Skip to main content
Loading video...

How Good is The Path to Carcosa? (Arkham Path to Carcosa Week 2025)

Transcript 55:26

Hello everybody and welcome to the penultimate video here for Path to Carcosa week. We hope you've been enjoying it. At this point, this is the last video we're recording for Patosa week. We've done it. It's over and I hope you've been digging it. Um, this one is just like we did with Dunich where I actually here I have slides explaining it. A few weeks ago I released a survey to everyone asking people to rate the various Patharosa scenarios of the metrics of fun, design, and quality. We at this channel have talked a lot about our thoughts on Path of Carosa, but now let's see what the community's thoughts are on the campaign. Uh we had 96 votes rating for each. Yeah. Uh and a few comments as well, which I've included in the survey. We're just going to um basically review your reviews. That's what this one is. We're going to go through and uh kind of just see how it is. There's not really any surprises to this one.

No,

it was like I'm like, "Yep, that makes sense being high. That makes sense being the lowest." Hey. Yeah. I mean, we've been talking about this campaign for like six years or whatever.

Yeah. And it's Yeah. And as you said just before we went uh we started recording this like that unfortunately for uh all signs point to us already.

Oh, come on. Come back over here. All signs point to Carcosa not seeing reprints anymore, which is a bummer. Uh there are alternative ways to play Path of Carosa, and I highly recommend you check them out if you have not. um played Patosa, you can't buy it.

With a little bit of luck, Fantasy Flight will uh set up the like the campaigns that they're not going to print anymore in like a print and play format. You know, you throw them five bucks and

get the file download and you've got to figure out the rest yourself. I mean, you know, who knows what can happen is like a lot of things could happen. A lot of things could happen. Yeah. Like things could change. It might not be like as soon as you want, but who knows? We could be looking in three years being like

got fourway reprint equity like that.

Yeah. Yeah. Bring him out of the FFG bolt.

I think I think they might not be unwilling to throw away like the 600 SKs or whatever.

Yeah, it's fair.

That make up the caros like that.

Hi.

All right, let's go with our first one here, which is curtain call, which of all the votes had an 8 out of 10 for fun, an 8.2 for welldesigned, and an 8.3 for good.

Yeah, it checks out.

Yeah, it's a very good uh opening scenario. We're all big fans of it. We all love Big Butt Baby, right? I just I'm just here to jump off the balcony.

Yes. Yeah. Well, there that might be referenced in the comments that we have coming up here, too.

Little fun things in this scenario that really make it just

fun to explore, fun to poke around in. Um, yeah, it's really solid opening scenario how it starts out where they, you know, hey, go just go explore stuff and you do and then it kind of comes to a

a head and something horrible happens, it floods or it burns

or burns or there's vines or whatever it is

and then at the end they're like, "Oh no, everything looks normal." And you're like, "So that's how it's going to be." Okay.

It's a fantastic introduction to the campaign.

Yeah. And Yeah. And also like Yeah. Like the jumping off the balcony, the uh stealing from the um box office, right, which I don't think we've ever done.

No, we're good people.

Yeah, we're good people.

In this scenario.

Yeah. Yeah. Next one.

No. Especially not Barkham. I kill all the cats there.

You hear that, Russ?

Oh god.

You want me to be like a cat from Barkham?

No. All right. So, uh, from Janderfix, we has a seven all across the board for the rating. Amazing flavor that dives you into the campaign story right away. Interesting monster of the week mechanic for an opening scenario. I do kind of like I dig the monster of the week kind of stuff that was like most prevalent in Dunich cuz that was kind of just like an episodic

adventure. Um, but like even like the this is my one of my favorites in Hemlock with the giant crab, you know, like having like the big thing that you only see once. I really like that vibe for this kind of stuff.

Mhm.

I think I prefer this incarnation of the returning antagonist to that of Miscatonic Museum. It is pretty much always a threat to be dealt with with its passive horror creation. Also, who doesn't like jumping off a balcony from Adam, which gave 699 for the ratings there? Yeah.

I mean, if it worked if it worked in Skyrim, uh,

yeah,

it'll work any place probably.

So, do you want to play?

Yeah.

Why are you such a problem?

I know. You just got to sit there.

It's cuz you're a cat.

Yeah, I know.

Um,

but my one of the things I really enjoy with this one is the stress it puts on you to make sure you finish it when Big Butt Baby is in the victory display. Yeah. Like, I think that's

a very fun dance to have here. Yeah.

Yeah. I understand how that might be like a feels bad moment, but um

only the first time really.

Yeah.

And even then it's kind of like well the victory is just on here as a challenge, isn't it?

Yeah.

Yeah. It really is just like a bonus objective where things are going well enough that we can afford to work around this. And if they aren't, you know,

we just we just get out. Yeah. Try not to be dead.

Yeah. Uh, while I don't necessarily dislike the scenario, I find it odd that we get two sort of recurring enemies with both Big Butt Baby and the Man in the Palad Mask. Additionally, while the last act is supposed to bring variation to future playthroughs, they all just kind of feel awful awful for the players. That's from Crafty. Uh, which gave a 667 for the rating. Um, I mean like I think I guess the big the man in the pal mask is technically kind of recurring because you deal with him twice, but I never really viewed him that way personally.

No, to me he was just like part of the objective.

He's recurring because he's in another campaign. Yeah.

Yeah.

Okay.

He is probably.

Yeah. Um

Oh, he is. He actually he shows up in Dark Matter, right? Yeah. Well, I mean like not not just in another fan-made campaign, but which is also awesome. If you haven't checked it out, you probably should.

Yeah, Dark Matter is a good one.

Russ, you're you're making this all about you. And I know people at home love it. They love you,

but you're not even on camera right now.

Yeah,

stop standing over there.

At least I'm on camera.

Yeah.

Um and then Yeah. Big Bud Baby from Photostorm 789. Big Bug, baby.

Yeah. I some I mean, of all the things that we've ever put out into the universe that have

That's the thing that's like that's the one.

Yes. Like that's the thing that's like it's like stuck and it's kind of just like that's so I'm that's my greedy for reason why I'm actually most upset

that Carcosa is not getting printed anymore because the Big Bum Baby is just going to

fall to the ether and we're going to lose Big B forever.

