Treasure Island Board Game - First Play Thoughts Review
Transcript
nice and Sherman welcome back for another first play force review and this is a short short video on the pneumatic I release of the Treasure Island this is a sentient game where one player takes the role of Long John Silver yet back there young John Silver Long John Silver and the others take control of pirates trying to find Long John Silver's treasure before time runs out and yes so let's check this out after I've run up the stairs
said it's a deduction game of sorts and what you're doing it was one pyre takes a role in Long John Silver for my sort of game he's locked up in his tenets ha WA and the rest of the plaza pirates who were trying to interrogate Long John Silver trying to get information out of him to tell them where the treasure is son I can run off random and follow right widest works is you've got a calendar board and the players will be receiving hints from Long John Silver but they may all may not be true and then what you've been doing you'll be the Pirates will be going off using these hints try and deduce where Long John Silver's hidden is treasure and you'll be using these sort of plastic sort of no blood curse was it etch-a-sketch looks like now Oasis ghost or graft hope things to be drawing circles on the board trying to find out where the treasure is you'll be using these compasses in this what I call a caliper but if you don't do it by a certain amount of time then Long John Silver manages to escape these shackles and then it's a mad dash to find out where the treasure is obviously Long John Silver knows where the treasure is but the by this time you're hoping that the if you're a pirate and you you know where it is so yeah so this basically heard well how deep is quite in it quite an easy game so and what do we like about this one so first and foremost obviously we've got to talk about the components and they are absolutely fantastic you it feels like you're opening up a maths pencil case why because you've got like a compass which can be easily confused
with the other compass so you got like a caliper which lets you draw circles and stuff with your marker pen and then you've got these these lovely plastic circle things that you can draw around to see where your search areas like a small one or a large one and then you can occur a nice purse or a compass Rosie you can you can tell you like that solving a triangular wave where the treasure might not be so yeah the components are absolutely stellar I mean the board itself is really colourful I mean so people say you have problems seeing where the markers asks of what I've done it put more washed out version of it on the other side but that done that looks really muddy and nasty so we don't use I want but yeah color force which is vibrant and the component quality is absolutely astonishingly good so yeah I mean what do you expect from a Toccoa they always pump out these really really lovely produced games sometimes people say the radical produce but I'm not too sure about out here so another wonderful metal over release in terms of quality or components so it turns a gameplay I mean we've only played this once but I mean it was quite tense actually I think a few we've done a round furnace so if you watched our video you'll see that my Gavin almost got the treasure on it on one of his what to go so there's me sitting there as long as on a silver figure are more goodness what's going on so yeah and then obviously missed it and then you just don't know where where the games are going to go so it's quite tense it's quite exciting actually yes so yeah the gameplay aspect is uh you know it's not it's not too bad you know they've got that uh sort of moments where you sit in there to are trying not to sort of look like use of nowhere here's and I found a
Carla times you know people will look at me trying to see where my lights going on the board it's awful our core use more mini much better so yeah there's that aspect of a guy who's quite tense it's it quite exciting yeah another decent thing they've done is I've given you like a double-sided calendar board so that balances out the player count so on one side you've got her four players and two players on the other side you've got four in five play so yeah they've figured out they you know you can't just that one calendar board you've got that you've got a sort of a cut back the amount of options available for the lower player counts all the hard blacker so if you've got three players you're gonna be going to beat one man down I guess I think they figured that out and that's one that's really good that they haven't sort of tried to sort of scrimp on that they've given you another board so yeah that's really nice it's good you've got your core ability so you can use all the time but your special abilities they're they're limited so you know you've got a every time you use an ability you've got a special ability got mark off on your little player sheet and one you've when it's done it's done you can't use anymore so in terms of the pyres they've got to be very very careful as to when they use a special ability and when they don't use it because they don't know because it's a time-based it's a timer based game is once you get to the end of the calendar then it's a mad dash in it so they've got to be very careful with do they use their special abilities early and then maybe you know not know when long john silver's telling the truth or do they wait for the spot clues to come out and where things get a little bit easier and then they can really saw but as they're getting close to the deadline they can really sort of
hammer those those things home so yeah there's that aspect of it is that this seems the character of special abilities being finite it really does talk about a better teacher for the players and I so yeah we really like that bit so what don't we like about this game one of mine thinks we found another seems to sort of jump how stripes the fat days it's really really difficult for Long John Silver to get anywhere near winning this game the minis ghazal he's only got really to bluff clues that you can use there none yeah some of the summer clues just seem too powerful women we got you've got the first clue that logs on silver gifts it's always correct and if you're dealt a hand of rubbish clues you can give up I mean look with the game we played I was the first three clues I had all of them were terrible at me I don't know which one to play all of them gave it away and you know the clue that I was forced in the plan which was the least the least damaging for me it really narrowed it down it'll make the one corner of the border be light and then by the time I actually had a cut at Bluffs it was it was game over I think they knew exactly where the treasure was in most of the case of they're finding it reads doing the researches and a problem is once I've narrowed it down into that little corner every time I do a search they get a bonus clue and it's I know you know it's a give up some of the clues are like well you know you get an extra goal where you get an extra search or you get an extra this and it's like oh hang on no I can't down we're only in round two and they're almost that close to a bond and the treasure so
