Skip to main content
Loading video...

The Crew Review - The Broken Meeple

Transcript 18:31

hey folks welcome to another broken Reaper review and today it's a short little game from cosmos called the crew the quest for Planet 9 why the subtitle of no idea but basically this was a weird one I mean I never heard of this game before it got mentioned to me I felt like what's this I've no idea what it is but suddenly I just heard nothing but buzz about it everybody went crazy as I the crew have you got the crew could have crewed my pocket to play it you want the crew and it's just like seriously but what's so great about this although to be fair cosmos game's small boxes that's already a pretty like yeah good bar set high type deal because cosmos make a lot of good little small box games but I just thought what on earth is this and so I didn't recognize like you know what the you know who the designer was and things I just fought ok tell me what is this crew about well it's a trick-taking game well not normally a theme I desperately go for but ok and then people were drawing comparisons to the mind double yeah suffice to say didn't sit well with me so I was like oh god you know what is this gonna be like you know is it gonna do the task well this is a trick-taking co-op game ok you pulled it back up a little bit for me there and the idea with this is that you are all trying to pass these missions and it's a campaign game enough that the campaign's people

seriously I mean a trick-taking campaign game come on but you can play them standalone so you don't have to do it in a warder of you know I think that's a gimmick just basically pick a mission based on difficulty rating go in it but the idea is is that each of you has to complete tricks in standard trick style so the whole play a card must follow the suit there's a couple of trumps in the few Trump's in there that will win the hand highest number wins the hand that kind of thing very basic trick taking rules but you have to complete certain elements in the game in order to win it's not just a case of oh we complete a bunch of tricks no people are gonna win tricks but as you go through the difficulty rating you have certain tasks to complete the task will usually require you to get a certain card in a trick so somebody must win a trick with the free of free blue and somebody must win a trick with yellow yellow 9 ok bus sounds pretty straightforward what's the big deal because it sets these restrictions and parameters on you such as you must do this one first and this one second and then this one third or you have to do this one before you do this one before you do this one or this one has to be last or this player must get it or you know you cannot do certain actions while you're trying to get this one it's there's lots of different restrictions that can put on you and as you go through the difficulty ratings it really put some other restrictions on you and there's a lot of tasks in general as you go through the difficulties but players pick a task before the game starts and it does it above the leader and goes in order so each player has different tasks

in front of them they are the ones that have to win their cards so it's like right so we got to work together to make certain that these players win these specific tricks again that doesn't sound too difficult why do they draw comparisons to the mind you can't speak oh yeah this is one of those silent games where you play cards in the tricks but you're not allowed to speak is this gonna be a repeat of the mind or could this actually win me over let's go into more detail so duration this is super super fast of a basic mission that the star can take you less than five minutes it's that fast you're talking maybe ten to fifteen to do some of the harder ones but again this is a very quick game the box cover says 20 minutes that's pretty accurate you know the hardest of difficulties including teaching the game would probably set you back half an hour tops absolute tops but to just get into it and teach new players and do like a semi easy one should take you no more than 20 minutes this is a very quick game it is a filler length through and through pick up and play it depends on your element on your experience or trick taking people who know how to do trick taking like I do we'll pick this up in no problem at all but if you're a brand new the trick taking and believe me I've played this with people who have never seen a trick-taking game in their it's not even Trump's yo they're gonna take a little bit longer to learn it and they have to sort of grass some of those concepts again simplest trick-taking rules here not anymore but yeah 20 minutes super fast can't

fault that at all ease of play as I was kind of saying if you're unfamiliar to trick-taking you should be able to pick this up quite well the rules in here are actually fairly well written I mean the rulebook is not particularly huge although mine got a little bit crumpled in the mail which is kind of wigs it was a sealed box not sure on product quality there but the robot looks bigger than it is well only half of this book is the actual rules so there's only about this much worth of rules and you know it is fairly text-heavy though that's the only thing there's some pictorial examples but for the most part it's text but it's pretty straightforward text it really is not that difficult a game to learn the reason the other half of the book is there is because it's a logbook for all the different missions it gives you some frankly pointless flavor text but then it goes into detail as to what like the tasks are we know what the restrictions are that kind of thing and so you can tick them off as you make attempts and basically track your campaign progress but yeah the game is not difficult to learn you should be able to pick this game up and read the through the rules in about 10 minutes 15 minutes max and at that point you should be pretty confident to teach the game too you know anywhere up to the 5 player account then it says on the Box pretty straightforward so tactics and strategy this is where it's going to be a make-or-break for some because yes it is a bit like the mind you can't speak so you know when you're playing the tricks you have to play the card and you can't make like you know you can't make