Okay. We still have like foot head. will always will always have squid too. Squid's another one. Squid. Yeah, for that one. Like I just see people like talk about squid and I'm like I mean they probably came up with them with themselves but I'm like that [ __ ] is not a squid. [snorts]

All right, second scenario here. We have The Last King, which has an 8.5 for out of 10 for fun, an 8.4 for welldesigned, and an 8.6 for good.

Yeah, it's pretty fair, too.

Yeah. Yeah, this one's this one's just good. like um

it's nice and simple.

Yeah. We get like the front half that's like, "Oh, okay. We're going to go investigate what was happening at the theater."

Mhm.

And then the back half which is like just kidding Resident Evil [ __ ]

Yes.

Yeah.

Yeah.

I mean like the

parts are good.

Yeah. The Ishimaru Heroku um transformation is still like one of my most memorable moments because just like cuz you knew you knew the stuff cuz you had to sleeve it all, right? And I actually went I I found the video when I was prepping for the history of video and your anticipation of like when you gave me the card.

Uh it was just like it's just exciting and that's kind of like the real fun part of Arkham. Those little twists and turns that come with it.

Mhm.

Yeah. Also memorable because the skull token is a nightmare which is reveal another token. If you fail, place one doom on the nearest lunatic enemy.

And that's like when you uh you shot me with it a few times. Bin went like skull skull curse auto fail.

Good times.

Like yeah, a lot of stuff there.

Good times.

Um, one of the most elegant designs of a scenario in a game gives a good feeling of moving around a party and gives a challenge of killing the guests to help you from future scenarios. I just wish there wasn't an option to burn the house down to get the reward anyway. And that's tens across the board from Mr. Bofan. This is something that you've said a lot in the past about how it feels like um burning the party is like the the right answer as opposed to like a fun choice you can choose depending on your run.

Mhm.

Yeah.

And I mean like I have to agree because I always burn it down unless I kill constants and then my choice is but should I try something else for fun? But if constant's alive I was like no sorry she's dead.

Yeah. Yeah, it'd be nice if they like

gave you bonus experience if they're in the victory display at the end of their act of of their respective scenarios like two each or something and then actually gave you a reason not to do it on repeat playthroughs and

Yeah, that'd be cool. Or if burning the house down came with like an actual penalty.

Yeah. Not just one mental trauma. Yeah. Which is like

Yeah. Not just like pretty much nothing.

Yeah. Cuz in the final scenario like you don't It's not even like it's it just makes it like slightly harder to get to uh

be there. But I think that'd be like leave them at zero for last king, but then after that, yeah, worth VP would make you want to

greet it out for them.

Yeah.

Yeah.

Uh I wish there was an alternate option between burning them smart bornees and letting them live. Stupid and difficult. Adam across the board. Yeah, exactly what

we were just adding to there. That's probably why I put them on the same slide.

Oh, there's a third option. You can go to the police and then they laugh at you.

Yes, they're all going to laugh at you, Travis.

Yeah. They're like, "Haha, aren't you supposed to be in the asylum? Yeah. Wait a minute. Yeah. Someone's like, "We are those those guys." Yeah. You're just like, "There they this lady her spine went." All right. Make them away toys.

You're playing a joke out of us.

Uh, the wording on Diane Divine should have been corrected. Only flaw in this otherwise perfect scenario.

Oh, yeah. That isn't basic.

But it was.

Yeah. In a thing that's even harder to get.

Yes. It does kind of fit in with the like going crazy like it doesn't matter so much on it's not really there for replays but on the initial play through realizing like hey I can just kill the hostess.

Yeah. I mean that is

just kill a seemingly innocent person.

Kill her or even just like empty out someone before she arrives and then she just talks to them all night. Yeah. Like there's like two weird little

exploits with her that

I don't mind emptying someone out one so much.

Yeah.

Um cuz it's like

kind of a reward

for being able to focus down one of them.

Yeah. Yeah.

Yeah. For sure. Um

Yeah. Because what is in the return to you can't kill her, right? And she also it's like it fixes both of them. She's also supposed to be on one with at least one.

You can't you can't kill her and she does go to like with at least one.

I do like in the return to it also has the the random people as well, the random party guests that can go crazy. I

think it's a it's a nice return to, but like you said, it's even harder to get than the the original.

Even more difficult. Yeah,

it is nice to for the replay though.

Yeah.

Uh maybe a hot take, but after a few plays, the scenario becomes very rote. You just go to your best person and parlay with them as fast as possible and hope they don't flip. I love the theme and how impacts future scenarios, but The Last King itself is a fairly average play experience. 675 from Norse Caroff.

I mean, that's a sweet username, but

like hard disagree. You go to a party and you show up and you're Bob Jenkins and there's like a venture capitalist in the room and you're like, I'm something of a venture capitalist myself. So, you go and talk to him and start trying to secure a loan

to expand your vacuum business or whatever it is that Bob actually does cuz I don't think we ever really know.

It's it's it's vacuum adjacent vacuum adjacent. It's probably it's probably some sort of floor cleaning supply.

And then he comes back in France to get the rest of his his his ROI. He wants he's like, "You

I need that I need that money.

You owe me some money.

Where have you been the past month?"

Yeah. And then Bob's like, "Suck them up, boys." And the vacuums come flying in. Yeah.

Yeah. That was wild when that happened.

Yeah, that was crazy. Um, no, but it like I I don't disagree with you. There is for most scenarios on a replay

a fairly straightforward and like this is what we do.

Like we want to win, this is how we play.

Yeah. Um, so like breaking out of that is definitely a little bit of like making up your own fun

as you go of like why are these characters doing this thing or like

and I I this is funny or like hey this guy's like trying to talk to me but I have a shotgun so that's too bad.

And I feel like even with that like even though if you have the game plan it's like okay we're going to get them first. I feel like every time I play last king there's always a moment where it's like okay we have a 33% chance that you flip. We haven't talked to you yet.

I hope it's not you. Oh my god, it's the one with our clover. Actually, we're in trouble, right? I feel like that's where the fun of the scenario. Yeah. Yeah. There is like a lot of mechanical

like variance. Yes. Within this within the situ like the the scenario because uh it doesn't always work the same way every time.

Yeah.

Like the plan going into it might be the same every time,

but

the actual execution is not.

Yeah. That's something that Path of Caros does very well designwise, I think, is every scenario kind of starts more or less starts the same way and ends the same way. He's gone.

Yeah.

Um, they all kind of start the same way. They all kind of end the same way more or less. Like you have some variance like the the penultimate scenario, whether you have to go up or down. Mhm.

