Adventures of Robin Hood: Discussion
Transcript
some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome to the discussion for the adventures of robin hood and also a uh a series finale uh discussion because it was short enough for us not to do one a few um uh a few episodes in um i thought it was only five but it turned out to be seven so this is a game by the same designer as legends of andor which uh not a lot of people i know have talked about that game um but the ones i do see it say they like it uh and legends of andor it's i think it's a weak excuse of a campaign but it's a fine puzzle game right um depending on which chapter you're playing here i do prefer this yeah i i think i think this is what does the campaign concept and literary richness yes better yes i i very much agree uh you do get the tale of of robin hood i'm pretty much told uh were and everyone is for the most part involved throughout the entire um seven chapters and the fact that it is replayable goes a long way yeah like um there's one particular chapter and there might be spoilers that we talk about but there's one particular chapter where the the story forks like you make a decision do this or do this and then that's gonna define your next two chapters and then it'll
culminate all at the end right i i don't know how to feel about this game i don't think it's bad i just think it's repetitive yeah it's not bad it's i'd call it weak yeah um not in in the sense that it's close it's close to being really good but it misses so many times too much randomness for the literary and the campaign nature of it it's just too easy to just lose and for people who don't get frustrated people who just are okay let's start over and do it differently and now we know more right you know kind of like video games do you die but you've learned something and then you write it next time right but with video games it's like immediate you're like oh i died boom okay i'm back to starting over versus this it's oh let's let's reset everything and even playing chapter of the chapter like as a like if you're going to binge play this even that gets tedious because then okay we finish it out and things don't carry over it permanently like a legacy it's legacy light yeah um it has some small elements nothing's permanently destroyed it's all resettable but uh well actually that's not true there are the whole game is permanently destroyed because the [ __ ] we'll get we'll get to that but um in terms of physically ripping up cards or destroying tiles or anything like that it's not in here but yeah you're constantly flipping over the
same tiles and yeah even going to those locations it'll change depending on where you're at in the story yeah um yeah i'm very impressed with the storyline and the options and possibilities that are all woven through it right you know it's it's definitely a precursor to the ones in the past couple of years literary based games yes i'm more impressed with just the production quality of the book right like it's actually hardback right like whenever i first saw that like when i saw prototypes of this game and it was back i'm like that's not retail there's no way that's retail uh and it is like you get a hardback adventure book uh with nice design and the the writing isn't bad like it's very clean and how you're finding stuff the the gameplay of this is very simple uh and i think that that's actually a good thing because too too many times of these campaign games it's very complex you miss i mean we missed like probably like three months of not playing this yeah and quit and we're able to quickly go back into being like oh man okay here we are versus when i took a time away from tainted grail and came back i was like i have no idea what's happening anymore so i eventually just quit the campaign because i'm like no i do not even include um but it's so it's like the the story isn't it it isn't bad but it's also not its strongest point because
the board stays the same and that's actually my least favorite part of the game where you end up really just doing the same thing like every single time you know oh we started over here we run over here we've run back uh and we that was for different reasons two different destinations yeah but it does seem like that oh we gotta get into the castle first time we had no idea how to get the castle right from then on it's pretty easy yeah yeah and and it definitely kind of holds your hand there was one particular chapter that we forgot that the rope lets you get in and out yeah i thought it just let you get out because that's how the rope was used the first time uh and don't do it wrong i do like the fact that you can look at the the board and be like because seventh continent and tangent grail and those kind of games do that stuff where you can be like oh like oh there's a person here like we can go talk to them or um in one instance it's like oh we need a rope to get out of the castle oh hey there's a rope on the you know the news probably that was once there's a good chance that there will be right so i i think that that's neat but to kind of string that along for seven chapters um i think this could have easily been done in five like it would have been succinct you wouldn't have it wouldn't have worn out it's welcome uh and you would be like okay that was that was a fun little romp yeah like of of robin hood if this is a theme you're really into yeah um do you have any like glaring negatives on the game
