Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 24:48

Some viewers may find the following video disturbing. Viewer discretion is advised.

Hey everyone, welcome back to Board Games Online and today I'm doing a discussion over 20 Strong Etherfields. This is the last one in the Awaken Realms set that Chip Theory has released and I finally have had a chance to play through all of them and I am very happy to say that Nemesis was the only one that I actively disliked. I and if you go watch my discussions on both of them, I obviously explain why. But between those three, if you had asked me which one I you would, you know, which one I thought I'd dislike the most, it would probably be Etherfields. And that is mainly because the board game version of this was the one of the most disappointing games that I had ever played, especially from Awaken Realms. I have since repurchased the board game cuz at that time they had not basically redesigned the whole game and I didn't want to pick it back up, but I have done that, but I haven't had a chance to retry it. So I'm going off of old memories of Etherfields, which was the theme was really cool, but the mechanisms and it was a slog before other campaign games came out that were even more of a slog.

All that being said this, along with Tainted Grail and even Nemesis to some extent, I had no idea how Chip Theory was going to implement this in their 20 Strong system with their 17 dice and push your luck element and so on and so forth. And out of all of them I think this is the one that actually captures the board game. So, they could have done it with the other two, but Tainted Grail they wanted to make it all about the combat, and Nemesis they didn't even try. Um with Etherfields, this actually to me pushes the limit on what they could do with their 20 strong system. Uh some of their and and they definitely took some aspects from their Tanglewood system, mainly through the aspect of every single card that is in Etherfields can flip to another side. So, every card is double-sided when it comes to the influence deck, the items, the enemies, the map, and the bosses. All of them flip. However, unlike the Tanglewood set, with this being actually fun, uh the the flipping of the items or items of the cards is persistent from game to game from forever. As long as you are playing 20 strong Etherfields, you will be permanently making changes to your next game. I guess permanently means,

you know, the card will stay flipped. So, for example, if you flip the, you know, you do the effect of the flashlight and it tells you to flip this, your next game, you will not have a flashlight, you will have a train ticket. And the train ticket's effect does not flip uh flip this back, so you would have to have something else flip it back over so you can have the flashlight. So, for the foreseeable future, you will have a train ticket and no flashlight. For the foreseeable future, your map cards, if they are flipped, if you had an effect that flipped them or something, they will now be that. Bosses that you fight, until you beat them, they will stay as that element. And I think that is probably the coolest thing that they have done with any of these these games.

Um whenever it came to the Tainted Grail one, I was curious how they were going to implement the exploration, the moving, the narration element, and they basically said, "Fuck that. We're just going to do the combat." Which again, I absolutely loved with the Tainted Grail. But they did it with Etherfields. This again, now the only thing I can actually say that they didn't really take from Etherfields based off my memory is one, they took out the in-between dream section, which sucked, which apparently has been virtually removed from the board game. Uh but also, you're not going to a specific dream and interacting with uh with whatever that dream might be about. And obviously, that couldn't be the case here, but they did a pretty damn good job on giving you that sense of, "Okay, you're actually moving around a map."

Although, I will say that moving around the map, it's not exciting. Again, Etherfields, the strongest thing it had going for it was its theme and the dream aspects. When you finally got to do a dream, it had some gimmick or some sense of exploration that was confined to that dream. Uh you're not getting that here. So, even though you're moving around the map, it's not as exciting. Really, what you're kind of doing when you're moving is you are looking for specific map sections that allow you to modify the ether, uh which is the color dial again, which again, I'll explain how this works. So far, anytime they've used the color side of the of the round track, it's gone really well for me. I've always really enjoyed that.

Um but there is still a sense of exploration. You actually don't have your own deck of cards. You're not using uh you're not using the dice in weird ways. They found a really awesome way to blend the dice again without it being a insane luck fest of just, you know, spend play 30 minutes and roll dice. You do have the influence deck, which is just a you'll always have a hand of five cards. This kind of feels more free to play because it's not so railroaded. Essentially, the game is broken up into two phases, the influence phase and then the opposition phase. And the influence phase is when you draw up to your hand size, and then you just kind of do actions as long as you have the economy to do so.

