Planet Unknown: Discussion
Transcript
Some viewers may find the following video disturbing. Viewer discretion is advised. Hey everyone, welcome back to Board Games Unlocked and Brad and I are doing a discussion over Planet Unknown and a part of the Super Moon expansion. um very late to the game on Planet Unknown specifically because I mean it was so hard to get I think whenever it originally came out because it just like everyone was like really into it. Yeah. I played it like two or three years ago. Uh a guy brought it to a Christmas party and we played it and I really remembered liking it then that's why back this Yep. Um, but uh because I really really like Polyomino games. Um, funny enough, a lot of them are sci-fi themed, but the the spatial awareness aspect is just something that always works for me regardless of like that's that's a genre that it regardless of how light the game is, I always end up enjoying it just because it's always fun to have have it all come together. And I wouldn't really go out of my way and say this is this one's like super unique in the polyomino placement portion of it. What makes it unique is of course the lazy susan. Um that makes the game flow so well. Like I think that whenever you're like deciding, you know, in what orientation you want it to be, you're thinking about, you know, what your opponents might be wanting, what you might be wanting to try and go up on these tracks. Um, and in a two-player game, I
think the variant is actually super solid where it just takes over. Yeah. I can't decide what I like better because there's the gamesmanship that comes into it when you're playing because I the only other time I played this was four players and whoever's the first player at that time gets to choose which depot on them. And then so you it adds that little feel like okay, you can kind of not hate draft but like like hate hate hate Susan. hate Susan them, you know, and you play with a woman named Susan and you just [ __ ] her over the whole game. So, it's just like, you know, I I kind of like that too, but I I like the two-player variant as well. Like, like having that option of being able to plus it makes it to where cuz, you know, we were having issues uh when we were doing our our first run through on it of not being able to find rover Yeah. deals. Like, if you're if we were playing multiplayer and there's a rover anywhere on there and you're the first player, it's like, yep.
It has a really nice element of like tiny towns. Whenever it's your turn to finally pick a resource, you're like, "Oh, thank God." But then if you're it's not you cuz that's why I like tiny towns in this game at lower player counts because there's not so many people that go before you where it's like great, nothing for me again. Nothing for me again. Like in Tiny Towns where it's like wood, wood, wood, wood. Can someone pick literally anything else? Um, the problem with the two-player though, I could see being an issue. I mean, I know it's all up to luck of what's underneath. Yeah. But like you can see and like if you're needing the same thing I'm needing, you're grabbing it and vice versa. Yeah. Like I'm grabbing the thing that you need and you're not going to be able to get it until hopefully something pops up. Yeah. And that's actually why they have the I mean it's a variant. You don't have to play that one. Uh but they say it's for strategy because there were many times where I'm like, "Okay, I know I need this particular shape. when is it coming around? Uh, right. Versus and and you can you can plan that like I could like with the super moon. Uh, I needed like a two-piece. Uh, so I'm like, "Okay, well then I know it's like in four rounds from now I'll be able to get that. So then I'll just build on my planet and then oh, it's finally here." Um, but here's the thing that's kind of uh about this game. One, I mean, the polyomin placement I really enjoy. Pair that with the research track that goes up. Uh I also really enjoy um I think that the two actually go hand in hand because who doesn't like going up on tracks in in board games. Um and Paul poly no
placement I think most people enjoy. What bugs me overall about this game and I know this was this company's first game. Um Adam's Apple Games. I believe it was their first game. Um their first big game at least. Yeah. The one that took off cuz they have another party game called Agree to Disagree. um which is which is actually a very solid um party game. But what really irks me actually about this game is the the base game is super simple. And I think that's what most people played whenever it was taken off because there's no way in hell people were throwing in all the modules uh and was still saying that this was a fun game, right? Because with every module that you add, well, sorry, let me clarify. If you add multiple modules together, it makes this game nonsense. Like, it becomes so convoluted and unclear and and just o an overall mess of like, hey, here's our simple game of moving up very basic tracks and placing very basic tiles. Uh, that works really well together, and now let's just [ __ ] that whole thing up.