because i i definitely do well yeah i mean we can get into the physical aspect of that kind of feeling too yeah but as far as the actual gameplay itself goes nothing nothing really wrong yeah again it just feels like it's really close yeah it's just misses on a couple of things which keeps it from being yes i want to do this again right right even so we went through the story and it's like i have no desire to try and go back on plus mode or second time mode just it's like i i do not care um and a little bit but not so much that i'll drag you through it well then here you can have the game and then you can you can play it um because this is a game enough to where you could probably attribute it almost to a gateway like a little bit like there's this style yeah there's really nothing like on your turn you take your two pieces and you oh there there and then we just go kind of like that and it's very like it's i wouldn't i wouldn't even really call it all that fiddly it because it's very lenient i'm kind of like okay yeah i kind of know it's a little bit but i'm right there yeah you know you don't have to take it too seriously and pull out the ruler yeah or anything like that like some warhammer games well yeah uh i actually do like how you move yeah i think that that's pretty thematic i like the use of the shade uh to say guards will ignore you i i like the risk reward if you can run out into the open and hope you're like okay well
there's still a white in my disc in here but the red is also and you can draw the red and you get captured um yep i think that that's relatively neat but in terms of like overall like major negatives it it is the absolute um crap uh advent advent calendar board i think that that is i thought that was gonna be cool i think you and i even had a discussion of like that should be like i was other i had i've had that discussion before where it's like oh legacy game should include that yeah you know where you pop things out and you can reset it and they did it here and in terms of that being it's like it theoretically works but they designed it in a way that everything even after set like seven playthroughs everything is still too tight yeah and some of them some of them are loosened up enough but those are the ones that also have edges that are curled up they're yeah completely frayed you you are destroying this game um and the fact there's two things that they easily could have done they could have made it to where it why is it so tight like they give you a sleeve for you to carefully stack your your tiles so you stack them and you put them in the sleeve so nothing should fall out but they still made everything so tight so it's like why didn't you just make them loose so that if this is going there it just sits in
it yeah it might move around a little bit but who cares like it's not like there's any secrets underneath yeah like the merchants and and the guards you know exactly what they're giving you the merchants never move they just kind of show up randomly which also the advent calendar i think kind of breaks immersion it's like oh i just beat up this noble well he's back like why is he back it's like i kind of get the guard thing where it's like it's rotating shifts but even then it's definitely that he went over for mechanisms instead of theme yeah like like whenever they pop in and out it's like okay that guy's shift is gone but i beat him up and or killed him or whatever it is got some hope back and i do like the hourglass going on showing that he's not coming back immediately yeah so you can shoot him or you can go beat him up and then you you can run through the shade a little bit yeah you're safe for your next move right most likely right but in the in the sense that the fact that you have to either pull out your own knife and use it as a pry bar and even then you're destroying the edges of the board i mean i couldn't tell you how many of these actually end up getting ripped or they're all stabbed in from us trying to flip them carefully and you yeah it's like we were just going like you you flip these so many times i mean hell even it like the ones that are
like ones i can't even get that one yeah like that are like oh hey this is a one one off yeah like that that's fine uh for it to be so tight i guess but like well it's so big that's part of what makes it more difficult to pry up yeah yeah and so it's not it's not the secrecy of things that are underneath it because you're gonna see what they are anyway right uh nothing moves so it's not like if this nobleman was here then you flip that down and then like and then he moves over here so you actually have to chase him which would be cool but right he's just a static noble and so it just destroys everything and it makes your board look like [ __ ] like i'm looking at almost every single tile and yeah you can just see white edges in fact there was one that i think we played a while back that um like almost ripped across the night and i had to tape it yeah it's over here yep and that's the other thing is like some of the ones stay permanently from round around that's the legacy part uh and it just makes no sense as to why they just didn't keep it loose so that whenever you do want to reset you can just oh okay yep let's quickly just flip that down instead of fraying it up on all the edges it just it's it's mind-boggling at how you end up destroying your own game and then the second thing is they didn't even provide you with a way to peel them
