Skip to main content
Loading video...

Eclipse: Second Dawn for the Galaxy Review - A Giant Box of Joy

Transcript 14:41

hello tally and farrell here from boardover and today we're gonna attempt to review this monstrosity of a box held within is eclipse second dawn a much hyped 4x game for between two and six players and you will certainly be exploring expanding exploiting and exterminating however we're overjoyed to report this game is not nearly as terrifying as it looks to learn and play and this is because eclipse condenses the usual genre of big box space games and fuses it to a wonderful euro-like core think twilight imperium makes a scythe and as ever with these games you'll take on the role of a space faring civilization

and your goal is to become the dominant force in the galaxy and we should say that even if this isn't your cup of tea stay tuned because eclipse might just surprise you and if you enjoy this video it would really mean a lot to us if you could like and particularly subscribe you start the game with a setup like this and the ability to do one of six main actions on your turn the first is explore where you'll take a tile matching the area of the map that you want to explore look at it and decide whether you want to place it and if you do you can orientate it in any way you like if the space is empty you claim any rewards and conquer the space but there might also be non-player enemies on the tile in which case you'll have to defeat them before you can conquer that space you can also move which is pretty self-explanatory you do have to make sure that you move through a connected wormhole like so then the third action you could do is to research and here you go to this textile tray and you pick one of the tactiles and these are randomized at the beginning of each game so there's a lot of variability and you'll take one pay its costs and science points which is exactly what i do at work when

i complete an experiment and then you put it on your research track and these basically improve your civilization or they improve your ships which takes us nicely to the fourth action which is the upgrade action to upgrade you go to this trade here and you take any ship parts for which you have the prerequisite tech and then you just put them on your ships to upgrade them the fifth action is build action and this just lets you build chips by paying the brown resource token which is materials you could also build buildings if you have the prerequisite tech and the final action is influence and this is just where you can move your influence discs around so you could take them off your player board and put them on an empty tile or you could take them off the tile you control and you put them back on your player board these influence discs are both used as an action marker and to show what territory you control this influence track is excellently designed as we were just saying these influence discs do two things they act as markers of territories you control or markers of actions you've taken so the more you do and the more you control the more you have out and this means at the end of the round the more you have to pay because you have to pay the cost of the right most uncovered space on this track and if you can't you could be eliminated from the game and it creates these wonderful dilemmas

where you could risk it and do a lot in a round but then you might end up losing some territories to cover your costs or you could go slow save up a bit and then end up having a super round later on or really anything in between as you gain territories you'll be moving your resource cubes onto the tiles and placing them in the spaces with the matching colours and the more cubes you have out the more income you gain what's really wonderful is that you'll start off small maybe only taking two to four actions per round but due to constant progression of your civilization careful planning can leave you with the ability to do pretty much whatever you want by the final few rounds you can either play as the basic humans which are the beginner faction and are symmetrical to start or flip your mat over and play as these somewhat asymmetric alien races these aliens provide nice little puzzles and are great for changing things up or to bring a bit of balance if you give the human factions two new players it's really cool that you get the option to do both and brings great replayability what we love about eclipse is how it manages to simplify everything it does while still being this meaty crunchy euro war game take the point scoring for example there's actually not that much that you score for with the main ones being reputation tiles and controlled territories it's really easy for a new player to come in and go yep okay i need to gain some territories and fight which are pretty simple concepts

to grasp everything you do is in direct service of being able to fight better and control more which really streamlines things when compared to other games of a similar type and just going back to the vp for a moment what eclipse does is it gives you this little player guide and this is great for new players particularly because it lists every way you can score vp so players have this in front of them the whole game and they can look at it and go right well this is what i need to do rather than um a lot of games which you could call i think they're called point salads where you get points from everywhere and no one knows what to focus on so again streamlined and it's great but one thing that might frustrate euro lovers is the elements of randomness in eclipse there's a lot of them and all these little things can combine to on a bad day cost you the game just as one example the explore tiles you draw are random and you know you could get a nice one that lets you instantly put down an influence disc and get some population cubes out or you could get one with a bunch of enemies that you'd have to fight first and then carrying on from this what population cubes you can put down will be random and you might even get a tile that has no space for population cubes at all and all these things can combine to put someone in a much worse position than anyone else at the table through no fault of their own and yes you can decide not to place that tile down but actions are so important and you have so few of

