Skip to main content
Loading video...

Talisman: The Magical Quest Game – 5th Edition Review

Transcript 24:31

hey everybody Welcome to driveth through review 790 today we're going to talk about Talisman fifth edition now the full name is Talisman The M iCal quest game fifth edition uh so this is a new edition and I didn't realize how long it's been since the last Edition because I was telling my friends the other day the last time I played tesman it was Third Edition and I went and looked and I was like no it was fourth but it was like almost 20 years ago 15 years ago let's say and uh and yeah so it's been a while since we've had a new addition of this and uh so it's kind of like a reset reboot there'll be more expansions and stuff coming which I'll kind of talk about at the end in the review there are some relatively significant changes between this Edition and an fourth edition uh and in terms of the rules and also in terms of some of the components uh a little bit uh so let's jump down to the table if you've not played Talisman before I'll give you kind of a brief overview of how it generally works and then I'll talk more specifically about some of the changes okay so you can see I've got the board set up here it's very much like previous editions um I will say I kind of like the graphic design of the board and the kind of the layout of where the text is at and the font and all that kind of stuff to me it's a little bit clearer although it's still kind of hard to read you know the text on the other side of the board and that kind of stuff but um once you get used to the board is not too bad um generally I like the art uh part of the design in fourth

edition a little bit more than this so it's kind of like two steps forward one step back kind of thing uh with the general kind of layout and stuff some of the spaces are a little bit different but generally the spaces are all pretty much the same and if you've not played the game you can see well let's just go down here here we have the profit test character and this is her starting zone here the chapel and on your turn what you're going to do is you're going to roll a die let's say I roll five and then basically you can move five spaces that way or five spaces that way left or right you choose you see where you might land and end up and so in this case let's just say we're going to move here so we'd move to the fields and a lot of the spaces have this little card draw icon and what that means is you're going to draw a card off the top of your adventure deck there which is a large uh deck of cards and then you're basically going to have an encounter or find an item or something like that so in this place we would place this card here and this would be a magical stream you'll put some tokens on it and from here you can gain strength and I'll explain what that is in a minute so basically this card will now sit there until in this case the counters are used up and then this card will move away so the next time that players move to the space or this space they won't need to draw a card so basically you always draw a card up to the limit in this case is just one card there'll be other spaces like this one here in the middle which is plus three so if you encounter this space here and it's empty you'll draw three cards if there were two cards already there when you got there you would just draw one up to three there and then once we go here if this gets

cleared somebody else comes here then you might draw an ogre card in that case you'll have an encounter basically a fight with the ogre if we zoom in a little bit here you can see it has a strength five sometimes there's some other special abilities and stuff with the monster that you might be fighting usually you're going to fight them in strength or craft so strength is sort of physical combat craft is Magic or sort of you know intellectual types of encounters and so you're going to be bouncing around the board every turn rolling a die moving that number of spaces until you kind of level yourself up enough that you start to stop moving around the outermost region here and then you there's a couple of places here is a sentinel for example that you can challenge them to get access to the center ring and there's some other things like you can build a raft cuz you can notice here you can kind of see there's a river going around there to go across there is uh some actions you can do on the tavern space that kind of thing so once you get in here these areas are a little bit harder and then there is over here the portal of power which is one of the ways that you can get into the final ring now once you you're in that final ring you will no longer be rolling a die you will be moving one space at a time until you get to the very very center now you can't get very far in that Center ring until you have obtained a Talisman so there's a few ways to do it that you can get a Talisman one of the ways is you can find it in your inventure deck the other way is you can do a quest there's a warlocks cave which is over here which will give

you a quest you can roll up on and there's some other different ways that you can get a Talisman so once you you have your Talisman you'll be able to get past a certain space here and then you can get to the center space and you basically fight the dragon which is a strength 10 craft 10 uh encounter so you pick one and then fight them and then whoever does that first will win the game so it's definitely a race around the board until you level up enough to get in there and you you found a Talisman at some point to then uh be in the center there and then have combat so let's take a look at a character sheet so if we take here here's the profit test here and so it gives you some starting items so youve got strength two craft four some starting special abilities and stuff uh the starting space you can see remember we had her at the chapel here's your life points you can see there's these little cones there are also uh the nice tray here you can just pull out of the box there are larger cones these count as five of a particular thing you have coins and such over there but that's easy to set off to the side there and so you start with one gold you you start with two fate which I'll explain then you get your life you can have four objects and you put these down here now talsman does not count as one of your objects which I think it's a change from fourth edition and you can have as many followers as you like now the prophetes here since it says on her card she starts with a random spell off of the spell deck so there's a bunch of spells in there and you can acquire

