Skip to main content
Loading video...

Messina 1347 Roundtable Review - Friendly Ties Podcast

Transcript 57:48

hey there welcome to friendly ties this is a podcast about board games and today we're talking about one game and that's messina 1347. i'm joined today by my good friends anastasia and nick and um we've played it a bunch so we're going to talk about a decent bit uh before we get into that though i do want to briefly say that we did not film a playthrough for this one like we have for many other games in the past um but we're gonna try to explain it as we go so hopefully this all makes sense uh yeah so nick why don't you tell us a little bit about the game yeah so messina 1347 just as a kind of brief overview of what you're doing in this game is a six-round worker placement game i say that with the trepidation in my voice because you don't place workers really except for when you get them or in the first round they really move around yeah um to different spaces on the board but work replacement is appropriate because when you've taken an action it blocks someone else from taking that action um the other thing that you're doing is of course like most worker placement games you're managing your resources um as you are going around this plague ridden city uh fighting the plague by burning things to pieces yes rescuing the citizens to bring them back to your your uh villa and in your villa they will you'll put them to work obviously they don't just get to live there for free um or they could live there for free yeah yeah even the sick vehicle unless you have a ton of people in which case they don't work uh so i guess in theory they don't have to work it just kind of depends on your situation and then ostensibly over the course of the game you will uh then use your great influence and power to

repopulate the city and you will send those workers back to messina uh to complete the full loop that's that's a rough overview what you're doing there's a lot going on in this game i remember i taught this to you two a few weeks ago um and we've all played it a bunch i think i played four times anastasia you have more plays than that i think and nick is about the same uh and i'm pretty sure i'm i am i have whatever both of your plays are combined because i've only played it with the two of you and i've played it every time either of you have played it sure so we played this one a bunch uh two and three players and we'll talk about player count a little bit more later but i did want to say that there's a lot going on to this game i remember when i taught it i felt like it was uh one more thing one more thing type of situation it looks on the surface like oh it's a work placement game with a few things going on but but it did end up taking me quite a while to teach and i think we're going to try to talk about different things not really in a vacuum because everything kind of ties together but the first big thing is the tile worker placement um you know there's a hexagon grid in the middle of the table it's kind of different every time you play the game like the tiles are shuffled up and then you like like nick said the first round you just place the workers and after that you move them around and you not only have the blocking of you know you can't go where somebody else's been but you have to pay money to travel farther and so it's possible that somebody might the good spots around you have all been occupied you have to spend resources just to to go to a spot that you might not even be crazy about i suppose yeah you know i love what you said nick about how you were like it's worker

placement ish right so on those tiles you know whenever you t you place on a tile no one else can go there right so it is worker placement in these spots but there's this such this spatial aspect because these tiles represent the city and you are somewhat limited in your movement on where you can go so i i love this decision space where you're like okay i wanna especially in the first round right you wanna i wanna place this worker down but i wanna be mindful that i i have to kind of think about where else i'm going to be able to go yeah i don't have enough money yeah i'm going to be kind of stuck in this area and and thankfully the city is not huge especially at lower player counts so you you it's not too bad but i i think when you get up a little bit in that player count it's a little bit harder to think about kind of where you want to be and and how you want to get there so in addition to all this there's this really cool incentivization thing going on as well because you have these hexagons that have actions on them that are very straightforward you know a piece of wood icon and a fire icon means you take a wood token and a fire token from the supply that you can then use later on for stuff and most of the actions are nice and straightforward but on top of that the game itself in most of the rounds drops these little plague cubes down onto random-ish hexes on the board and it also drops citizens down onto random-ish hexes on the board and when you visit a spot if there's a citizen there then you can rescue them and if there's a plague there that you can fight the plague if there's plague in a citizen then you're going to rescue a sixth citizen who goes into a quarantine hut but

citizens are important and we'll talk about them a lot more later on but it just adds an extra interesting layer you're not just going there for the action you might specifically go to a spot just because there is a nobleman there and you really need a nobleman to do the other stuff you want to do and you're like oh i guess i'll take two wood as well maybe i'll find something to do with that later on and i like that extra layer of incentive that happens the play cubes just stack up the uh the populist kind of stacks up but if there's playground then it's gonna wipe them out so they don't build up that much no but i what i love about choosing an action space right is that even though these plague cubes come down the the plague the game and we'll talk about this a little bit more later but taking a citizen on a tile that has plague or taking a citizen off a tile that doesn't have plague is like either way it's this extra bonus action because of of the various benefits you get if you fight plague you get to go up on these tracks and you your workers go into a different space if you take citizens they go straight on your board and they also get to do cool things no matter what happens there's multiple options for this bonus action on top of whatever the action space is doing and so when you're choosing your spots you i find myself oftentimes being like ooh like i don't want to just take an action like i want to take an action that either has a plague in the citizen or has i don't want to take one that just has plague right like you're like it feels bad if there's no plague and no person like you won't you actively avoid