Um but ultimately it's like the variation in the middle parts that makes them all so replayable despite the story staying the same

pretty much every time.

Yeah, I agree.

Yeah.

All right, on to this is The Last King again. Let's go. Good job. Pass Justin. This is Echoes of the Past. 5.6 out of 10, 5.2 out of 10, and 5.4 out of 10. Man, I'd give this one way more fun on the rating, but only for the first three and a half turns.

Yeah. Or alternatively, if you're playing the assets only challenge and you can just play all your assets and have tons of fun just doing your all your [ __ ]

So dumb.

Yeah.

I mean, they didn't get us and we had like a million things.

Yeah.

Yeah. I I think this one's commonly considered to be the like

the weakest one.

Yeah.

Yeah, that's fair.

Um comments here. I like the idea of cultist literally looking for clues at the same time you are and it's a race. Unfortunately, once the big boy arrives, everything stops and our focus shifted to the boss.

I think the flavor of this one is very cool.

Um, just like the idea that the cultists are also there. They don't actually engage with you except for agent of the king, like the guy who actually hunts you down.

Yeah.

But they're just kind of like looking through stuff, too. It's a big historical society. You can move through, maybe interact with them, but if you don't, obviously, you get punished because they're trying to do the same thing you are. Or they're just people looking for just normal stuff.

They might be. Yeah. Who knows? Uh I don't like I don't like the the flavor of um like guy finds something that he was looking for

somehow manages to communicate it to everyone on his team around the knife in his throat now.

Yeah.

Like okay, sure. I get it from a I get it from like a mechanical standpoint cuz like if you could just kill them then

this isn't really a scenario at all, is it?

Yeah.

I mean it's kind of the same for the investigators too. like a a little bit of suspension disc.

Yeah, but they're not going to kill me

for the game mechanics though. No, but it's like if you're the clue up top and you have six clues and then your flex is down the bottom with three clues and you're like, we spend them cuz we magically know that we have all the information we need,

right? Like

Yeah, they have the same sort of like hive mind, you know, that stuff. That doesn't really come up too often for me.

No, it doesn't.

Yeah.

Yeah. Uh we like the hidden library, but the scenario felt really lame. Yeah, it would be nice if they like flattened out the difficulty.

Mhm.

Um I think that the start of it's good, but if they like had guys spawn and chew up some clues on acting agenda flips or something like that.

Mhm.

Yeah. I think just like it sounds weird because the scenario is so in your favor if you survive the three like the first three and so against you if you don't. But I feel like it needs like um more threat like the various points throughout it, you know? Like I feel like it should have been one of those scenarios where like threats came on the act flip as opposed to the agenda flip, right?

Yeah.

I think that might have done a better pacing for it.

Yeah. Like we're we're doing better at figuring out what's going on so they send guys to break our legs.

Yeah. Like like a r like a rubber band catchup mechanic. Yeah.

Yeah. Uh, every campaign has to have a bad one, I guess. And honestly, 546 is actually like a good rating for a bad one.

Yeah, like if this is the worst, if your worst one is above average on the scores,

unless of course people are using a video game rating system, in which case a five is awful. But, you know, that's why everyone has their own scale and we just average out their ratings because then it, you know, gives hopefully some sort of semblance of an actual rating here. Um, generally talked about as the lowest ranked scenario of the campaign, but I never felt it was that bad. Basic Arkham gameplay is still fun, but I get that the loop that can occur makes it a bit too long. Definitely can be like once you've survived those first three-ish turns.

Sometimes the rest of the scenario just

you just you have to do it. like we're going through the motions and like we'll get there eventually, but

yeah, it feels kind of like fighting the broods.

Yeah.

Yeah. Uh speaking of my my group only plays the first two or three rounds, then calls the scenario over and picks the resolution we want is once you handle the first wave of cultist, the scenario is effectively over. Okay. So that means that your rating doesn't count for anything because you don't play the game. Yeah.

So

you're playing like a different game. You've made up your own game, which is perfectly fair and like I'm glad you enjoy it.

Yeah. But um it does make your rating meaningless to the rest of us.

Yeah, you gota you got to sink the blade in either Mr. Peabody or the possessed O speaker to really feel like

what kind of data analysis is you for this? Did you like control for any of the uh

No, no, no. It but it's it's the it's the most official one we have, so we have to take it. Okay.

All right. Right, on to the unspeakable oath, which has nine, 9.3, and 9.3. This one was crazy. There was no I think like no rating below a seven for this one, and the sevens were very scarce.

A great scenario.

Yes,

it's the one that we played.

Yeah. I mean, after the first time I played it, I would have told you this one sucks. But after like every time after that, it's like, no, this one's the good one.

Yeah. Like

the best one. There's a lot of good ones.

Yeah. There's like actual pressure to like do well.

Yeah. like an actual like real like choke you out consequence.

No, no fail forward here. We don't do that.

Yeah.

Yeah. There's like more pressure in this one.

We go back to the stone age if we fail.

Yeah. No, there's more pressure on this one than there are in the ones that just lose you the campaign cuz then you're done. Like who cares? You're all you're all start again or play the scenario.

Yeah. This one you still got to play and your guy just sucks.

Yeah. And you can watch everyone else who made it out with like all their XP and you're just like

Yeah. But also you can't play the investigator you picked. Yeah. They're gone. Like they're just you know, labbotomized or whatever.

That's fine. There's always other

So, you got to pick somebody else.

Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.

All right. Um, great mechanics, awesome theme, challenging difficulty, satisfying to overcome, integrated very well into the campaign, oath is a perfect storm of how an Arkham scenario should be.

Yep.

Yeah, pretty much. I I would like to see more penalty for failure.

Yes, it's fun

within within the game. Yeah, it's fun. Even even if that penalty comes with like a little bit of uh like hey so you lost bad but not bad enough to be dead right now.

Yep. I would love it if they here's a thing so you can keep playing. I know the community at a whole the the the opinion would skew that they would hate this but I would even love it if like you could like lose an arm like your character could lose like a hand slot. Like it might [ __ ] over your deck but it's like exciting and interesting that a story could have that kind of like story beat to come with it. Just like just like a little bit more Cola Cthulhu flavor. Not like the whole jar, just

Yeah.

Maybe say like a guardian weapon or something like that, like volatile hand cannon and

it's like pretty good, but if you get defeated while you have it in play, it blows your arm off and you get like a permanent weakness that saves you one less hand slot.

Make it multiclass and it happens if you draw a scholar or an auto fail.

Yeah, there you go.

Guardian survivor. Oh, [ __ ]

I think it actually does. It does like a [ __ ] ton of damage to non- elites, right? Like like a comically large number.

Yeah.

Like nine.

Yeah.

Or something stupid like that. That's like, yeah, you don't need this much damage to kill a thing.

Yeah. But like, don't [ __ ] up.

Yeah.

Yeah.

Uh I think it'd be really see a campaign that took place over like a long period of time and had the intention of killing your investigator like a third or halfway through. Oh, you honestly gave me such a great idea where it's like

uh like every like like the kind of like it where like every 20 years he comes back, but it's like every like 10 years at like a site where a ritual happens by like just like when the cosmics align. Like that would be really cool.

That would be a really interesting uh like revisit for Aster actually.

Yeah.

Where they uh you know they have the play like one time and then for like you have three scenarios leading up to it and then those investigators like die. Yeah. and then the next five or whatever the the successors.

That would be like I mean that would be like also like a cool way to do like a dream eater style thing without just like aping the dream eaters like concept.

And they could they could if they really wanted to they could have like a carry forward experience mechanic or something like that. Like if your investigator survives that third scenario, they can pass on like what they they get visited in the asylum by their new investigator who gives them like a third of the experience they had or some [ __ ] Or even would be uh I I some custom campaigns do this and I think it can be really fun where like you can give like a card from your deck to the new person. So they even can break their deck building stuff just like here's this

vacuum cleaner to die in the police force or whatever. He'll help you out.

Man, that would be hype. Okay, anyways. Oh man, that's I want to play that right now. [ __ ] Um, I'm not exactly sure where the line blurs between me thinking this is one of the best scenarios ever and Justin always telling me that this is one of the best scenarios ever. It's the second one.

It's one of the best scenarios ever.

So, here's the thing. It's actually the same.

Yeah.

It's the same place.

Yeah.

Yeah. Just let Justin decide your pain is for you.

Well, at least this one.

Yeah. Yeah. No, this Yeah. Yeah. All of them because we all Yeah, we all agree on this one. So, uh, top five scenarios in the game.

I agree. I agree. Uh, some Arkham War scenarios in the campaign are so intimidating that you feel dread when you know they're coming. Some are so amazing that you feel excitement when you know they're coming. This is scenario that I feel both dread and excitement when I know it's coming. Is by far my favorite scenario, never failing to raise my blood pressure and deliver a feeling of relief and accomplishment when I make it out of the asylum.

Yeah,

I mean, I agree with this cuz like I love Carcosa. Obviously, it's my I it's my favorite campaign and I doubled down on that after this this theme week. But to me, this campaign is like the push towards the asylum. And then afterwards, I'm like, "All right, I got to just like enjoy the rest of this now." Like, I feel like I've won the campaign because I just

enjoy going through the asylum so much. And it's such a big like

hurdle that I I like jumping over it.

Um, not to break. Well, I'm not This is not related to the video, but do you want to do a like Carcosa run where at the end of the Carosa run, we play Dark Matter with new investigators who get like a card or like

Yeah, I think that'd be a fun thing to do. That'd be fun. Yeah, that's a great idea. Yeah. Yeah.

Descendants.

Yes,

that would be cool.

I mean, we just made a new format, by the way. Everyone always talks about carrying over your investigators. What if you can like gift a card and we can

We can do it. We can do it.

We could do that.

I like that idea, though. I like that idea.

A standout for good reason. Incredibly tense with exquisitly timed progression/ escalation of threats. Perhaps this scenario that best captures the doubt versus conviction divide in terms of getting the players to question their own actions. Why would I want to start fire in the kitchen again? still the best mid campaign end to part one finale in my book.

The only that's honestly the only part of this scenario that I dislike is when they're like you try to start a fire in the kitchen. You can't like you kidding me. They got gas stoves in here and I can't start a fire in this room.

Well, it's easy. It's like it's really on you for not doing it well.

Yeah. Like that's not right. No work. Um

show up with your one book and you're like you like punch the stove or whatever. It doesn't explode. You're like,

"Oh,

your guns shoot it." It doesn't

I do I do uh I do love how uh

movies

like the the threats like like you get all the stupid patients that spawn in the in like the middle yep the middle halls and they're like this guy doesn't matter. He's not going to matter. And then you're trying to get out and you're like

they he matters and there's three of them.

That would never happen to you.

That happens every time. actually changed the way that I approach deck building where I'm like, what if

just getting out was good sometimes.

Y

um

yeah, like yeah, the escalation where it's like you get two turns of setup and then the patients come and then it turns into monsters in the last one is like really nice.

Yeah. Like before this scenario, I would have looked at like I'm out of here and been like this card's pointless. It just commits for two two foot.

Yeah.

And after that I'm like

card's pretty real.

Yeah. Yeah. It's It's

not just for this scenario.

No, but yeah, it's just like a great tech place. But

yeah, they forgotten the age helped with that.

Yes. Yeah. Uh another thing I do like is the whole like the where this now puts the pushes the themes of the campaigns on the player. Like the starting a fire in the kitchen. Uh and when I was doing the retrospective with Erica, it was like why is my character doing it? But like when you play Carcosa a few times, you start to understand, oh, it's because I might be crazy.

The card said I could.

Yes. Wouldn't that

the stove was just right there, you know?

It would be kind of funny if there was one that was like a trap or something.

Yeah.

Yeah. One of them that's like, "God, why would you do that?"

Yeah. Some guards show up and they're like,

"What the hell?" It's not even on the act to do it.

Um, giving the scenario nine instead of 10 for fun because it makes me panic. I mean, I think that's fair. Like

I think that like it is a scary stressful scenario and it makes it both fun but I can also understand you know

the roadblock that comes with it cuz I mean honestly I'll be real every time we start a Pat Carosa in the back of my mind I'm like okay but who's my backup just in case but I still love it.

Just my ass pick someone with a similar card. Boom boom deck.

That's the new way. Every day you're going to come with the lost homunculus and you're just going to be like

there's no downside. you just die,

you know. I get I do get it though, like some kind some kinds of stress are fun and some kinds are not. And which kind is which, it depends on the individual.

Yes. Yeah.

Uh I forgot I did four for this, but that's because of the name of the user for the middle one, which we'll get to.

It's so good. Everyone knows it. I just wish there wasn't so many tasks you could do in the basement. I want to force you to explore more on replays. I like this. I like this message because you really only have to do like you have to do what? Four tasks, I think.

And there's three in the basement.

Yeah.

I think it might be like I think it could have been cooler if there was like the one first aid ward that we never go to. I know there's victory there to make it.

Yeah.

But I think that it the

they could put something in there in the return to.

Yeah. And I was going to say like even just like having a more variety I think really would make this one pop somehow even more.

Um walk boom. I just had to put you on this one cuz it's a great great name.

Yeah. Who have you lost in the asylum, Justin?

Um I lost a Matteo in the No, a Dexter in the asylum. Uh that's my most recent one. And I lost We We did a run together where Brenn and I got in but you got out.

Yeah. I'm not sure I've ever lost someone in the asylum.

No. Well, it makes sense because you're the one who's like, "I'm going."

Yeah. I'm leaving.

And then we're like, "Okay, Travis, how can we get you out of here?"

Yeah. I'm not going to ask you who you've lost in song, but I know you can't.

It's like actually it's actually probably like more than half of the people I've played through this scenario.

Yeah. I don't I don't think I've ever lost when I was doing two-handed solo myself. I think I've only lost like two or three people.

Yeah.

You know, the only one I know for sure is Father Matteo because we were doing a theme paradoxical run and let me tell you, it was bad.

The curse and bless runs were great. Paradoxical, not so much. Paradox paradoxical is like a little bit of a hot mess.

Yeah. Well, I think that's also just my complicated thing on mystics and two-player. I think the because they don't have good melee options like guardians relying on spells. As soon as you run out of charges, you're like, I hope my next one's here. That's the It's complicated, but

poor Dexter's inside. And Eric losing Dexter uh when uh doing a delve too deep on the last turn was the best.

Yeah. No one to to blame themselves.

Yeah. And I I

didn't know, but

I just Yeah. They played it and I was like, "You're dead. I'm sorry." Like,

it's over.

Yeah. Uh, very thematic with a possible wipe out on the table. I love it. And I think if everyone gets locked in, you do lose. I think your your story doesn't you don't continue unless somebody makes it out,

which I think is like the best way of doing it, too. It's just it's just really good. It's just really good.

All right. The Phantom of Truth Brin. I included Torturous Quartz here for you. the antibrin card. Man, I think I think How many of these are there even in the deck? Like 17.

Three.

Two. I think

there's only two.

Maybe three. Like I'm pretty I'm pretty sure I've ended up with three in play. So either Travis is griefing me

or he's right

or there are three of them.

Um

play through this and we're going to put your coffees into

Yes. Yeah. Yeah.

Yeah. That that card is that card's a beating sometimes. Well, it's probably because you also come in with like a zero XP rogue deck. That also doesn't help.

That also doesn't help.

You're like, "My lockpicks cost six."

Yeah.

I mean, like, it's a lot of fun when you show up and you're playing like stupid cheap assets for stuff and you're like,

"Sorry, how much did painkillers cost in Paris?"

Yeah.

Oh, um, this one got a 7.2 two for fun, 7.5 for welldesigned, and a 7.3 for good.

Yeah, I love I love I love the enemies in this one. There's

Yeah, they're really cool. I think

Yeah,

a very neat way to approach um like maybe you should evade like I mean obviously if you're good enough, you don't like your numbers big enough you don't have to. But

yeah,

but yeah,

think you could.

Um the two different ways the scenario plays are genius. Hunters are hunted. So clever. It is implemented very well.

Yeah.

Yeah. Yeah, I would probably given this higher than the seven and a half or whatever it got for design. I probably given it like a nine, honestly.

I think the design is Yeah. very tight for this one. Yeah, for sure.

It's very impressively done.

Yeah. Uh the design of Phantom is way higher than its actual play experience. Mechanically, it makes sense. The sense of surviving a night of hell is actually reflected in the game. Big dread factor and a nice open map that richly a map that richly reflects the Parisian setting. Why isn't it more fun? Maybe because it feels on rails somewhat where the players are stuck reacting more than acting.

Sorry. Do you not like Resident Evil?

No.

Like that game's also on rails.

Yeah, it is. Yeah. I

mean, maybe it doesn't.

Yeah. But

I think that's probably because it's not like there's like an indeterrent amount of time before the the scenario ends, right?

Yeah. Well, I think that reacting more than acting is an an interesting way of putting it because it is like I think the best scenarios are when there's the balance between reacting and acting. It's like when do we push the objective? When do we like have to solve a game's problem? This one, especially on the um

it's kind of funny cuz like the one where you're hunting him, it's all acting and the one where he's hunting you, it's all reacting. So, you kind of just like don't get

Well, that's a that's a fair point actually. reacting over acting cuz when you're when you're hunting him, if you're ahead of the game, you can just push the objective and win faster. Whereas, if you're ahead of the game and you're running away from him, you still have to wait the same amount of time for the game to end.

Yeah,

you can't really advance it. I mean, you you can like pay clues for doom or something like that.

No, I think just Oh, I think you can. I think you can.

Yeah, but it's like always better to evade them usually.

Yeah, but uh it is mostly just kind of waiting.

Yeah. Yeah.

It's like kicking the the beast.

Yeah. Yeah. Down like we're gonna win. He's like, "No,

please. I'm all powerful. I I saw the library the library of Alexandria burn down." You're like, "Back in the pit."

He's scrambled at the same kick.

I don't care, Grandpa. I love that we only played that scenario once and we're like, it was just We hated it all so much. We've never even I haven't gone back there. Even when I've done it with other people, I was like, I don't want to go back there.

That's fair. Although I mean like our our like every rerun we've done of the Scarlet Keys has been like

Well, we've only done one.

We could we could go to Louisiana.

Yeah, I think we've only done one rerun, right? Well, we technically did two when we did the groundhog run where we follow the exact same path.

Yeah. Yeah.

We should do another Scarlet Keys where we just do standal ones again. It's a great time.

I mean, it was actually like fun.

And we have I have the uh I have the Midwinter Gala which is it's a there's some great allies in that one too that you get.

We could also buy like that Hollywood one in. Yep. Yep. When it ships in Canada. Yeah. Like if it ever does.

Who knows?

Uh very creative design, anxiety producing antagonist. One of the most memorable scenarios in the campaign.

Um I do like the I think the like the hunting um organist is very good. I think it's a really good translation of the short story, too.

Mhm.

Uh about the most middling scenario in existence. Interesting design, but ultimately falls flat. And then I like this one. Feels like it's underrated a bit. I mean that's why we have all these things like a little bit of a little taste of everything.

Honestly, Gear Master Nail, they gave it a eight fun, nine design, eight good and the scores were like seven and a half, 7.3 or whatever.

Yeah, this a little tiniest bit. That's funny.

Yeah. But is that the last one for this one? No, there's more.

Um, it's okay. We only ever we've only ever gotten the guy who runs away from you and it's just annoying. And it's still a neat puzzle and even some of the worst scenarios are still kind of fun and interesting though I might not enjoy them much. So does that mean you rarely burn the people or do you just choose doubt for everything else if you always get when he runs away from you? Cuz I think he runs you on doubt and he he chases you on conviction. I think cuz we always get the chase and we always burn the people.

I don't remember. That's part of the fun I have with this campaign.

No, that's the thing too. I actually forgot that there's a third option for fighting Hastur at the end where you have to put on the mask. When I was going through the cards and I saw the back of one, I was like, "What the [ __ ] is this?" Oh, that's the one we never see.

Yeah. I mean, we also haven't played the finale of Carcosa in like probably like two years.

Yeah. It's been wild.

We died in the Black Stars Rise in the last one.

That's I mean, just like one of the things that can happen to you, which is which makes it fun.

Yeah.

Mhm.

Uh the difference between doubt and conviction is what makes me rate this on the lower end. Fighting the organist is way more fun than running away and can be awkward for many fighters to manage the running away variant. Uh this is also why I actually included this these two on the same slide because if you're if one is more fun or you're always getting one, try the other path is something you could do even though we always burn the people.

Path to Carcosa. You're suggesting this should have been called paths.

Yes, it should have been called the paths to Carcosa.

Yeah.

Yeah. Something to consider the next time you play this campaign.

Yeah. Yeah. I mean like Yeah. No way. We're just

Yeah.

We're just going to leave that shot on fire.

All right. On to the Palad Mask, which got an 8.2, an 8.4, and an 8.3.

This one's good.

Yeah.

Yeah. They got

I mean, they mostly they mostly are. And like there's a there's a reason this one is like

Yeah.

You know,

love my favorite. Yeah.

Like I I enjoy I enjoy several of the other ones, but this one is like

the good one.

Yeah. Yeah. You know,

not that other ones are all bad, but

Yeah. This is the one that really one of them's got to be the best.

Yes.

Yeah.

Um this guy, this thing has a lot of hint, like a lot of big hits in it. The catacombs do is a great uh enemy that can turn into the the big guy. There is the I like the return of the ghoul set and I they just feel like a fun little like addition to the whole thing. Nice to have grasping hands.

Um

makes sense they live in the catacombs.

Yeah. Yeah. And then the the sprawling map is kind of like a revolutionary mechanic that is been used multiple times since. [clears throat] Yeah.

I think every time we've played this outside of the first Travis and I have been like what's the worst direction for the map to go for the camera?

Yes. Yeah. Every time. Yeah.

Every time.

Yeah.

Yeah. That's the way I want. It's a fun little It's a fun little mini game that we get to play that's unique to us.

Uh oh, baby. Corpse dwellers are so cool. Fantastic enemy design. Hey, we can't deal with that guy that's a spawn at a connecting location, but if he stays around too long, you turn into an enemy we have to deal with, so be ready. Spectre of death is interesting. The scenario tokens can really hurt you if you get the wrong ones. The scenario plays well, but sometimes you only got to go to go in one direction. It's not too fun. I want the wackiest map. I mean, the map variety is what makes it so exciting. How it can be just a straight shot, but then the next time you play, it's like a wibbly wobbly. There was one where you and I did a bin. It was the assets only where it was the last location in the deck, which was really cool, right?

Yeah. We had to we had to we had to we had to like go back through like half of the map to get to

Yeah, we had to we had to go back. We could we could like put another location down

and like it was a mess. and like how it can do all of that without any added complexity, right? Like it's just like that's the way it plays every time, but the map can be completely different. This is what you were saying earlier

about the replayability within the campaigns is a big reason why Carcosa is so good.

Mhm.

Yeah.

Uh it's a fun explore mechanic, but nothing really screams out at me. Not even the ghost watching behind you. Oh, no. That is the ghost. Skeleton Ice King.

Yeah.

Isn't that Arthus?

Yeah. Oh, yeah.

Yeah.

Uh something like that.

Great, great design for the time it was released, but since then there have been other scenarios that I feel do a random dungeon map better. Hemlock Veil First Night Scenario for instance. But as we always say, someone's got to walk before other people can run. I mean, I think the best dungeon map, maybe not for terms of location, but in terms of threat, is like the opening of Inmouth where like

it spreads out and can really impact it.

Yeah.

Yeah.

Yeah. I don't like that one because I know what all the pieces are.

Yeah.

And I now I have to remember which ones they could be and what the

might next time play some of them out.

Then you won't have to worry about it. Yeah. Cuz there'll be no,

you know, that was what I was hoping for out of the out of the like the return to

that we never got.

That we never got.

Yeah. Just some randomized for the title. just like two or three extra tidal tunnel locations that were like shuffle these up.

Yeah.

Take two of them out.

I mean, there was a a fan-made um in that was really good, but there's nothing saying that we can't do it either. We could just make some and then I could print them and

I'm just going to make one that like kills me.

Yeah. I mean, yeah, of course.

Like if you're playing the one that kills me for bring you're dead. Like

what the [ __ ] Dang. That's what the card says. That's what we got to do.

Oh man. All right. Uh, one of the most replayable scenarios in the game. I absolutely love the focus on the man in the pallet mask and the maze-like structure of the catacombs below.

Yep. Hell yeah.

Yep.

I do enjoy anytime the man in the pallet mask poses a real problem, you can just show up with like a flamethrower or whatever, like light them up.

All right.

Mhm.

All right. Uh, Black Stars Rise here. 7.3 7.6 7.4.

Yeah, that's pretty fair.

Yeah. Uh, I wish there was a moral way of setting up the random objectives since that can often be done wrong during blind runs and fiddly to do in physical either way. Love the concept of two agendas and no act though. I mean, it is kind of a nightmare to set up

in paper. You've always said it. It's never been enjoyable.

No,

no,

it's not the worst one though.

But I do feel like I think for me and I always feel like I have to like double check cuz if you screw it up like you you [ __ ] the scenario like you're going to have problems. is I swear if you [ __ ] it up, you're just like, "Yeah, we did it."

Yep.

Hand wave. No, it's all good. It's all good. Don't worry about it.

We would have got there.

Uhhuh.

You play with it. You play with new people and you realize you [ __ ] it up, you just like pick up the identic card, you're like, "Oh, uh, yeah." Sners are over R2, too.

Yeah. Yeah.

Yeah. No, the part of this one that I love is the attention to detail

with like the artwork on the locations.

Yes.

Now, it is also something that I love about like the organists. of truth. Yeah.

Sure. Yeah, that's what it could be called. That's what I That's what I said.

No.

Yeah. Yeah, it is.

Um, but uh

people watching you guys can just rewind a couple minutes [snorts] and and check for yourselves.

No, you can't.

It's against the rules.

Okay.

Yeah. You [snorts] just made up.

If you rewind the videos, you're stealing watch time from me. So, please don't do that.

YouTube scores on watch time right now. Sorry, start the video over and watch again to that place.

That's that's preferable, please. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Thank you. Thank you, Travis.

Yeah. But like how how uh how much attention to detail they put into the art and making the [clears throat] locations look like the real world place that they are.

Yeah.

Mhm.

I love that.

Yeah.

It's a nice touch.

Mhm.

Uh really cool mechanic with multiple act decks and trying to figure out which one to progress through.

Yep.

That's a trick you don't figure out. You just do one.

Yeah. You just you just

That's not good. Yeah, I mean, you kind of have the time, right? You run one, run the other, run one, and then you go m we're in trouble or smooth sailing.

Uh, once you know it, it's easy to game the system, but overall, I really like the idea of having to balance different agendas and the scenario does it very well. It is easy to game the system once you do know it. But somehow you can still die if you're playing a limited collection and you see nine clues on your location and you think, "We got that." And then suddenly you don't.

You don't got it. No.

Mhm.

Sometimes you don't.

But it's funny how quick it can slip away, too, cuz there's some treacheries in that that encount in that uh encounter deck that can really like act three where they just brutalize you.

Yeah. Yeah. There's also also like the whole Yeah, we got this. And then the beast of Aldderon shows up and you're like,

yep,

guys, I don't think we got this.

He's huge. Um, very standard arkham with a slight twist at the axe of the agenda. Kind of like a brightly colored fleing without flavoring.

That's not unfair.

Yeah, I mean that it is the hook of the scenario, but there isn't much going on beyond that.

And this scenario is the reason I like Arkham so much. Hell yeah.

It's a good It's a good penultimate scenario.

It is.

Yeah. I mean, if we all agreed on things that weren't just the asylum, it would wouldn't be such an interesting hobby.

Yeah. Yeah. Exactly. But if you disagree with me about the asylum, you're wrong. Feel bad.

That's the one. That's the one that we have. Yeah. That we take.

That's uh final scenario here. Dim Carcosa 7.8, 8.0, and uh 7.9 here for the last one.

Mhm.

Yeah. I think this one's probably my favorite like showdown with an old one.

Yeah.

In this game,

cuz Lost in Time in Space isn't really a showdown. You're mostly just like,

he's just kind of there. He's like,

"What are you doing?"

Yeah. Yeah. But this one you're actually and you're like, I'm gonna I'm gonna leave.

Yeah.

Um

you you don't really fight. You just run away with

Yeah. I mean or or you show up with the intention of fighting him and you just brutalize him with like a machine gun or whatever.

Yeah. That's an option. Aithoth, you don't really fight. You're just like desperately

Asithoth is there and he But he's like, [clears throat]

"Why are you in my house?"

Yeah. He's like, "Would you like to look at my house?"

Yeah. Would you like to look at my beat up? and you're like,

"Is there another choice?" And he's like, "Yes,

but you won't take it."

Um, but I think yeah, like cuz I think what also helps with this one is that there's the different flavors of Hastur that you fight, like the one in your mind, the one who's actually there. I think it's really neat.

I do really really enjoy the uh

I actually think the return to adds quite a bit to this one as well with the extra location that you go to. Um, but no, I like this one a lot as well as an a final scenario. You actually get to explore Carosa and interact with lots of references to the stories and the lore that

are like kind of related but kind of disjointed.

Um, and it does feel a little bit like a play as well where each of the people in the on your team kind of has their own role to fill.

Yep.

And you need to be a little bit autonomous. You can't just roll around as a death ball. um you are probably going to need to split up a bit and the sand mechanic is also very fun.

Yeah. Very cool. Unless you're playing three rollings.

Yeah.

Yeah.

Yeah. You know, it is really neat to like the set for this one is always really impactful when you're playing with new people and you go to

Carcos like Yeah. You take half your sanity damage also like being they're like I'm going to die. I'm like, "No, going crazy does not kill you here."

Yeah. Yeah. It's very cool. Yeah.

Yeah.

Good finale.

Yep. I like having the two different variations of Hastur based on the decisions you made over the course of the campaign, but I question the value of including the third variant. The odds of finding organically seem profoundly small and gunning for it on purpose requires intentionally failing scenarios and other counterintuitive behavior. It seems like a waste. I mean, there's got to be ways to do it like cuz you there's one option where you get to choose and I'm sure there's there's going to be ways you can do it without failing scenarios.

Yeah, probably.

Yeah. I don't remember enough about the resolutions to say for sure, but

yeah. But I mean, I do like that there's three. Uh I think that was something that like after Dunich, they started to add like reasons to kind of run campaigns back, things to strive for. Like with Forgotten Age, they had Alejandro and

Well, they already had that a little bit in Dunich with like the different starring scenarios and the you got

Yeah, that's fair. Yeah. And like who was sacrificed? Yeah, that's fair. Yeah. Um, and I like that this is kind of like uh Carosas that like you get like a final changing boss fight. I think that's kind of neat.

Mhm.

I like the mechanic of flipping locations. Veiled was redone a few times, but would like to see more of it. It is a very good story.

Like Yeah. And like that's the thing about like

what if I got a campaign for you?

Yeah. No, definitely like seeing this rather than I mean interludes are fine, but I would much prefer seeing the story cards.

Yeah.

Um

like in the game, not

Yeah. as part of the setup or

because that was what um uh Axelottle the designer of dark matter his inspiration for scan was he was like veiled and story cards are cool how can I make that be in the game more you know and I think like scan is the best mechanic made by a fan I think and it's because of that it's basically just like a reiteration of what happens here and he still found neat ways to explore it

that's my biggest ding on Arkham personally is that They have cool mechanics, but I feel like they don't explore those mechanics.

They do kind of underexplore them a little bit. I think I think there's a lot of pressure for them to come up with some like they design something initially and then they kind of settle on it

and then I mean they have actual time pressures to push out the door for printing and whatnot. Um or they might not be able to develop something as much as they can but there's also a lot of pressure to uh innovate new mechanics as opposed to revisiting old ones.

Yeah. And that's like why like but

even like Drown City I was excited about flood. I wish they did a bit more with it. But like hopefully maybe like they come back to like a hast retread and they're like we can revisit these mechanics and try to explore what they mean with a different perspective.

Yeah. Uh not a fan of Dim Carosa. I rate it lower than Echoes of the Past.

I'd like to know why.

Yeah. I know some people um don't like this finale and I don't want to speak for Half Orange here, but I know a lot of people don't like it because it's it's a hard finale, which I understand people like winning, but I kind of dig it that it's one of the finales apart from Black before the Black Throne where I actually like,

okay, if I didn't tech for and bring horror healing, there's a good chance that things could slip away for me very suddenly.

Yeah. I mean, I've I've always been of the opinion that if I'm playing a cooperative game and it's never difficult and I never lose,

why am I playing this game?

Yeah. You know, like if I don't have to try to like hard to win.

Mhm.

I could go do something else.

Yeah.

Yeah. If you want the story, you can like go

Yeah. I could just I could just like, you know, go watch TV or whatever.

Go read through the cards.

Yeah. Yeah. I think

um not like to disparage you like you know you're fair enough. If you don't enjoy it, you don't enjoy it.

If you're if you're watching in the comments, definitely let us know. You can uh expand on that.

I'd love to read it.

That's just like my take on

Yeah.

on difficult difficulty pertaining to cooperative games. Like I I need to be losing sometimes.

Yes. Yeah.

Yeah. Um, I like how the finale changes based on your actions during the rest of the campaign. It's a very successful thing in that and it's kind of like a different version of the Dunich thing where Dunich kind of was more like um you had the reactive to like how the agenda set on the back for when those flipped, but like Carcosa actually can change the structure of it.

And I also really like it's a very simple thing, but just where you entered where you enter depends on where you finished the last scenario is like a fun little touch. I

think it's really neat. It's those little things that really make the campaigns feel good.

Mhm.

It doesn't take much for a lot of those things.

Yeah. This is the the shirt you want, right?

This is this the shirt. Yeah.

Very good finale. Not necessarily the best, but underappreciated in my opinion. I thoroughly enjoy the horror mechanic and the variety of playthroughs. I agree.

Yep.

My f my favorite final scenario in all of Arkham. The vibes are again immaculate. I love the story card backs of all the locations, the creeping feeling that maybe none of this was real, and the way horror works in the scenario all make it very memorable. I think that just echoed what we've been saying from the start of this one. But that's uh I agree.

Yeah, that little the like hidden ending of if you leave like if you leave this scenario and you've got one of the whispers in your head or

very cool. Yeah, the possessed. Yeah, very cool. Yeah, that's some cool stuff.

Yeah. Okay, time for the overall ratings. And this is no, this is no surprise. This is unlike uh Dunich which kind of had like variety for which one was the most fun, which was the most design well designed, which one was the most good. Uh this one it's all Echoes of the Past for the bottom and all Unspeakable Oath for the top.

Mhm.

So like that's uh no, as I said, no real surprises here. I think everything rated kind of like where where I thought it was going to fall. Mhm.

Um I know people love Last King and Palad Mass, so those make sense being like after those. I wasn't expecting Chronicle to get as high as it did. I guess that'd be the one thing because I think it's I mean I I love the scenario, but

8.2 [clears throat] I mean seems pretty was just higher than what I was expecting for it.

Uh and we also have some more stuff here for the first one. Starting to put the campaign rankings that we have here.

Crushed it.

Yeah, crushed it for Dungeons Legacy. And we all, this is going to look very silly with what we have right now because we only have eight, but this is going to look better as we do more of these um

data

over the like over the remaining theme weeks that we have left to go. But this is

But this is like literally all we have. These are the 16 scenarios that we have rated. So this will be more interesting once we add like it'll be like get to circle undone where we see some really cool stuff here. But uh I think unspeakable oath is going to be hard to beat.

Yeah,

that's fair.

And I think undementioned unseen is going to be hard to beat as well. Probably that was going to be my my followup here.

Yeah,

like I don't know those bottom three are like probably got that unlock for a while.

I imagine Heart of the Elders will probably like part one will probably and also knowing I mean I feel like uh City of Archives is going to be very divisive too. [clears throat] So, it's probably going to hover.

I That one probably I imagine like a sixish. Yeah. Six. Like high six, low seven.

Yeah. City of Archives is sweet. Yeah. I like it. But

yeah, we like it, but we also like our games to be challenging.

Yeah. Or we like the game. We like disruption.

Yeah.

Yeah. Yeah. Make Make me play the Make me adapt my game plan to the way that the game works. Yeah.

Yeah. Just let me run my

Like I [clears throat] want to be able to run it at least once, but

Yeah. But you got eight scenarios for that.

Yeah.

Yeah. All right. Well, thanks for watching everybody. That is it for the Whoopsie. There we go. That is it for the three of us here for Pat Carosa week.

Yeah. Pardon. Oh, sorry. The four of us. Sorry, Russ. I'm so sorry. My little angel. My little angel right here.

Be nice if my camera.

Yeah.

Yeah. It just goes to like the I I go to cut and just see me like just like [clears throat] just cuts right before there. No, we love Russ. Well, we actually I He annoys the hell out of me, but I still I love the hell out of him outside of 4:00 to 10:00 on Wednesdays.

Yeah. Yeah.

He's so cute, though. He's so cute. He's cute.

Uh, one last Carcosa week video coming to you tomorrow. Get ready for that. Thanks for watching. Have a good one.

Progress saved