Spirit Island: Discussion
Transcript
viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome to the discussion for spirit Island Dale and Chelsey had to leave but Kat and I have played this game a few times now so they told us what they thought so I'll mention it as we go along but yeah so Kat what do you think first of all let's start off with things once again where what things we don't like about this game because for me there are definitely way more things I like about it then I just like yeah now I'll spin off of what Chelsea mentioned earlier what we were just talking off-camera was that it kind of feels I know that this is for every single like individual person but it kind of does feel a little bit stacked against you the lower level you are like we had really good abilities but they just seemed to get out of control really really fast yeah so I guess that's like their turn like you think she said that I think actually during the run-through told us feels like an uphill battle it did and yeah I think it's supposed to be it is supposed to be difficult and I've heard this game is brutal since it came out like I knew people who had it who were like oh well we lost again and we're gonna try and tackle it again because it's very very difficult to win not on top of and I think there's ways within the wolf attacks to make it easier yeah and then but there's also
ways to make it harder or new scenarios and then there's just you couldn't like get a I mean just yeah so whenever you're doing these epic abilities just slaughtering a bunch of them it's like yeah I know we were making improvement but then come back which I can see how that would feel like very daunting and very just kind of like you know almost what's the point yeah but I think that for me it's kind of like a yeah I mean I would agree with that because I'm sure there are some people that just look at it like a tug of war and they like that struggle yeah and I do I do like that struggle of okay well I'm gonna do something awesome and then they're just going to come back so it's constant back-and-forth of we're still doing something awesome and managing it but they're they're relentless they really want this you know this island they are gonna do whatever it takes but there was never really a time where I was like okay we're definitely gonna lose like we added a lot of hope they like because we got the terror level to and it's just like oh we actually don't have that many towns or cities to destroy the only had by the end of it four cities which you just focus on those areas and then because like we were pumping out fear right like a lot so it wasn't that much off where we would have been the terror
level 3 and there's no cities there okay well then there just don't win so that doesn't really bother me but I can see how that would bother a lot of people right right there's no like because pandemic kind of has an Evan flow where it's like you you get [ __ ] on and then you manage it and then so it's like roller and Bravo and a lot of people just started as a rollercoaster you're going up and then just goes down then you have that climb again and this game does that as well I think where it's like yeah then okay there's really no in here then we figure out oh they're only gonna ravage there yeah or or if it and build there I can't remember if I said this about this I think I remember saying at the beginning when I got the general concept of wearing the game that it's two steps or sorry one step forward two steps back mm-hmm what was my general thing and it kind of feels like that I don't ever was you know unhappy or mad at any point right right oh definitely is I think that I think this game goes very well with introducing the game Chelsea and them mentioned that the board and everything is confusing and I think initially it is but in all reality I think this was an easier game to grasp from teaching it yeah I think I think you do need to to play through it because initially I remember just looking at the at the player board just
being like yeah like and then because we played it a while ago as an introductory game and I was like thank God we did not record that yes it would have been just selling a horse yeah and so but their game does a really good job it's like hey play with this play with these you know these spirits play with the card that gives you your power stack so you're not drawn randomly don't play with any of these variants these scenarios these you know special people just base game and once you're comfortable with games then add that stuff which is good because I like when it game instructs you like that it's not just like here's a [ __ ] ton of variants that you can play the game it's like have fun yeah cuz if you even make a game or did you just make a bunch of rules that way no I want to play the game so and I think daelin gheylens one complaint that he was actually gonna comment on which I actually agree this is a big big complaint I have is that this game looks pretty shitty like the board is boring as hell the miniatures and I understand that they're not but you're using them a lot yeah they're constantly putting them in and the game actually full tray which i think is awesome yeah but like I mean the cities and talents are ok quality I really like their design on Jaime day track their damage like you rotate them to track the damage that song and I think that's really cool
but other than that like their flimsy like being like already bent and stuff and then really stand up that's pretty garbagey the but where there's artwork it's really good artwork like the cards are awesome and this is more of a cart this is a berry it's a car driven game so I think that where they put all their money into the artwork they lacked in other components even use their cell ferry yeah because it really really you could have actually made a hut right you made mushrooms do these disks feel like the cards don't feel light or or cheap right right oh yeah and I'm sure they were trying to be I think they were I think they're gonna be simplistic yes yeah just being like hey this is what it is just so you don't have to be like okay so where's all the lands you can immediately see green green and I guess looks good on one thing but I mean for a game a somatic and like I'm not really sure why this is blight it just looks like kind of like a great green so yeah so they're miniatures were not there their strong point the fair tokens are kind of lame lame looking but then again like I said it is for simplicity purposes that say you can just look at and be like okay this is a target targets I know Mountain oh I can I immediately know where that's
