Skip to main content
Loading video...

New York Zoo Review - Chairman of the Board

Transcript 11:00

hey everyone today i'm taking a look at new york zoo which is a one to five player tile placement board game designed by uv rosenberg and published by capstone games this one takes around 30 to 60 minutes to play depending on that player count now as you'd probably expect from a mr rosenberg game this one is a polyamino style game that looks like this when it's on the table where you have this big communal longboard here where all these different tiles have been semi-randomly laid out on these different notches in the board here where you have these smaller tiles kind of covered up by the larger tiles at least the ones with the biggest surface area and you've also got this elephant marker here which is going to be the almost like the player piece where people are moving around to determine which actions you're going to take and also each player is going to have their own individual zoo which is going to start off as a basically a bare bit of land with a couple of houses here which lets you kind of um manage your kind of intake and outtake of animals and also you've got your little kind of actions breakdown here additionally you have all the different animal meeples which will come into play a bit later you've got five different types here ranging from these penguins to these flamingos meerkats these arctic foxes and these kangaroos and also you've got these attraction tiles which is another way you're going to end up trying to fill up your board because the objective of this game is to be the first player to completely fill up every single square on your personal zoo so the way you're going to fill up your zoo is of course by placing these tiles and when you do that depending on the player count you're going to move a number of spots around this rondelle so you can see here i've basically mocked

up a three player game here but i'll only be using one player board and in a three-player game you move one to three spaces around that rondelle so i could go let's say one two three or i could just stop here if i wanted to now these spots here these these darker spots do not count towards your movement spots and also if any bays become empty then that will also not count towards your movement so you're only going to be counting these full bays here or the blue ones now let's just say i stopped here with these tiles now i'm going to take the topmost tile and i'm going to place it somewhere on my board so let's just do this without really thinking about it like so and once i do that i can choose to either move um one or two types of the same animal into this enclosure so let's just say i put this meerkat in it like this taking up one individual square but if i had another enclosure on the board with a meerkat on it or at least more than one makeup on it i could move that one into there as well to try and fill up that tile faster now if i ever land on one of these blue spots i'm going to take a number of animals either one or two of the matching type and put them onto my player board so you can see here we've got the arctic fox and the flamingo we're going to take the arctic fox and flamingo so let's say about the flamingo here i can either put them into this house here this kind of storage area inside or i could put it on an existing tile where flamingos already are so i could go like this for example or i could put it on an empty closure if there is one so i could say put this arctic fox here like this now why are we trying to fill up these spaces

the reason why we're trying to fill up these spaces completely with animals is because once it's completely complete we're going to remove those animals and potentially if we want to put one on an empty house if we have that option and then you're going to claim one of these attraction tiles which will help you fill up your board a lot quicker so let's just say i managed to fill up this box this um this five tile here with arctic foxes then i could take maybe this big one here and fill up a big chunk of my map like so now you may have also noticed these dark spaces here now whenever the elephant piece moves past one of those ones bearing in mind that is not one of your movement points to do so then all the players are going to have a look at that animal type and refer to their player board and see if you have at least two of that animal type in an enclosure so you can see the flamingos we've just passed we'll have a look at our flamingo enclosure there's two flamingos in there so therefore they're going to breed and create another flamingo and you can do that twice as long as you have you know two enclosures with at least two of the animal type in it or maybe more depending on the player count but that's generally how that mechanism works and that is essentially how the game works going to keep either breeding animals or placing tiles until somebody has completely filled up every single square and that player is going to be declared the winner okay so let's go in some thoughts on new york zoo so as you might know uber rosenberg is very much known for these poly amino style games and all of these games seem to have a very slight little twist on the last and they're not massively different of course the twist

on this game being that animal breeding mechanism you know when you place these animals and you have at least two then they're going to duplicate and fill up these tiles and i think that's quite a cool mechanism but particularly because you have that conundrum of wanting to get the big tiles down because they're going to fill up a lot more ground and cover up your wood quicker but the smaller tiles are good or they go hand in hand better with the animals because they're going to fill up a lot quicker and because of course the bigger tiles have a lot more spaces and therefore they're slower to build up additionally you want to be making sure that you always have that efficiency going where you've got at least a pair of animals on on a tile because when you're crossing these regions you will be making sure that you're always duplicating and not missing out on that and um you know weighing that up and knowing how to be efficient with that is quite an important decision because if other all the other people are breeding and you're not then you're going to be slowly falling behind and because of course this is essentially a race game and i like the fact that you know you need you do need to weigh up that decision of am i going to try and get these big towels down and fill up that big surface area or am i going to maybe pick up some smaller tiles with the aim of filling that with animals quicker to clean these attraction tiles because these attraction tiles are really good and particularly when you get them early because the early ones you're going to end up getting these massive ones you can fill up a lot of space but also these smaller ones are useful later in the game because they help you fill up these little nooks and crannies that you might not be able to feel otherwise there's also an additional decision of how to manage your little house buildings here because whenever you complete a building or

