First in Flight Review - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
hey everybody today I'm going to be taking a look at First in Flight which is a one to four player kind of deck building board game that takes 45 to 75 minutes according to the box now before I get started on my review of First in Flight I want to give a shout out to the show sponsor kendra. co.uk who are my go-to online retailer and if you use the link in the show notes or the QR code then you can get 5% off your first order okay so unlike my usual reviews I'm going to be taking a bit of a shortcut when it comes to the rules overview here because I think I can explain the gist of the game without going into any detail so essentially this is a deck building push your luck Style game with a Time Track um mechanism and the idea is that by the end of the game the end of the four rounds you want to have fly flown your plane further than the other players the game will end again after those four rounds or until somebody hits 40 on the flight track back here now every player is going to have a deck of cards which consists of these different types these standard one flight cards these kind of minor fault cards which are your kind of your pushy luck Target where if you hit four of these you're going to go bust um as well as these upgraded cards which let you fly further than the sted ones and they go up to a value of five there are also these additional ones here which will give you a little booster by adding Cards into your hand um each time they come out of your deck standard deck building
experience just um filtering through your deck and trying to um go as far as you can without drawing those bus cards now the end of the game or the end of the flights is a bit different to other push games because you actually need to call it quits um two cards or before two cars that you'll draw additionally um to see if you'll actually go bust so um I'll explain a bit more about that later now you have some additional things you can buy such as these upgraded characters um other things that will let you manipulate your deck to hopefully let you avoid those fault cards and fly farther or further um each person will also have their own little player sheets here where you'll have a unique character which will give you an ability so in this example Alberto here will give me some money at the start of my turn and once you've hit a certain flight threshold by reaching 15 they will get upgraded um ready to be an improved version of the existing character so on your turn of course each player will have their own player piece which I've been too lazy to get out here you going to land on one of these action spots using this kind of one-way track system and whoever is further back on that track will keep on taking turns until they overtake another player and then again the person at the back will then continue to take turns now each of the actions you can take are fairly simple um such as buying upgraded cards and when you buy them you're going to get these things here and you're going to spend a an amount of money I think it's two coins to draw two cards and keep two but you can spend more than that say spend five coins and then keep keep twoo and you'll
also take one of these fault cards on these special fault cards which are particularly um punishing so you can see here that it says if the next card added to your flight is a one card you remove that one card from your deck so yeah there are particularly nasty cards and you do start with some of them in your deck and these ones here allow you to buy these um special upgrade cards such as new people you can tap each round use their ability as well as some kind of flight abilities which which again will let you manipulate um your deck so this one here it says like when you begin flying you may pay one coin to look at the top three cards of your deck put any number on the bottom and reset the rest so you know an idea of to get rid of those faults if you're going to draw them early you got to take money and make repairs so normally when you um do your flight which again I'll explain later um if you reveal one of these major fault cars they'll go in your little garage here or your Workshop which means when you visit this Workshop action you can spend money to fix it and convert it into a normal fault um so you're not getting hit so hard with these and but you do get a nice little reward when you fix them which is definitely a A plus on the game and you have the flight itself which again we'll touch on shortly um and the any action which will let you take any action on the board but pay an additional coin to do so you draw a one card or one of those experienced cards um draw one of these pilot cards which again will give you some more manipulation tactics look at the top five cards of your deck and return them and look at top three cards
of your deck and return them in any order when you draw a fault card and the previous five cards in your flight have no fault put that that card at the bottom of the deck instead or look at the top four cards of your deck draw two and reshuffle the rest get more money cards more upgrades and so on and again the flight action is where you will um reshuffle any faults back into your deck you'll go through that Pusher luck system drawing cards until you draw four faults and go Bust or until you do um a a landing basically a successful landing and if you land the plane without um going busted at all you'll fly further and of course track your progress on the sheet here hopefully beating the other players by the time it gets to the end of the game and that's essentially how the game works and of course again the player who's flown the furthest at the end of the or by the time the game ends um will be the winner okay sorry for rushing through the rues there but I wanted to get straight into sharing my thoughts on this one because it is a fairly light game and I'm sure you guys get the gist of how this works so um the time track system is generally something I enjoy in board gaming and I think this game does a reasonably good job of giving you the incentive to go further because what I normally don't like in Time Track games is when everybody's going along at snail's Place visiting every single action as they go it kind of defeats the purpose whereas in this one because the kind of flight actions which is the main point of the game um they're not not actually that common on the board sometimes you're incentivized to jump really far to get to it to stop
the other players from getting another flight or of course trying to actually fly further um yourself so this this does actually come through quite nicely again that desire to push further is there now unfortunately that's where the positives end for this game for me um and that is because of one distinctive feature of this game and that is the actual flight system um itself this is a pushy luck Style game of course with that bit of deck building and of course this Action System but the glaring fault with this game is that when you take the flight action you are doing it on your own and not simultaneously with the other players therefore the game completely halts while one player goes through their entire deck and um starts going this big flight and when you start adding in all the special characters and all the abilities and that that can be quite a long and drawn out process while you just sat there doing absolutely uh nothing so I think you can't really talk about this game without talking about some other ones um which are similar such as quacks of quedlinburg you know the reason why that game is so fun is because everybody is doing their Pusher luck at the same time therefore you're kind of you know kind of enjoying your own process you're guarding other players to pushing further and going bust this one it just comes to a complete screeching halt while you just sit there and watch your opponent have fun um and of course they're doing the same for you and you feel bad when it's your turn because it's taking so long um and it just doesn't quite feel right when comparing to those other more enjoyable games and on top of that if