at so it kind of makes the games flow pretty quad pretty quickly so and do you have any other complaints no okay so I really really really like this game yeah like this is easily jumping definitely to the top 100 it would probably fall in well above maybe top 20s or 30s of all time it's definitely making games of the year for me because this game is just so unique and there's really nothing like it like I think it's awesome that you're playing one of the spirits and each spirit plays completely differently oh yeah from the get-go like not not including the cards and the innate abilities and stuff from the get-go of their growth like which growth you pick kind of determines how your how your spirit plays and then you look at your presence which is okay how much energy and how many cards in my plane which is also different and thematic towards them then you have your Nate powers and special rules which also make you different and then you have your initial cards you start with your I think for initial cards that you get and then with it with the beginning spirits you can also do that somatic power cards that you that you can draw but oh my god this game is just so awesome like I was enamored with him whenever we first
played it oh yeah anything nothing like just the like that tug of war which I personally like beat the flow of everyone's you know if spirits okay well this is what you can do Oh like like Chelsea night I make me fast yeah I mean I can just do a lot of damage cleanup yeah it's like elfin over here in daelin was kind of protecting this area it sucked because I was trying to manage over here as well but I couldn't I needed help on that side I could if there were more people over there I think we actually fit about a chance so you want to manage your presence really smart because [ __ ] I don't even know you got a [ __ ] ton of presents out on the board maybe that's why in Chelsea just had really good a ways to kill them so we all worked really really well it's just the one area that [ __ ] us was that over there that I can't do enough by myself also because I couldn't I I was gonna make that a sacred site but I went over here to wipe that area so if I have some help over there from anyone it would have been a lot easier to manage and so just even even the way that the game presents itself from the get-go on the back where it tells you kind of your play style for each yeah each race that you can handsome and be like well like I don't understand the car doesn't mean yeah we'll just read the play style no way you're not trying to play aggressively when really you should be playing offensively exactly you mean the defensively yeah
like like with your River you're definitely support until later on whenever you get some of your major minor powers to where you start becoming a little bit stronger utilizing your innate abilities with other minor major powers and then because yeah you are supporting you are hey hey we're gonna flourish the land before day on which will inherently allow us to move them around and have them fight that theme is all over this game yeah like I think that even within just the card names and stuff you can just picture what's happening yeah the card names are pretty uh pretty descriptive because there was one one time whenever we played was where we you were your ability or your card was basically gonna put like a water or I know him aside Devin's ability and he was he was gonna wall him in your water was gonna rush in and kill them and it's like oh my god that's pretty well good what do you think about spirits well it yeah because we are the spirit so we're just like [ __ ] these invaders but like I mean these are actually just people in any other game we would be the invaders playing against spirits and that's why I think I like this game so much is because the because it's the reverse kind of like faded the older guys where you're the cultists fighting against oh yeah summoning instead of being the investigators yeah it's just new its innovative and it's definitely not for everyone though
because I don't think it's as intuitive it is kind of difficult to grasp okay well how am I supposed to play whether these symbols mean but I think once you get like a round or two in it just it flows so smoothly like oh okay well let's just go into the spirit face okay pick your growth and then okay I've got my energy now pick your cards and well my favorite thing is the the speed of the cards that brings in such an element a different element of strategy to where it's like because I want to Billy we're talking about where Debbie was gonna wall Amanda your water is gonna rush in didn't work because it was a years was a slow ability which it's like [ __ ] but if we has a lightning person who makes everyone fast it could've worked and so you just see how it's not oh I'm doing my own thing it's a coffee game but someone's you know carrying the team no I never felt like we were all useful and I think that I'm enough you agree or not chat that element of simultaneous card picking and stuff like that and kind of really doing them all at once prevents what's called I think it's called quarterbacking or it's like okay like what I do in pandemic almost you know not on purpose or it's like I'm telling everyone what to do because once you play pandemic so many times there's really only one way to do certain things this one I don't think if it prevents that from cuz they're half of them I was just like
okay baby you're doing your own thing alright cool like I wasn't like baby I don't let me and you need to do this in this in this because we're gonna do this it brings in a lot of coordination and cooperation more than a lot of games actually do um what do you think of the fear pretty cool I I also really like the fear because there's so many ways to get it that's also in written theme to where that if you generate enough fear it's actually not just it's not just trying to speed up the game because hey now your victory conditions are so scared you don't have to kill all of them right now you have to store their towns or cities if you scare them and dolphins just the cities and if you even do that if you go through all the fear then you just win but oh and then the cards come back and help you which is also grounded in theme depending on the level of which those cards come in and some of those would just hate remove people and it's like okay sweet and I think that that's awesome but I think that the way that the fear pumps out the more players yeah you're gonna I feel like actually now the other thing about it that it's gonna keep the length of the game the same you think because the number of fear tokens you have to do is dependent on the number of players so you need it's four per player so in the four player game you have sixteen tokens that you need to push in before you get