you know don't know it just seems a bit unbalanced in favor of the players I mean other and when you get into those those black spot cruises so how they get really easy and I'll just think maybe it's a bit of a superlative once so but it just seemed dark from where I was sitting I just couldn't see how long john silver could he hoped to win this one yeah one of the other things we found that some of the rules were a little bit unclear I mean in a rulebook you've got it mentions about the hints first before even tells you what the hints are about really I should have been at the back of a book I should have told you what a hints for about and the the thing about a compass clues was it was split into two parts of the rulebook so you've got the one bit telling you what it does and in the next bit later on referring to something else and you're like this this does this mean this West on the compass mean this triangle bit borders it the whole of that sort of the board now there was a period in the game that we played where there was two to close have mentioned West one of them referred to the plastic compass and one of them referred to the board where the board has only got four points of the compass and the plastic compass has got eight points what does that mean does that mean the whole of the West on the board or does it mean the same thing as West on the thing and it wasn't really really clear and we ended up just saying well it must mean that and yeah we didn't really we didn't really know what to do but I yeah that
rulebook is a little bit unclear I don't know if it's or such as icing sauce it's a French kind maybe other night but it seemed a quote that the bits were there there's bits of the rulebook there in in the wrong place it could have been explained a lot lot easier or been rearranged and yeah I don't like those Louisville page flappy ball books you know that sort of a for flappy wall books because I just get ya when you've been you've got the fing off in front here it's very difficult is flapping around and you've got what they're both it no no pay for that fits in a box right you can print them you want we want rule books that you can print off yourself and stick in the box will have an having their shape anyway get off Kilauea so one of the other things that we found a bit of a pain in the neck so far as the way the game is structured is you've got these huge screens in front but you've got a reach over and to to write on the board and it's like you know clambering over this huge thing and if you knock it over that's it you'll you'll all your plans are exposed so that's a that's a pretty big fall for me I'll just thinking like you know you know I could have done it but it just seemed to it just seemed that yeah you were you're asking for trouble no breach an overture we found out can you just mark that there it's like well whereabouts you want us to do you want me to mark your process or wherever anywhere and so you know yeah having little things like that that really bugged me with some games you
know you think well if they take just take a little bit more time for about it but anyway yeah that's one of the big Downers so probably the main - two of the main things that we don't like about Treasure Island one is that if for any reason if the lungs are so up of drawers as unlucky enough to draw crap cards at the beginning and to put all the players are lucky enough just to guess correctly where the treasure is in the first color rounds the game's finish this it's over so now we'll just build up and then it's like oh it's all done you know there's that thing where if it all goes wrong in it all it all goes but really badly wrong no kissy I thought gaff was gonna find the treasure in the first round you know the straight way and that would have been like couldn't we probably would have take this going back if that happens but you didn't so they had it a bit of drama but yeah that's one thing and the second thing is if Long John Silver makes a mistake with a clues which is all my staff and swass you know everywhere the rules are unclear then you can't none pick the game you can't go back and say well we take this back and we take that back - no you can't this hump it's on pickable so you it's that thing where some of the things in the game kind of unclear maybe they'll become clearer as you play it or as you might vehicle with a key or something I so it's a couple of major of major flaws with a game but you know it is what it is maybe it'll be ironed down the future maybe you get expansion to this the line all out so to summarize Treasure Island
after one play we enjoyed this game I'm not gonna say that we didn't enjoy but there's a couple of major things they make the game problematic for me and that is the the unclear rules is the fact that the game could be finished within the final of us round if you know if the players are just lucky or if long time Silver's unlucky you know another major Daenerys is it seems very very very difficult for long till silver tool to get anywhere near winning this one I mean part of this seems to me that the fun lies with just trying to frustrate the place we'll just bluffing because I just cast you onto a silver win Ernest the clues the players get too many clues and one if they get more experience then I just don't think there's any way around it I'll swing for John long dong silver being Long John Silver's just it's just playing cards on the board I mean it's not really much to it really so there's that and from we're all sitting I was like oh applies Norfolk and you again for Australia with this day yeah scrabbling around in the dark looking at the clues thinking whoa hang on a minute it's gotta be around here somewhere or what why fo I just Troya I'll just try so even though it's deduction it was place to me it seemed like sort of just ran guesswork you know I don't know but yeah treasure wanna I mean not saying we don't like the game but there's just a couple of it is it's a good game it's a very very good game but it's just a couple of major flaws with the game that prevent it from being great right so if you enjoyed this video if you if you like Treasure Island go and watch our our playthrough at that one and yeah
like subscribe comment on the channel help this channel grow you know the more you comment the more you tell us what you did like what you don't like you'll kick YouTube's algorithm up the backside like subscribe comment and we'll see you next time you