up like if if you're going to make it if you want to make them so tight then be like hey here's a device spudger yeah or something yeah yeah uh hey i i think that was a huge design well yeah i've tried i tried using these i tried using these but you just smash the the piece together yeah yeah they could have included something with a enough of an edge that it yeah wouldn't have been a dangerous but yeah so if you're watching this deciding if you should get it um do and make sure you have a needle or or a small knife that you can very very just slightly like spreading knife should work fine you know yeah but even then i also realized on some of our tiles it's not even the ones that you peel up even the board itself gets frayed um just from trying to wedge under it so you don't destroy the piece i don't know i think at the end of the day it kind of came down to one one flaw in an excellent production quality one fundamental flaw in an excellent fun otherwise excellent production quality yeah system the book the the pieces yeah i mean all the wooden pieces are solid um it's good quality cardboard it's heavy duty stuff right that's part of the problem right exactly because then then it's like oh well no they'll become loose yeah after they're all torn up
um i mean and the art is fantastic like this is really good really good art i mean even um uh the art that wasn't legends of andorra i always liked because i think he does his own art okay um he's kind of like a ryan locket of that where he designs his own games and i don't know if he did the writing himself uh but if he did then props to him on that oh yeah um but i mean overall it's it's a very light legacy-esque euro game with an interesting theme i can't imagine a lot of people are going to copy this with uh the advent calendar idea right um how old is this this came out i want to say 21 wow yeah it's like it's relatively new okay um i can tell you exactly when it uh i thought it was several years older for some reason uh andor came out in 2012. yeah that's what i was thinking this was like three four or five years later of robin hood um yep 2021 okay so and it came out in germany first and i almost actually bought it in germany or in german um and use it as an excuse to learn more of the language but um i mean each story kind of did delve into
because we played like four in a row three in a row uh no we did four we did four and then three uh and it did kind of delve down to the same the story turned into especially in a two-player game was one person oh i have the item so i'm going to be doing the quest and you just distract guy of gisborne you beat up the nobles cubes yep collect white later successes yeah and then okay and then we did it which it's it's up to four up to five four like i can't imagine what two other people would be doing right right well yeah because whenever you set it up um so like okay we'll just set up for chapter seven uh you have less time right and it goes quicker um i mean hell and the very last one you started out with the same hope but i think you also had less hope from chapter chapter uh no you had more sorry yeah in chapter six you had um 11 if you had four people okay so yeah that's actually a good point because it doesn't change the number of discs don't change right um well well more player discs for them yes you have two more uh actually so what changes is the red
disc you lose for hope now yeah because you lose a hope per player and then the purple disc brings in four which means that the other two players would basically be knocking out nobles and guards yeah and there's not enough side quests for everyone to do something fun yeah like you're the guardian you're barely doing anything with they're always there so that's really your only quest uh but you have everyone potentially running over here and talking to all the people and it's like oh okay well i talked to the blacksmith's wife i talked to the boxings i talked to the carpenter and i talked to the priest and three of them did nothing and one of them gave us the quest we needed so now let's all run back i can't imagine that'd be too fun honestly i think the reason we might like it as much as we potentially do is because we didn't have two other people [ __ ] doing nothing right yeah and you know even even the the chapter that did the big split you know basically you pick one or the other yeah because you can only talk to the people once and then they're gone yeah so you can't pursue both even if you had enough people to do it right yeah that's that's a good point and then just but that gives everyone yeah and everyone has their own special abilities um by that by chapter four everyone gets a new special ability yeah honestly in a two-player game i felt we had more than enough like two of them you had something you were doing then the other two i was