you do manage to go bust on your turn when doing the the flight system you actually lose Time by going along these time tracks and moving your player piece this far along further increasing the amount of downtime so if I do my flight and go bust and jump far far forward then another player has a flight for example by taking an any action you are waiting so long before you get another turn and it just feels really um disengaging and it does take you out of the game quite a lot unfortunately I also feel like a lot of these cards are either really uninteresting or completely um imbalanced because um a lot of the time these things are know look at the top five cards of your deck and reshuffle or not even reshuffle and put them back in the same order you not really got much control there because you're going to put them straight back in the same order and if you're going to go bust you're going to go bust so you can look into the future and it might be useful at the start of the turn um but you know overall it's it's not going going to change the trajectory of your flight rather than maybe preventing going bus by stopping um immediately which is again not too satisfying but these two particular cards I had a bit of an issue with um because one of them I think is objectively better um than the other so one of them I think is quite a cool one where it says you know once per turn you can actually share the action spot of somebody else which can be very useful to get you out of a sticky situation and to guarantee yourself the action that you want whereas the one above it above it which again cost exactly the same amount to purchase we say when moving your Pawn to any action space you can take any action
therefore you can just move one space and take anything you want there is under no circumstances is this card better um than this one which is um very strange for me considering they are the same cost and that's why you know you like kind of internal um you know economy systems to balance these cards out where in this case you know the person is obviously going to take this one over the other one and whilst on paper I do like this flight system this kind of Tide TI line system where you want to go as far as you can um and that's your best score for the remainder of the game so you know even i' I got to say 17 by the end of the second round um if I got to 5ifth 14 after my score will remain on 17 because that's my best flight um so far you know I like that mechanism I think it's cool with games like Coliseum and this one um it kind of Falls flat because if you manage to have a successful flight you know get a reasonably respectable score and then in future rounds you you know completely start your flight negatively you you've got say two faults in your first two cards you know it's going to be an unsuccessful flight you're not going to get very far then it kind of feels like you're wasting your effort and it's a whole wasted turn because you get no compensation at all through unsuccessful flights again like talking about games like quack of quber is so enjoyable because even if you have a terrible round you still get a currency to improve your standing for future rounds whereas this one you do not get that and I cannot understand why that is the case you know you should have got coins depending on how far you go or there should be some kind of catch- up
mechanism and just in general it feels like there are too many faults in the deck now we understand it's all about trying to create aircrafts by well from scratch which is of course is going to mean that there's going to be lots of crashes um but it feels like the game sometimes stops before it even starts when it comes to a a flight phase because you draw those faults so early and it's going to be unsuccessful and these major faults are really punishing um at times yes you can fix them in your Workshop which I think is quite a cool mechanism actually um but you don't get rid of them you just replace them with a basic fault so you've still got that fault in your deck and even when you take those improved actions or the improved um distance cards you get one of these as well so again it always feels like you'll kind of go on anchor or a ball in chain chains you um to stop you really taking off and flying far and this next comment might sound like a nitpick because you'd expect the this with a deck builder um you do need to shuffle these cards a lot and it does become quite tedious now this one you actually do need to shuffle more than a usual deck builder because the decks are relatively small and because halfway through your flight or just as you're about to end your flight you have to reshuffle your deck to stick the landing and again it becomes very tedious sometimes and again another small nitpick here you forget to shuffle your faults back into your deck and it just becomes an absolute faff especially when you know the other players are just sat there they watching you do it the interaction with this game is a mixed bag you know again the time track system is absolutely fine and there is some competition there which I do enjoy but
again the interaction is badly hurt through the fact that you do have to just sit there waiting for other people to do uh their flight action there's some good competition for the extra cards um because they do not get replenished immediately so again of course that's going to ramp up the tension to jump ahead and get those but all in all again again it could have been more interactive if you played simultaneously and talking about the scalability here I actually think this game Peaks at the lower player count and it does have a solo mode which I haven't tried and I can see this game actually being better solo for that reason that you are not interacting anyway with the other players apart from the the time track me you can really take your time to manipulate all your cards as efficiently as possible to get that best flight um two players is going to be slightly better if you play multiplayer um and when you get more than that I think the downtime is just a bit too much and the production for the game is spot on really it looks lovely um on the table all the cards are nice and clear they are well worded as well um and of course you do have these additional wooden pieces that would be on the board to um to track your movement and your actual score itself um the card quality is pretty good I they are L finished actually they are linen finished um illustrations are lovely and it actually comes with some nice little inserts as well so you know no issues at all when it comes to the production okay so let's share some final thoughts on first in fly and sadly this was a big dud for me definitely did not stick at the Landing for that glaring glaringly obvious reason that you are just sitting and
waiting for too long while the other players take U their flight actions and maybe if I play this game first and in isolation it's um better that it would be directly comparing it to other games you know I'd much rather play a game like quack of quinber or even games like heat which have some kind of um Crossover with this this one by you know keeping your deck lean and I'm trying to keep it as efficient as possible this one I don't know I just think comparing it to those it just Falls or really short and I can't really see the incentive of owning this one over those affl mentioned games for those reasons yes it looks lovely I actually really do like the subject matter the time track is fine you I don't want to criticize that at all because I actually think it's quite difficult to pull off this mechanism to a high standard but I think it's done it well but the downtime is just too much um the card balancing didn't quite sit right for me some of them are just purely disinteresting um and yeah I just I just didn't quite um it just didn't work for me at all this game and um you know it is what it is really I'm not a big fan of deck builders anyway so take that into consideration but there are deck builders I enjoy and this one was sadly uh not one of them that pushy Lu mechanism just did not come through strong enough really unsatisfying turns at times when you just crash before you even begin and yeah it just it just was a massive um Miss for me so as I said if you if this does interest you and you're not aware of games like qua quber um games like heat and even games like the living Forest I think they all do parts of this game to a higher standard and a
more enjoyable standard um to be honest so yeah sadly a big Miss for me this is first in flight