Pergola Board Game Review
Transcript
Grow plants, gather insects, and make your garden look beautiful in pergola.
Welcome to Tantrum House Studio D. I'm Melissa Delp.
And I'm Kevin Delp. Pergola is a competitive action selection game for one to four players that takes about an hour to play. It's published by Rebel Studio and distributed by Asthma. They sent us this copy to review.
After we give a brief overview of the gameplay, we'll divide this video into our four C's. The components, our critiques, our commendations, and finally, our conclusions.
Here's a quick overview. Pergola is played over 15 rounds. In a given round, each player will take one turn gathering items and taking an action. You'll be getting different kinds of plants like magnolia and buttercups and different types of insects like butterflies and bumblebees. Your garden will score at the end of the game from all the things you've collected.
Here's the game in a little bit more detail. On your turn, you'll choose one of the four tools available in the market. The tools show two things that you'll get from the supply and place in your garden. These insects and flowers will score in different ways at the end of the game. And each player has a reference board that shows how everything scores.
After you place your items, you take the corresponding action from where you took the tool. Here's a look at the four actions. The frog lets you move your frog from one lily pad to an adjacent one, either gaining you an insect or if you've completed the goal, a dragonfly. Another action is water movement. You'll advance one of your water droplets down your cascade board. gaining an insect. If your water droplet reaches the bottom of the board, you'll unlock an additional endgame scoring bonus.
Another action is the bird flight action. You gain a leaf that gives you a benefit. And the last available action is the insect flutter action. This allows you to move insects onto different flowers around your garden.
The tools slide down and replace before the next player's turn. After completing 15 rounds, your tool pot will be full and the game ends. Players count up their points and see who wins.
All right, let's move to our review with the first of the four C's, the components. So, there's a lot of wooden bits with the insects and the flowers. I think they all work pretty well and I think they have a nice shape to them. They all fit in that tray really nicely. And the top of the box in the back has a like how everything everything fits back in the box. And I like it when games do that.
Yes.
Very helpful to organize everything and know how to lay them out.
Um I like the tools. You have your little tool pot and you slot them in, which is kind of fun, but it does serve a helpful purpose to let you know how many turns are left in the game because there are 15 slots. So, I can look and go, "Oh, there's only three open slots left. I only have three turns left to get everything done that I want to accomplish."
The leaf tiles, you're trying to collect different colors throughout the game. And I did find sometimes myself and other players were saying, "Oh, is that the yellow or is that the orange?" So, they're maybe a little too close in uh they they looked a little too similar to each other.
I think if they're next to each other, you can tell them apart, but if you just see one or the other, it's kind of like, "Oh, do I have that one? I I don't know." So, I agree with that. Um I thought that the little frog tokens, each player has a different design.
Yeah, they're designed and a different color.
They're super cute. And my mom loves frogs, so I have seen lots of frog figurines and everything. And I thought these were cute.
The other thing I found interesting was the player board. A lot of times when you have a player board, you have specific spots to put things. This one's like your own beautiful garden, which looks nice. It's sort of like this blank canvas and you're adding the flowers and the insects and you get to decide, you know, sort of where they're going on your board. And I thought that was nice.
So it's kind of like you're creating your art piece as the game goes. creating your own garden. Well, why don't we move on to our critiques? So, in this game, you're trying to be as efficient as possible. You're collecting the different insects and flowers, and that's great if you can get the things you need. Sometimes you're like, "Oh, I really need buttercups because I have bees." But then the market, there's no buttercups coming out. There was one game that actually happened. I had a bunch of bees just flying around my garden and I was like I will not score these bees if they don't get on buttercups.
Eventually it the buttercups came out so I was able to but those you then you need actions. You need to be able to put those bees on the buttercups. So figuring that all out is really important in the game.
So you felt that the way they came out meant that you couldn't be as efficient as you wanted to be.
Correct. Another thing is maybe the things do come out but other players are drafting the tools that you want. So I had a game where the player in front of me went a very strong magnolia um strategy collecting all of them. Those are the ones that won the ladybugs, I believe. And so I was like, well, I guess I'm not really getting any magnolia because every time one pops out, he takes it. So, I had to pivot and go a different strategy and try to score in other ways. So, that is something that can happen in drafting games.
