Wingspan Board Game Review
Transcript
check this out in this new timeline where board games are suddenly gorgeous wingspan towers above the rest strutting its stuff like a linen textured peacock from the lovely wooden dice to the birdhouse dice tower to 170 unique and charmingly Illustrated bird cards to some sort of magical paper this rule book was made out of seriously what is this stuff it feels like it was made for the Queen and of course the oof there is the stones these nice plastic eggs that work as a resource but careful don't confuse them for a mini egg and accidentally eat them it's fine this one actually is a mini egg but you can't have any have to get your own artist Natalia Rojas Ana Maria Martinez her Emilio Beth Sobel and publisher Jamie Stegman should feel incredibly proud of themselves because wingspan is a marvel of boardgame beauty every little piece of this game comes alive and gently whispers come play with me let's take a look at the rules wingspan is an engine building card game fans of games like race for the Galaxy or terraforming Mars should feel right at home during the course of four rounds you unfold a player board that looks much like a menu at a Masonic Lodge and find yourself in a race for having the
best time watching Birds each round you can do one of four actions I think I'll have the ruddy duck please thank you the first and arguably most important thing that you can do is play a bird each card has a whole bunch of things going on first birds eat and you'll have to pay the right food to play it then each card also has an ability that either happens when you play it or activate it later in various ways there's a whole bunch of information like the type of nested roosts in its wingspan and so on that will be referenced by other abilities in the game and let's not forget the all-important victory points it will score at the end of the game finally each bird can be a forest bird a field bird or a water bird or even a mixture of the few or all of them giving you a choice in which row the bird is played a choice that turns out to be pretty important because these rows aren't just places for your feathery friends to hang out they are the other free actions and how powerful they are depends entirely on how many birds you've played into each row for example if you choose to do that take food action you'll get a choice of food from the bird house but if you've populated this row with birdies then your action transforms into take two or even free food accomplishing magnitudes more with a single endeavor ah how do I even choose if I focus on the bottom road then I'll be able to draw loads of cards but will struggle to find the food that I need to pay to play those cards
however if I focus on the middle row I'll be able to lay lots of eggs which are not only victory points at the end of the game but also can be spent as resources to power various abilities but if I haven't drawn any cards who's actually going to lay those eggs Oreo oh but my young plucky friend what really makes this game strut is that choosing either the take food lay egg or draw a card action lets you then activate each ability on each bird card in that row this is what wingspan becomes a classic representative of its genre of cards driven engine building games each card I play into my tableau becomes yet another cog in the machine and there's some expected combinatorial potential happening here let's say you've got a kill deer in your field bird row it's a cool bird that skip school and likes to steal an egg and if it does it'll draw you two cards which is all fine but if you manage to place a red-winged blackbird just before it a lovely specimen that enjoys reading books and walks on the beach you can tuck one of those stolen cards underneath it to lay that egg right back here's the thing every time I touch something under a card or place on top of it beat an egg or maybe even a worm that is a victory point at the end of the game so this happy little combo accident just netted me two points and an extra card and we'll keep on doing so every time I take
the lay an egg for a good friend action talking of which one of the things that wingspan does exceptionally well is not only represent each bird it features with mechanisms but also lets those like me who have developed a recent appreciation for these creatures that are all fowl learn about them through little tidbits gently printed at the bottom of the card first of all whoever named this bird originally is a genius but look it makes so much sense it's a vulture right so of course it has a mechanism that lets it feed whenever another predator bird succeeds on a hunt which is already cool but what a projectile vomits to defend itself I'd like three of those as pets please I did mention I recently started to appreciate the wonderful world of birds and that's all because of Jack last year he got trapped in our chimney for three days and when he eventually got out I nursed him back to health lived after him so the kites flying above our house didn't get to him until he was ready to take off you're not eating anything apart from banana but you really like banana there you go such a good boy so despite this videos talking quite silly I'd love to instill some appreciation for the winged world for those of you who haven't quite yet been bitten by the bug of I want to say orthodontist tree but as you can tell I'm not very well equipped to do that so
instead I ask for some help from the bogey world's premium bird expert Quintin Smith to lay down some bird facts taken away Quinn's Africa it's called ornithology and did you know that crows have a higher brain to body mass ratio than humans hmm we'll have more bird facts from Quinn's as we go along but for now back to combos a previous example was a great illustration of a potential combo but rarely will things play out so smooth there is a hundred and seventy different cards in this game and you won't start with men you'll draw five initially but you'll have to give up one resource out of your starting five for each one of these that you want to keep each time you draw a card you can pick one up from a display of three or draw blindly from a facedown deck this gives you a little mercy of choice but you'll still be beholden to the whims of fate which simply means that wingspan isn't a game where you'll pick a cohesive powerful strategy but will bounce like pinball from card to card trying to figure out which of these birds is oh no I was about to say which of these birds is hot but that's it's a very bad town with our British audience quick save me Quinn's did you know that eggs are really really