those actions yeah you like you you're kind of gauging them based on like okay what do i want to do or what's going to give me the most like layers of actions that i'm going to get to do so sometimes you might be like oh i think i want to go take like you said a fire in a wood but oh if i go over here and i build i'm going to get i'm going to get to fight off plague i'm going to get this citizen who's going to go do this other thing for me and so like i love that so the actions it's like layers they kind of they're like constantly changing and giving you more options while the the action spots themselves are essentially staying the same yeah i mean you're landing on it what i think is the dopest part of this game like if you looked at this game and you're like oh it's a work replacement game like what are the actions it's like get a couple of resources spend a couple of resources advance on a track like the actual like action spaces are not interesting but what makes it interesting is exactly what you're saying you ask the question like is there a play cube here or not and john you talked about how like normally you want to go where there's like a lot of action but if i don't have any fire i actually don't want to go to this space right and i think that that like it's not asymmetry but that that circumstantial difference right like you have fire and i don't have fire yeah or i already have three nuns and so going here to get another nun is actually not beneficial for me at all um and that's actually really cool that sort of uh that fact that every spot has multiple pieces on it i think one thing that's that's could be off-putting about that though uh is that it is it is a pretty random in terms of like at the beginning

of the turn structure you're it's not outputting randomness it's input randomness but like at the beginning of a round those things are gonna get put out by the game board and then you're gonna say oh well that spot's just amazing for me obviously i'm gonna go there this does lend itself towards analysis paralysis though um you know you could say that about a lot of uh work replacement games um you know like crunching through well you know there's these three things i need to do and what's the priority because if i don't do the highest priority and somebody takes it then everything could fall down and you can spend a lot of time thinking through that you know what action spots do i want to go to what action spots can i even reach by moving my workers around do i have enough money to move the workers as far as i need to go oh crap i really need a craftsman are there any craftsman out there there is a craftsman over there canada think about that one and then once you add the next layer of like what are my opponents gonna do you really can spin off the rails unless you are really vigilant about stopping yourself from doing that and and we as a play group are generally pretty cool with take backs and can i fix that yeah uh but if a round goes by someone else has moved to another location and like taken choices you actually really you really can't roll those things back so it does lend itself a little bit more to that ap problem for sure and i think that this is definitely one of those games where you can make a mistake that that does hurt you i mean the timing of when you take your actions is so key i mean john and i literally just played this last night two player and at the very end of the game there are only three spots that

do that move the only three spots that did what i needed them to do and i i took one and he took one and then i made a calculated risk by misreading his board and didn't take the other one and then he went to take it and we had one of those moments which you never want to have in a game where i was like look you can say like i already went and you can go but i'm going to tell you right now my whole game is tanked if you do this right now like if you didn't find this i was going to yeah the sound you made when i took that spot it was just like this combination of horror and and bewilderment because you were so sure there's no world where i would do it because you had glanced over at my board and and misread where one of my tokens was you misread it yes completely misjudged it and i was just like yeah if you do this i'm gonna just sit here and just be devastated and like you'll just win by like you will definitely win by tons and tons of points because it's just like so um he was very gracious and let me take it back and let me do it and he was still ultimately able to do it in a different way or get the movement he needed to yeah it's about having fun right yeah oh but i'm so grateful it's one thing to say oh i didn't think of that it's another thing to say oh i misinterpreted that you know like looking at a board where is that token on my board versus your board there's a lot of tokens going around so that actually you know lends itself to another analysis part is is there's a lot of little little tokens to consider where they're

at for yours where your opponents are at and how that applies to everything because if you if you glance over and and think it's you know one spot but it's actually an inch away from where you thought it was that could devastate your whole game plan and it's interesting too right like i don't i wouldn't describe this game as like a crazy brain burner like i'm like calculating like this and that i find that the mistakes come in like a one plus one plus one plus one mistake and then i'm like that equals three it's like no it equals five wait what yeah yeah and i think i mean we're going to go into some details of some of the other pieces and and you know and how you get here and like what are these spots doing and and why it becomes this kind of fun you know wild like chaining of actions kind of thing but before we do that i don't want to go too much farther without just kind of acknowledging the inherent um player count differences here right because because it really speaks to what we're talking about right this the ap the randomness the tightness of these action spaces and now we have all played this i think i played it five times so i played it we we the three of us played it twice there and we're gonna talk about this a little bit more too but there's a beginner game in an advanced game so we played it one way each at three john and i played it twice at two one way each and then nick i think you and i played it twice at two players well just once right yeah just the ones okay so i am very curious to hear you guys thoughts though i think i know them but i ain't gonna say unequivocally

this is a two player only game for me plays to four it's absolutely a two to four player game i'm sure there's many people who would love it but i will probably only ever play this game at two and that's because for me there's just enough control over your actions and and i and that kind of counteracts that randomness and like kind of self-limits my personal ap right like so that that that way that weighing i was doing with with the action with john i was like i can calculate what he's going to do enough enough but at three so many you know two other people going and taking moves and blocking your spots it is too hard to plan when you're playing with three players there's no way that you're gonna know what's going to be available to you so by the time it gets back to you the downtime is crazy because you're just like okay wait well now i just need to like completely re-analyze the board because i have no sense of what i can do because i've got you know two people going and i i might play to three but definitely would never play it at four if you're if you're at four you have to be ready to throw fifty percent of your your plans out the window at any given time yeah i'd say that's generous yeah maybe yeah i think i'm just really good at planning as far as like hard numbers are concerned i think it's worth mentioning that you know our first three-player game took almost three hours not quite and the very next night we played it three players again and it was