Let's Okay. Well, how does my planet work? Your guess is as good as mine. Yeah, cuz it Well, cuz I had to switch planets out before we started this game because I had a planet that didn't have any ice on it. Yeah. But my corporation, its ability was, you know, you're supposed to gain the benefits when advancing your water tracker even when it advance. Oh, wait. Advance your water tracker once for each water terrain square it covers. Yes. I don't have any water terrain on that deal, so those were unplayable. Yeah. And and I mean, that's that's fine. Like if they give you 10 planets and 10 corporations or however, I don't know, 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 12 planets and and a bunch of corporations cuz they're all 100% unique. That's awesome. What they failed to do is do like a Santorini thing where it's like, hey, don't play these corporations together. This like the the Petra planet cannot be played with the Oasis Oasisuh Corporation.
Um, and which one could say, well, that's kind of stupid. Make all your corpse and all your planets, you know, work together. Or at least provide something in the rulebook of, hey, these are not, you know, these are mismatched corporations. Uh, I don't know how many of those examples there are. We ran into specifically the one that doesn't have ICE. Um, and then one, I mean, it it just feels like they they kind of just went wild with their asymmetry without finding any semblance of balance or uh clarification, which is very, very frustrating whenever your base game is so clean. Again, that's kind of why I say, "Oh, each individual module is good. I like the asymmetrical planets. I like the um asymmetrical corporations. I like the event deck. Uh we'll get to the expansion in a sec. Just don't do all that together. Yeah, cuz the you know they have the on the flip side of every planet is the the basic starting planet that we all use. This is an easy game to teach. Mhm. You know, especially because everybody plays on that one side.
Everybody has the same stuff. So you can kind of do and then you jump into the the Yeah. And I don't even think they say everyone has to be asymmetric. I think they just say you choose if you want. Yeah. You don't have to. Yeah. So it's like I'll play with everyone can play with the basic corporation. Yeah. Yeah. Cuz they have complexity levels on them. Um barely barely. Yeah. That I mean it it does definitely feel like there are certain games that lately I'm feeling like playmats are almost a hindrance. Yeah. Um because it's either like uh I mean Hamlamakus is a great example where it's like okay I can't even see that's oh that's connected you know here it's like you can barely see the complexity. Um but just just don't combine them is what I'd say. Like if everyone's going to play like just either have everyone be with the basic corporation or and and the unique planet. But even if you're doing that, if you have any type of question, it's not in here. Like, and that's that's so frustrating because like my corporation sounded very straightforward. Hey, your things can can go diagonal. Okay, cool.
Um, well, wait a minute. Does that mean I gain the benefit again? Like, if I'm gaining this civilization cards, like I already got it from my civ track, but if I move something else over, do I gain it again? Well, there's only, you know, in a two-player game, there's only three in the game. Does that mean in a multiplayer game if everyone gets one, but I I regress a track and then I, you know, I move them up and then I move it again. Do I reach in the box for one? Uh, especially because the event cards constantly cause regression. So, it it it's too much. And that I mean that could just be on us for turning a simple game and making it complex, but they give you all those modules in every module expansion. It's usually, hey, pick which ones you want to play, right?
Uh, and they usually work well together. Here, it's like, nope, nope. We're playing basic game now. We're playing with events. And I don't know how I feel about that. I would I would like the sandbox nature of being able to be like be able to pick which modules I want to play with. at any given time, but I almost feel like it's going to mess up the whole game. Mhm. Cuz we had to go to Google a few times to find applications on stuff. And even then, like it it took some digging to figure figure it out. I'm dying. Other than that though, um I like the event deck. I thought it was a nice thing, but it sets another timer on on the game, which could be for some people would make the game shorter. Uh yeah, cuz you know when with adding the moon deal like you had said, it makes sense, I guess, to have that because it would make the game, you know, longer because you'd have to keep going until you filled out until somebody couldn't place a tile. Yeah.
