Beacon Patrol Review with Sam Healey..."Cooperative Carcassonne"
Transcript
Hey folks, welcome back to another review right here on the Dice Tower with yours truly, Sam Healey. Today we're going to be taking a look at Beacon Patrol, a game from Torbin Ratzle, uh, put out by Pandasaurus Games. And basically you can think of this as cooperative carcassone because some of the mechanisms employed are very very similar but it's all cooperative which makes it interesting to me. Let's get down to the table and take a look. So here I have a four-player game of Beacon Patrol set up for you. And uh basically as I said in the intro, this is kind of like cooperative Carcassone. There's a lot of the same kind of uh mechanisms employed that you use in Carcassone, but you're working cooperatively together to form a uh common goal of scoring as many points as possible with the group. Uh so uh what we're doing here is you're going to be able to take a turn. You randomly determine who goes first and the first player is going to be able to take a turn. You can turn you can do uh basically three different actions uh here. You can place a tile, you can move your ship, or you can swap a tile with another player. Now, that can only be done once per turn. You can do any of these in any order that you want. And with the uh except for that one restriction, you can do any of them as many times as you're able to do. Uh so, basically what you're doing here is you have two uh movement tokens that you can
use. Once you use a movement token, you're going to flip it over to its other side to show that you've used that movement so that you can keep track of how many times you've moved using the movement tokens. Uh so that's your that's the move your ship action. Uh and you can only move your ship um uh with in between two tiles that share a common water edge. So keep that in mind. Uh one of the main things you're going to be doing and really kind of the main gist of the game is to place tiles. Now, when you place tiles, like I said, uh it's very much carcassone like. You have to make sure that all of the edges are matching. Uh but there is a caveat that all of the um tiles have this orientation triangle there and you have to obey that orientation. So, on uh White's turn, they could uh place this here. Now, when you place a new tile, you have to move your ship. Now, that's mandatory, but it doesn't cost one of your movement tokens. So, I placed this one tile here, and I want to place another one. So, I'm going to go ahead and place this one out here like this, and I'm going to move over there like that. Now, you'll notice that I didn't use any of my movement tokens, but you don't have to. If I wanted to, I could spend one two to go back there, and that would be that. But since we're trying to expand the board, uh, and I don't have to use my movement tokens, I'm just going to go ahead and stay out here. And that will be the end of my turn. At the end of my turn, I'm going to discard any tiles that I have left over that I don't
think I can or don't want to play. Um, and then I'm going to flip over my movement tokens. If I used any of those, then I'm also going to draw up to my limit. In a four-player game, you're going to have two tiles. So, basically, I would I would just draw two tiles like so. And that would be the end of my turn. Comes over to blue. And blue is going to play uh let's see here. Wow. Um we're going to go ahead and play this one right here because it matches that one side. And then we have to move over there like that. And then we're going to play over here like this. And move over there like that. And that will be the end of Blue's turn. I don't have any tiles to discard, so I draw two more. Uh, just like this. And that's the end of my turn. On black's turn, let's say that they want to do a little something a little bit different. So, they're going to use a movement to go here. And then they're going to use another movement uh to come here. And then they're going to swap one of their tiles with another player like this. Remember, you can do that once per turn. Then they're going to uh play down here like this. And they're going to move down there. And then they're going to play another one here and come out there like that. And that would all be valid. Red is going to start their turn by placing one of their tiles right here. And that moves him down there just like that. And then he's going to swap this tile with this player over here with the blue player. And he's going to play this one
just like this. And that will put him in there. Now, he is kind of in a uh culde-sac, so to speak, here, and he doesn't have anywhere to play. So, he's going to use one of his movement tokens to come back out here. So, he has a place to play down here. He could also uh use his other movement token to come back up here, but he's going to start moving down this direction as long as he can. So, at the end of his turn, he'll flip this back over and draw two tiles like so. And that's the end of Red's turn. And so after a few rounds, you're going to have placed or discarded all of the tiles in the game. And that's when you're going to go ahead and score your points. Now, the tiles will score in such a way that if they are explored, which means that all four of the t sides of the tile have a tile that's touching it, those are considered explored tiles.