And that is exploring, which is revealing more cards of the map. That is interacting with action spaces, which could give you items, it could let you modify the ether, it could let you move from one space to another, it could let you flip the map, whatever it might be. And this is where you are both using these multi-use cards for their attributes up at the top, or you can actually use your dice for stuff other than rolling. Uh so, for example, if I needed to move, uh if I needed one cunning to move one space, I could either discard a card that has one one or more cunning, or because cunning is yellow, I can actually take one of the yellow dice and move them over.

If you need to explore, you can get rid of cards that give you the explore resource, or you can get rid of green dice. And exhaust them. But, you're making all those decisions knowing that you won't have them until you actually get to the opposition phase and you fight some of the enemies. But, it's so nice to see them actually come up with a use for the weak dice, the really bad green or yellow dice that only are have some benefit if you happen to have an item that buffs them. In fact, there's actually a card in here that makes the green dice really powerful, and that is the um the gambling uh the gambling card, where if if you apply a crit on a green or yellow die, you can reroll that die, and if it's a hit, you just defeat the enemy.

And this is a really powerful card, and you know, it sometime it might actually get flipped. So, it's it's really really cool that they finally found a way to utilize the dice in a way other than just rolling them and seeing if you get lucky. Um so, I really like the fact that even though the map exploration is not super thematic, uh 20 Strong is never meant to be thematic. It is literally a push-your-luck dice chucker.

[snorts]

Um but I love the fact that you can do as many actions as you want as long as you have the capability to spend the resources for them, and the influence deck is very powerful. I know in the board game, you had your own deck, each player had their own deck. So, I guess effectively that is why, cuz this is solo only, that it that this deck is effectively a upgraded kind of version of your own deck in the board game. And they also found a way to temper the enemies because you will pull out enemies uh that are just kind of there. Sometimes the enemies are there's no specific phase of okay, I've done all my movement, time to go to the fight phase. I mean, that is kind of what it does, but the enemies will come out uh before, and sometimes they might even pop out more, which could just be a atmosphere uh, enemy. Like one of the uh, first ones is the in what in the tutorial if you do it is the ball lightning.

And that is just there to be a nuisance. Uh, but you don't have to deal with it right away. You get to see the enemies come out. If you move into a space that has an uh, a skull icon, then you would add more. And when you're done playing your cards or holding on to cards to use them for combat or anything, then you can finally go to the engagement phase. And each boss will have kind of a passive effect that it will need uh, to that might exhaust some dice. It uh, might make you discard cards from the top of the influence deck. And then you go to your standard 20 Strong system where you will choose to how many dice you want to commit, very free uh, form how Tainted Grail or Solar Sentinels kind of does things.

And then you're rewarded with items or stat buffs or whatever it might be. So that is more familiar to what 20 Strong typically has. But I love the fact that you're able to just kind of if you see the enemies that are coming out and you think that you might not have a good shot with them, uh, you might be able to get to a map location and activate uh, a space that could end up being beneficial to you. And then a lot of times whenever you're defeating enemies, what's also cool is if they do flip, sometimes they might flip to an actual card in your deck or they might flip to an item. Like that's really, really neat. It's not just an AB side of monsters. It's you know, or AB side of items. They could items could flip to be enemies. It's just a really awesome system that they've done here.

Uh and then what's also kind of cool is there's no set timer in this one, which is kind of interesting. So, you do kind of have something you have to keep in mind and that is every time you have to draw from the influence deck and you can't cuz at the beginning of each round you draw five cards and if you can't, you have to either take two damage or banish two cards. So, eventually you can't just just explore until you just become super OP. Eventually the you will either have no health to take and you'll just lose or you'll have no cards to banish of which you would have to then take two damage and then you would just probably lose. So, there is a sense of urgency, but it's not so much so that you know you're going to have five rounds to do something or like in the Nemesis one, hey it's 10 rounds and each of us tick the you know, tick the timer down or if you're playing solo, then yeah you just have 10 rounds to get out. Uh but the boss has a condition that has to be met that is the ether needs to be in a certain color or and and something else might be the the first boss you fight has needs the ether to be red and it starts on yellow.