like two hours and 20 minutes so like it was already significantly faster on our second play at three players but then subsequently i know the two two player games i played uh with you anastasia those were both a little under two hours and nick and i think played it in 90 minutes you can definitely get it down if you if you're kind of going speed yeah i'm a slower player than nick for sure yeah nick john and i love to just kind of be lazy in games and let our minds go with them and that's the thing i'm totally down with a two-hour experience for this game and for me personally i would play it at three in the future but i also prefer it at two um it honestly it's been a joy to play it too it's a little bit of a spoiler for how much i've been enjoying the game um and i enjoyed it less at three not only because of the analysis paralysis but the downtime it just because there's a lot to think about it should sometimes take a while to get back to me also because there's differing numbers of workers that you can have in this game which i'm sure we'll talk about a little bit later on um so in that second game there was three players i definitely found myself in a situation where like i was done and i was not gonna be able to do anything for like at least 10 minutes because both of you had like way more workers than me and i was just out of it at that point so so the overall time is important and some people are totally fine with a three-hour three-player game um and some people for some people that'd be way too much i don't see myself ever playing this at four players uh just like you said i just feel like i would play a different game at four because there's just two

it would just be too long that's the other thing like you take the same number of actions per player no matter how many players are around the table and you know six rounds three workers minimum per player that's 18 turns so you add another player in that's 18 more turns minimum that happens and usually you get a fourth or even a fifth worker so you know just you know if even if every turn was only you know one minute long then you're looking at adding you know close to half an hour just um for adding another person in there like maybe a little longer than a minute but you get what i'm saying it's it it scales linearly i i agree um i i'd actually uh first of all cosign your all your comments about the the two three and four player i'm actually a person who prefers to play euros at like three and four players and i i think you're both totally correct this is a game that's better at two or three i want to actually take on that that point that you had there john because that's something that i struggle with in this game is that uh it it feels to me like it is pretty hard to catch up now i don't think that it's easy to fall behind in this game but if you do fall behind i feel like i could see the writing on the wall and get a little bit bummed a couple rounds out from the end of the game you know in a six round game i feel like it could be round four and i could be like i'm just dead and i i don't like that feeling in a game um i don't like the like death march to the end of the of the scoring rounds yeah i think that uh anastasia though you had sort of a different experience in this with this game that you played with john last

night so i'd love to hear about that yeah yeah i mean i love that you brought that up nick because and i guess this is sort of the perfect segue to talk a little bit more about this these kind of beginner boards and then the advanced boards and so there are you have a personal player board right that is it's called the overseer board which is i don't know if that's the best name but i guess that's what it's called uh and i you i think you said we're overseeing villas is that what we're overseeing nick yeah it's your villa i it's just messina's in italy right so it's a villa okay sure i think this is a village but sure villa sure um but you have so it's definitely italian yes so you're overseeing uh these villas and i think we'll go a little bit more into the mechanics on that in a minute but the the reason i'm bringing that up is because i think it makes a big difference in terms of getting behind whether you're playing that beginner board or the advance board so last night john and i played a game of this where we it was a two player game we were playing the advance boards and we had two very different boards he had one that had these immediate bonuses that were fantastic and it they just john was doing things in the first two rounds of the game that if i didn't love this game which is a spoiler i love this game if i didn't love this game i would hate this game

like if that was my first play of the game watching jon just pop off with these magical turns while i sat there very slowly building my little engine i it was awful like i had to like really kind of hold it knowing that my board was super selling this game by the way i know now bear with me bear with me the advanced boards are different right they have different bonuses and different benefits and different things you can do and we had all agreed that the board that i was playing was subjectively what we thought was the weakest board and that's because it doesn't have shiny as shiny moments it had more end game moments right it had things that really benefited you later in the game and i had to wait and i so so i was watching john do all of this stuff and then suddenly my game started taking off and then i started having crazy turns and then my my bonuses started kicking in but that all happened in the second half of this game this game has arcs and and so i had to wait and i just the reason i'm saying that is so both to respond to what you're saying nick that like i do think it's possible to come back in this game i don't think it's possible to do that with the beginner boards i don't think there's enough kind of going on so i do want to kind of like just flat like warn on that and i may be totally wrong but that's just my impression i do think it's possible with the advance boards because there's so much more going on and you have kind of different goals that you're going for but

i do think you have to be patient and i do think you have to play very tactically and react to the situation and be very like and i think you have to stomach it like i think you you can't if you just sit there and think my game is tanked and you give up it it will be tanked you do have to kind of like know that your experience may be on a different pace and that's exactly what happened and i did i will admit i lost to john but i only lost to john by like 13 points or would we you know and if he made one less move it would have been five points i mean it was and in this game that is very tight it was super close and considering that when we sat down i was like oh i'm playing the worst board and john's playing the best board and then it was so close and i i was it was kind of amazing to see that happen actually there is a flip side to that um like that that game was it was really great to see you come back like that but when i played that advance board the previous time um i had one of the worst gaming experiences i've had in like the last year um yeah it was just it was miserable yeah and we played the exact same super selling this game guys i know i know but whatever okay right now favorite game of 2021 i'm just gonna put it out there massive spoiler so if don't stop listening keep listening i just want to say that like you can fall behind and i did and i feel like i i'm not blaming the board for it i made some poor decisions but i was two rounds into that six round game and i just had this feeling like i am totally toast and nick literally doubled my score and anastasia

