Crystal Palace Revisited - 4p - The Discussion
Transcript
so John it's your first play of the game what do you think of it it's okay okay all right give us your thoughts so I'll the things I really like about it are the way the dice work obviously I mean that's the biggest gimmick of the game um the way you pay for the Pips and have the reveal your workers are as strong as you want them to be yeah and that's really cool um I also really enjoy how you could completely shoot yourself in the foot in this game like there's no handholding I mean the loans keep you in the game but I mean obviously you lose a lot of points if you're not careful yep um that I really like and I like the tension of where you're putting your workers um I think the spots themselves are kind of boring um they're just pretty basic right yes um which which is also fine I think what I wasn't thrilled about was it I think it's one round too long um like it felt like by round four the game was over to me it seemed that way um but it wasn't like in hindsight come but even if there was another round after that you could also say there there's more potential for comeback I just felt like it was one round too long that's fair okay um and it I didn't enjoy it's not you played really well but it wasn't fun watching like then I do this and then I do that and then I get that and then no down yeah and that has a lot of potential in games like this is um couple that with I also like don't love engine builders that much so um yeah but like it it's certainly a really fun game
I would recommend it to someone who says I want a worker placement game that does something different like and this definitely nails that um but yeah I mean it's it's fun okay a lot a lot of my problems with the game are are some of yours I um every time Edward says we all love it here at heavy card for I I want to put an asterisk next to it and be like except for Greg okay fair enough all right i' I've never really been a big fan of this and while like the group again collectively everyone's like we you know we love this game we love this game uh I sit there and I go I kind of hate it really I I don't hate it I don't hate youve played it like six times I think it's because people love it so much that it is why I I want to tend towards the hate but I'm like no I don't I don't hate it I just don't just to be contrarian no I just don't like it is what I'm saying on a on a base level it's just like eh it's fine and the reason why I have six plays is because I don't really actually hate it um if someone really wants to Play It Again people love it in this group I'll play so but why like why do you not like it let's hear okay so I like engine builders and I don't really know if I would put this in the same category as that my big sickler is like this action and this action some rounds can feel like Duds mhm that is true and this is the same thing I had the issue with uh windmill
Valley I like the theme if the theme is these are the inventors and these in the inventions I would like that to be the most interesting part of the game and often times it feels arbitrary whatever's out there is out there and that's what you kind of just deal with mhm um it it doesn't the theme super is there but it also just it feels like there could have been something more with a theme but like you said most of the actions are boring they're just do a thing collect a thing and the race is to get there first I guess but once we've revealed our dice you can kind of go oh well I know where that that's going to end up there's no way I can do you I I was going to say I that last thing you I totally can see everything that you said until that very last thing the because I there to me at least the most fun part can I outweight you little or do I need to go there early or can I stall to see if you're going to that yeah that that that brinksmanship or even that's that was good the first time you put you have like what I'm saying is if you don't have the capital towards the end of the game to afford a lot of heavy dice sure I have one thing that's
going to make sure I get a spot but I don't have enough Capital to cover all the things that I need to cover I can see that Edward though who is winning oh he's got three fives I might have a six but then that's it my counter to that is a plan better and play better to where you have more liquidity or B take an extra loan if it's that important to you kind of like an age of steam yeah I you don't want to go you you really need that Loco yeah take a share you take an extra share you can do it it's how important is it to you right now and so to me just on the Counterpoint like the the these being Duds sometimes totally yeah and and all of these individual actions are fine and the Synergy is a it feels like why am I even bothering for the 4o like it so I totally get that 100% however the the aspect of this game that makes it sing for me is the fact that you can set your workers to any value you want and then it becomes a okay I know that I think that's going to work so that's going to be important to you so I need is it important for me
do I need to go there early do I need can I can I wait can I risk having lower pit values and then so the the the core of the game like a lot of people say in age of steam the game is the auction and so here the game I if you're going to if you're going to boil age of Steam down like that you could say the same is choosing your strength of workers and then trying to figure out the puzzle of the order in which and that brinksmanship and to me that makes everything work enough right that that carries the game well enough for me but the rest of what you said I totally can see M yeah absolutely I I also um this this part with the the uh asymmetric thing where we all going up yeah it it feels like almost a gimme I like you you're going to do it not even a gimme uh sorry k sorry not a gim me so much as a like yeah yeah like of course I'm going to get three Bank of England things by the end of the game well maybe no no I I almost never do yeah like so but yeah of course two sure but like three sure I'll I'll that extra action to get a third uh for seven more points well it's only three more points though yes for seven points total rather yeah but again like you said it's so I could have got that or that in that last turn but that was more because it's only three more points M right um and then