spells anybody can acquire spells if they have enough craft there's a table in the rule book here which shows if you have let's say in her case she has four craft she starts with one spell so she could acquire another spell all the way up to six or more you can have up to three spells and that spells are something that you can do basically at any time on your turn you can also cast them on somebody else's turn but you can only do one spell cuz you kind of could negatively affect another player and you can fight other players which we talk about but you don't just get spells you've got to do an action on the board or encounter some kind of creature or something that will grant you a spell and so what you want to do in the game is level up your strength and your craft so you can fight uh ever increasing you know more difficult encounters and the one way that you could do that so let's say we had defeated this ogre in this case so at any point on your turn you can discard uh creatures equal to or more than your current strength or your craft so in this case we have an ogre of five five strength that we magically beat with our two strength but maybe we had a sword or something that gave us extra strength that kind of thing so if you discard creatures equal to or more than that you can discard them and then you can add another strength to your pool there and so you can keep doing that until you build up a massive amount you can also get more life um when the game tells you to heal life it'll heal up to your starting value but if you quote unquote gain life you can actually

go above your starting value uh just while we're on the board here you can see you've got coins there are different little Merchant spots on the board or new ones may come out of the adventure deck where you can buy items there is kind of a a merchant deck here so you can just go through these you don't have to shuffle them you can buy copies of armor and weapons and uh mules and things like that that will actually give you extra um spaces for more objects uh you can get like water so you can live in the desert a little bit longer otherwise you're going to have to lose health so there's a lot good stuff to purchase in the game also you have fate now fate you can spend any time to roll one of your dice so if you're combating a monster here and let's say they rolled a six and you rolled a two you can use that fate to roll your die or when when you're rolling to maybe uh do one of the actions on the board you can R roll one of your dies but you can't spend a fate to reroll somebody else's die or kind of like the NPCs die so that's the main way to use fate and new in fifth edition is after you roll to move if you choose if you don't get the roll that you quite want which can be a frustration in the game you can actually just discard a fate and move anywhere you want left or right within six spaces so if you're right next to a space you know you only that you want to go to you can only get there by rolling one on this turn but if you really want to get there you feel like the RAC is is in question then you can just spend one of these and just move right there and the other thing to

notice here is we can see the alignment now you see I have an evil alignment on the profit Test Now by default she starts as good and in the course of the game you can have encounters that change your alignment but one of the changes with fifth edition is you can just go ahead and pick an alignment at the start of the game which is fun because you could do an evil prophetes or in this case I have over here a good thief who normally starts off as neutral so you can have a little bit of fun with that as well and there'll be different spaces on the board that will benefit you if you're evil or be of a non-benefit to you if you're evil and vice versa with good as well there'll be good spaces that are good for good and spaces that will be bad for good and I should say there is 12 different characters to come uh in this starting box here so that's good it gives you a lot of variety um I don't think the gold I don't remember it being plastic in the last Edition so that's kind of an upgrade there generally the components are really good like I said I the board I'm sort of like I like really some parts of it and other parts you know I don't know I kind of miss sort of the General art of the board but the graphic design and Clarity I think is a little bit better here I do think the art and everything uh on all the cards and the components and everything is much much better I just like how these are laid out a little bit more I mean I'm kind of quibbling there the only other sort of component complaint is they still have these cones um and the sometimes telling the difference between a five and a one um can be not as clear I mean and I'm

really that's really a super nitpick that's not that big of a deal uh the one thing I do really like with this is I think the Miniatures are actually very very very good especially for kind of a big bux you know uh you know Big Box store Target you know Walmart type of game that's you could see in a lot of places these are some very nice Miniatures here and I've actually seen some people um that I know that play heroquest um that are going to make use of these in there so these are these are pretty good quality here for you know the kind of the price point of this game and everything so I think that's also very very good quality there and I will say um if you do get stuck if you you know you've played this before you can go here there's a nice page here where been here before it's got all the updates and then there's a couple of them that aren't actually mentioned there like I talked about leveling up the creatures and so on like that's in here and but anything that you see that's marked with this and it's marked very clearly in the rule book with that symbol uh that's a change and it's very easy to find in the rule book um in here to go through there like that oh and I should say let's just go back down here the other really big change before I forget is when you die in this game or you get turned into a toad which I'll just leave you to find out if you've never done that before it is not the end of the world you basically just go back to the Village over here you reset to one hit point but you keep all your stuff so you don't have to discard