gestures or weird things or like I'll put down my five yellow it's a you know you can't do that so thinking like well how on earth does anybody know what they should be playing it you kind of have to figure it out from the cards themselves and that is where this actually elevates itself above the mind because in the mind it frankly just feels like guesswork and there's gonna be people out there who go on and make articles about the strategic brilliance of the mine come on guys no no but you know with that one he just feels random you know it's like I put down my 38 how on earth does anybody know that somebody else doesn't have the 39 if they've got the 40 they don't they can hover around for as long as they like but you don't truly know anything you know you can make a guess but most of that game is basically just guesswork it hate the mind don't get worked up don't get worked up but with this one because there's nine in the suit and any for trumps you can game the system a bit more with the cards have been played out being public information you can see what cards remain in the particular suit and that allows you to make decent educated guesses or educated ideas as to what cards you should think about playing particularly is the tasks that you are trying to get are public information as well on top of that there is a semi communication aspect where you are allowed to play a card from your hand face up for everyone to see I put a token on it to say whether it is your highest lowest or the only one that you

have and this is critical information you need this be curly if somebody has got the card that they need for the task not a recommended move but still you know the card that they need or card that's very important in their hand and to reveal it you only get to do it once each though so you got to be very sparing with it but this communication is key to working out some of the strategic elements to it and yet other than that not a lot of talking not a lot of interaction which is a bit of a problem but I like the fact that you can gain the system better than say the mind or the game even yeah this one just there were times where I'm thinking to myself I gotta play this card but hang on a minute why is he told me that you know or why didn't he tell me this and then you're looking at the rest of the cards thinking well a lot of the low ones have gone there's a good chance you haven't got a higher one to beat this one and I need to win this trick could I do it and you still get a bit of that tension of like do I do it do I not I'm the best of the game if I do because one failure and the game loses so you've got to get it right all the time and it just it's a very healthy amount of tension yeah I would have liked for more speech I would have liked there to be a bit more player interaction but this one just feels like you can actually work the system yeah that's gonna be occasions though where you get dealt a situation where you physically cannot win there's a bit of a bummer but at least once you realize that you just scrap and go again I mean yeah a lot of these higher difficulty ones you are gonna need multiple attempts because they are hard oh my god you want to challenge this is

a challenge I mean even some of the lower difficulties will hurt you and possibly beat you in some cases as you're learning the ropes and luck can just be a dick sometimes you know say like and just be paid so you have to accept this but oh no I like the tactical play in this you know you can't have a strategy per se but you can think on the fly and make these decisions in better ways particularly with those added bits of communication as well as knowing what tasks are coming up so all in all not bad for a 20-minute filler so aesthetics yeah I mean what do ya want it's a trick-taking game you've basically got a bunch of mini cards with the suits on it you've got the big cards with the suits on it and I'm glad although maybe they could have made it slightly bigger cards but never mind the artwork is decent enough it's colorful if you know it does the trick no pun intended but it's basically just a bunch of suit cards of different colors and they look nice enough but it's not exactly screaming artwork here I mean the planet on the back is nice and you know you say I'll take some color I'll take some effort but it's a trick-taking game it's simplistic you get a few little tokens and you know to mark the TAS and they're pretty basic they're pretty just to see components a tiny little standee for your you know cardboard standee for your like who's the leader but yes it's not much in the way of aesthetics I mean it comes into teaching little box like so and when I got my copy this was bent and crumpled

up like somebody had basically screwed up and thrown it in the bin and and strained again yet it was a shrink wrap box I wonder if anybody else had that problem but yeah it's it's fine it does the job but it's a trick-taking game were you really expecting it to look gorgeous immersion a theme again not a lot in this one I mean the theme is non-existent this hold the crew planet a nine and campaign that it tells you flavor text and to tell a semi story on the on the missions but frankly do you care it's a trick-taking game you are doing tricks with cards there is nothing in these tricks that means anything to do with space exploration you know it's not really going to make you think oh space me if I'm gonna make space ball references and stuff while I play this game no and it doesn't help that there is little to no interaction you know you're thinking about what the other players are doing which immerses you in it but that's more tactics that's immersing you in this not the theme and certainly not the player interaction because again you don't talk and as much as these games are popular with some people I'm okay with one person not talking you know the whole like mysterium thing of I am the ghost I can't talk but I'm still doing stuff and you know I can still wisecrack and still make comments but these games where you're not allowed to talk at all it's not really bringing out the atmosphere among the party group is it's not it's not like kind of bringing out joy it's more just we're all doing nothing silence mr. serious it doesn't go for me

