Between Two Castles of Mad King Ludwig: Discussion
Transcript
viewer discretion is advised hey everyone this video is brought to you by audible audible is offering you a free audiobook with a 30-day free trial membership all you need to do is go to audible.com for word /bg unlock the link is in the description below and now enjoy the video everyone welcome to the discussion for between two castles of Mad King Ludwig a quick caveat this game was sent to me as a review copy so once again thank you very much Jamie for sending that I very much appreciate it bye sexy person I mean here's the thing so stone Meyer games has only ever let me down on one game which was tapestry and it only let me down because it was like it was like called tapestry and then underneath it was a civilization game if that if that wasn't there my mind said was been different going in so that I wouldn't have had high expectations oh because it's not said game game yeah and it really wasn't in any semblance and there had so much hype around it that I was like oh it's gonna be amazing anyway we're gonna talk about this game because once again still entire games just I think knocks it out of the park so we have done a discussion for between two cities which we all very much enjoy we works fantastic as a three-player game and that that collaboration of being able to like you're competing but you're not at the same time it's a microwave there's no way it's like you can't [ __ ] one Castle exactly just cannot right I
mean this I kind of learned that in two cities I was like you can't really ever won cuz you're just gonna get Brett Rice just right really if you really think about it favor one yeah you're hurt you're hurting yourself and your cuz like I was really hoping you got you because if you guys will not hoping but if you guys focused everything on that you essentially hand me the victory right because then I'm gonna get the better of the two so so between two cities worked wonders the expansion capitals was pretty good to add it just enough to add a little bit of spice and then we just split castles of my King Ludwig which we all ranked very high as well that kind of auctioning bidding where you're just weirdly trying to piece here castle together okay what do you think of the amalgamation of the two very I mean I enjoyed it I mean I've never seen such close games right I yeah it was a good time I mean I remember enjoying two cities it definitely had some changes to it they don't have the combined tiles anymore correct and a little more around shorter as well because in between two cities you have your singles then you have a second round with the doubles and then your third round with the seniors again right I think this is a really good mashup mm-hmm like a really good mashup of the two yep yeah I I completely agree like I really actually have no complaints with it my initial worry was really you're taking two games and you're gonna put them together and that's just gonna that white why I mean it really works it's radically different from the other two
well not not radically but it grabs both the best of both of those and puts them together to where you get a feeling for both of the game right I mean they're both like a tile placement style dream yeah and it's just they just took the bones of another and put it like it like I can't say bones in a frame the meat of one you put on the bones together yeah actually they are the bones of Steel II had the victory meat of the castle yeah yeah yeah so it's like I feel like this is more between two cities than it is cast oh definitely um because the biggest thing you're missing from this game is there is no auction there isn't or no it's not really an auction but there is no price thing where it's like oh man whether they want I don't have to pay for anything so at its heart it is basically a replacement for between two cities but they add in that wonky castle building and specific tile placement which between two cities had okay that's like a scoring system but yet the room placement theme of it is what it was kind of driving it exactly because I mean you have I mean what really makes this game sing is exactly what you said you have the final scoring which between two cities had but here there's just so much variety like it's like because I mean he'll just these three foods alone you require so much you know puzzle - oh this needs to be connected to this but this also needs so each time I feel like you have way more decisions to make in this one
than you do in between two cities between who says it's like okay yeah obviously we're just gonna put you know that that building there we're gonna sew it so it's not next to a factory or something like that here it's like well this can go here or it can go here or way over here oh no there's an outdoor building so we can't put it there you have a lot more thought into your city right and you have to think a little bit ahead here know what this one like what tiles you're handing off because I have to think of like what's running dry what do I still need and it's so interesting like you you have to like plan to build completely different from each of your cities yeah or each of your castles yeah because they go with me and cat I was like oh wait we're gonna have to build the mirrors that's wait that's what we were focused and I was able to go Oh full utilities right build off of that early game and then that's kind of what constructed that from there so it gets completely different cuz if you mimic your yeah you're gonna be hosed because you're gonna sit there and I mean we saw it like I was going all living rooms on this one and then I'm like oh crap we looked like I was really hoping that for some reason the living room was floating around and it never was so we lost out on eight points off of off of those um cat what do you like what do you like about the game well I always enjoyed I like the matching of it i I just think probably my favorite part is just the interesting aspect between working and like for yourself but with other games like this is a like semi cooperative