your character although that is in there as an optional rule if you still want to play that way it gives you the steps to do that but you don't have to start completely over which is a huge change you know based on that was probably my only gripe with the game which I'll talk more about in the review uh from previous editions and even Relic which I'll talk about um but yeah so that it's not as harsh as it could be and uh you know but if you still want to play that way the rules are still on there for that okay so that is T man fifth edition let's go into my three pillars of review and first I'll jump into playtime because uh the Box doesn't actually mention it and I'm not going to look on Board Game Geek to see what it says I will say the earlier editions could go longer because of two reasons one uh when you die uh you uh start over completely which is no longer the case in this Edition at least with the default rules you can still play the optional Rule and the other thing is the leveling up in the early game is a little bit quicker because instead of having to spend seven strength or craft you can just spend equal to or higher than your current so you start to level up much much quicker like in the first couple of turns which is nice because you know it it just gets you going and then it's a nice way of kind of putting pressure on everybody uh to to get things moving there so my experience with this has been um about two hours to play the game um now I've not played this Edition with more than two players I have played the

other Edition with three and four players and I this goes up to six and so that kind of bleeds me into the um player count and I would say four is probably a sweet spot there it's kind of nice to have other players there because I didn't mention this in the rules overview but you can attack players um mostly it's a strength combat and when you do that then uh you can either knock them down a life or steal one of their items and that kind of thing um so having more players on the board makes that a little bit more opportune and it's a little more fun because that's kind of more what the game's about it's it's I'll talk about this more in the review part but it's a little bit more traditional amerit trash type of thing where you're kind of just more having fun than being super strategic not that there's no strategy or no choice basically but you know there's a little bit there uh but it's nice to have the other players when you just have two you know you kind of not you don't really get in each other's way which could be nice too if you want to have more of a casual game and and I've played it where we we played it where not this particular Edition but in the past where you just there's no attacking each other and that's actually fun too you just kind of played that like I got no problem playing that way and then it's just a pure race game which is which can be very fun uh but I think I I don't have a desire to play with five or six cuz I think then the play time even with the new addition with the changes it's still going to take a long time and not that the whole game is going to take a long time but there's going to be a lot of time between your turn and sometimes your turns are really quick

it's like move here you know grab a token or something and then that's it your turn takes like 5 seconds and then other people might have a little bit more involved turns so if it's going around the table like that that's just too long to wait so four would be the absolute Max you know three and four should be fine but as people have played the game you know they won't have to be like reading all the spaces and all the cards then you will get kind of the gist of it so in your first games of this uh they could take some time to kind of understand the spaces and it's I would say it's good because my recent experience of this has elucidated this even clearer for me it's good to have somebody at the table that kind of has knows everything on the board pretty much and kind of knows how things can kind of pace itself out uh with the decks of cards and things because you can act as a facilitator and I think that's very important for a first play with this because it can be kind of a lot going on not in terms of like the Strategic overload but just amount of stuff that can get on the board with all the different cards and stuff like that um so it's good to have a facilitator to kind of help things along almost acting as a as a as a GM but you know still playing the game um so what is this game like well obviously I'm going to compare it to the earlier editions of Talisman and then also another game called Relic which is basically Talisman engine but in the Warhammer 40,000 Universe which is currently published by Whiz Kids it used to be published by Fantasy Flight but I

think you can still pick that up so it the things that I like that it does I already mentioned the leveling up quicker that's great the kind of softer dying I think that's really good the one thing that I was actually thinking I would miss from Relic that is not in any edition of Talisman that I've played is in Relic that you have kind of colorcoded deck so there's three I believe three different colors of Adventure cards and they'll go to certain areas so it kind of scales things up a little bit more gradually in terms of the types of encounters you have versus this which is like you can grab anything out of that Adventure deck so you can like on your first turn you can go fight a strength seven Dragon you're like you're going to lose and that's going to be there for a while until somebody else can come along and you know and then get after it or you can run into something very easy or a couple of easy things you know kind of towards the middle end of the game and some of those center spaces um but I kind of like this better I think I don't know it's probably like seasoned to taste kind of thing because even if you draw a dragon let's say on your first turn you move to the hills you draw a dragon you get you lose you lose a Life Point okay no big deal then you keep playing and everybody's avoiding that space for the rest for a while not for the of the game but for a while and it kind of takes on like a character of its own and as you you know play through the game you get kind of