that's what I mean it's like you do you might focus on this and be like that's just seven points yeah in the scheme of things whereas getting patents and hiring employees is you had one turn being 22 or something like right off the rip right it was it or no D Derek got 19 points yeah and and and what what was mine worth the first one mine was one well I mean theoretically they're balanced for a power right cost you know uh uh opportunity cost cost the whole thing I did I did deplete everything I had in the first two rounds and with and had no money so I was basically like I'm pushing myself as far so this game because I do play it a good amount um you can use uh different ways to play it right so so it seems like you would always do the same thing when you play but as you play it more and more you tend to follow different Avenues based on what other people are doing because it's so dependent on other players like when you do spend that money on that dice you're like I know I want this one thing cuz I'm taking a six or I don't want this dice I can just float away as a three so then everything out is negotiation because there like that like what he was saying there's a game of chicken that's very important in this game because like if I want to push I'm going to put out that one or that two or I'm going to hammer it and say I'm just taking this so there's like a poker aspect to this game that isn't in a lot of Eur games 100% I I will agree that that is the most uh interesting part is
that um there is no 100% of the time you play this game you are not going to do the same thing oh totally not no no uh get like like the the most loans I've ever taken in this game I'm saying I've never had six workers yeah 20 times playing this game oh wow yeah I've never SE I've never seen everybody have all their workers I've never seen everybody have all their workers yeah yeah and I was just like well if if you're going to have six workers and then I was like I hate having all these workers and I'm like let's get rid of them which which I should have done I should have uh ticketed for but it I would have lost anyway it was a big gap um no I mean eh it's fine no and that's fine and I'm not trying to sell you guys on it you like what you like you don't you don't um to me and and shrey basically Echoes what y'all are saying that I think there's a really good game with an amazing H or it's a good game with an amazing hook but I'm luk worm about some aspects of it and how it can feel cuz yeah I'll be honest when I'm like chaining boom boom boom and and like it didn't feel good like cuz I could feel the hate well every time you like five light bulbs I know like I get it um now why did that happen is that us or is that the game well there is some of the things where we could have taken away some of those characters that would have been important and we could have utilized those yes I I saw a couple of those characters when they came out cuz
I've played so many times they that's a super that dude's super strong and he's going to take advantage well it's not it but they're also they have a cost on them that correct and he had already moved himself in good position to not pay a lot for those type of characters so and I mean I but I it was a it was a conscious Choice like with ad Doo like I ended up paying almost 20 bucks in expense for him for six points yeah yeah so it probably wasn't but it did also what it did is it got me the other stuff and it got me some Tempo 20 points versus our six yeah so so it so there there's a offset now I've never done this I've never raced up the normally I'm like in this world but I was like oh I see an opportunity let me try it and so it's it's a being it it's a pretty tactical game um absolutely as well as I have experienced playing the game I've played this a lot um so some of it was I think I played pretty well some of it was opportunity and then some of it kind of like what Greg said about windmill Valley last night it didn't feel great that like things just fell to me because y'all were going in different directions and I was like oh here let me just boom boom boom what do you want a gear good yeah right yeah so so there is there is some
of that the hilarity between your income and Derek's being that one turn was no no not one turn was cuz I had nothing I I literally was had nothing here for the long but In fairness I was scoring a lot of points and I was spending all of my energy on scoring heavy cards early cuz I I see that what was out was saying hey you need to go up there and do that thing and that's how the modular variability and you know what I have had a lot of people that I've spoken to at Gen Con that do like this game that have come up to me that have said I house rule the synergies out yeah because it's 4 point it feels like a lot of work to try and make that and it's just I got from them sure um eight yeah yeah you I got four but ultimately I last thing I'll say though I will say if someone ever says I want a worker placement game that uses dice in an interesting way it's now going to be this panamax and tiou Aon all you you forgot the arguably the best of all of them which one madira I didn't play madira and see we need to remedy that but yeah yeah so I mean um I think um is it is it there's it like a game about illusionists that use magnificent talking about that one actually has but but it's not as that one is much more of a a resource management game and this is more of uh it's more uh we're worried about each what each other's doing a lot more in
this game I would think yeah few twons kind of rides that line of yes it's a resource management but yes also I'm worried about the dice that are and I'm worried about everybody going around so I would say a lot of similarities even though it's very different um and apples I mean if we're going to oranges and lemons if we're going to go on to the fruit uh then uh oranges and lemon um for me uh a lot of the parts that I loved about oranges and lemons are Parts about how you gain resources and the how things get uh activated and um the way that the uh the turn order happens in oranges and lemons is I would say equally as good as paying for your stuff by being placing things but you have more control in this game than you do in the other game because even though you're placing things and you have control where it's going you still have to take those actions having the money gives you the control without having to say I'm placing pit and hold on this thing so my I have to basically boot a boot a whole round in or in Le oranges and lemons um to get myself in a good position for that next turn and here I feel like like with this game I can put myself in a position where I'm doing a few things that I'm actually gaining a little bit of points and not feeling like I'm falling behind um and still having that same but I I I have to say that that game definitely is moved up on my list and lemons every time I play it I'm like okay I because the problem with Euros is I feel really great about three plays and after the three plays does it really still hold up and that that's how