on Java T this one should actually last you a good while actually because yes you can run through their campaign but frankly why would you unless you've got a dedicated group who's gonna play this religiously you're not gonna do the campaign you need like a group of four of you to play through 50 games and that's 50 if you succeed at them all some of these are gonna take you some attempts some of them I swear are damn near impossible but again challenge why not but yeah forget the whole thing about campaign mode just basically pick one you've got 50 different variations to pick from go in it granted the first 5 to 10 a kind of pointless certainly the first 5 are at site first mission you have two tasks that's it second mission yeah free tasks fourth mission you have two tasks and they must be done in one and two it's like really small increments here guys you know you really want to start getting to about 15 plus and then you get into some other like they're more meaty stuff but there's plenty of options here for you goes from three to five players the player scaling is a bit problematic here because it goes from three to five but five and even acknowledges this in the rulebook is expert mode like it is hard to win this with five players this really feels to me like a free and four player game I think it plays fantastically at free it but compared to the other pair accounts you know free just super fast there's enough discussion you got enough cards in your

hand to make some choices about do I throw this away do I have to I follow suit with this can I throw away a green here you know free players I just think works best for is still good but ups the difficulty a bit five is just too many I think it drags the game out a bit too long it just makes some of the scenarios like really hard if not impossible and frankly I think that the Richard you just put five on the Box because it's like no reason it can't do five let's just sell more copies cash grab as kind of the way it is it but they just didn't want to make this a free the four player game only interestingly they didn't put two player berry in here or solo mode that is different I'll give him that I was expecting this to be like a over that's a dummy player two player rule but no they just straight-up say doesn't do two players so sorry if you're a couple sucks to be you but I live alone so sucks let me mean really but no solo mode either in fact so three to five players I think this will give you for the money Bera minus costs you why 13 pounds tops to buy in the shops at the moment for a 20 minute filler it's got a good amount of replay value I mean I could even argue that this could have been in my teams for my recent top 10 high replay value video you get a decent amount of value in here if you're enjoying the game because you've got all those different variations and frankly you could just design your own just put some tacks out and just say I want to use all these tasks if there's not a mission here already for it then make one up

what does it matter you know go nuts I'd say so my final word on the crew is whereas it's not the most exciting game out there it should be commended for trying to take two mechanics corporation and trick-taking and merge them together into something that is never been done before truly an innovative design this one I think over regular group players who will be able to play through the campaign in its full entirety for others particularly those who weren't a fan of the mind maybe this won't necessarily swing you over but for its cheap cost and cheap tightening you know short time on the table why have you got to lose so the crew for me gets a decent seven out of ten you know I would actually play this I will not touch the mind with a bargepole I will not touch the game with a bargepole but I would play this you know I might even hang on to it for a while actually because it's a small little game and I can teach this to pretty much anybody who knows about trick-taking games I in prime very impressed I'll admit with the whole co-op meat trick taking not something that's been done again the merging of old mechanics into something with a twist it's pretty decent I don't think this quite needs the massive buzz that it's got I mean people are like holding this like they hold in the mine like I mean if I start seeing this on like top filler game of the year or something I'll be like really but though I think this is going to impress other people and cosmos puts out regularly puts out decent little box games like this so I'd say if you're tempted by it give it a try and see what

you think but of course you need to be into trick-taking and you need to be into coops and also the whole thing about being silent you know those three things you need to consider and that will hopefully tell you whether this is the game for you so I'm gonna sign off on my own little space mission and if you like what you see please subscribe to the channel the patreon thing the dawn ring the bell whatever you want to phrase it as so find me on Facebook Twitter and Instagram please share this video on social media if you can get the word out there that the review exists I very much appreciate it so that's it for me I'll see you on the next broken people video and regardless of whether trick-taking sure thing coops your Thane or whether the mind drove you insane it's still only a game take care and

Progress saved