A Quicker GWT Experience | Great Western Trail: El Paso Quick Review
Transcript
hello everyone and welcome back to the board gaming doctor my name is Phil and I'll be your board game doctor today this video is going to be a quick review on El Paso or Great Western Trail El Paso the newest game by Fister Alexander Fister that is a more streamlined version of Great Western Trail I have played Great Western Trail a few times but not enough to really understand the nuances that that game provides as it is one of the most beloved games in the hobby so hence this is why this is going to be more of a quicker review and a review of someone who does respect the original game uh also knowing that I have not played the game with the expansion Railways to the north I believe it's called and the other newer versions Argentina New Zealand Etc just I've I've just played the base game and this and this is now available as of today with this recording on beta in beta on board game arena so anyone can play it so in this game it mirrors a lot of what you do mechanically in Great Western Trail where you travel around this smaller board visiting these buildings taking advantage of the actions gaining resources and using cards from your hand such as the uh Cowboy the engineer you've got the worker as well the Builder pardon uh and you also also have your cattle cards as
well that you're kind of doing some deck building with to go around and gather more points in different ways such as by building more buildings acquiring better cows for your deck and U and fulfilling objectives essentially that are uh found here some major differences uh and some people might be able to find some minor ones or more nuanced ones but some major differences include one the uh streamlined and cut down version of the board you are missing a lot of those alternate paths and outlaws that uh are seen in the bigger game you essentially have less uh places that you can place your buildings and not a lot of roadblocks as you saw in the past game another big difference is the rail track or Railway track I forget exactly what it's called it's replaced in this game by a deck of train cards that you can use with your uh engineer and you essentially uh can grab these uh train cards that are uh you know shuffled and variable as a market to utilize its effect and so the way that you acquire some of these building cards too is different it is essentially you know you pay money to grab these cards it's there's no job market which randomizes the offering of different workers or types of workers that you have in the game uh in this game it's uh more I
guess driven by the buildings that you see and uh and objectives that you have uh as well you also have these bonus tiles that you can uh grab mostly from the Builder track here or the uh cards that you get from the sorry the uh um engineer so and you go around until all the cimel cards are out of uh play and have been acquired and then the game ends rather than in the original game when the job market gets to a certain point and this also has a solo mode which I have not played I have played multiplayer such as this game and and uh but yeah so take that as it were as a quick uh comment on the peer review I've seen mixed reviews for this game that you know a lot of people have said who enjoy the depth and Nuance of Great Western Trail having a sort of lack lust experience with this game a lot of that Nuance has been cut out and the decision space isn't as large whereas other people enjoy this experience because of the opportunity that you get to play the mechanisms of Great Western Trail at a more streamlined and quicker pace and so if you do have less time or are playing some with someone who is not familiar or ready for the full Great Western Trail experience you do have this game to introduce some of those ideas the interesting thing too to note is how
board game arena has these games uh listed in terms of these categories such as complexity strategy luck and interaction now it's a straight three out of five for Great Western Trail versus El Paso which right now is listed at a 35 and a two for complexity strategy luck respectively and no interaction whatsoever uh I don't know if that is completely true and so you know take this with a grain of salt but I think a lot of the luck is reduced in El Paso because of the lack of the job market the randomization does come in the train cards as well as the buildings and objectives and bonuses that are offered and different from game to game uh the complexity is listed as about the same I would say this is definitely a less complex game so I don't know why this is out of three minimum and uh the strategy is off the off the charts here which I think is uh not accurate I think Great Western Trail is a more strategic game it probably has a little bit more luck involved as well but that once again that's coming from someone who is relatively naive to the Great Western Trail experience if I were to compare this game to some other iterations it's interesting to have a game like Pirates of marra Kaio being a second more streamlined experience compared to Mar Kaio the base game I do feel like those two games are different
enough that uh I I don't know I I guess Pirates Amic Kaio is a quicker more streamlined experience but I don't feel like that's the right comparison to make for Great Western Trail and El Paso I think another thought is the differences between terysa and Teran NOA I think that is a closer example to what this feels like I've played both Tera mystica and teranova which are both on board game arena as well and teranova I think does take the complexity way down farther than the difference is compared to Great Western Trail and El Paso but it very much is similar in its approach where it's essentially the same game but with a lot of fat cut out to make it once again more streamlined look in the Rosenberg Universe I think another interesting comparison would be to Black Road or uh glass Road and black forest which is the opposite of what happened in chronologic release with glass road coming out first and then Black Forest being the more complex and grandiose game coming afterwards but it's essentially a very similar experience when you compare those two games to this comparison where many of the mechanisms are shared but there are tweaks in some of the mechanisms to make the game shorter essentially and I feel like that is another similarity so for my final review without going into each of these areas one by one I give this game a 7.3 out of
10 I think this is a fun game it like its bigger brother Great Western Trail is a game that I don't find as fun maybe partly because of the theme but also you know the mechanisms as well I kind of mentioned that before but I you know I I think I would prefer to come back to El Paso more just because it's a that I can more feasibly bring to the table and or play online with other people I do think that this game has legs because of the variability that comes with the buildings and objectives for some of course it's not going to be as deep of an experience that they're looking for and may not replace the experience that you get with Great Western Trail but I think this game as others have said will be a good option to either introduce to other folks the me Ms that are used in Great Western Trail or just to play as a standalone game and have a good time I yeah I think I think it's easy to learn relatively easy to learn and retain the rules it has enough variability and I think replayability based off of that variability and timing to make this game a good one it's just not exactly what I'm looking for in board games if I am being uh specific about what I like and don't like so still I think this is a good rating at 7.3 three out of 10 for me for El Paso thank you for listening or watching this video rather and comment down below what you think about El Paso give it a shot on board game arena and thank you for Consulting with
me and Hope you join me on a future video take care