doing everything yep so you have one person doing the quest and the other one is support yeah yeah it feels like it's just made too much of a compromise between literature and mechanic yeah um and i don't know i can't think of a way to do it better i can't think of a couple of tweaks that'll fix it not with the the board being the way it is yeah i think the advent calendar board is actually a hindrance on its storytelling yeah because it locks too many possibilities down right it's like well you drew the art and and some of them you flip over and it's something else underneath like oh hey this is nothing you flip it now it's a carriage or you remove it and then there's something from that layer i think that's super cool yeah design wise but the way the mechanically the way it works is very few possibilities yeah and you always know what those possibilities are exactly so even on multiple playthroughs you're kind of like well i know exactly well the carriage is going to be here on this chapter so we need to be here whenever it shows up and then beat it up and the only real strategic difficulty is achieving the goals means going all over the place and sometimes hunting around randomly until you start getting some lucky good information yeah and two of them we finished just by luck right pulling the right cubes out of the bag at the right time yeah that's true um so speaking of the bag otherwise otherwise it would have been doing the same thing again yeah again and again yes for the same outcome which i don't
like to do yeah uh hell even if i'm not recording i definitely don't like doing it for the channel because it says hey thank you for watching this two hour video and you watch me do the same thing um but i don't even do it if i'm not recording because it's like i don't want to waste my actual time this is [ __ ] okay yeah we did it let's just see what happens i did play mansions of madness once where this particular scenario ended up being coincidentally i could tell it wasn't geared this way but it ended up being you know the first half was all investigation and then the second half was just a slugfest against the main villain sure and and that doesn't color my perception of the game because i could tell that wasn't how it's supposed to be this one it really seems to come down to okay you got to keep drawing from the bag until this happens right and that's it yeah and and combat is an exhilarating um no it's it's literally well it's a fumble around in this bag of every component in the entire game and okay one one one okay got him yep and then you just throw those off and then like okay flip it hey i got him okay that gives it oh wait no i can't get it hold on let me get my tool to flip it and that's two i already knew what that was okay that's a bag that's a money bag we're never going to save that because it's valuable but for us to use it right now yeah hmm the bag the bag this is stupid this is such a stupid idea like i don't mind the bags for for the
it it seems like he wants to he wanted to be a minimalist so you put every thing in the bag and it's all here and it doesn't really matter you just have to fumble around be like okay there's the disc robin goes okay do your one thing the guy of gizmos okay well now i drew the red one and then now i have to reach in and draw one of those discs discs thin discs cardboard yep oh there's and they all stick together because they're cardboard to be fair everything in the bag is a distinct shape so if you'd think it would be really easy to just grab what you're looking for right but it turns out that it's really not cubes are all at the bottom yes okay so i just need to dig through every everything yeah everything they're all in the corner and then you have to weirdly yeah you have to pinch them and then be like oh hey look at two white cubes and then it's bizarrely difficult to when there's five six cardboard discs in the bag and one wouldn't to find that last wooden disk yeah and you really don't have to if you know because you're just like okay well the blue one's left so let me just look in here and find it um i'm not the biggest fan of bag drawing anyway especially like with cardboard tokens like my quacks of kwedlenberg is are plastic they're the upgraded plastic pieces because drawing cardboard it's like they're all sweaty and stuck together and it's just [ __ ] um and then vagrant song pisses me off because the bag is tiny so you're like pinching and then they never mix so in my arkham horror i upgraded and now they're like glass and metal with the
design embedded i got them off etsy and it's a bigger bag so it's easier to grab that stuff but this was just more annoying and did never really make a whole lot of sense like why it was all just shoved into one bag it's not that it doesn't work it does like just mechanically yeah it could have just two bags yeah or i mean you know kind of a different shuffle in reality we didn't even need to shuffle those in the bag you just make a stack and set them off to the side because they only come out when the red ones do so then you're like okay that's true i mean i guess because they have a different design you could theoretically memorize which ones they are be like oh we have a snake symbol coming up that's going to be this this and this but that would also work with the all the other stuff that you know that you shouldn't know about the board yeah so ultimately i think it kind of comes down to this is not a horrible game to play once i do not see any reason to ever play it again yeah like i've played the pandemic legacy like three times like season one three times and have have had a blast every single time um and then uh that's really chill and i'm glue maven i've technically played a few times uh for different groups i've played um three different um uh sleeping guides sleeping gods yeah and all those games you're like man i want to come back yeah this one i'm like it wasn't the worst time but each time we finished a chapter i