that actually works yep this is and that is hard to come by it yeah it really is and I mean so because there's a lot of things I'm trying to pick apart so I mean essentially we can we can assume that this is basically between two cities which still admire made so it makes sense that they would kind of focus more on that one and then because it says with bézier games who made castles so it makes sense that they would focus more on their own game and then take in the theme of the other one because if it was reversed it would probably be more just like then castles with between keep cities mixed in um but the key differences that I think are important that we can talk of if we like or dislike and there's not that there's really not that many one there's no pricing so you guys love did you guys like that aspect of castles of Mad King Ludwig or do you feel like that's missing in this game no no no no this one definitely I mean Willy they built it around the city yeah I mean which they had no room for a price sure a system sure game I thought my issue in and right yeah so yeah so that was the easiest one to throw out now the biggest one is they kept the bonus cards in this one which cities did not have the expansion brought in like those endgame ones that you could plan for remember if so it's like oh if I can't remember if specifically what the cards were but they were like if you had the most of this one then you've got this many points in that second place got those many points so if they had
those in the expansion but here they took the bonus cards from City not cities from castles okay I'm making losing what you guys think of the bonus cards they're pretty you know I mean beneficial I mean you guys saw your just random like well if we pull this off it's gonna be ten points we got it early which was awesome so we were able to build for it so I mean that one definitely had the most potential yeah super random but I mean I liked them in castles of Ino I do too what do you think what do you like the bonus cards yeah I like it I mean it's I mean definitely in to flavor up you know when you get the threes right I mean each one of them definitely has a value to it I mean the food just an extra free tile here you know pick five it's any like whatever you need there it is yeah yeah so the bonus Carly what intrigued me about these is that in the other end castles you you can basically build get a bunch of them and then you can just go for endgame soaring here you have to assign it to a castle which is interesting because it's not just like oh here's mine I'm gonna get points for both my castles it's wherever it was placed so now this is the only one that can score off that and luckily you get to draw three and pick one but I find that interesting because now you have another thought in which one am I going to focus on because here it's like we're gonna get 10 points but that 10 points might make it 70 to 30 right and it's a crap like this that 10 points or it could be like 60 61 and
be like whatever 52 well yeah right it's just I mean cuz on your second Castle you gotta think you know so you weren't placing utility rooms when were you placing and I get that assignments cuz their bonuses are all very balanced mmm I mean granted the food room could I mean can vary wildly it could be just that right thing you need say we were dry on our living room right I can just set off that one zero needed the living rooms I mean could be up to 10 points just if you're building for symbol but on averaging you're looking at like four or five I mean you're looking at about an average of 5 points on any one of these like fountain 5 flat 5 Tower 5 has been our gain average yep grand foyer it could go up to what was it 6 7 8 8 potential point yep averaging you probably looking for [ __ ] so they're all averaging about the same you're like a 5 point net yeah that is true that's true but you can also and that's that's the third thing that's the biggest thing are the bonuses for each of the rooms which I think make this game elevate over over the other to be as as a comparison really you're kind of comparing this to between two cities more than anything but because like you just said is the food room not only other can give you exactly what you need if we placed our third one and drawn back I'll think god there's the living room or you can be like oh okay well we only have two living rooms and like so I can draw that and get that can get us our third one which can hit another bonus or hey here's our third downstairs which now because you can essentially go
for based if you get five of a lot you can go for all towers and just have okay well there's five points there there's five points there or fountains flat fire like you said so the bonuses I think are puts what makes this game really really cool and give you that extra layer of strategy um is there anything you guys don't like about the game because there is I mean I'm gonna say there is so many tiles it's very hard to shuffle them we did our best like whenever I drew that snack and it was like five sleeping rooms and I was like dear God I'm like the good thing is the rotation I mean another thing about this game is that like it's gonna be one of those games just like seven Wonders is gonna work it plays up to seven like that's that's radically interesting because in a three-player game where you do kind of miss and this is even in between two cities if you do kind of Miss that like two people are probably going to tie mm-hmm like yes unless unless you happen to do poorly on this one and then I did poorly on this one and then cat or cat did poorly on this and I did poorly on that one that's just that's just kind of how it rotates but usually it was 60 60 61 so that was already outside my time for 60 tied for 60 yeah this is like the most balanced game I ever seen I think so I mean I just think they were wildly different builds on each one of them wait we built like concentrated rooms over here with utility that's true utilities and then we went for it