it makes it in my top 50 and and and for me I I enjoyed my plays of oranges and lemons but the the mhip that this has uh with the with the way the workers apples and giraffes right they're totally different in the way but this just hits better and I like that you can effectively cut your own throat by taking too many loans and fight walking that line yeah really threading that needle how many analogies can I make of going too far one way or the other that's what neat the game's not going to hold your hand if you didn't have that really great influx you would have had a couple more loans and you would have been first yeah and so it's I I still like this more I've played this a ton more than I have oranges and lemons but I also really enjoy I love this at five I love this at three I love this scalability yeah um three to five I I I like it at all just it's a longer game at five don't like it at two um I've never played it at I don't think this is it's kind of a little too mean this is not I I would never consider this it two three it might be great but it's just not no this is like one of my go-to fives cuz it's like princes princess of Florence this gamei orange and lemons I mean that's it's great that a zero at five that actually feels good at five it doesn't feel like I want to strangle everybody at this table cuz it Tak too long cuz I take my turns relatively quick when went
on on Stream So if the other people aren't taking their turns and I'm like oh I'm not going to play another game with you even if it's this group I I I it's too much for me sometimes I don't want to take too long on a game that I feel like we should move a little quicker um and Stephen uh there there's some other points that were made that basically are echoing both sides of the table like like and you know not as much and uh Stephen said I think it's a big strength of the game that Edward and Derek played as different as they did and ended up close to each other no no people yeah he has no employees I went harder into that than basically heavy four scoring during that section which normally is a little it's a little bit here or there like you get like here's Five Points and maybe a special little thing what it show was utilizing character cards in a very uh in a very small in a different way that I've never seen and also I do like some people are not going to like this as much uh some will that um Derek and I have played this quite a bit y'all haven't first second no I still played quite a bit I just not very good at it okay all right oh okay fair enough fair enough has played a lot so so yeah that's no that makes sense if I had crushed you guys that would have been weird yeah right because like I said I knew look congrats in coming in third but if but you weren't going to win this but that's that's a good sign now but you could have found Synergy yeah that could have
come out with cards because of varied abilities and and gone in a different direction like you went crazy cheap and crazy high right on on no I love that was awesome that was really really definitely played it differently than I've seen for for a pro time player you were you weren't afraid which is important oh uh and last thing before we get out of here the expansion so it's a play expansion I really dislike it hard hard hard dislike it it is more rectangles no what it does is it changes the way newspapers work it it is a deck of cards yeah which it's print and play again so it's pieces of paper that you sleeve but anyway that you draw cards and it gives you some sort of rule breaker more drawing not only is it more drawing it removes the flexibility of this and they are only situational you can still use them for money but they have to do with the actions on your board so so if I had a newspaper and the newspaper dealt with British museum when I go to British museum I get you get a benefit an extra benefit like so so we played it three times um the the only good part about it is you can use it for for its value in newspapers Mone discard discard a card as a money but you're spending the newspapers cuz they're physically but you're not getting all this other stuff no it is a money every every card has two parts to it and every card has two different actions I mean I don't have one in front of me but it has two different places that you could use it but the problem that you run into and
especially at the very beginning of the game is you have no way of in that oh I can just spend a little bit to do this or I can do this little thing yeah and it just it's it's too limiting and it removes some of the cleverness that you can I mean the I I don't see this necessarily as a crutch I see this as a way to any time right right and it allows you more uh more Ingenuity more originality in the way you want to play the game I think they it came out during 2020 and um it was during a time that everybody was at home and they basically wanted to give some something to somebody because the game had come out during 19 and the I think there wasn't a lot of my guess was there wasn't a lot of push behind the game because it came out at a time when basically people weren't really out getting new things right and so they gave us that print and play but I don't think that print and play had spent the de the dev time to be able to work as a as a a really strong where they would actually have printed it and sold that to the public so it's something fun that gives you a little bit different way to play and if you do play it a lot yeah especially if you play it a lot yeah then it is a a different way to play but it is a very different game with those newspapers I don't think it benefits the game I think it's a net negative on the game so I just won't play with it again that's me so yeah all right cool that is Crystal
Palace for the 84th time or what third fourth whatever it is uh thanks to these guys for coming down on a Sunday I appreciate this thanks to all the patrons uh thanks to everybody that watched if if you enjoy the stream please like And subscribe it really does help the channel and we are doing a patreon drive so you get benefits you get the slack Channel you get videos uh extra bonus content uh being a patron and honestly it helps us improve the quality of the channel and keeps things going so certainly would appreciate considerate patreon.com slq um Martin's not here so we would really appreciate your thumbs he he's a traveling through Europe and he wants to see them go up so give us your thumbs give us your thumbs appreciate it I'm Edward I'm Derek John I'm great be back tomorrow with top 10 we'll see yall later take care y'all bye by well you made it this far I think you like the video If You did leave me a comment tell me what you thought about it certainly would appreciate apprciate it more you here subscribe watch other videos patreon all that fun stuff thank you I appreciate it seriously leave a comment I want to know