was thinking i wasn't thinking that was how fun that was i was thinking one one down yep almost done yep yeah it it did start feeling like an endurance test yeah not just like oh what do we need to do now it's right what do we need to do this time yeah how okay yeah okay we need parchment and probably run all the way over there yep and then well i bet we're gonna have to go back to this wagon wheel for some reason right yeah and i think there was even times where you were like oh do you want to investigate this is there any reason no because there's not yeah it's a very very streamlined quest you go to this person you go and do this except for the times when you have to figure out where to go and do it too late like that disappeared well you can't get in the castle now right which huh looking at the re-reading the items i was like oh nope there was very much a way we could have easily gotten in because it told us exactly what to do but we just forgot what a item did otherwise we wouldn't even bother with that yeah that was that was your second alternative way to get in yeah but i don't even know how you get like that actual item without going and trading um first chapter we got it from because we started in there yeah um yeah yeah we know we had to find a way in did you guys find a way and that that was a huge oh i think i did because weren't you like you were trapped in there yeah you were in the castle i was out that sounds that was that was the first
yeah it started off with promise i think it actually kind of ended very very poorly now i think about it the overall story yeah like disappointing yeah more than see again it just feels like too many compromises for it to be exciting and it's it ends up being disappointing because it came close yeah it's like oh fourth place in the olympics yeah you almost got them you can see it your name is almost up there with everybody else's but better luck next time um well with that being said on a scale of one to ten what would you give the adventures of robin hood crap um six six i initially thought a six but i think i'm gonna drop it down to a five i think it ended up being pretty average it didn't it's not that it overstayed it's welcome but it's overstayed it's welcome like it's like it's hard to nail down yeah it's like it was seven chapters it could have been longer but it could have been shorter yeah like if if you really wanted to like do the the split in like your story then make that from the get-go like make your choices matter the entire time and not just one time yeah i could see that but that would also take a whole lot more preparation sure and literature sure but i mean wouldn't you want your game to have staying power i don't think this
game has staying power right i think it's in which case you could release more scenario books played the same mechanics and board well no you have to make a new board well but yeah i wouldn't want to right i know but that's the thing is like he basically did shoot himself on the foot by making the advent calendar yeah it's very very cool good idea it just doesn't quite i mean it's executed extremely poorly because your your board is destroyed by the end of your first game but uh yeah i mean and i know there's there's very specific tiles that we haven't flipped like um that would come up i think if you're yeah if you're playing in plus mode if the other two stories we didn't do yeah um but it's kind of like i don't really care like to to see what that is because while the writing isn't bad it's also not the best like i didn't feel like i was really reading a storybook right like this had some story sections in it but it was largely um like oh hey you know put a ribbon here so you can remember a rule which i do appreciate yes and i think and i love
and the fact that the book specifically calls it out hey place the golden ribbon here so you can remember what your special ability is place the red one here so you know what your objective is like brilliant yes and the fact that he kept it concise where um your your chapters were at the beginning of the section and then all the tiles that you can explore are in the back um so uh so i mean there's there's more good things but i think overall it's not that there's major bad things except i think an actual bad thing is the tile flipping yeah uh the rest is a very lackluster and i and i probably wouldn't want to play it again yeah big step up for mandor though oh yeah yeah and or i can't remember exactly what we gave andor but andor tanked hard yeah this this uh this flatlined yeah like it was i like the first couple scenarios i was like oh this is pretty neat but then once the allure of the flipping of tiles kind of wears off then you're like okay yep now i'm kind of over it with you there so well that's our thoughts on the adventure of robin hood let us know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you hey everyone thank you for watching i really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever i upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top tens
or whatever i feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you