Twilight Imperium (4th Edition) Review - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
hey everybody and welcome to chairman of the board today I'm going to share my thoughts on twilight imperium 4 which is this huge epic space opera game for 3 to 6 players it's a game roll area control and basically trying to fulfill these different objectives to score victory points at the first a 7 or 10 victory points will be the winner now I have to say I've generally not a big fan of sci-fi games but the way that Twilight Imperium embeds the theme and scope over this huge you know space opera and the mechanics is absolutely wonderful the way you can upgrade your ships the unique powers of each of each race is really really well done the upgrades to your technology just the the idea that you your influence over these different planets affect your kind of galactic influence and you can pass these different laws and you have these votes very very cool mechanics I also love that struggle for mech at all Rex in the middle basically that's a huge kind of like a bikemaster planet where all the all the bigwigs go and you know controlling that area in like a like a king of the hill style manner will get you an extra victory point each time very very clever idea creates a good amount of tension and that struggle is really really engaging that being said the game is it it has its issues for me don't get me wrong this is a game I really really respect there mechanically
thematically absolutely wonderful people regard this as their fav a lot of people regard this as the greatest game of all time and you know what it's hard for me to argue because it does what it does so fantastically well but for my personal taste I have a couple of issues with it and I'll try to explain them but again it's a personal thing and number one the game length it's a very very long game it's going to take six seven or eight hours or depending on the amount of players you have I played this with I think four and five players and I think the longest went for about eight hours in the other one for about six hours and to be honest I thought that it did a out States welcome get me wrong it does it does do its best to a try engage players it uses some very very clever mechanisms such as the action selection which generally tries to address downtime by basically if players choose a second action players kind of get a lesser variation of the action and basically - just to keep the uptime going but it just still doesn't do enough minute but downtime sometimes it's like half an hour between turns and for me that's just not on and for me to stay engaged I'm going to have to be completely in love with that game completely invested in the theme and care about what everyone else is doing but basically there can't be things going on on the other side of the planet that I really don't have an interest in at all such as combats between players and literally I've just not invested in their decisions so I don't care what
they're doing and therefore I'm not engaged with the game I hope that kind of makes sense another thing for me for a game that takes you know six seven eight hours the combat in this is its dice driven and for me that's it's just a bit too swingy for me don't get me wrong again it's a personal thing I generally I generally don't like guys dice combat and games so I find it a bit too a bit too random for a game that's going to take that long I want something to be a bit walter monistic and not be to the mercy of the dice to that extent obviously there's like modifiers and stuff like that and probabilities are going to be in the favour but I find it personally you're unsatisfying again a personal thing but again this these are these are things that I personally have issues where though this is a game that I completely respect the design of again the mechanism very well done I absolutely adore the laws that come in you basically think at two or three laws come in a turn and you vote using the influence of the planets you're controlling and some of the things that that you can do are really interesting so well implemented I remember one example where we voted to basically set off this bomb and it blew up a whole kind of section of the board and it killed like most of my friends army and everyone just had a huge very very fun I love that idea and I think more games should do it one of my favorite games Lancaster does that as
well and I love that idea the idea of spending influence to basically modify the game rules absolutely great great idea the game also uses negotiation which is something that I really like and it does do it well so basically you can kind of buy and use each other's trade goods and give each other benefits or even just like let players kind of come past you and promise each other things and stuff like that so the level of interaction is generally really good but as something again about my combat the combat just is not it's just not satisfying for me when I'm building something up and someone just comes in and just absolutely trances me and I have no interest in fighting them I just want to kind of do my own thing and fulfill the objectives that aren't aggressive I just I just don't like that at all so that is more me because I do kind of lean towards the the euro side of games where conflict isn't such a big issue again personal personal taste so yeah overall the game is it's so well designed it's so well designed just absolutely epic in scope the thematics are absolutely wonderful really nice components nice looking bits nice chunky hexagonal tiles you've got the variation of the board set up each time again the unique powers do make you feel unique great kind of theme in the flavor text loads and loads of replayability because you've got all the different powers different routes and strategies you can go down but again
those those real kind of those real kind of anchors to the game for me the ones that I can't get the house is number one that downtime number two the game length number three the dice combat so yeah I well this is a game that I can absolutely recommend to players who do enjoy this kind of game honestly it's it's brilliant if you're into that space opera you like dice combat if you do like those things you have to check out this game it's absolutely fantastic if you are that kind of gamer for me it's not something that are looking to play again it's just not worth the time investment for me I could play something else you know 30 40 to 40 minutes sometimes 40 minutes downtime between my tabs is absolutely mad it could be a personal thing maybe the players I play with have bad ah ap but still just too much too much also the setup and pool downtime of this is quite significant but again if you're going to dedicate a whole day to it then not so much of an issue everything looks great ships look great the board looks great nice quarter you're comparing us as I said just just it's going back to like combat so overall it's something that I definitely recommend if you do like these kind of Americana thrash kind of games but with some very well implemented kind of Euro style strategic mechanics yeah overall it's a funny one
it's a bit of a you know a bit of a push poke for me because I like so much about it I respect so much about it but just those few factors are just just kind of outweigh the the urge to want to play again and again so yeah I hope that that gives you an impression of my opinion of a Twilight Imperium 4 again a great accomplishment one that is just gonna continue to do well as more and more editions of this come out because it does what it does better than anybody else theme honestly I can't bolt it the epic scope of it absolutely amazing you're gonna have a big big story arc you're gonna have great stories to tell each other for years to come as a result of playing this game but my tastes not quite you know not quite a fit for me so yeah I hope you enjoyed it enjoyed the short review of Twilight Imperium 4 if you have please hit like and subscribe my channel and check out my other videos too and for everyone else I'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye