Living Forest - a pretty, push-your-luck, deck building game.
Transcript
i received a review copy of living forest from the distributor so thanks to coiled spring the spirits of spring summer autumn and winter compete to gather guardian animals by spending sunlight or to grow trees which generate flowers and wind and water um i don't know how they or hang on uh don't forget to put out the fires started by the fire demon on ib or otherwise you'll end up with fire spirits among your collection of guardian animals and some of the guardian animals are are um baddies but they can be counted by the ones that are goodies or um something like that wait let's start again a push or luck deck builder that's full of pretty pictures of animals that's the hook i'm adam porter i design games and i review games with a focus on their likely success as commercial products living forest is a strategy game for two to four players from publisher ludonaut and first time designer oscar christiansen the game has recently been nominated for the 2022 astor the golden ace which is the prestigious french award for game of the year in living forest the goal of the game is to be the first to grow 12 trees or to put out 12 fires or to gather 12 flowers you start the game with a deck of animal spirit cards and the round starts with players revealing cards from their deck until they choose to stop or they're forced to stop essentially you're trying to build
up a collection of matching symbols each of which is a form of currency that's going to give you access to a different ability suns are used to purchase new cards to add to your deck each with different costs and different symbols on them saplings allow you to purchase trees to add to your player board and these give additional symbols which are always present regardless of your card draw and if you complete rows columns or cover the corner icons you gain yet more symbols or extra abilities in general on your turn you're allowed to carry out two different actions the wind allows you to move around the central circular board which is going to give you access to the action that you land on in this way you might be able to do the same action twice in your turn for example if your first action was the sun action and your second action was wind well you might now land on a sun space on the central board allowing you to purchase a second card the wind action might also allow you to steal a token off another player if you jump over them on the track the flower symbol doesn't give you an action but it counts towards the end game goal of amassing 12 flowers in a single round and the water action allows you to put out fires but more about that later so to reiterate generally you have two actions per turn but if when you're revealing cards you reveal three solitary creatures you must stop drawing cards immediately and you lose one of your actions hence there's a big push your luck aspect to the game the punishing solitary creatures can be mitigated by adding gregarious creatures
to your deck each of these will cancel out the negative effects of a single solitary creature at the end of each round fire is added to the central board and the value of the fire is dependent on which cards were purchased from the display so buying higher valued cards adds more punishing fire tokens to the board players can put out fires using water symbols on their turn and doing so 12 times is one of the end game goals but any fire remaining at the end of a round is liable to burn the players if they don't have enough water to fight it if your total for water isn't equal to the total showing on the fire tokens you'll have to take fire demon cards and add them to your deck these cards have no symbols on them and they're solitary creatures so they can really mess up your future card draws if one player achieves any of the three end game goals then they win the game so let's kick off with a customer journey map i was attracted to the game because of the cover image the name itself is very bland but it does declare its intentions clearly this is going to be one of those trendy right now gorgeous nature themed games full of attractive art and targeted squarely at the new wave of hobby gamers those who didn't cut their teeth on high fantasy role-playing games or epic sci-fi battles but are looking for a light and breezy wholesome experience which they can share with family and friends without scaring anybody away from the box cover alone i knew there was a strong chance my wife would love this game for a game to be truly accessible the
onboarding process needs to be super smooth and this wasn't my experience with living forest the game has loads of bits and it's not immediately obvious what's what one of the downsides of picking another worldly theme there was some construction involved to create the lovely token holders and lots of sorting and organizing required not to mention a lot of table space honestly setting everything up was a bit of a chore then we get into the rule book the rules aren't complex but they are unintuitive the game subverts a few of the mainstays of familiar deck building games and as such for an experienced gamer there's a little bit of unlearning to be done before you can really grasp what's going on the heavy use of thematic names is a barrier on ivy the fire spirit guardian animals protective trees sacred flowers the fire baron board the circle of spirits all of this is a little bit hard to digest on a first reading it doesn't help that the narrative is pretty nonsensical the best thematic games integrate their settings such that the narrative justification for each action and item makes absolute sense and actually helps you to learn the game and recall the function of the individual components this isn't the case in living forest it feels like a slightly confused retheme pasted over a more traditional medieval deck builder with suns in place of gold coins trees in place of buildings and flames in place of attacking marauders and this highlights
a dilemma for game makers should you stick to a clear understandable logical narrative which has been done a million times or should you break the mould and imagine a brand new evocative setting which might intrigue jaded gamers but potentially obscures the player interface living forest clearly took the latter path my first play was with two players and i was a little bit conflicted about the experience my wife and i loved the artwork on the cards and any weakness in the storytelling was more than made up for with atmosphere the game does feel magical mechanically i really enjoyed the push your luck deck building combo it felt very similar to cracks of quedlinberg which is one of my favorite games you're constantly tempted to push your luck just that little bit more and crucially as in quacks if you go bust by drawing that third solitary spirit you're not out of the round you simply have one action instead of two so far so good the negative impression came from the end game trigger now i have a big personal distaste for race mechanics in strategic games it always feels anticlimactic to me when a game ends suddenly with one player taking an instant win okay so you've amassed your 12th fire token well does my beautiful arboretum of trees and my bountiful crop of sacred flowers count for nothing i guess so this is a criticism i've directed at other excellent games in the past most recently in my review of viticulture i
want my efforts to be noted even if that means taking second or third place on the pedestal please designers allow me that achievement at least let me count my victory points the sudden ending in living forest particularly with two players was a little bit jarring particularly because it highlighted a quirk in the game relating to turn order as with many board games the order of play in living forest moves clockwise around the table and it can't be altered at the end of each round the starting player token is simply passed to the left and turn order is really important in this game because the early players in a round get the first opportunities to put out fires this means that you've got to be really careful about when you purchase cards because doing so adds fire to the central pool and the value of the cards you purchase dictates the strength of that fire that you add generating a lot of firing around is potentially gifting it to the next starting player and gathering fire tokens could win them the game this is particularly noticeable in a two-player game and it creates an odd tempo essentially buying cards is disincentivized especially when you're the start player because next turn your opponent's gonna play first and they're gonna gobble up all the fire once you clock this weird dynamic the game opens up you start spending suns more frugally only buying cards when you really need to and placing much more focus on the trees and the wind track this creates a bit of a learning curve to the game players of a strategy game like this are likely to have played
other deck builders where buying cards is always positive they might not immediately recognize that purchasing cards in this game could directly benefit your opponents and spotting that quirk late in the game can leave a sour taste as your opponent runs away with a fiery victory it seems to me that in a game where turn order is so significant players really ought to have opportunities to take control over it rather than simply following the traditional clockwise sequence of play fortunately we had enough fun to warrant another play and second time around was much more enjoyable subsequent games with a greater understanding of the dynamics at play were tighter more competitive and just more satisfying i fear that some others are going to be put off after a single play though especially if playing with two players only with higher play accounts the game becomes more interactive the turn order issue is obscured a bit and players are far more likely to cross each other's paths on that circle of spirits thereby allowing them to steal tokens from each other this adds a whole layer of tactics and chaos to the game which is absent in the two-player version so let's plot some pain points setups are chore learning the game from the rule book is tricky and the end game is anticlimactic but the core of the gameplay is really entertaining on my ladder engagement system i rate a game between zero and three in 5 different categories and that overall score of 10 or above propels a game to the highest rung on the ladder and indicates a real favorite with me
for thematic immersion living forest scores a 1. it's a confusing setting and but it's lifted by the evocative artwork for interaction it's a two the awkward turn order and the lack of interaction on the circular track at two players prevents me from awarding it the full three points but you certainly do need to keep your eye on what your opponents are doing at all times because of that race to the finish with the end game goals for stress and challenge living forest scores too i constantly find myself striving to achieve certain mini goals which are just out of reach if i can just pull one more sapling from my deck i can buy the tree that i want if i can just generate one more flower i'll win the game the feedback is high every round your card draw rewards you with tons of different symbols which you can use to explore different strategies when you purchase a new powerful card is placed on the top of your deck so it's going to be the first card you draw in the next round it's very satisfying to see the benefits of your actions immediately rather than having to wait for a shuffle of the discard pile as in so many earlier deck builders from meaningful choices it's a two there's a lot of luck involved but the choices in the game are satisfying do you purchase the gregarious creature who has few symbols but counteracts a solitary creature or do you risk purchasing that solitary creature who gives you loads of great stuff but risks tanking your round if it's drawn along with two of its mates the ultimate score of 10 indicates the
potential of the design but it's not helped by clunky onboarding both in terms of setup and unintuitive rules so i'm deducting a couple of points because that stuff just gets in the way nevertheless a score of eight positions living forest high on my ladder indicating an engaging package which falls slightly short of classic status moving on to my product design checklist so is the product innovative no not really there are many deck builders out there and many push your luck games i understand that the combination of these mechanisms used in living forest is very similar to the mechanism used in mystic veil another popular deck builder which i haven't yet had the chance to play innovation isn't the be-all and end-all so long as a game iterates on what's gone before and living forest combines popular mechanisms in a slightly different way to what we've seen but it really doesn't feel like there are even any micro innovations here it's all very familiar does the product fulfill a need again no i'm not sure quite which gap this game fills there are plenty of titles available in the niche of beautiful nature games there are tons of deck builders out there with a wide range of complexity levels and push your luck mechanisms are well represented in the hobby too cracks of quendenberg remains the pinnacle of the accessible push your luck deck building games though its core component is a bag of tokens rather than a deck of cards is the product able to grow with its user i don't think there's much opportunity
here there are three or four core strategies in the game and players will need to balance two or three of them each time they play there isn't that much to explore beyond that so variety in repeated plays is dependent on reacting to the actions of other players rather than any in-game content there's no variability to the setup which is one of the big strengths of cracks of quedlinberg so ultimately i can see players coming back to living for us from time to time but they're not going to uncover deep strategic opportunities over a prolonged period the game could grow with expansion sets though any expansion content is likely to be of the modular variety bolted on modes of play or additional cards with new symbols to access additional strategies and end-game goals this would increase variety but it would also inevitably add complexity so let's chart living forest on my idea execution matrix massive sellers combine a brilliant core concept with outstanding execution pushing them up into the red or orange part of the grid living forest is a pretty good idea it functions well as a game and i've had a lot of fun with it but it doesn't stand out as particularly innovative and even the iterations are insubstantial in terms of execution i'm once again scoring it middle of the road the animal art is the highlight but much of the presentation is a block of dark green the theming is a little bit confused and the onboarding is clunky the cover and title are pretty enough to catch your
eye but they aren't exceptional enough to be truly memorable overall living forest is a very good game but as a product it struggles to stand out it sits in the middle of the grid hardly a failure but it's not going to trouble wingspan or azul however if you're a quacks fan looking for a pretty game and a subtle change of pace this might be a really good option for you if you enjoyed the review please check out some of my others hit like and subscribe to the channel and i'll see you next time all the best