really really small houses Quinn's that was very silly I thought you were a bird expert I am a bird expert thank you very much I'd like to see you getting an egg you wouldn't be able to do it because they're they're small as I said in my my second bird facts when you said you knew a lot of bird facts how many is it that you actually know I know loads I know all well not all that would be ridiculous but I know like I mean Oh better question is how many facts don't I know because I've got just so many facts how many I know one fact of course Thank You Quinn's that got a little bit tense there which is only appropriate because this game Oh a little bit stressful not the kind of stressful where you and your friends will be at each other's throats but the kind of stressful way there's lots of things that you want to do but the reality of tight game design will just curb-stomp your expectations at the start of the game you'll have eight actions each a caring parent delivering but a tiny worm to you're starving beats as you grow the number of actions dwindles but by then you feel like you're ready to take on to the skies and soar the attention of your meager
resources will be in constant competition between the engine that you want to build the current round objectives which score additional points to the best performance and your secret objective handed out at the start of the game there's a lot to think about every time you sit down and play and the wild distribution of cards will ensure that you have a different experience which makes wingspan a game-like certainly appreciate but really sadly not one that I love let's take a look back at these cards they are loaded with information but whereas there's always one element that is dynamic so much of the rest of it is static the type of nest the bird roosts in the number of eggs you can put in it the number of points printed on it the type of food it eats its wingspan they're all technically things you should consider because somewhere in this game there is an effect that reference is one of these but so frequently they just end up being symbols that you'll shrug your shoulders and play the card anyway I wish wingspan had a more cohesive way of tying these elements together I mentioned games like race for the galaxy and terraforming Mars and in both of those even disparate tags have multiple ways to integrate with the strategy and also tell a narrative even if that narrative is wonky nonsense I could be a galactic rebel raising an army of resistance fighters or I could be an environmentalist focusing on supplying
Mars with top grade oxygen whereas in wingspan your strategies narrative is at best a collection of a certain type of bird for example predators but unless you have an end objective that directly references that type of bird strategically it's meaningless that doesn't mean you can't go a little funky with this game one of my friends for example played cards exclusively with the effect that let's eat our cards underneath them and only play them to the water bird row one that lets you draw more cards so he kept drawing and tucking each card scoring him a point until eventually his board resembled something like this he came second in case you're wondering and whilst it certainly amused this it felt less in the spirit of the game and more just an attempt to push the design towards its limits but the real problem for me is the variety of effects on these cards which feels to borrow a phrase from Bilbo thin like butter scraped over too much toast yes there are a hundred and seventy different cards but many of them are slight variations of the same card with maybe a different nest or a slightly different points value like those knockoff Nintendo cartridges you got in the 90s promising four games in one pack but you load it up and it's just the same game starting at different levels of course many engine building card games can be accused of this but it feels particularly prevalent in wingspan which is a shame because I think designer Elizabeth Hargrave has a very
competent design on her hands that feels just a touch shy from excellent if only more work went into developing unique effects into these cards I think it could have been my favorite engine building card game instead I have something died visually and conceptually a door but wish it didn't feel like it was d feathered thankfully there's already talks of an expansion hopefully adding a little bit more variety to this game and finally this play account the box boasts a whopping one to five and whilst I'm no expert at solo gaming I can safely say that at four or five this game is just too slow and I prefer it at a less crowded table which isn't to say that wingspan isn't enjoyable if you'd love to get yourself a pretty treat of an on earth illogical color right this time experience you could do far this gorgeous production and I think there's a case to be made that having a competent game with such lovely pieces is just good enough if you're still feeling tied up however I've prepared a list of handy recommendations that will hopefully help you make up your mind and perhaps even enhance the experience I recommend watching John's playthrough from John kids games that excellently illustrates the subtleties of gameplay and if you'd like to find out more about the production of wingspan I recommend this interview from a friend Ross from more games please with one of the artists the publisher and the designer
but if you're strictly looking for a great engine builder I think the classics will prove to be more engrossing experiences finally if you do decide getting this I recommend that you play with this website on your phone where if you enter the birds name it will play the sound that the bird makes like this one or this one
or this one thank you so very much for watching this review but MPI viewers I have an exciting announcement in just two weeks time no pun included we'll be launching our third kickstarted support another year of board game reviews but this time not just board game reviews there's something exciting coming along I don't want to spoil just yet you're gonna have to wait a couple of weeks to find out what it is but I didn't want to say thank you for watching us and supporting us throughout the last year you've enabled this crazy thing to become a reality but you also enabled these I hope you agree excellent board game reviews here's to another one