was way closer to nick than i was in that game like i never got up like i essentially was crawling that whole game and that was pretty miserable and i i did it to myself i made those decisions but the game also let me make those decisions and let me find myself in that place where you know it was a three-player game i kept coming in last in the in the player order and i desperately needed to get citizens to make my little plan work and i kept going last and the both of you kept taking all the good citizens and and the only citizens left were the ones that didn't make sense and it was it was a downward spiral for sure so it was really happy to see anastasia you did awesome with that board when i did so poorly with it um but you know i think that's because you played it better than i did yeah i mean clearly there's no there's no hail mary that you can take in this game to try to catch up right like you need to you need to be there and what i'm hearing from anastasia is leaning into the asymmetry of by the way the advanced boards and the basic boards the short differences that the advanced boards are asymmetric and the basic boards are not uh so leaning into your asymmetry was what helped you sort of play that catch-up game and doing that well sort of rewarded you uh which is which is interesting i think that's a lesson for anyone who's picking up this game for the first time that sort of being generous in the first few rounds with players uh just in terms of like what's gonna happen or like really kind of like stomping them down is gonna change their experience and how they're how they're playing this game and since we're already talking about the like advanced versus beginner boards uh i i i know that anastasia's a fan of the

advanced boards i prefer the beginner board so john you got a tie break for us here we actually we talked about this a little bit last night i think probably my preferred way to play would be right in the middle uh uh that's because you have this advanced that i'm beginner well you know we have a you have this asymmetric board in front of you but then there's a separate board that has these end game scoring conditions and it's a it's a completely different token and you could play with the normal boards and go with the asymmetric different end game scoring tiles or you could go asymmetric on all of these things and i think it's probable that my favorite way to play this game is with the basic boards but the asymmetric slightly more advanced end game conditions because that's going to mix up how what you're going to do from one game to the next like what's emphasized by those different scoring conditions um but i will also say after playing last night that i'm i'm much more on team advance board than i was before and i also want to say that while i had that absolutely miserable three-player game i wasn't blaming the game itself i just had a really bad play and i really wanted to play it again and i played it twice since then and had a blast with both of those so i was very happy to see that that was a an outlier but you know it's still a data point yeah and i think that that is just that is just a product of a game like this so i compare it to another one of my favorites grand austria hotel and and the reason why i see such a comparison between the two of them is because both of these games have a lot of input randomness there is you're just you're adapting to the randomness of the board in this game and to the the things that come out in the same way that i feel like in granasha

hotel you're adapting to the dice and those in both cases just as we've already explained they're gonna it's gonna dictate your actions it's gonna dictate your choices the citizens that you take that you put on your board we haven't quite explained this yet but there are three types of citizens right and they each go into different places and they each do different things and so but they come out randomly and so you have to adapt to that and i think the very nature of that means that it's going to be possible that you're going to have a bad game it's going to be possible where like nothing is going to go your way or people are going to take what you need and it's just it's just not going to come together that is just the nature of these games and then on the flip side you're going to have games that like totally pop off and you're going to get these crazy chains and it's going to be super satisfying but i think that in order to have games that can go to that like pop-off super satisfying place it inherently comes with the flip side of games that may just may just not like not come together that is a fact of grand astro hotel it's a fact of this game and as long as you accept that and know that going in in a game that can play pretty fast like this i think if you played it really tight a two-player you could even get it down to 75 minutes people on board game geek claim they can play it in an hour i think you can have a ton of fun with that but you just you kind of do need to know that and john you've totally highlighted why that's totally a piece of this game before we move on from this i want to very briefly talk a little bit more about the workers the specific number of them because you start the game with three as i said and you can get more you can get all the way up to

five and i have a really silly thing that i want to say and the workers aren't the citizens just to be clear we have to kind of like clarify that right you have workers that you're placing and citizens are like little people they're a resource essentially yeah and the citizens work for you so don't get confused but the thing i was thinking about specifically after i had that that really unhappy play is that this game is fun when you're doing things and i think that's a very s it's kind of a silly thing to say like duh but a big problem that i had in that game is i was trying to play it with just three workers um there's a few tracks and one of them lets you unlock more workers and i felt like i was gonna try to to be successful uh because there's lots of other ways to squeeze bonus actions out of different um mechanics that we haven't discussed just yet and i kind of fell on that sword of like i'm not gonna get more workers i'm gonna try to do good with three well both of you got up to five workers and you just did so many more things than i did and like i said with the downtime like i do my three actions and then i'd have to wait for both of you to take two more actions between you which cost downtime and at the end of the day i just found myself feeling like it's only fun when you're doing stuff and so i personally feel like every time i'm gonna play messina i'm probably gonna try to rush to get the four and five workers that's what i did last night i got my fourth worker in the very first round and i got my fifth worker in the second round um which is why anastasia thought i was going to run away with it and it was awesome that you caught caught up considering i had five workers for several rounds where you had three uh like you'd be done and then i just like take a few actions by myself and uh

so it's cool to see that rubber band back from a bounce perspective but from like a fun perspective i i see myself always leaning towards getting more workers because just having less wasn't this fun to me i mean let's let's be clear and the games that we've played no one has ever won this game with just three workers uh the the game it feels really bad to not have them and you know in most worker placement games getting more workers is just really good and in this game there's no payment you don't need to feed them there's no sort of like consequences for having extra ones you just need to move up this track to a certain distance and so it's pretty clear to me that not getting the fourth worker is just a shoot yourself in the foot decision in this game you probably don't need the fifth one but but you got to get that fourth one um i mean that being said anastasia you got him late last night and you still managed to make it work i did and i found myself you know i don't like games that sort of force you in one direction and if there is a critique to have for this game is that the nature of this game there's an arc here and and we'll talk about that in a minute but it does kind of point you in some directions it sort of feels like you have to take it and i don't love that and whenever i see that in the game i tend to naturally be like well what's option b like i don't know why i'm so contrarian but i just i'm like i don't like to be forced to do anything and so i don't love that it does kind of feel like you need to run up this one particular track that that that gives you workers and