them that it almost feels worse to you know discard that tile and have to do it again as opposed to just putting it down and working with it and doing the other things you want to do so one thing that i'm in two minds about is the random drawing of textiles from the tech bag on one hand it's great for replayability and variability game to gain but on the other hand it can be very limiting depending on your play style we personally think that some of these should be permanent fixtures in the tech board and then the rest are drawn randomly as an example the monolith tactile will let you build them and each is worth 3vp at the end of the game this means there's an alternate route to victory for players that don't want to go around attacking everything inside the whole game but we've had games where we've never even seen a monolith tactile so this means that for players such as tally who prefers not to directly combat things they're forced to and in another example the population cubes it's really crucial for you to have lot out to have a strong empire and some of the best ways you can get more out are through the advanced population spaces which require tactiles or through building orbitals which also require a tactile and when these come out and which ones come out it's entirely random and you know if another player manages to get the only one that's come out for a few rounds just because they're first in the turn order it doesn't really feel

balanced but none of these are things that you should really worry about the game is well designed we're more talking about this in terms of personal preference we think this would improve the game for a wider range of people but you know some of the more important tactiles there's a few of them in the bag so you usually will see them as the game goes on at least but you know it's just that there is the potential there for this game to be a bit unfair or one player to get a leg up through the randomness but going back to the combat and players who might dislike that aspect of it what eclipse does which we think is really game changing is the inclusion of non-player enemies which you can fight to get vp we really love this system because even though you do still have to fight for vp it means that you don't have to piss anyone off around the table of course at higher play accounts there might not be enough aliens to go around so the game will probably descend in the later rounds into the usual infighting and backstabbing between players but at lower play accounts this can be a surprisingly friendly affair because everyone can just focus on the non-player aliens for their vp they don't have to directly combat each other unless you want to and this makes it a much more enjoyable game for players like tally who prefers not to directly combat other players and also for me because although i am devious and i do love backstabbing other players at every opportunity it's really stressful because once you cross that line

they are going to be pissed and they will come back for you and you just don't know when so then you'll always have to look over your shoulder thus eclipse is sick because it gives you the option for both one thing however that eclipse does not manage to streamline is the combat system and here is the classic combat system where you just continuously roll dice until everything blows up or someone retreats and this could be a personal opinion but to us this isn't the most exciting combat system and it's not the best we've ever seen uh you know it like and in the clips the turns are really quick and snappy and then you get to the end of the round suddenly everything screeches to a hole so one player can continuously roll dice and keep getting bad rolls for five minutes as they try and defeat a guardian or an ancient on the plus side the combat does tend to get quicker as the game goes on because everyone's ships get better also what we like is that the combat only occurs at the end of the round so it keeps the main part of the round moving nice and quickly i'm sure a lot of you will have experienced having to sit there for five or ten minutes whilst two players at the other end of the map endlessly roll dice and all you want to do is take your turn eclipse nixes this by having combat have its own section and it has the added bonus of limiting the amount of combat that occurs and making the decision to enter combat much more tactical and important

hello everyone and welcome to tally's corner the reason i like eclipse is because as faro mentioned i'm not someone who enjoys high-risk combat very much and in eclipse the combat never really feels too stressful and this is because if your ships get destroyed you can quite feasibly just build them again in the next round you only ever have two dreadnoughts so with the amount of resources you'll usually be getting by the time combat occurs you can just build them back up again so i'm quite happy to enter combat it doesn't stress me out too much we're delighted to report that eclipse is excellent at any play account without the feel changing too much at two players it is more solitaire as you explore your half of the galaxy and fight any aliens you come across but it's still terrific fun and the engine is the same at four players plus the game starts out the same but then towards the end it gets more tense because the only way you can conquer new territory is by taking territory from other players but we've also had four player games with no major battles between players so it is possible to keep it generally friendly also eclipse has an excellent play time with it coming in around 30 minutes per player so a lot of player counts is a game you can actually play quite quickly and maybe even get a few uh games in during a session so now we're going to try and sum up this monstrosity and we can do that by saying it is

brilliant personally it's one of the best games i think i've played this year you know i think that the mash-up of the euro core and the war game have made eclipse more accessible to more people and it also plays quicker than other games like it i think several design choices they made are outstanding such as the inclusion of non-player aliens to fight and the fact that you can make your ship and design it however you want but the price that is something to discuss the price is an issue here and it's not that we think that it's unfair because the gameplay the custom game trace inserts the components the miniatures the art are all top-notch we don't think anyone would regret buying this game however there are a lot of other great games out there for the same price as a cheaper option empires of the void 2 although not entirely similar is also a very fun space game with a great combat system at the end of the day the decision is up to you but final word from us is eclipse is a terrific game and we cannot wait to play again if you enjoyed this video please give it a thumbs up we'd really appreciate it and if you haven't already please subscribe to our channel for regular bored game reviews always with a little hint of these two derp doggos

Progress saved