a free Ricard so there are but so on the two-player game you just need eight and then I think that that's also balanced out with a number of blight which we're playing with just the base blight which is five tokens per player so we have twenty there there is a card that your that you can actually play which is healthy so you put white tokens on that and whenever that runs out then you flip it over and now it's blighted land but the game's not over yet so I think that will kind of make it and feel not so you know uphill battle II because now you have another chance uh like yeah I mean I am enamored with this game there is an expansion that brings in just more spirits I just want I just want more spirits because there's some in there that Devin and I looked at that were just like oh my god oh like that and what's great about this is that there's also the complexity rating on each barrier as a here's low a if you're experienced maybe you play with this high one and uh and try and help out like one of them was that guy camera whose name because like about the nightmares and he was just about pushing you know people around you didn't do any damage but I think his damage was turned into fear so I was like oh my god just the possibilities of fine let's have him and the shadows that flicker like flame and just pump a [ __ ] ton of fear into this island and I'm sure there's another
but it's basically an end spirit the tree spirit that also you know next the land and it's like well [ __ ] you to fear than do two of them but then you're probably not doing a lot of damage so it's it's just very very interesting there's not actually a single mechanic in this game that I don't like maybe it's not really mechanic but I think it's just I really wish that instead of the four basic ones having their own power you know decks that you draw from I wish everyone did because I felt that that kind of made even more thematic you had your specific power cards that you were getting about you even better instead of just oh hey I drew this one oh I got like I'm the shadows that flicker like flame and I got tsunami yeah right it's like well that doesn't really that doesn't make a whole lot of sense cuz you want we want to using your advice to their yeah well you want to immaculately yeah I think you're doing I mean it doesn't matter who's getting it like I I just wonder why they decided to do that instead of making each spirit have their own power yeah yeah so it's like oh hey I got you know wings of rust and atrophy which is one fear and defense six auto-ship thank you cuz I did I was pretty imposing surprised when I got when I tell Susan altitude yeah so I mean maybe it's like I probably just knew in a combination since of hey oh I'm playing the river surges and Sunline
I got my power again because you're gonna play them the same way at least with the minor major combinations right that would tell us would make this not feel so repetitive right so I guess that's fine because the powers are still really cool uh let's see yeah I I got nothing I can't talk about the scenarios cuz I haven't done them I guess what I could have showed Chelsea and then was the back they have these which makes it more at least colorful but is there also for like what they call it like somatic dry thematic ways or thematic playing to there's also more in the back of the world book which is really cool yeah somatic map it's just how you with up what the other side of the board they have scenarios they have adversaries so they've the kingdom of brandenburg-prussia kingdom of England kingdom of Sweden which effect the invader card so that even makes it more thematic there's solo so you can play by it you can play it solo it also comes with ticks ticks tips and tricks that streamlining gameplay or basic strategies for new players so they definitely put a lot of thought into hey I know we're making a complex and hard game but here's ways to make it easier or more understandable which is always nice because it's not it's one thing to make it making them difficult and it's just hard as I know like you don't wanna
make a game of heart like you like ghost stories yes Emily whereas I think it's hard well no you just threw a die in there and you're like hey that's what makes it difficult this has strategy behind it but it's still difficult but it's manageable those stories are just like man if only dice went my way this game oh they didn't okay so nothing I do matters it's the pride factor of just like knowing that something that's difficult and you did everything in your power to versus right right and I think this game even though it's very difficult I can look back and be like well there's probably more things that we could have done areas of focus like putting more presents over there to help me where we got [ __ ] the most protecting more areas just ways the things that we could have done so that's pretty much all I got it on that scale on the 10 18.5 any particular reason you really like it yeah I don't like I don't like it so much like it's just it's not like a pretty like a really really good game to me but I do like it I like it I'm like like it yeah I'm gonna give it a 9.5 like in pretty much it would be a 10 but quality is very much lacking and artwork besides cards is pretty shady permits to
the board it's just kind of hey I wish it looked better none of it looks like it goes together it looks like we pulled everything from a different game exactly yeah yeah so that's that's a good point so I just wish yeah that would just make an even more captivating just to be like oh my god this looks all amazing so definitely 9.5 I'm very much like it I still have yet to beat it but I I think that's okay that's okay cuz now it's a challenge so that's another one that is our thoughts on spirit island let me know what you think in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful with every time of day it is for you hey everyone thank you for watching and I really hope that you enjoy the video if you want to support us you can go ahead and click that link to go to my patreon account if you have any suggestions you can go ahead and click the link in the show notes below the girl of my BoardGameGeek list other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful with every time of data is for you