Explored tiles will give you a base of one point. But if you have buoys on them, then they'll be worth two points. And if they have lighouses or the uh headquarter tile here, the one that started the game, that will give you three points. So, for example, uh this is not an explored tile because this one right here, there's no tile right there. U but this one is because there's a tile here, here, here, and here. So, this one will give you two points. This one right here is also explored because it has three tiles adjacent to I'm sorry, four tiles adjacent to it. So, these two tiles would get you two points each. This one's going to give you two points. This one gives you three because it's a it's a considered a lighthouse and it has four tiles around it. This is also a lighthouse that has been explored. Uh, this is another buoy that has been explored. Um, this one right down here, however, is an explored tile, but it only gives you one point because there's no buoy and there's no lighthouse. And that's how uh points are scored at the end of the game. Now, with the base game, what you'll do here is you'll take the diagram here that'll tell you how well you did as a team together. Now, you'll also see here that there are a couple of mini expansions that are in the game. So, there are tiles. There are nine tiles that have first of all windmills and windmills basically score um in a similar fashion but it has to be
explored by open C tiles. So like this right here. And so if each of the four orthogonal directions are um open C tiles then this will score you one point for every open C tile. So it's possible for these point to be to score you four points. There are also peers in the other expansion and these of course are going to be um connected to land masses. So let's say that this tile was placed right here and then u somehow they were able to get another tile up there uh something to the effect of this. So this is an explored tile. So what this pier is going to do here is it's going to give you one point for every house that is on the island that is connected to.
So this pier right here would at the end of the game score 1 2 3 four points. So that's how scoring would work and a little bit of an introduction to the two expansions that come in the box. Let's get to my final thoughts. So that's about that for Beacon Patrol. As I said earlier, I'm going to say it again, it's cooperative carcass zone, but it has a pretty neat theme on it as well. You know, the idea of you're not just building up a castle or, you know, fields or whatever like that. You're you're searching out um a archipelago. I I like that nautical theme that's attributed to it. Um it it really could be any theme where spatial organization has to take a a point, but I like this theme. I think it's cute. Um, I think it's well illustrated as far as that's concerned. It's not a beautiful game.
It's a functional design and it's a it's functionally aesthetical as well. So, I I did enjoy that. Uh, I did like the fact that it is cooperative. I I've always enjoyed Carcazone as a game. Um, but I always felt that it was a little take thatish. um because people were always trying to get their, you know, get ahead and that kind of got in the way of making an aesthetically pleasing experience. I get it. I, you know, I'm not trying to make too big of a deal here, but this one's cool because everybody's working together to finish that map that's out on the board. And I like that. I like that cooperative uh aspect of tile laying of of this tile laying game. Everybody's working together to make the best possible map of this archipelago as possible. I I think that's fun. As far as final thoughts are concerned, don't don't expect too much out of this. Um, but it's also enjoyable. Let's get to my pros and cons.
My first pro is the fact that I really do enjoy tile laying games. And this one is cooperative tile laying. And that makes tile laying more fun in my opinion. It's not that I dislike uh co competitive tile laying games. I I like those as well. But this one has a sort of, you know, kind of chill factor to it. You you don't have to worry about beating everybody. You're trying to help everybody win and do as best as we possibly can. I really think that that's that's a that's a cool aspect of this uh tile laying game because I've always liked tile laying, but the fact that it's cooperative just raises it another level for me. My second pro are the too many expansions in there. And the two mini expansions for me are kind of those kinds of expansions that you just put into the game um from the onset. does kind of, you know, encourage you to play a couple of games first before you add the peers and the windmills in there.
But from my opinion, this game is so light. It It's so uh simple that adding them in from the beginning isn't that big of a step up. So, I just encourage people to go ahead and do that. And that's really kind of how I taught the game. I I I never really um you know, kind of baby stepped people into this game. It's just a simple simple mechanism of uh building a map and you're doing it cooperatively so you can help people on their turns and all of that kind of stuff. So, I really did enjoy the Too many expansions because they didn't add so much to where you kind of thought like, well, I won't be able to play this with some people and I and I won't be able to play that with some people. I'm going to have to, you know, find the No, they weren't that difficult. So, I like the mini expansions in there. It's just nine tiles. add them in, you'll enjoy it. My third pro was the movement mechanism.