john i've seen you do that in every game and i don't like to think that that has to be the path and i have not found myself in a position in any of the games i've played that i have i have felt like that was the best move for me and so in almost every game i have only had three workers for most of the game and last night with no exception there was only six rounds i had got my fourth and fifth worker both in the fifth round right so it is possible to still do fairly well by not having them but it is true that john just had more opportunity to do things by having those extra workers and i i do worry that that you it will always be better to get that fourth worker earlier to get that fifth worker as soon as possible and uh the one disadvantage that i do want to point out is that you you can pay money to move up on there are three tracks in this game one of them is the plague track and whenever you fight plague you're going to go up it there's no way to move up that otherwise the other two one of them is going to give you workers and the other one kind of makes your overseer board the board we've been talking about that we haven't fully explained but it makes moving on that board better and you can pay money to move up the worker track or the overseer track and once you add another worker the cost for moving up that goes up so i do see i do think it is interesting to consider possibly working a strategy where you keep low on workers and you use money to

move up higher on the bottom track which is essentially what i did last night and then get your workers but i still don't know that that's enough to over balance you know someone having their fourth and fifth worker fairly early on so you know a lot of things to consider well i think we should really talk about those uh overseer boards now because you know yeah somebody who doesn't know how the game plays you might be thinking how the heck could somebody uh vie for contention with three workers versus five and that's because workers aren't the only way you get actions in this game you have this player board in front of you and you put citizens down onto it six citizens go into little quarantine huts and they stay there for the couple rounds and then they're able to use them out on this board and i'm not going to try to graphically describe it to you feel free to google it if you want it's effectively some looping tracks and many actions many different things in this game let you move a token down these tracks and you have your citizens next to the tracks kind of on either side and when you move these tokens around you can actually pop off with them and get a bunch of bonus actions for them especially because you can upgrade them and whatnot so from a very high level what that means is like these workers you just move the workers around the board i remember last night there was one turn where i moved my worker and i got one wood and that was my whole action from that one worker so yes i had more workers but i didn't get much out of that one action i needed that wood but still versus anastasia moved one of those overseers on her board and did three things with it she like flipped over a citizen she got a major fire token and then she spent some money to go up one of the tracks it was just like

whoa okay so this you can have these little action explosions without even using your workers uh and so there's ways to weave all this stuff together and it's honestly challenging to describe all this in podcast form i mean the way i view the citizens right there's green brown black citizens there's three tracks and they're they're forked at the end of the tracks you choose this green guy is going to pair up with browns or the screen guy is going to pair up with blacks right and you have to like choose how you're establishing that on your board and so that's how you get like your crazy combos right is by like choosing what those pairings are this uh visually is very cool on the board and i would say is maybe my favorite or if not my second favorite component of this game is these uh again unfortunately named overseer voids um where where you're using these citizens to cash in on all these extra bonuses um the games that have felt the most insane have always been with setting up nice little combos that trigger like resource gain and build a thing uh multiple stuff is going on like these these citizen boards are like really where the cool stuff happens in this game and also the stuff where you're like well i set this guy up here and now i'm taking this action because i'm very amazing at this game by having like lined up these two tracks with each other and now they're pinging off of each other and

that's so awesome uh and so the over zero board is is uh unique in their in its interwovenness of the of these sort of like three colors of rewards that you can get with her which are the citizens yeah yeah i don't think i've ever seen anything like this before like i it is is this very unique to this game i agree nick this is my favorite aspect of the game it is it is so cool and it looks like like almost like a flower like i i don't it's hard it is really hard to describe yeah i was gonna say like a fleur-de-lis and it's like and you really have to think about it you might sit down and look at it and think oh i'm gonna do all of this but you're not you're gonna do like one segment of this and it's and it's like you said nick it's going to be two different colors i mean like two halves of two out of the three colors it's probably what you're gonna do most and then maybe something else and that's how you're gonna make these crazy combinations because there's a real ramp factor with these boards like the first movement only lets you choose from like two spaces but then as you keep going you're allowed to choose from these different segments and then as you get further then you can choose from two different segments and if you're able to then flip your token which is something you can do when i was talking about those different tracks moving up on that track that kind of affects your overseer board will let you flip your token over and doing that is going to like let you take an additional action so as you keep

going and like kind of working your board and obviously there's work replacement spots within the city of messina that are going to let you move and when i was talking about the three actions that created the situation with john in the game last night it was an overseer movement move that i needed to take right because it's it's so it just leads to so many other things because the action spots with on these boards are also like the action spots within the tiles on the city of messina so it's like you think you're taking one action but then it's just gonna build out into a whole bunch of other things and it's so satisfying it's so fun and i i just i love it i love this part of the of the game and i think that it it's it's just like i said it's like nothing i've ever seen before i think your fastest strategy level up in this game is to realize that you should get citizens because they're relatively free to get if you pay attention to where they are and then the overseer actions are the best actions you can take in this game yeah yeah for sure yeah and that's not really work replacement that's just this little puzzle that's in front of you um and you know paying attention to other people's puzzles is good too i just want to be clear that like when you're when we're talking about these action spots on the board they only work if you take a citizen and put it in there whether like john said you pull them from your quarantine cabin or whether you take them off of the board and so when we were talking about earlier about these kind of interesting decisions that you have to make do you take a sick citizen and do you put them over here or do you put someone onto your board these are kind of what you're thinking