And somehow, I mean, we end up scoring higher. Yeah. than than the previous games. So, well, because the these give you if you give you a lot of points. Yeah. Um, but I don't know. I I almost I almost would just rather keep this game as simple as possible cuz the lazy Susan idea is is very nice. It's uh the only game I can think of that has a lazy Susan. Yeah. Besides the games I play on the weekend, am I right? The the only issue with that is the and it's not a tough deal. It's just having to pull all the tiles out and shuffle them and stuff. That's kind of an annoyance, but I mean there's no really other way around it. There isn't. So setup and tear down of this game is kind of a bear. uh overall.
Um so I mean I if you're looking for like a Polyomino game, I mean I don't know if I'd necessarily say like run out and grab this. If they had knocked it out of the park with the synergies of the Corp and the the planets and it's like you get this really cool unique combination uh every single time you pick one. I'd probably be like, "Oh yeah, no, this game's super unique." But like I didn't find my planet all that interesting, right? Um mine was kind of cool, this one. Yeah, because it was broken into quarters and there were and you couldn't put a certain thing in each quarter which adds to the cuz I was having a little bit of AP there for a little bit because I was like, okay, you really have to look at these polomos and make sure it doesn't cross over into the one Yes. zone and all that stuff. So you have to kind of again just minor things like for stuff like that like there's no checking in every in every game. It's like hey make sure that your placement is correct. Now there's no real placement rules unless you're playing on as asymmetric planets but it's like what do you do? Like do you just remove the tile um but you already got all the benefits of moving up on the track? It's just it clearly screams like first big game or first design. Uh, which I was hoping they would like, which I mean I've only played these as like a group.
I I didn't play Planet Unknown before the expansion, but had I I would be like, man, I really hope the expansion polishes this out because it's a solid game. It just needs some refining, polishing, some some uh yeah, some people to come in with like, oo, let's actually correct this. So, with that, we go into the expansion completely unneeded. Yeah, I Yeah, cuz you know, going back to because I backed this game and I chose not to do the Super Moon expansion because I just played the base game and enjoyed it and I'm kind of glad I didn't cuz it really doesn't it doesn't add really anything. I mean, the planet's kind of I guess this is okay. It gives you points and stuff, but like I don't know. Yeah. Yeah. And I mean, and I say I say partial uh review on the expansion cuz Yeah, cuz we we only did the Super Moon one and but they have salvage styles and terrain patches which some things will call out terrain. So then you can like grab things and and extend out patches. It It almost feels like that they were like, "We want to do a reprint of Planet Unknown, but you can't do the same thing." Yeah. So, it honestly I actually didn't really like this.
Um, like because it it really offered nothing. Yeah, it made our score higher, but that's it doesn't do anything else. Well, and it could be a a placeholder for if you don't have a tile and don't want to screw up your planet building. But that's the whole point of like Yeah. Like that's kind of just like a dump off like a sideboard. Yeah. It's almost Yeah. It's like people were bitching where it's like I never get the tiles I want. They're like all right. Yeah. you kind of have a a a moon, whatever. You can put tiles on. Who cares? Uh the satellite thing was so stupid. I utilized it quite a bit to clear mine off, but it wasn't It worked out, but you can also put rovers over there. So, it's like you're I could, but then you're not going to be able to get them over here, the rovers. So, it's like Yeah. I mean, you kind of do need two to to maximize out, but I think they mean for you just to use the Yeah, it just I mean, with with an expansion called Super Moon, you'd be like, "Oh, man.