the mid to late game the board every time you play is going to kind of shape itself out so you're going to have these different locations oh that's the little healing cave or that's the place with the hermit that gives you the Spells you know and that kind of stuffing some of the cards are just going to stay there once they're out they're out there's no really removing some of the cards and so each game's going to kind of like organically create like a little kingdom or whatever uh that's going to be different than the last time you played and so because of that I'm kind of leaning towards H I do kind of like this because in Relic it can get kind of syy you know because they had like red yellow orange and blue cards if I remember right on the adventure card so you kind of know what you're going to deal with so it's a little bit more I mean it's more balanced I guess but it's also a little bit more obvious and predictable whereas this is I don't say I wouldn't say it would be be unbalanced it's just a little bit more unpredictable and you might have a turn that's a little bit wasted because you're going to encounter something that is too easy so you know you just get it you're like whatever I don't really need this or it's too hard and you don't get anything but then you know it's just okay no big deal because that that'll happen in this game anyway and then you can kind of like work towards it it gives you a goal to work towards to try to beat that Dragon um so anyway I like that part of it the other thing thing that I think I really like here is that the Fate movement thing because that that plus the dying rule would be kind of like a

deal breaker for me in the other editions and I don't think Relic had that either so I think this is brand new to any of these sort of talsman engine games where you can just spend a fate token and move anywhere you want within one to six spaces I've not played any of the expansions and stuff for the older edition so maybe these were stuff that they added later but um that's really cool because you're just like I'm good I'm ready now I know exactly what I need to do I know exactly where I need to go and I just want to go there I don't want to wander anymore and collect items and level up I want I have a very specific thing in mind and it's and it's kind of a big choice to spend that fate for the movement because there are going to be times when you um you're going to need that fate to like you know beat a very critical encounter even like in the last encounter of the game it's good to have some fate stocked up for some of that stuff um but that it's a really cool rule cuz it's nice it makes it a good decision there um yeah so the other part I would mention is I just wanted to wrap back up to the thought of the facilitator um because I in spin Wason I played Talisman I played Relic much more recently but the center space that's a good teaching if you can kind of teach from that space out because there are certain things like you're going to need a certain amount of strength a certain set of items and then um you know some different things like that and so if you teach people like okay you want to start going to the center about you know here when you have like let's say 10 strength probably and I don't know however much six seven

craft you can have some spells and that kind of thing um so you can kind of show people like what you're going to encounter when you get there so that gives people some guidance and stuff and I found that that was pretty helpful um with the with the teach of the game but yeah so the other thing I wanted to mention which I said I would mention earlier in the review is they've already got one expansion and they're going to probably have a bunch more which has me excited which is it's going to be like a co-op sort of campaign and I think you're going to play through like four or five different sort of um I can't remember what they're called but they're like going to change the end game I think they've released a little blurb about it in some pictures but it gives you like four or five little quests and it's Co-op and it's going to be campaign so I think some stuff is going to carry over from game to game and you're going to have different sort of Adventures that you're going to take place you know in that Center uh crown of command you know Talisman space right um and that's really cool cuz that was that's some of the stuff that I really like in Relic that I'm glad that they're bringing here is some different sort of endgame type conditions and also Co-op um the the Bas Relic game had that I think it had three or four or five different um end games where the basic one was was just like basically the same as Talisman and then you had some different conditions which made it interesting so having that variability in endgame is going to be really cool and plus playing at Co-op which allow me to actually play solo uh cuz that was one of the funnest ways I like to play Relic is when it got I think it was the

second expansion you could actually do co-op so just it was cool so it's like a little Adventure game and you know you can see from the rules and everything it's a very simple game and uh some of those simple types of adventure games um are really a fun way to pass the time so I'm really excited for that I don't remember the name of the um expansion but it is on board game geek so if you go to the page for Talisman 5ifth Edition in expansion tab there's a you can get a link to that and uh and I think that's coming out in the fall so I'm definitely going to be hanging on to this and taking a look at that expansion uh which frankly is the thing that has me most excited about this new edition I didn't really know what the changes were in the rules uh but these changes I think I'm pretty excited about and then again the solo Co-op thing uh should be a lot of fun so you'll definitely see me talk about that down the road this fall so anyway that is a Talisman fifth edition thanks

Progress saved