So, you have to tick it you have to find map locations that you can activate that will say, hey if the ether is yellow turn it to green. If it's green, then turn it to blue. If it's blue, purple, purple, red, now you're ready to go fight the boss. Um but other bosses I don't want to spoil everything because this game kind of has a spoiler element, but other bosses will require more things other than just find the same map locations and flip and and turn the dial. So, I really think that that's super cool and you just will have a different variety of options every time you're coming to play. Uh the the way that the boss or the characters work is also cool cuz they have a they have their non-lucid side and their lucid side, which makes them really powerful.

And that's super awesome. And the thing about the ether that I also like is depending on the color at the dice recovery step, you will recover equal to your recovery die, but you'll also at least recover one die based off the color of the ether. So, if it's purple, you'll gain at least one purple die. So, it gives you a little bit more freedom to use some dice more than you normally would. You don't have to kind of hem haw around what you might want to use. You can at least throw in a purple if the ether's that purple and then some other dice if hey, this enemy has four health or it has six health. Okay, I'll throw in one purple and my recovery's three, so I'll throw in three blue while I'm at it. So, at the very least if I kill it with that roll, which I definitely wouldn't have with this, but oh hey, there's four damage or whatever. That's what I needed to kill it.

Uh you're going to get these dice back. You can get the purple back and then you can get the the blue back. And I just really like that. I think with this one in Tainted Grail, they made it less punishing for using dice, so they kind of mitigated a little bit of the luck. I mean, there's still not a whole lot of rerolls except in this game, you have items as well as cards you can play in your hand that could let you reroll or items that might have passive effects that hey, if you spend a um you know, a cunning not a cunning and awareness, then you can reroll two dice. Whatever it it might be. Those are just you have your items and then you have your cards and I like having both of those.

So, surprisingly, the Etherfields one, which is the one I was the least excited about, ends up being probably the best 20 strong experience uh because they actually did something with with the IP. This Nemesis I felt just was devoid of anything. It was It was IP It was Nemesis in theme alone and I felt that none of the mechanisms were actually enjoyable, especially the semi-cooperative part was just so empty. The Tainted Grail had phenomenal uh combat because it's all It was only combat. It was basically solar sentinels just with the Tainted Grail theme and card combo, which I loved.

But so but it wasn't anything really like the board game. But the Etherfields one, they actually kind of did it. They They sucked out the shitty parts of the board game back when I first played it. And then they uh you know, they put in some effort and did something even cooler cuz I don't remember a card flipping element in the board game. So, it might be there. I don't remember. But they They were able to capture the theme at least on the art and then add an extra element of permanent card flipping uh from game to game. So, I mean, this is the first 20 strong box that people's experiences and uh is going to be completely different just because of the sheer nature of hey, I got this item or I got this enemy that now flipped and he's flipped in my game.

So, this is a really cool system. I I can't stress that enough on how much I was not necessary I wasn't really looking forward to the Etherfields one. Uh but I remembered how the board game was and had especially after Nemesis, I had zero hope that they were going to do anything good with any of them. So, I'm very happy to say that Tainted Grail and Etherfields are they they kind of did a fantastic job with the putting it into the 20 Strongs um system. I mean, I guess the only negative on this one I could think of is again, your goal is still to pump the ether around and what's nice is that whenever you uh whenever you do move them to the the color that you're needing, well, depending on the effect of it, um a well, a good example is one of the maps tells you to move blue to purple.