What do they do?" Oh, they want a different pairing of icons to score. Oh, okay. So, it kind of just again muddies up the simplicity of the game. And again, what we did this last game was we had asymmetric planets, asymmetric corpse, the super moon, and the event deck. Right. It was awful. Oh, it wasn't awful. It it was still like we finished the game but it was like it it it was kind of convoluted. Yes. Like we this is where we had to look up a lot of things because like the corpse my corp was better to understand. Yours was kind of confusing. Mine originally sounded super. I'm like oh okay cool. But then it like it's like they almost added you know how you can like uh complicate things by saying too much. Um it's like any tracker may claim any benefit. Okay.
Yeah sense. Tech levels are locked if no tracker is currently unlocking the tech. Does Does Okay. Does that mean I have to set like because I know how unlocking texts in the base game work. Um, do I have to set a a tracker on it to unlock it? It's it's just it's too much of of something that I just do not really vibe with. So, I mean, if you're going out to get it, I would pass hard on the Super Moon expansion. It doesn't really add much. I mean, it adds more events and adds more, you know, uh, civ cards, which I'm honest, I think the civ cards are my favorite aspect of the game. I just they're pretty decent. I I just really like the idea of getting a you know higher higher upgrading on like either endame goals, endgame scoring or just one time benefit. It always feels good where it's like, oh yes, this is the perfect one for me. I get to take three life pods um off my thing. That's awesome. And then later on, oh sweet, I got this the Civ 4 thing that turns my life pods into two points each. But then they have set collection in here where it's just like, okay, the chances of that being in in the these decks are slim to none. So yeah, it's weird cuz I it's like I definitely don't don't dislike this game. No. But I I feel like if I had played this whenever it was really all the buzz, I'd be that like [ __ ]
that's like, "Guys, it's not that good." Um it's like, "Oh, you just hate it cuz it's popular." It's like that's that's that's how it would have came off. Yeah. You know me. Yeah. The person with the Cthulhu sleeve and the and the Legend of Zelda hats. I only like obscure things. But yeah, it's it's okay. I think overall I it's just I don't know. I don't know. I'm not as wowed by it as I was expecting. I just like the like this the base game with the the ease of teaching it is going to be something it can get to the table and it's something unique that people don't see. You know, like if you have gamers that are kind of getting into not I'm not talking like total new beasts, but people that are still kind of stretching their legs and trying to see what board gaming is, this is a nice simple game to put out there and placing and stuff like that. Yeah. Um, they definitely have the wow factor with the lazy Susan in the middle where I mean it's completely unnecessary in all honesty. It just makes it easier I guess. I mean, but taking apart the whole shuffling of every deal like I can just imagine setting stacks out on the deal and trying to figure out because part of the game is the whole rotating and picking stuff. It would just be a pain in the ass. They did incorporate that into their actual system. So, it's nice. So, it's it's it's good. It's But yeah, I mean I I still like the just the
base game is is solid. I think for sure. I I mean I agree like if you're playing the symmetric stuff I I it's so weird because it's like I don't like the overall systems and mechanics of the game is is solid. I don't I wouldn't like this game if it was just that, you know, if it was the same planets and the same core because it gets very boring after a while. So, you want to play with the asymmetry, but then the asymmetry almost feels like it doesn't want you to play the asymmetry because they made it so difficult to understand what the hell your planet or your corporation does. So, I'm that's kind of where I'm at where it's like, okay, I want to like this game a lot more, but there's a lot of hoops I have to jump through. and then you bring in the expansion that just doesn't offer anything except an excuse to reprint the game, right? So, I don't know. I'm kind of torn on this one. Like, I think it's kind of one of those hidden movement uh scenarios where I have so many Polyomino games that I really like.
Uh Isle of Cats being one is fantastic. Feast for Odin being another. I mean again two Feast Ruin is like not even it's way over here in it's not even in the same league as this one. Uh but Isle of Cats kind of has that yes that similar vein. Um yeah it's it's uh scale of one to 10. Brad, are we just doing each one the expansion and the deal or overall? Yeah. Yeah, we can do we can do each one. Okay. Because base game I'm gonna go with a seven. Okay, I like it. You know, there are games that are better, but you know, seven's a good solid solid score. Yeah. I'll I'll keep keep the base game, you know, and keep running with it.