These little uh fan blades that allow you to move a space for everyone that you use and the fact that you can use them every single turn. You didn't have to do something to get them. It's just an ability that you're able to utilize. I like that because it keeps you from getting uh socked in somewhere where you can't play anything. Um I also like the fact that you're able to kind of just dump tiles if you don't think you can play them or if they're not going to be very helpful for you. I would recommend that you stay away from dumping tiles that are going to be worth more points than just one. So those buoy tiles and those um um uh lighthouse tiles, you need to make sure you kind of use those when you can. Um but I like the abilities of movement and the abilities of dumping tiles that you're not going to be able to use or something to that effect. Thrown in with that, the one um ability that you have to swap a tile with somebody else. I like the fact that you can do that. I also like the fact that they have to agree with you and there's room for discussion as to what they were planning to do, what you're planning to do, and and that kind of thing. It's not uh the kind of thing where I'm I can just say I'm going to swap with you. No, they have to agree.
So, it's again, it's that cooperative sense of the game that's really kind of at the forefront. My fourth pro is going to be that it does have a solo mode built into it and it is kind of a chill solo mode as well. It's not going to be very robust. It's not going to be very very um you know thoughtprovoking or anything like that, but it can do well to just kind of let yourself chill pass the time and uh play a game while you're doing that. So, I do like the fact that they decided to make it a solo variant that's in there and the solo variant does work well as well. So, take that for what it's worth. But that's my fourth pro. It's a good solo mode. So, the one con that I have is that this could divulge into an alpha player situation problem. But with that being said, they did make some decisions that help the players or rather empower the players to battle against that. Um, you know, you could have one person that's just going to start doing that swapping tiles whenever um they want to. again, only once per turn, but you could have somebody that tries to force those deals. And the rule's in there. The person has to agree to it. Yes, alpha players are probably going to want to steamroll their their way and and kind of bully their way past that. Um, but it does empower the the game empowers the players to uh battle against it, and I like that. The the game did what they could, and I I appreciate that. It's a con, however, because alpha players exist. that's going to happen. But just
take that for what it's worth. I think I'm going to give this one a 6.5 out of 10. And the reason it's not a seven is because the artwork really didn't do it for me. And that's not to say that it's bad artwork. That's just to say that I would have enjoyed a more picturesque aesthetic view. It's functional, as I said earlier. Um, it it's very helpful in scoring and that's probably one of the reasons why they chose to go with this graphic design rather than a more ornate one because ornate artistry is harder to score than what this did. It's very stark. The buoys are very stark. The lighouses are very stark and all of that kind of stuff. So, I understand. I get it. I see why they made the decisions that they did. But me being an aesthetic player, I wanted to see something that's a little bit more pretty on the board, not necessarily functional. I really want functional and pretty, but this one definitely checked off the functional aspect. Um, so it's a little bit of a knockoff there. As far as gameplay is concerned, I I would not have a problem calling this a seven, but me personally, because of that artwork, it comes down a little bit. So, a 6.5. It's fun. It's a good cooperative game. Maybe this is a great game to teach people a Carcazoneesque kind of game so that you can maybe next
step them into Carcazerone or something like that later on. Um, but this would be good for that because it's cooperative, so you can kind of um maybe not so much coach, but you can help. And I like that. 6.5 out of 10. I did enjoy it, but it just got knocked off a little bit because of the artwork and and me not liking it as much as maybe other people will. But it's a good game. It's a good cooperative tile game. So, check it out if you get a chance. A 6.5 out of 10 for me. Thanks for joining us. We'll see you guys and gals on the flip side. Take care. Hey everybody, thanks for watching this video. So, if you like this review or whatever you just watched, wasn't it amazing? Uh, check out our channel, Dice Tower. We have all kinds of things. We review games. We do top 10. We play games live. It's all about board games, but especially the people who play them.
Check out Dice Tower YouTube channel.