yeah utilities because that's what we're yeah but we built utilities like over here we built mirrors we need a we need a symbol focus yeah here oh really this one was kind of like the more uh what's what's the word like not balanced but like the most we really wait for it know like this has everything in it mm-hmm like and we went mad at castle I guess so yeah because here we went for theme in like we went for food I think this one we kind of went for the bonuses because here we had for the three food which got us the extra R and then we went for outdoors which guys are fountain then we went for our living room which got us our tower so we kind of went for threes and then we went for endgame bonuses so you're right yeah they were all radically different and another aesthetically pleasing thing about the game is that just kind of like castles did you get to look and be like huh here's my weirdly themed castle that makes absolutely no sense and I hate it you don't have a court you don't have a good air you don't have the weird layout the different size tiles like I'm castles but here you upgrade that with beautiful artwork then castles does not have in any way that is one thing man if they could just yep yeah pretty much so yeah you're right like it end up being a shared victory into Java castles yeah I like when Devin said sixty I was
like right like whenever you're like I did better unless I'm here I was like man 61 that's not that good because there's only four points better than the last one which funny enough the one you and I worked on end up being the better castle but I just love that I love that it's like is another one okay no because it somatically makes sense if you look at it he met the Mad King shows up and he's like oh what the [ __ ] is that one like that's [ __ ] I'm you're fired um so - they're not negatives but there are things to keep in mind one if you're thinking if between two cities and Castle Mad King Ludwig are any type of complication to play which I don't think they really are this one is basically add the complication of both of those together because this is kind of eight it's not a complicated game but it's like there's a lot to think about hmm like there this game is definitely a be prone to analysis paralysis because you you draw nine and you're like and unfortunately kind of what well I feel like do you guys feel like that the start of the game isn't as solid like whenever I'm sitting here with my nine tiles I'm like I don't know it's too thick no I think it makes it fluid in my opinion really you have you have so many options that you can just I mean yeah if you're gonna like overanalyze and be like I need to know exactly where I'm gonna go from right now did ya I don't think that way I think it's a good building yeah I think the foyer kind of guide to you that's why I was gonna say
yeah the throne room yeah or if there's yeah a good start something to work with right off you know staring at this you know hand no hand of nine tiles that all you're just like oh I got to pick two of these because every time I get my hand in I'm like oh these two go perfect together damn it okay neither hopefully I pass it on to someone and he's gonna see that and and find out find the the combination but yeah you're right like I'll resend that because yeah you have the throne room where it's like okay and it's not broken it's four points max which isn't gonna make a break but I think that's cool how each of the throne rooms are a little different these different symbols and they each have a different course icon yeah and different placement sometimes of the tiles right uh so the other one that I is I guess I guess see whenever we initially played this we went for the very first time at 57 we got 12 points off of sleeping your first one well we got 12 points off of sleeping how many points did you get off sleeping over there three on the first one oh the first one I the either or four or okay so it's okay you probably only had one sleeping room cuz initially I was thinking the sleeping rooms are gonna be Opie mmm that's gonna be the easiest to go for because they're worth four points and you just have to build around it but I feel like if you're actually going the sleeping route that's four points on every single one of them but that means even make any combinations for the other ones because you didn't built a bunch of sleeping room right so there's definitely so that was my initial thought of like well sleeping rooms are
gonna be to go to but not really because twelve points here and what I got 57 score and the other one to two points over here and got a score of 61 yeah I mean the game is just super balanced I would definitely like to see it at a higher player count because then you're gonna have if it's me can't you and Josh well now you and Josh are work together mean you're working together but me and Josh aren't working and now there's that it has an extra layer of like oh now Joshua is getting up thirty and you got a fifty and I got a fifty and seventy so now it's already radically different right and you're most likely not gonna be getting at I um I look at that those aren't even really negatives like everything has its strategy everything synergizes together synergistic there we go don't worry mmm yeah yeah it's just really cool the extra icons just add another layer of flavor the more flavor to the pot with these artisans where it's like okay I'm a place them around inators I mean 12 points or nine points and things like this yeah it's just it's just fantastic I okay so now here's the big question because this is actually because since this is amalgamation of both between two cities and Castle Mad King Ludwig do you guys think that it is worth keeping all three I would say honestly in my opinion I would almost ditch between two cities