complete a tile full of animals you can actually place a remaining animal on there if there is that space available which can be important because when you place a future tile you want to be able to move things in there straight away and if you have duplicates you can move them both in there and then start breeding again so that little bit of efficiency does come through on how to manage these animals but it's not terribly complex and i like the way that this game has such a clear endgame and game objective you know you you don't have to fuss around with points or there's no fiddly convoluted rules it's just who can get those spaces filled up the quickest and everybody is going to understand that objective now i will say i feel the game goes on a little bit too long not terribly long but because i think you come out the gate so strong with this game by picking up all the massive tiles on top and then the tiles below start getting smaller and smaller it has that weird pacing where you know you feel off that you're starting strong but then it kind of starts bringing itself to a halt and starts i'll just start slowing down now i understand the board is going to get tighter and tighter and therefore you're going to need those smaller enclosures to fill those gaps but it just does feel a little bit weird up time of the game is pretty decent you know the decisions aren't massive here you know you only got like one well one to three spaces or maybe one to four spaces to move around this rondelle so your options are limited and i do like the fact that when people do go past these spots at least you have some engagement there of wanting to you know breed your animals and and you know place more animals on your personal board so you do have that level of investment on what the other players do now the player interaction really does come through by the race of the game

because you want to be kind of looking over your shoulder to see how well people are doing and trying to beat them to the punch um but additionally you're going to be competing over the same towels because you know you might want people to only move one space because you're next because you want the tile that's three spaces away so there is that kind of passive interaction that way additionally there is that competition of filling up your tiles because you want to get the particular attraction tiles down as quickly as you can because they are limited you know especially these bigger ones there's only one of each of these and so you want to be making sure you're getting those first so that's really where the competition lies the production of the game is a mixed bag really it looks lovely at a glance i would say that the setup and things was a little bit annoying because you've got to place all these tiles on top of each other and they're not the easiest to differentiate from each other yes you can go the size but it just becomes a bit of a chore ready to set everything up because they're also kind of similar in the way they look additionally the meeples themselves look fantastic they're really intricately designed and they're wonderful really but the problem is that they are very small and quite fiddly and when you start placing them on your board here you get to knock things over and things it's it's very fiddly especially when you start getting in gaps like this um and if you have big hands like i do it becomes even more problematic but other than that i mean i do like the uh the look of the game these boards are fine they're just like basically cardboard um but everything else is perfectly up to scratch you know the attraction towels look good and the tiles themselves are not too big but they're still quite durable and it doesn't take up too much space apart from the actual main board itself but yeah i'm generally happy with the production just a little bit fiddly

um when it comes to completely cramming in all these meeples on your player board okay so final thoughts on new york zoo this is a game that is what it is really i'm not terribly excited by it if i'm honest it's just another polyomno game with a little twist on it in terms of breeding these animals and i do like that in theory i think it's quite a cool idea and you know how to use them and how to manage that most efficiently to make sure that you're triggering every single time is quite a cool decision and it's something you need to manage accordingly um but i don't think it's enough to make it feel um different enough and to make it stand out amongst the pack of so many great tile placement games now i am saying that through the eyes and kind of perspective of a more kind of seasoned gamer i've played hundreds and hundreds and hundreds of games but i played this with um with relatively inexperienced gamers who've not played many games at all and they had an absolute blast with it so i am kind of being objective that way and thinking you know it definitely has an audience who are going to enjoy this one um but for me it just didn't feel like it had enough going on for it to make it appealing appealing to me personally especially it became a bit of a chore to set up it becomes a bit of a chore to actually move things around and things again it's just so filling you knock things over all the time and they go everywhere so that for me was a bit annoying um but other than that it's a fine game i do think there's other rosenberg games that are better um in this genre i think patchwork is still um head and shoulders of the rest um but that's just my opinion but yeah there we go it's a it's a game that's going to be good for families it's got a nice visual look to it um lovely production um

if you if you can have um small enough fingers to move things around but other than that it's just not terribly inspiring to me personally but i can't really fault it objectively i like the clear objective of of trying to be the first one to fill up your board but other than that it's just a bit of a a bit of a meh for me that is new york zoo by ube rosenberg

Progress saved