But, you really do have limited options. So, I think you're going to be able to score in all the things that you get, whether someone's doing the cascading or doing the different flowers or how they're different um getting the different color leaves or whatever. I I do find it interesting just thinking about the game mechanic. not only game mechanics, but just the game design itself. Most people's scores are pretty similar to each others by the end. So, they're really that different.
Oh, like whether you're getting butterflies or whether you're getting bees and buttercups, all of that.
I mean, the the one thing would be like if you're like so focused on like if you didn't pivot and be like, well, I guess I'll go after something else. If you just stayed in the Melia route, would you actually score anything? Probably not. So that just takes a little bit of thinking, but you decided, oh, I'll just go after the dragonflies or I'll go after something else instead.
I would say most things are scoring between one and three points, so it's not a huge uh difference. Um, with the whole scoring thing, a slight critique is this is a fairly simple game, but teaching it is a little bit more complex because you do need to cover
all of those scoring things before you start so people know what they're trying to collect and the benefits. Now, I will say that each player does have a little like the little board player reference that talks about scoring. So that is very helpful. Now I don't know that someone could just look at it and understand it. But once you explain it, having that reference I think is helpful, but it just takes a little bit longer to explain the game because everything you're working towards is basically endgame scoring. So they need to know all of that up first.
That's very true. Unless the person doesn't care about scoring or winning. You could play this game and just collect things
like, "Oh, I like ladybugs and butterflies. I want I want to get those sort of things.
Yeah, I do feel a little frontheavy loaded in those rules is um
Yeah, because your turns are fairly simple. Take a tool, get the stuff, and then do the action.
But how that all works out with the scoring. Not complicated, just there's like eight different things that score and they all are slightly different.
All right, let's move on to our commendations. So, first of all, this game is just very beautiful. It's very aesthetically pleasing. All the not only the bits, but just the artwork and even the game play. It just fits really well for that, I think, casual board game.
Cozy.
Yeah, cozy.
I think you could introduce this to pretty much anyone, even if they're not really big into games, and I think they'll have an enjoyable time.
So, it's casual. I think it's a casual. I don't think it's the um super heavy like I'm gonna minmax this to the you know all that kind of stuff.
Yeah. It's more of like I'm gonna build a beautiful garden with fine
with insects and flowers.
Yeah. So going into that casual experience and having just an enjoyable time I think is fine. Well, I personally enjoy games that some people would refer to as point salads where you can get points lots of different ways. And Kevin sort of mentioned that earlier, but I do like that normally everything you're doing is benefiting you in some way. It may not be the most optimal turn, but it is growing your garden. It's getting you more insects. It's moving you down the track. So at least you don't feel thwarted, I don't think, during the game.
Yeah, I think the game flows well. We mentioned that a little bit under the critiques for a different reason, but I think the game does flow well once you are playing,
right? Once you understand it,
once you understand how to play, it plays really well cuz you're basically going to take one of the tools in the market and you're going to do an action. So very simple in gameplay. We've played this at the two, three, and four player count.
I think that's all. Oh, it does play one player. We don't play
four. We don't do solo games.
So two, three, and four. I I felt all those games felt very similar to and and I'm not calling that as a negative. I'm saying that's that's great as a combination. It's like, okay, you're going to get that same experience, that casual game experience. You're going to have 15 turns. You're going to get all the things that you want. They they just build it out. So if you have more players, there's more tools available so that everyone's going to get 15 turns. Yeah, I would say that com two-player compared to especially four player is you can't plan quite as much in a higher player count game because it's a drafting game. So different tools are going to be out. They're going to be in different spots. So there's a little less forward planning you can do in the higher player count than in a two-player game. But
again, you're getting points for just about everything. So, it's not going to tank your strategy or something like that to have less of that planning aspect.
Lanterns.
Oh. Oh, I don't think we've mentioned lanterns yet.