Yeah. Um expansion is just kind of there. And mind you, we haven't played with everything, so that's kind of a it's going to be a little bit of a hollow score for the true deal, but maybe a five, four or five on the expansion, maybe. Yeah. I mean, we played with the module. Well, again, we shouldn't have we can't play with all of them cuz the game won't [ __ ] let you. Yeah. Or it will, but it'll be a mess. Um, yeah. Uh, I think with like I definitely agree with your scores, but I think I'm going to go with a six on Planet Unknown only because while I like the Polyomino system, I like the tracks, it just feels like it just fights against you and makes it just makes it way more kind of obscene to try and play with any of the extra stuff.
Um, but like I think if all that if all that was ironed out, yeah, I could see a seven uh for it. Uh, base or base game uh expansion, god, I mean zero, which shouldn't even exist in all honesty. Uh, I'm going to go with a five. It's fine. It doesn't It doesn't take away from the game necessarily. I think I mean kind of the super moon. What was I saying? Because you could just play with the the events, right? Um you could just talk Well, the events are from base game. Oh, okay. I thought that was part of one of the modules. No, they have events. Never mind. They have events for the uh um for the expansion. I I was But so I mean it is a little bit more content of uh like of of like events. I think that's why I didn't hammer it too bad cuz I mean it just adds a little bit more but you just don't want to add all the crap. Yeah. I mean if you're one of those people that really doesn't like that people can kind of dick you over until it's your turn. Uh one I would just say play with less people like Tiny Towns I think is a horrendous game to play with like max player counts. Um just because again you just have to sit here and watch people constantly. It's like oh man there's don't put don't put that one on me and look look at that. R adds AP to it, too, because if you, you know, like the way we were playing it, you can kind of think ahead. But if you don't know what the person to your right's going to be like, I think I want this one. All right, everybody pick.
Yeah. You're just like, [ __ ] Oh, okay. I guess that's what I got. Then you're trying to uh while you're also thinking of, you know, I like the scoring objectives. I think that's really neat. I like the neighboring or like the private ones. That's cool. the event deck. That one is actually kind of cool because it's three separate colors um that you get to be like, "Okay, how much do we want to get [ __ ] this game? Let's put in 15 red red ones and only one green." So the players can kind of dictate that. Um it's it's just it's just so weird. They they were like, "Hey, do whatever you want with our game, okay?" But we can't because these planets and this corp doesn't doesn't work well together. Well, just don't do that one. Okay, but then how does this tech work? Don't even Don't worry. Just just put place polyomino pieces. I can't because I can't play the game. Um and then yeah, so maybe the super moon is there for I guess just to be like put that over there. Um yeah. So I don't know.
Slightly slightly disappointed on this one. Um but it is easy to teach. It was very very simple. Yeah, that's the main reason it stays going to stay with me because it's it's an easy game to just get out and show somebody and and a gives you that option like you talked about earlier where if you know the the people that they could be on the the other side, the easy side. Yes. And then for challenge so that you're not running them into the ground, you could be a hard one just to True. Just to kind of make it a little more complex for you. Yeah. And stuff. So there's just a little bit of variation. And like I said, it's not the greatest thing in the world, but it's definitely one that'll stay with me. Yeah. All right. Well, that's it, everyone. That's our thoughts on Planet Unknown and Module One of the Super Moon expansion. Let us know what you think of the game in the comments below. Other than that, like, comment, share, and subscribe, and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you. Hey everyone, thank you for watching, and I really hope that you enjoyed the video. If you would like to see more of my content, go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever I upload any new content. If you feel like supporting the channel, you can go ahead and click that Patreon link to be taken to my Patreon, and any help is truly appreciated. Other than that, stick around for any any other runthroughs or reviews or cool top 10s or whatever I feel like putting on.
Other than that, like, comment, share, and subscribe, and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you.