Skip to main content
Loading video...

D&D Builders Of Baldur's Gate Review: Quick Take with Tom Vasel

Transcript 4:19

Builders of Balders's Gate. Now, that's a game that has me interested for a few reasons. One, it's Whiz Kids. Their production is pretty good. Two, it's designed by Matthew Dunston, a designer I think quite highly of. Three, it's about Balders's Gate. I love the video game for Balders's Gate. And four, I'm a big fan of Dungeons and Dragons board games because Lords of Water Deep brought many people into the board game hobby because they said, "Oh, it's a game about Dn D." And they played it and enjoyed it. Will this do the same? Spoiler, no. And in fact, I don't have an overview here for you folks because um Brian Drake already has done uh this on our channel, so you can go watch his overview. But I I'll give you a little bit of an idea of how this game works. you have a a city that you're building up and and this is the the first the biggest I mean this game could have been builders of blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah because it has nothing nothing nothing to do with Balders's Gate and I've played all the Balders's Gates games. Um this could have been about anything but let's take that out of the equation that it's not about anything. There's some really cool concepts here, but there's a lot of problems with this game. There is a lot of luck involved as to the tiles that come out as you're trying to control different areas on the board.

And you're building these really cool buildings. There's wood in here. There's catapults. There's plastic. There's all sorts of things, but the board itself is messy. It's hard to see what attaches to what. Every time you build something, other things go off. So, there's this this kind of area control, but then there's these cards that you get in this line. And the biggest problem I have with this game, and here's the thing, I went into this game, we started playing. The first time I played this game, I was like, "This is pretty good." And then the game spiraled into almost broken territory because people just kept dragging it out and dragging it out and deliberately dragging out because if you don't think you're winning, there's no reason to push towards that end. And it just kind of got boring. Now, the game will eventually end. it will come to an end um mercifully, but it gets worse as the game goes by. And as you control these different areas on the board and towers and there's there's a lot of complication to the game. The game here is not a particularly long rule book.

What is it? It's 15 pages with a lot of different things, but it feels like there's just a lot of I need to do this to get money. And also that was another problem in one of the resources. you can just have so much of this resource that you're just over swimming with it and not this feels like a cool idea for a game that had a theme slapped on and didn't have a lot of play testing done and I mean I'm no no offense to the play testers there's only a few of them very few of them that are written in the book here and there's attacks that don't really seem to be a big part of the game there's building which is cool but there's just so much it's such a proc procedural game to take this, build this, put this, do this. And I never felt any real sense of accomplishment at the end of it. There's some cool cards.

There's really neat stuff as the game goes by. Doesn't seem balanced. Seems like there's broken cards. Seems like there's good areas in the board. It's hard to see which areas attached to which. That's a real big mess. And overall, this one was a miss for me. Not horrifyingly bad. I give this a five out of 10. And I got to wonder sometimes how much of that five is me just liking everything about it. I like the production other than the board that you can't see, but I like the buildings, but the concept of it, it's hard to see the what you're doing through the mud. It's just not one that I like much at all, unfortunately. So, five out of 10. builders of Balders's Gate.

Progress saved