when you're when you're looking your overseer board am i going to be able to use an action because i have a citizen there and i just i want to make sure we're clear on that and one other interesting thing about the citizens is they're they're a multi-use resource to a certain extent you know they they can come off the board sick or they can come off the board healthy uh when they're sick they go into quarantine cabins and you can actually build things so that sick people in your cabins make you resources or points or money or fire tokens that you can use to fight the plague um healthy ones go on to your main board like we were just saying that you can then activate with overseers and then you can also construct these buildings to then remove healthy citizens from your combo board and put them into this little house which will either give you immediate stuff or ongoing stuff and when you move those citizens kind of through this system you you get various things out of them you know when they're the quartering nuts you get income when they're on the player board you get pop off combo stuff when you remove it from the player board you're you're maybe breaking that combo up but maybe that's fine because you just removed a black token and now you have another black token that's about to come in and finally these citizens as we mentioned way at the beginning return to messina you know the arc of this game is there's plague has arrived everybody tries to leave and by the end of the game you want to bring people back and you could remove people from your combo board or from your houses even essentially removing those incomes in order to repopulate the board and this is a big action that we haven't talked about yet when you move your workers and place them onto the board you either do

the action that's printed there or you could repopulate and um that just essentially just spend your people um you lose them they go back to the supply it's it's the uh the end of the overall system uh you've squeezed a whole bunch of value hypothetically out of them and now they leave and then every time you repopulate you put a token onto a hex and you get a pile of points for the end of the game you are opening the door to a conversation that i wanted to have about the and no theme is a fraught uh word to use in the board game world like we don't necessarily agree on what what theme means in games but the theme of this game or the story of this game and um it has a couple hits and misses for me and i i am not sure where i really land in terms of do i think this game is like thematic because i have those like very dichotomous feelings so let me start off with the hit and the hit for me is that the designer of this game very explicitly said they wanted there to be an arc in the game right and the idea here is that the plague starts coming out the play gets insane and then the plague is washed away and you take these citizens and you return them to messina and the mechanics of this game and the reward systems of this game make that happen every game it is always going to ramp up you are you are motivated as a player in the game to then kind of repopulate the city and i think that flow of the game is is a total hit for me in terms of the theme and the the mechanics being married to

the theme here is there a miss that's coming after that oh sure yeah i just wasn't sure if there was anything that y'all really loved before i like took my my beef here so my miss is the plague cubes which we haven't talked about the play cubes in in depth and it's even it right now in this moment i called them plague cubes not the plague and i think that's that's bad um plague cubes come out in this game at the beginning of every turn they go on a third of the of this of the areas in the city and sometimes they go with citizens and sometimes they don't and if a citizen is in a place with a plague cube then when you save them they need to go into the quarantine cabin and if you don't save them they go straight into your villa as you've saved them and they're they're relatively healthy um i don't like this mechanic because uh in general you are motivated to fight plague in this game rather than avoid plague which i think is counterintuitive there is a there is a penalty for going to plague locations but in the games that we've played the penalty has been minuscule enough that if if you need to go there you will go there and largely what you're going to do is be prepared to fight the plague anyway um i don't understand the idea of like i'm this like villa owner who's like rescuing citizens but also like trying to collect my own like money and resources like i just seem like i'm doing everything like i'm both a philanthropist and a merchant and then the thing that really

really got under my skin the most was i was playing a game where i wanted to just i was trying to decide what action to take on a turn and i asked john who's you know our perpetual game teacher i said can i take a citizen that isn't sick and put them in a quarantine cabin because that was the best thing that could happen for me in the game and of course the answer is no and the fact that that went through my head is nonsense to me right the fact that i would ever be motivated to to get sick citizens rather than like healthy citizens is like it just it just boggled my mind and it really bothered me that happened last night in our game with anastasia we were in the uh i think it was the sixth round of the game it just started and uh anastasia commented like hey i need to get a sick person i looked out to the point i said there's no sick people there's none they don't exist that's it there's no more sick people for the rest of the game and you're like yay but i got all these i could really do some sick people right now yeah i mean it's just it's so funny because i mean you're right nick i mean it doesn't i like i could twist the theme here and like make it make sense i'm like well you don't want to put healthy people into your quarantine cabins because they've been infected with plague and like blah blah blah blah but and but i at the same time from a game design perspective i just i love that decision i love that you're

that you have people in quarantine we haven't really talked about this but people in quarantine stay there for two rounds they move you know they stay there for one round they make this the stuff that they make you and then they stay there for another round and then they come onto your board and so you actually there's this kind of ongoing timing mechanic right like i'm gonna put this person down it's gonna work for me for two rounds and it's gonna go do something else for me and then to your point about the arc of the game nick then i might go put it to work doing something else for me in a building where it can live and then i might go put it to work repopulating messina and so it's like if you if you really are playing the game well these citizens are going to move all through all these different places on your board and i think that is so cool i just i i love that and so it's interesting because wow when i hear you take it apart i'm like well yeah that's like it it it doesn't feel perfectly thematic but at the same time i feel like this is one of the most thematic euros i've ever played i mean to to to see the way that arc plays out and the play gets worse at a certain point and it gets harder to fight at a certain point and that it encourages you i feel the opposite of what you say nick like it encourages you to fight the plague to stop it get it out of messina rather than to avoid it and let it overtake messina like i do enjoy that there's a fight back element to that and that there's a reward for that and that you have citizens who actually

