that's it. Another thing I could do on a future turn is I could play a card from my hand onto the table by spending the ether stone requirement that's shown in the top left. So, you know, recipe fulfillment kind of stuff. When you put these cards down, they do stuff. Sometimes they do stuff immediately. Sometimes it has ongoing effects. Uh, if we look over here in my photo example, I don't actually have any immediate effects, but as you can see, there's some ongoing effects here, ongoing effects there, other effects that activate in various points in the game. And again, putting a card down, that's one of your actions. You could look over here. Uh, yeah, you can't quite see it, but these lightning bolts are immediate effects that happen when you put the card down. So, you've crafted a hand of cards and the during setup and then you've drafted dice and you've put these things down. What do you actually do with them? Well, one of the things that you do with them is activate them by drafting dice. So, I already talked about the dice, but if we zoom back in again and look down here, this unit, the mountain smasher, which was very expensive, says, "Every time I draft a die with a value of four or five, every opponent loses two health."

So, this is a good segue into the fact that this is a at least arguably highly interactive game. There's a lot of punching back and forth, specifically punching people in the health. you are a leader and you have a little health dial that tracks how much health that you have. And there is no targeted attacks in this game. If you ever do an attack, it hits everyone around the table. So yeah, in that case, I am obviously motivated to try and take fours and fives so that I could punch my opponents. I could look down here and see that every time I take a five or a six, I'm going to get a victory point for every one of my units in play that are um not exhausted. So that means if I get a five, I'm going to get victory points for my unexhausted units in play. In this case, two of them. So, I get two victory points and then I punch everybody else to health. I want to draft fives. Like that's that's essentially the uh the short of that one. And of course, the five is hopefully going to have the ether stones that I need. I will say that every single card in the game has a wild cost and then a many of them have a specific cost. So, if you're drafting a five just for the five and it gives you two green ether stones that you don't care about, odds are good you could just use those as part of the wild cost to actually get cards down. Now, another thing that you can do is attack, but in this case, you attack neutral things. This is another action you can do on your turn. When you attack, you are going to be exhausting some of your units, and you can also use your own hero, and you will get the attack power in the bottom right corner, like here and here. And sometimes this can be modified. For example, this uh Chin Chin Chewy. The names are just bonkers, and the art is so cool in this

game. Um, it says, "When you attack, you get an extra attack value for every void card that you have in play. And this is a void card. Uh, so obviously it doesn't account for itself. But if you have other void cards, like I had, let's see, one, two other void cards in my hand. If I get these things down, then that's going to increase the attack power of my Chenui, which is great. Now, after you get that attack power, you're going to attack enemies that are kind of in a tableau over here. And this is straightforward. They have a certain amount of health. You need attack equal to that. If you don't have the attack equal to that, you cannot do this action. You have to do something else. So there's no randomness here. Uh if you send your hero, you're going to get punched. You're going to lose victory points. Then you're going to get various bonuses and then you're going to get victory points for that card at the end of the game. You then tilt all your cards over to show that they're exhausted. And there is ways to make them ready again. One of the main actions in the game is just ready all of your units. Now, I mentioned that there's a lot of interactivity, and I want to come back to the Chin Chin Chewy because this is where uh you can start to see some things that aren't just attacking. This one says it costs an extra uh ether stone for all players to cast any void cards that um as well as technology cards. So I put this down. I was like, "Hey, by the way, everybody else, if you have any technology in your hand, if you have any void cards in your hand, you have to spend an extra ether stone." And they're like, "What?" So again, a negative effect that's hitting everybody else. I also put albido down.

