Skip to main content
Loading video...

Kutna Hora: The City of Silver - Board Game Review

Transcript 16:35

welcome to allies or enemies I'm Jess and I am sha and today we are looking at CA hor which is published by cge and designed by and I apologize if I'm not getting these perfect Andre bistan Peter klava and pavl jeros and this copy was supplied by the publisher and we had heard of kahora before the game coming out but it is based on a historical place it's the city is silver and it was over 800 years ago that silver was first discovered in the region and it didn't take long before it was producing onethird of Europe's silver so pretty impressive yeah so it's based on a real place and people here have told us that it's beautiful as well like we talked about this to a few Folks at Essen and they were like oh I went there on a school trip and it was so nice so it also seems like somewhere we want to visit in real life but for now let's visit it in board game and start off with how it plays in kahora players competitively build the city of silver together on your turn you will choose two of the cards in your hand and then use the action on the top or bottom of each of those cards these actions include building mines claiming the rights to build buildings claiming plots of land to build those buildings on and building

those buildings which will do stuff like increase your production of different goods and increase population which can move market prices down or up if you build public buildings it might also impact taxes make petrics available or gain you a token that lets you build the cathedral which brings us to the fifth action which is spending tokens to build the cathedral which gets you bonuses or you can take an income action where you gain money for the goods you make times their current market value and if a pettion is available put them into play these guys gain all players points at the end of each round if certain criteria are met finally there is also a Joker action that lets you do any of the above at a cost most of these things will cost you coins or resources which you have to buy from the market at whatever the current value is which is always shifting at the end of the game players gain points for the amount of income they can create their place on the utation track extra stuff they have left controlling a majority in each row of the mines and how many icons on the buildings they own match the buildings around them and then the greatest builder of cahora is named so that's how it plays but how does it feel and I think the main thing really to talk about here is these guys cuz this is such an interesting Innovative device in the game and actually if you if you want to check out the publisher the designer

diaries for this it's one of the few times that I've done that just to learn about this cuz the early versions of this are insanely complex it's like these crazy like d Vinci esque rings that are connecting and you're turning around it's really something else this is such an elegant Marketplace system and how it works is you saw in the how it plays that you can build various buildings and stuff and all of that will manipulate that market and so there might be times when you're increasing the Notch and that means that there is a lot more available so usually the price will go down but also the population cards will uh go to cards go behind yeah and when that happens that might lead to the prices going up because there's more people wanting more things and you never exactly know we're not going to memorize all 40 cards and all the different states based on The Notches so it's some sometimes a change of the card will be like o look at the price now other times it will stay the same which is really interesting yeah I really like that about this because you know that moving the cards will eventually move it up and so you want to do something especially for this guy here I found this was me a lot of the times when we played but I want to do something to push these back and push these back and I'm just hoping please please go from 3 to 4 please go from 5 to 6 because then when you do your income turn it's based on the amount of the stuff you've got times this so as you get more stuff this goes

down so then you got to get this back up and it has played we've played this like five times now and it has played so differently depending on what stuff we own because only one player can build half the buildings and who actually builds it cuz J last time we played would not build wood and everything got outrageously expensive well because if you are the owner of the building and when you build it you're increasing the supply meaning the price is going to drop and you don't necessarily want the price to drop because that will change your income so it's this tough balance of making sure you have some so you can still get the income for it but not having too many where it drops too much so I I just gave it a test to see if I keep wood price High what does that change and it changed a lot it made like so many things more difficult yeah it made life very very difficult and so there was a lot more mining this is actually we just finished playing it um for our fifth time and just messed with the market and so we did a lot more mining this time because this was so expensive to build these buildings that we did this but it was still fun like that it changed it and it was a little frustrating at times when I was like I really want to make this like silver depository thing but it was still fun to be able to do this and just like eek out my income and build it up so I can build something and it felt like a big event when I actually built something versus other games when this has been packed

and this has had a lot less on it well and I think because the market value impacts everybody that even if you're finding it frustrating to build so is everyone so I think that makes a big difference so I think the market is definitely one of the key factors and it's going to take you like a game to wrap your head around at least yeah so when when we first were introduced to this it was at ukge and we did a demo of a couple of rounds and we felt like it was this really big complex game and then since we've played it we realized it wasn't as like heavy as we thought which I kind of appreciate it cuz on your turn your actions are actually really simple it's just a card play and it's a they've done each card has two different actions and so you almost have to plan out your whole round because if you end up playing a card that has the the the the action you want to do later but you play those early you won't be able to necessarily do it later so that double-sided card makes it interesting too yeah it does and and you're right even though the card thing sounds like it's heavier and it is a really interesting decision cuz all of the actions are on those cards twice except for the uh Cathedral and the Joker action which means that you you can you're going to be able to do things as long as you chain them right but even with that it is way lighter than I remembered it being it's not a light game this is definitely this is like in the heavier part of the midweight I would say like a lost ruins e maybe a

smidge more than that but around that weight I would say so this isn't going to totally melt your brain and it's really way easier to set up way easier to learn than I had expected yeah and the rule book I like that they included a little bit of the history as well yes so it has a bit about the the kahara the city itself but then also the different gilds so if you're interested in that they have included it in the rule book the other key thing to mention I think is the components and look of the game how do you feel about it yeah it looks it looks beautiful these little so it's got these little houses and these little Miners and they're like these like 1200s what you would picture a minor to be like they they are not well protected they just have a a cloth hat on and these little houses are great all of the buildings look really nice it looks nice when you flip them the one thing I'll say I hate this box it's just so plain and everything else is so nice and this is I get what they're doing but maybe if this was shinier I don't know but this box doesn't do it for me but if you don't like the Box don't be fooled the stuff inside's really nice yeah cuz the tokens as well are made I think of a a rewood so a recycled W it's a special thing that they've done and they they look really good the player boards are dual layered so everything stays in place and the tiles themselves because it's the city of silver the buildings that you're putting out flip and they have a Sheen silver side or a Sheen like a Shiny Gold side so and the score track