unlike a lot of games they just come onto your board and they just sit actually do do different things and they move and then they move around and then when they go repopulate they stop working for you like you can you don't just get to hold on to them so i i really enjoy how they have worked the theme into this game and actually added that and i don't usually care about them you give me the driest hero and i'll still play it like i don't care but you know if it's there and it works you know i love it i think it's great so i i i hear you but i think i disagree with you well none of us have ever once named our citizens so there's there's a whiff remember though when the first game we played this i built them a little house like i repopulated them i like drew that we've we should acknowledge we've only played this game on tabletop simulator i have ordered myself a guppy from uh europe but it uh we so we haven't dealt with a lot of the like we can't speak to like how fiddly is it to reset the game and we haven't used the spinner or any of the stuff that you know the the mod has done all of that for us but um i did i drew them a little house uh because i was sad remember i was sad that they were leaving my town to go you know i miss them live a better life right yeah but yes i made them a little home i drew out on the board so from a mechanical perspective um you know the end of this loop of the repopulating messina is probably my least favorite um part of the whole game uh and yeah and the reason for that is

because so many of the things that you do in this game get you stuff and potentially popping off or potentially setting things up to pop off but in order to repopulate messina you spend an entire action repopulating you don't do any of the other actions you also rip your engine apart which i'm kind of okay with i like the the idea of that arc but the but the real kicker is that you need a wagon to bring these people to messina and that might seem like a strange minutiae but in this game you're going to be doing these construction actions you can build those quarantine cabins that we've talked about and the buildings we've talked about or you could construct a wagon and the only thing these wagons do is bring people back to the city and they give you a couple of points and this leans into a bit of a pet peeve of mine that i have sometimes with euros where the thing that's good for you to do might not actually be the fun thing to do um constructing a quarantine cabin or maybe one of those late game buildings is fun uh that late game building maybe bumps you up a couple times on a track which unlocks your final worker and you're doing cool stuff or you buy this wagon and it gets you two points and then at some point in the future you can essentially take a non-turn to cash in a bunch of points uh because whenever you repopulate that's all you do is you just remove the people from your engine and then at the end of the game you're going to get a bunch of points and again i'm totally fine with the removing people from your engine part i like that overall flow it's just the fact that you have to essentially have an a boring build action to make this wagon and now that you built this wagon you have a big incentive to use it

in order to have another kind of boring turn just getting points and like you need the most points to win so i get that but i definitely every time i've done a repopulate action i found myself wishing i was doing something else but like i guess i really should do this right now and usually that was the right call if you don't think scoring 15 points is exciting then i don't i don't know what to do wait and that's on the kind of the unfortunate part about it right is it's it's one of the major ways to score points on this game john's already talking it could be significant yeah yeah it's it's a big it's a big thing there's a there's another way he already talked about these kind of scroll boards that you get and they they do give you these like we've said these asymmetric end game scoring points that are also fairly massive right so you can you can i think get away with that repopulating messina but but i the game really doesn't want you to and this goes back to what i was saying too about kind of the kind of i don't say ruts but there there is a path here and it sort of wants you to follow it yeah and so i i totally agree with you john it for me it is the least exciting part of the game and you know we were talking about this play john and i had where i came back you know in the second half of the game but a big part of that was because my board incentivized end game scoring and it's not the funnest thing to do and i had to sort of accept that and lean into that and john and i played another game uh like last week where i just didn't want to like i didn't want to shift into end game scoring and then i lost by a ton you know because i was having so much fun

doing all the other stuff and we talked about this a lot after that play it was like you know we wished that when you took a repopulate action you got to do something else and you had to take the action you got to do something else and it wouldn't work like it wouldn't work for that to happen but it does feel kind of lame but i i just want to kind of like loop back on all of that to say that what i did notice last night was that by the end of the game john and i each had five workers and by that point it did feel like there was really nothing else for the fourth and fifth worker to do but to repopulate right and i actually felt like by that point let's be clear that was my sixth play of this game so by the time we did that fifth or sixth like by the time i felt like oh this worked out in a way where i saw what they were intending with this that i had already had to play the game five or six times to get there but i did see that having that fourth and fifth worker i was like okay this is what this one's supposed to do and i think i paired it with with fighting off some plague which moved me up on a track which moved me up on another track which did give me some kind of follow-up actions it didn't feel as good as taking an action but at that point i also just didn't have anything else to do because i had built to that moment so i don't know it's it's i think it's just something you have to accept about the game but it is the least exciting part of the game yeah and it's a bit of a pet peeve um

