Skip to main content
Loading video...

Expeditions: A Sequel to Scythe - TCbH Review

Transcript 5:39

2016's Scythe came at a flash point in tabletop gaming the proliferation of Kickstarter as a pre-order service the breakdown of any lingering meaning to long-held labels like Euro or ameritrash and of course the foundation of a little review blog named the cardboard Herald now seven years and numerous titles later stonemeyer is returning to Jacob risolski's 1920 plus modernist meets Mecca setting with Expeditions a sequel to Scythe dropping the combative in Civ elements Expeditions puts players at the helm of a singular Mech exploring vast stretches of long abandoned land to achieve Renown and stake your claim while on the surface it may seem that the biggest takeaway from Scythe is the austere steampunk theme there's a lot of familiarity if not literal transition in the gameplay itself each turn you slide a cube to cover one of three possible actions leaving you to resolve the other two still revealed in any order moving your character which if to an Uncharted location will reveal it playing a card which gives immediate bonuses augmented if a worker of the corresponding type is spent or collecting resources or activating abilities at your location which in turn Nets you resources workers cards permanent upgrades and if fulfilling the objectives boasting to put out the Stars which when a player places their fourth triggers the end of

the game and each Nets points based off of your reputation level there's a fluidity to playing Expeditions well this turn leading to the next and the next and the next play this card which lets you complete a quest boosting your reputation spending resources to gain rewards which may in turn allow you to clear corruption tiles on future turns using the effects of other cards and when you exhaust your pool of cards you can spend a turn to rest retrieve all of your cards and workers with the added bonus of a mega post rest turn where you can take all three actions in any order which lends to another strength of the game its flexibility for only three actions on your character mat you have so many options and what you can resolve and when largely because of the varied effects and consequences of the cards and location bonuses which only increases as you reveal more of the map and amass more power by permanently attaching equipment melding alien Tech and completing quests each being a different type of card that can be played in and of itself but through different means can be removed from your pool of available cards and permanently effects to your Mech for immediate or ongoing bonuses the thing is no matter how fluid and flexible the game is there's a specter of flimsiness about it when everything is so special nothing is special and as a consequence there's very little weight one of the most distinctive things about the original side was the looming threat the

oppressive cold war that informed every decision you made in an otherwise economic Adventure combat was seldom but the risk of exposing yourself weighed into every action which in turn made every foothold every resource every upgrade meaningful Expeditions on the other hand is bereft of tension sure everyone is racing to have the most points at the end but who cares if you reveal a location before me yeah it might mean you get to claim the map token but they have such little use and they're plenty enough to go around and besides you revealing gives me more information there's almost no player interaction director otherwise aside from maybe taking a card I wanted but again who cares because the pool of cards instantly refills you claimed the corruption token I was going for itching you closer to the seven corruption token goal well there's plenty more where that came from and you might have revealed a bonus ability on the location that I can march on over and use just the same as you ultimately Expeditions is a curious concoction in that it's beautifully crafted and exceptionally smooth to steer but what you end up doing smacks a busy work and because your Mech ends up darting all over the map once everything is revealed in the back half of the game just to get more blue or orange resources to spend it to clear a couple more blue or orange tokens or pick up a card on one half of the map to fulfill its Quest on the other end you quickly lose the Thematic Grandeur of the setting and well it devolves into

incremental numbers and efficiency which is okay there are plenty of games where the beauty comes from the process where crunching numbers and amassing materials converting them to points is the fun of the thing which is exactly what Expeditions counts on it does feel cool to have this beautifully sculpted Mech with its own power combined with the starting combination of character card and animal with their own powers eventually outfitting your Mech with a upgrades to Skyrocket resource accrual and improve fluid outcomes but I can't help but feel it learned the wrong lessons from Scythe for all the freedom and flexibility it gives you without tangible challenge risk or cost the constant rewards feel hollow leaving a game full of fun moments with flashy turns and gooey synergies but altogether less than substantial foreign hmm

Progress saved