And if you do, well, it costs you five awareness to do that, but if you do that, then you get to recover all your purple. So, it's another way for you to get all your dice back without relying on your um recovery stat. But, you can't really use purple or red or blue for anything as a resource. You can use your red one, no, sorry, you can use your red one as your wrath. Which is another uh attribute you can spend to just outright deal get rid of enemies, uh which is really cool again. But, you can also if you flip that map tile, then it'll be cheaper cunning, sorry, it'll be cheaper awareness, but you don't get to recover the dice, which could be beneficial if you have all your purples ready, then okay, I'll I'll use this item that lets me flip the flip the map tile, and great, now I'll use this uh oh, what's it called? So many possibilities card, and use the three awareness on that to now set that to red, or set it to purple, and in my most recent game, I had a way to actually I had to spend a cunning not a cunning, an awareness, uh which I could use a green die for, and that would let me draw two map cards, and decide which one I wanted to place, so that gave me a lot of of uh agency on which which uh tiles I was actually putting down, and I was able to get a lot of the ether manipulation all within one section, so I was able to kind of go in a

counter-clockwise circle, and then up to the area where I needed to activate to fight the boss. So, that might I mean, your your mileage may vary on if you have any way to manipulate that. I guess that's probably the biggest negative, is if you need to get the ether if you need to get the ether to a certain color, and you just have no way of map manipulation, the game might be longer than it might than it's going to be worth. However, uh cuz then you also need to find the map the one map tile that allows you to even encounter the boss. So, again, the weakest aspect of this is the map exploration, cuz it's not really all that thematic, but the fact that it is here, and that is something that's from the board game, it trumps anything that the Tainted Grail and Nemesis even tried to do. I guess Nemesis does have map exploration, but it's boring and un-fun. Uh but this is at least strategic, and with the multi-use cards, having them having uh instant effects, or ways for you to make them items.

It's just It's so cool. This one is is an awesome awesome, uh, implementation. Which kind of bums me out cuz that that means they could have done They probably could have done it with Well, I don't Now they I feel like they could have done it with Tainted Grail. Uh, maybe not because there's there's a lot of enemy decks and I don't know how you would actually do that. You would pretty much I I guess what they were trying to do is make every single game feel different from one another, which I will say even with Nemesis included, it they all do feel different from one another. So, I guess if they did try to do this map exploration with Tainted Grail, then it would basically be They'd probably have to do it exactly like this.

Just without the cool card flipping. So, yeah, I guess I guess they I they they couldn't have done it with Tainted Grail. Or really with any of their other games. So, I guess something some good did come from the Tanglewood set because that's where they did a lot of that card flipping stuff. And they did it way better here cuz this is an awesome set. Anyway, on a scale of 1 to 10, man, do I Man, I thought Tainted Grail was was the highest up there. Do I like Etherfields more? I think I do. I think this is now hit It's going to be a nine because I still your game can still be varied based off how the dice go. You have a good amount of I love the extra uses. I love the fact you get a little bit more recovery.

They do the dice system justice in here. However, I don't think I can give any If I have, I'd have to modify I don't think I can give any 20 Strong box set a 10 because you could still roll like [ __ ] and then just get wiped. And you could still play this one for 30, 45 minutes, maybe, and roll get to the boss fight and then roll like [ __ ] And that would just be unfun. So, I am going to give Etherfields a nine, which ties it with Tainted Grail and I have my phone on me and Solar Sentinels. Do I have Solar Sentinels? Uh where do I have that sitting at? I know it was number one on my ranking.

Solar Sentinels. That's not even on here. It must just be the 20 Strong system. Well, all that being said, yeah, it's going to be the 20 Strong system. Um I will say that this is now this would go to the top of my 20 Strong ranking. I think they do the combat The combat is a lot of fun here. Uh the enemies aren't OP. The map exploration is serviceable, but it's really the multi-use cards, the freedom to use dice in various ways, and the flipping of cards from game to game is such a cool idea. So, I hope to see that implemented in the future. But, with With all this being said and done with the 20 Strong set, I think that they they killed it with two out of the three, which is more than what I thought they'd be able to do.

So, that's really cool. Anyway, that's my thoughts on 20 Strong Etherfields. Let me know what you think of it in the comments below. Like, comment, share, and subscribe, and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you.

Progress saved