is like one of the most beautiful score tracks cuz it is super shiny but still really legible so I think they really tried to incorporate like the silver aspect with having like the gold and silver in it the one thing I will say is this is a little tighter than I would like it's already getting a little worn here and that's after what five plays so when you pull them they're just they're a little tighter than I would like um it's a little thing and it's still going to work it's just going to have little Nicks here and there so that is one thing just if you really like things to be pristine this not going to be once you've played this 12 times is not going to be pristine it's just going to have a little wear but you know what that shows that you played it so there's pluses and minuses I guess and the cars though were a lot easier to just move cuz you have to move them all the time and the way the holder is done makes it super easy to slide so I that was really good cuz I think that's a change they may have done since ukg as well was just figuring out like how to slide the cards right yeah the first time that we played it was on a a prototype um how do you think it plays so two players we've primarily played this two players we have played it once with three players uh how do you feel they've adapted it for two players they have made it a two-player game or a three to four player game basically if you're playing two players you use a different side of the board so it makes the mine smaller it makes the city building area smaller as well compared

to the other side which is for three or four where everything is just bigger the other key thing is for two players there's this event deck that you use and it's a super simple card that goes out for each round um so at the end of each round various things will happen so well at the start the tax rate might go up but it often has to do with the building market and it's a way of being able to change the building Market a little bit more so sometimes moving some the buildings to the bottom or to the end of the rows and all of that is pretty important in a two-player game where it might get a little bit stale yeah it's good too because it's a it's a market shifting thing but you don't know how the Market's going to shift because most games have it a two-player just move the stuff at the end but it's nice that it's like sometimes it moves the stuff sometimes it gets rid of buildings it it does it in different sometimes it just shuffles the different Stacks so you can't really plan ahead like you couldn't if you had a third player and playing it at two it just yeah it feels perfectly comfortable and like there's not a lot missing I will say though at 3 or 4 you won't have hopefully you won't have as much of that situation where one person controls something like the wood or the coal and then they're holding on to that um and not moving that up because you'll have two people who control each thing especially at foro two people who control everything so then you got two different chances for people to build stuff so the Market's going to be a little bit more interesting I think and um and you won't be able to like fully manipulate it how

you want to manipulate it cuz someone else is manipulating what you have so I think it would be really fun to play it four and it plays quick enough that four is not going to be a problem yeah because the other difference that I forgot to mention is that two players it's six rounds and even then uh we just still feel at the end like we want to do so much more there's so many times at the end that we wish we just had like two more cards cuz each round you get five actions um but it goes so quickly and so at three or four you're only getting five rounds so I imagine you can't do as much and in terms of replayability what are your thoughts yeah I think the probably the biggest part of the replayability is each game you only have three of these buildings that you are able to build and are like in control of that part of the market and those change each time they got a whole bunch of cards that switch that up and that is by far going to be the biggest part because there's like four buildings of each there's um 12 of these fancy buildings or 15 or whatever there is and we've made sure that we have a different three each time we've played and it has felt quite a bit different yeah cuz there are a few games in a row where I didn't have the wood one and I know that's what sets the price for building so that's why last time I was like whatever I want I want the wood one for sure so that you're right that is the biggest key aspect and because the market is so fluctuating each game is going to be completely different for how

expensive things are what you're building when uh where even the tiles get placed randomly at the beginning like which one is going to be the cheapest well most likely be the one that you'll build first so even just the small bit of how they go out at the very start start that might influence a little bit how how you begin so finally who is this for and I think there's a lot of Gamers who are going to get quite a bit out of this game because it just it fits that nice space where it's it's a little heavier maybe than some folks are used to but not so much heavier where I think they're still really going to be interested in this and get a lot out of it but also it gives enough for those people who want that heavier experience but not at like that that huge kind of exhausting like after you play this you don't need a nap you can play this and still want to play something else yeah I agree it is that right level of complexity if you're not looking for a heavy game but still want a bit of like depth to to a game for sure I do think if you get frustrated at not being in control that this may not be a game for you because if you don't have that Guild or if you do what somebody else also does you know the value of it is going to be so out of your hands and so you're just going to have to make do with what is the best option available at the time and you won't be able to plan for something yeah and there also is there's a lot of math in this because as you're regularly

adding up your income you're doing a lot of multiplying this by this and this by this it was nothing that we found too difficult and the losing control was also something that was I did not have any problem with at all even at the worst where I could not build for like two rounds it was still super fun I don't usually like Market games and I like this and I like the the building is fun and engaging I there there was a lot that I liked about this yeah I I agree and on top of everything you said really the how how it looks I just really like silver and gold shininess and the buildings and the score track and everything and even the like little wooden pieces they it all looks really good uh so I think we'll be playing this a lot more yeah yeah it's very silver and gold Burl lives would love this and I I give it um like four Burl liveses we don't even know what the scale of burl liveses is it's a it's the classic Burl lives scale but thank you so much for watching please let us know in the comments if you've played kahara and as usual please like subscribe and hopefully we'll see you next time for another game J

Progress saved