There is another piece in the game called another board game piece. The lanterns, they they go in your garden, but they sort of can be activated at any point when it's your turn and they give you like extra water, extra turns, or move your frog again or like do extra things. But normally on the on the tools, you're usually getting two things. The lanterns are sort of like a delayed benefit, which I liked a lot because we talked about efficiency earlier. That allows you to be even be more efficient because then you can take that extra thing at the right time in the game. So you're like, "Oh, now I want to get an extra water cascade because that's going to get me this thing that will lets me sort of like not combo, but like connect the dots to what you're trying to accomplish." Yeah, Kevin had one game where he was the lantern king.
Well, I I had one and because we didn't talk, there's ways to get um there's goals in the game that you can get extra points.
Oh, that's going to be my next commenation,
but I was I was able to connect the lanterns.
Yes. So, there is a few places for additional endgame scoring. So, like maybe scoring bonuses. And one of them is getting to the bottom of the cascade. And then I think you have three different choices of things that you can score. There's also honeyotss. I think one of the honeypotss was for lanterns.
I sort of went off to that early. I was like, I'm going to do lanterns.
So, I liked that the game has that endgame scoring and it's not necessarily the same for everyone because you can make different choices. So I think that can differentiate scoring whereas everything else is like oh I get a point or two for the honeybee or for the flower or for this. I think you can it's not exorbitant amounts of points but you can get a good number of points from those special bonus endame scoring. So I like that it gives you a goal that you can go towards and it could be a little bit more differentiated from the other players. I think that's probably what's going to differentiate an experienced player from a casual or a new a new beginning player because they know sort of how those things,
right? Because I could even start a game knowing, oh, I think I'm probably going to want to do this endgame goal, so I'm going to set myself up for it.
Yep. All right, let's move on to our conclusions. All right, first for this ending part of the game, we haven't talked about the game name pergola.
There is a pergola.
Yes. on one little side of your board side of your board where the bees and the
which is a part of the game,
but I don't think it's like explains what the game is.
So, I wish it was a there was a better name for the game like Cartage Garden. Cartage Garden, of course, is already taken um and I enjoyed that game, but it has more of a garden feel to it than just a a pergola. Okay, so the name didn't bother me and probably kind of like Cottage Garden, most of the other generic garden type games probably are already taken.
You can play this, like I said, at multiple player counts. I felt I would say the word sy, but for replayabilitywise, there's not a lot of extra strategy. Yeah, you can go after those extra goals. you can do a lot of those other things which is fine but in the end you're collecting the insects and the flowers and you're trying to put them on. So the set collection there's not a lot of extra variability or strategy on that in that set.
So so you're thinking maybe it doesn't have a lot of depth to mine during the game. You know you're gonna play it. You're going to have an enjoyable time picking your garden and stuff, but it's not you're not going to unlock amazing things.
Oh, yeah. Like, oh, I wonder if I did it this way. Like, I could get way more points or something like there. I can do these combos or something like that. So, c a very enjoyable casual game and I will probably introduce this to other casual game players.
Yeah, I think maybe my parents maybe try to play it with my mom cuz she really likes frogs and there are frogs that hop around on the lily pads. Now, she might not get that extra layer of strategy, but I think she would enjoy collecting the things and um getting points that way. So, yeah, I do think casual family way. It plays in about an hour, probably less if you're doing two or three players.
And it it's not going to be a brain burner that is causing people to, you know, get headaches and and sit for long amounts of time with AP, which sometimes happens to me.
So go just in the end, I'm like, we go back a little bit. Will we will I bring this game to the table for new players? Yes, maybe if I'm trying to introduce them to something, but that that front load is going to detract for me from bringing it to new players. I'm like, do I want to spend 15 minutes explaining how to play the game or can I just bring another game that's easier to bring to the table? So you would probably say, "Hey, this is for the people who are at the Azul ticket to ride, maybe even Cascadia level, want that kind of cozy game, a game that's beautiful and pretty, but not a I've never played board games before." Not the people that were introducing like No Thanks and Flip Seven. So it's the the next category up.
Yeah, I think that's true. So, if you enjoy cozy casual games, um, if you've played other garden games like Cottage Garden, um, and you can think of like, oh, I wonder what what I would, you know, if you enjoyed those types of games, we'd love for you to tell us in the comments what those games are and if maybe you've even played per already if you've enjoyed that. Thanks for watching. Please like and subscribe.