i don't have a problem with the idea of the repopulating i just wish there was more fun sauce slathered on top of that as opposed to just like here's here's a pile of points i wish you know the the cart wasn't there to have like one less step towards that whole thing happening but again that is minutia and and honestly i think that's gonna kind of bring me to a point where i want to back up a little bit uh and to kind of sum up a lot of my thoughts about the game overall i've i've mentioned a couple times that i had like a miserable play and then some wonderful plays and where i land with messina um all combined is that i've really enjoyed playing this game with two players um i had an okay game at three and an awful game at three so i think that's kind of where i land like i'm actively looking forward to playing this game at two players more i'm looking forward to exploring the advanced boards more this is uh it's been a fun game overall like i really like the puzzles and the stuff that comes together i think the the pet peeves that i have don't drag it down too much as long as the downtime is kept in check yeah yeah i mean i think i've made it pretty clear throughout this podcast how much i have enjoyed playing this game i i think it is it's just it scratches my brain in the best way there's just there's just enough randomness to kind of limit my ap but just enough to think about that there's plenty for my mind to chew on it doesn't break my brain it gives me lots to do it's very satisfying and i've i've had an absolute blast playing it and we've played a lot of great games this year and i thought arc nova

is going to be my favorite game of 2021 and i really really enjoy arc nova too for similar reasons but this game they're very very different i'm not trying to compare them in any way shape or form i just think that for me with the the way this game moves and how satisfying it is i just i i don't think i'd ever turn down a play of this and i you know i went out found myself a copy of it and i'm i'm kind of constantly saying let's play this once i greatly enjoyed it and i i just want to circle back on you know two two pieces of it that i do think are a little bit of my one is an excitement and one is a hesitation and my hesitation is what i've been talking about which are the sort of ruts that i feel like you can fall into and i as much as i enjoy exploring the game and really hope that i can find different avenues i do worry that you know moving up on that that worker track is really important or you know that you have to kind of switch to repopulating in the later rounds and it is interesting that you start this game with absolutely no resources like you just start so you're always starting completely blank and it just kind of starts flat but the the hit the other hit for me is something we haven't quite talked about is that the advanced boards unlike the beginner boards have these immediate bonuses that you can take when you put a citizen on it immediately does an action rather than you put it down and then you

have to take an overseer movement to get to it that's for me the biggest difference between the two and i just think that is so much fun it pops your game off from the beginning depending on the board that you play and it just it just creates constant fun choices and constant different avenues about how you want to execute and i just i love that i can't wait to explore that more and i hope that as if this game kind of sticks around if there's more to it that there's just even more variability around that to be explored within what i think is a really cool design it's so funny to me because i like this game but the things that anastasia's pointing out as like some of her favorites are some of the things that are really stand out is the things getting in the way for this game being really like a game for me really i mean it's i think it's it's very good i enjoy it and uh i would play it you know with anastasia anytime she wanted to basically right but i'm not i'm not seeking it out and i'm not going to teach it to other people um the things that really stand in the way for me are as she mentioned uh i don't like that that everyone starts with nothing in this game and the first round of this game is like this game's already long enough as it is and i think not as an expansion but just straight up as a component of the design i think it would be better if the first round was abstracted out and you had some starting bonuses it could be something like a zulkin where like you have different starting bonuses or whatever but i really think that the game could have been cut down in favor of that and i think it would have just improved

improve the experience maybe not the whole design but i think would have improved the experience so that's a whiff for me i also in general don't prefer a game where you can do everything and you know all of us now have played at least one game where we've just like popped off like crazy basically done everything in the game and broken the scoring track like the scoring track doesn't even go to the points that we've received yeah it goes up to 150. and and we've we've gone above that definitely gone over that yeah and in my second game i scored in the 170s or something like that like i just i i like a game to me variability in a game is you can't explore all the avenues and so that's that's something that's that's a personal preference for sure that's not a criticism of the game it's just something that doesn't land for for me as much um and then you know i mentioned way earlier in this podcast that i didn't like the advanced boards as much anastasia mentioned and i agree with the biggest difference is the one-off actions i just feel they're unfair and that's the part that i don't i don't like about the advanced boards they are exciting uh for the person who's executing them right and i think i think on i think they they induce jealousy and the other players not um not joy and i think i don't i don't i don't like that it does that um so i've talked about the things that i haven't liked but i i also really want to hit the things that i do think are cool about this game when we first played this game the work replacement worker movement thing seemed okay to me but as we played a little bit

more the fact that every space asks you three questions what does myspace do what are the citizens here and what's the plague situation on this space those three very simple questions with very simple rewards make an easy decision into a very interesting complex decision and i think good complex games take easy decisions and make them into complex decisions total victory right there that's my favorite part about this game and then as i mentioned before my second favorite part about this game is that overseer track the fact that you can have these citizens as anastasia actually mentioned and when we're talking about the theme section right like live a different life they can do this and then they can serve this purpose and this purpose like that is cool from a game design perspective it's like a huge victory that you can think oh this guy is going to go here and then two turns from now he's going to come out and he'll live there and then i'll get those rewards like you can really sequence stuff in a way that feels so satisfying uh and so that's that's a total w as well for me yeah so yeah i think that's gonna finish uh pretty much everything that we have to say about this one we had quite a bit to say about this one um it's been fun exploring it for sure and um i imagine uh some of us more than others will be playing it more in the future but i can imagine we're all gonna get at least another couple plays in uh so yeah that's gonna bring this one to a close um if you have anything you'd like to say about this if uh any questions or if you have experience with the game and you want to weigh in then please comment about it uh there is a youtube version of this podcast you can find that in the

description of the podcast or if you're watching this on youtube then hello and uh go ahead and comment down below we'd really like to see that kind of feedback and uh yeah that's going to bring this to a close thanks again for listening thanks everyone bye

Progress saved