it's gonna worry Matt yeah yeah I like yeah I definitely like this one more than two cities and I still really enjoyed the castle game yeah Castle yeah and that's actually a really good point because that's gonna be the question is should I own I own between two cities and castles should I get this one absolutely you should get this one because it makes both of those games just it just makes both of them sing together but like you said this just adds so much more to between TCS without making it like super brain burning correct now even though cities has the expansion which kind of adds that extra oomph this already has an extra room with a better theme like I really like theme and castles of Mad King Ludwig is radically different playing then than this one I think because how in succession do you know which one came out first um so this one came out in 2018 and I never got it because I was like well why would I get it if I have the other two and now I know why but I can definitely look it up so between two cities came out 2015 and the expansion came out in 2017 and then castles of Matt came out 2014 so castles came out a year before and then I don't know if castles has any expansions okay gotcha I was would say I was like they almost
mainly just because I thought two cities came out first but they they kind of did what like Marvel did honestly like they were trying to like play around with their formula and then finally they were like okay we've done these two games let's smash them together we know what works right and this works really well yeah it's interesting because the because yeah like I said this came out in 2018 so but I mean it's two completely different companies so that's all so that's that's really neat that two companies could come together with radically different games and actually make a really good one cuz you you would expect this to just be like a gimmicky game be like really okay but it's it's so good like that's the thing is the game is also it says 45 to 60 minutes it's short like but thinking that entire time you're involved yeah okay which I mean after that first you know to breaki in its gonna start a zipping right on by yeah then you have an idea you know what the builds are yeah like then that's just always a big positive with me like that's what I liked about castles so much it's like just your fun level the whole time and you're thinking and you're talking with your friends and you're just just trying to figure it out where you can like you can kind of give each other [ __ ] like whenever it's like oh so you're gonna focus on that one huh well good that means this one's gonna fail [ __ ] but you can even yeah cuz like you can even like even be involved in someone else's build like it's over like yeah like I want to put this one over there it's like well
if you do if you put this one over there you'll get these points but because I want this one to come over here and it'll benefit it'll benefit me as well as you it's just it's so good and the fact that it's German castles also just just makes me makes me moist babies do a euro boner yeah it's fantastic and production quality is great so um yeah I mean I don't really have a whole lot without just constantly nitpicking on like certain certain areas so scale one to ten all right I'm just gonna start it off hi I like it just as much as castles okay nine point five good deal played it two times in a row like immediately one after another and I enjoyed it yeah and it's like oh yeah and then you kind of do better and then because you're gonna get that variety each each stack of nine and the organization by the way is just it's so good stone Meyer is really doing doing wonders with their with their inserts because it's just like boom boom okay put a lid on that net and it goes in the box and that's it Devin hmm I mean it's pretty perfect for its size I mean how much does it cost oh that's it okay so I'll I so it was a review copy that they sent me but they gave me an 80% oh so I got it for like 18 bucks but but that's not fair to actually say here let me pull it up real
quick so you can probably get this off cool stuff Inc four and a mount here we go between two castles and eventually if it pulls up you can get it for God okay let's do Amazon you would ask that because they didn't have it on uncool stuff okay between two thousand you can get off Amazon for $36 Wow a retail it looks like 45 well that's not bad it looks like oh no that's that's an expansion to castles nevermind yeah so you can get it for $45 or 36 off Amazon yeah I mean really good thinking game without being too much you know I definitely up the earth Canada give it a 9 yeah yeah yeah it was fun I play against very easy to set up and the inserts great its price good yeah yeah yeah I mean so I I mean for everything that we said for the fact that like everything that you just said I mean the price point for just being able to get it the fact that it took two fantastic games I think I like it better the both of them and it's just the right amount of thinking that any you can
bring almost anyone in without being like hey okay so guys I know this is gonna be a six-hour game and here's the rulebook it's like Oh God okay so this tile does this well this one it's a I mean everything just makes make sense I'm honestly gonna give this game a ten well liked it because like I really like between two cities that cooperative semi cooperative nature it was just unique I don't I can't think of a lot of games that are you want to work with both of your partners in an equal amount cuz like never once am I like trying to sabotage this one because that's gonna hurt me right so it's like okay well I'm trying to do the best of both with these and just hope that the the score is even now um and I mean short short play time like great price point great great production quality yeah I really even the negatives that I had were very hard nitpicky that I even took back because I don't know it it doesn't make sense so yeah this game is fantastic you guys good any thoughts anything else good deal so that's our thoughts on between two castles of Mad King Ludwig let us know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like how much share and subscribe in if a wonderful would every time of day this for you hey one thank you for watching I really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever I upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other
than that stick around for any any other run throughs or reviews or cool top 10s or whatever I feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you