This is the first thing I did in the game. And it says all opponents when they put a unit into play, it starts exhausted. So that means they have to spend a turn to make it ready again. So, I'm slowing down the effectiveness of their units so that they are able to fight those monsters less often. So, again, a universal interactive thing. Do not play this game if you can't handle that. I guess the short way of saying it because this kind of stuff is happening constantly. Um, one of my opponents had a card that hit everybody that we lost points based off the number of cards we had in our hand. The more cards, the worse it was. And he put this down early. So, we were getting punched over and over again. And you may be wondering what happens when you get punched. Like why does it matter if you run out of health? Well, it's really simple. You lose victory points and a little bit of uh time. If your health goes down to zero, then you put this token onto the leader card and you are corrupted. And if you ever have a turn where you are corrupted, you can't do any action except the void packed where you take one of these tokens, you put it in front of you, and you reset your health. And that's your whole turn. So, it's almost like a skip a turn. And then the void packed is worth minus seven points at the end of the game, which is significant compared to how the scores actually panned out. So that's the rough idea about the game. I think I sprinkled a little bit of uh thoughts in there.

But when it comes to the actual play and like how it actually felt to play, I first of all was bewildered in the draft. Like the first time you played this game, it has some suggested starting hand that you can play with instead of drafting, but it also tells you there's some broken combos in there. So don't expect to have those amazing combos when you do those. We just did the draft and obviously I was trying to piece things together. You have leaders and I had a leader that said every one of my cards that had an even cost had a discount to the wild amount. So I tried to draft even cost cards. I think I only ended up getting three out of the seven which isn't great. I did not try very hard but then I I was able to draft towards that leader effect. You draw two leaders and choose one of them after the drafting so you can kind of work towards both of them. I really enjoyed that drafting even though it was a little bit bewildering u trying to piece these things together. Like obviously I got the Chin Chin Chewy which is stronger with void cards. So now I want to try and pick up more void cards so I can power that card up as well. You only have seven cards. So there's only so much like um uh bouncing off you can do within them. But you know like I said I had this card that said um I get a benefit when I draft a five and another one said I get a benefit when I draft a five. So that's also a really cool synergy that happens. I enjoyed the drafting and I enjoyed the card play. It was a little bit slower than I expected.

These cards are kind of expensive to get onto the board. Uh so you're going to be drafting a lot of dice in the early stages of the game. Um and you're going to start to get punched. I didn't really mind this because I knew that ultimately if my health hit zero, it's lose a turn, lose some victory points, move on. I ended the game with two corruption. So that's minus 14 points. And I came in second and it was pretty close. I think I only lost by a couple points. And the scores were like in the 30s, so like really low. Like I lost 14 points for that corruption, but I got so many other points for doing other things. These are victory point tokens that I was able to get by taking fives and activating points for all these unused uh uh units that I had. I really liked piecing all that together. I I like the puzzle of working through this hand that I had already drafted. And I could see this as being a game that works best in a group that is going to play it multiple times.

They could start to figure all that stuff out and figure out how these synergies work. I will say that we barely touched this deck. This is the deck of cards that we draft from. This is a four-player game, which is the maximum player count. And I think we used less than half of the cards, something like that. Yeah. So, there's a humongous variety of the options that you're going to have available to you. And, you know, one person commented like, "We're interacting a lot. Like, we're punching a like there's a lot of punching going on. There's a lot of negative effects." And it's like, yeah, well, maybe some games you're just going to happen to draw more cards into the draft that punch more. And maybe in some games there's very little of that based off of how these cards come out. Although, there's a lot of cards that are interactive. So, you're always going to have some interaction in every single game that you play, I think. So, yeah, I think it's not going to be for everybody because you're going to be getting interacted with quite a lot, but you also interact with your opponents, and that feels good as well. Uh, the person who won is was actually the player who didn't interact at all, but they had a really nice synergy and they were able to fight a bunch of these monsters and they just barely squeaked a victory. So, I don't think you can say, "Well, that means interacting is bad because the scores were so tight there at the end."

Uh, it just means I think there's lots of ways that you can play this. Also, there's a bunch of leaders and this is going to really change how you draft. Like I said, I could see this feeling very different every time you play, at least as far as the combos and stuff that you're putting together. Uh, it's also a surprisingly fast teach. I I covered most of the rules here. So, I I enjoyed it. I'm super biased, of course. Wrote the rule book, etc. Made the video, etc. But I liked the drafting. I I liked every element to this game. There was no part that really rubbed me wrong. Maybe that'll happen if I get this game played more, and I do want to get this game played more often. Uh, we'll just have to see when we get there.

Progress saved