Skip to main content
Loading video...

Fives Tribes Review - Still Worth It?

Transcript 14:01

hello welcome back to the channel and this is a channel where we give you reviews playthroughs unboxings which i really like to talk a lot of bollocks but a tabletop game in general in this video we're going to be talking about a bruno kefala game we're going to be talking about five tribes and in this game you'll be picking up meeples dropping them off on certain spots using the powers of the genies i think that's how you pronounce it that will give you special abilities that will allow you to win the game so in this video we're going to be giving you a very brief overview of the rules i'll be telling you what we do like we don't like and we'll come back and we'll tell you whether or not five tribes it's still worth your time and bother done again seven years bloody has it been that long seven years after this one was first released in 2014 so remember if you're new here then please consider subscribing to my little channel leave a comment in that section down below and we'll see you after this

bollocks so five tribes how'd you play this game so first thing you're going to do in five trials you're going to lay out the tiles in the game in a six by five grid you will then reach into the bag and you'll pull out a load of meeples and you'll put three random meeples on each of the 30 tiles right each player is going to get 50 gold coins and also going to get a bunch of camels that seem to have got the um right you'll shuffle the resource cards and you'll place nine cards face up next to the ball right you'll shuffle the gins or genies or whatever and there's gonna be a lot of this in this video sort of mispronunciation so i don't even think i'm gonna bother doing it but anyway you shuffle them and you will put three of them face up next to the boardway you stick all the palace in the palm trees next to board and away you go you're gonna be playing five tribes so first thing you do is get a bid fraternal right everyone's got one of those sort of phallic turn order markers yeah especially brilliant if you've got a pink one and what you do you look at the turnover board and you will bid an amount that is listed on the board and you'll place your phallic object on that space if you bid zero then you'll place it on the first available zero spot and if somebody else bid zero then you will be forced back what the game calls laterally nice into the next spot yeah so if you bid zero somebody else does you'll be pushed back in further in the turn all the way so once everyone's finished bidding and everyone's stuck there phallic objects on the board then you will place your turn all the marker into the first available spot on the turn of the track but obviously the person that bit the highest is going

to occupy the most lucrative spot in there so next thing you do you're gonna move a few meeples around the board you'll pick up all the meeples on one of the tiles and you will move them to another spot there's a couple of rules you've got to be aware of in this is that you'll have to drop off one meeple on every tile that you cross you can't backtrack immediately so you can't sort of go one two three four you know what i mean i know you're thinking that you cheating bastard you can't go diagonally and also the last tile that you drop a meeple off has to have a meeple of a color you're dropping off last week so then you'll check to see if the tile is controlled if there's no camels on it you'll take one of your camels and you'll dump it on the tile and that means you'll score that many victory points the little numbers on the tile yeah you'll score that many victory points at the end of the game so once you've finished moving all the meeples then you will take the maple that you last dropped on the tile and all the other maples matching that color back into your hand you'll put in front of and then after this you will do the tribes actions if you've got yellow meeples in front of they will give you one victory point at the end again for each vizier or yellow meatball that you got in front of the end of the game right the white meeples are the eldest tribe and they'll score your victory points at the end of the game and you can also spend these at certain points to get extra stuff you'll dump the green maples all the green merchants tribe meeples back into the bag and then you'll depend on how many maples you dump in a bag you'll be able to take that many resources from the available cards so the blue meeples are the builders tribe and you'll put these meeples back into the bag and then you'll gain as many gold coins as

follows you'll count the surrounding number of blue value tile including the tile you ended internal then you multiply this number by the number of blue meters that you just dropped back into the bags this is quite a nice way to get some money for doing absolutely bugger all so the red meeples are the assassins tribe these will let you assassinate and me pull a certain number of tiles away depending on how many meatballs that you put back in the bag right so once you've done killing of off meeples and you've been done drawing some ancient benefits then you'll take the tile action you'll look to see if there's a palm tree or a palace on the tile and then you'll put the respective token on the top and if it's a palm tree this means it's an oasis and these will give you certain number of points at the end of the game and if there's a palace you'll dump one of them on there and these will also give you a certain amount of points at the end of the game right so there's also the small market icon and what this means is you can pay three gold coins to pick one resource card of your choice from among the first three visible cards on the row and then there's a large market and you'll be able to pay six gold coins to pick two resources there's also the sacred places this allows you to pay either two elders which are the white meat pools if you can't remember or one elder and one slave to take the gin of your choice from among those visible and what you do you put the gin in front of and you have to look at a little cheat sheet that tells you what they do so you might have bowel and each time someone gets a gin you'll collect one gold coin if it's you and two gold coins if it's your opponent you might have letter and this allows you to take control of one empty tile and place one of your camels on it or you might have nikia and each time an assassin kills one meatball

collect one gold coin if you did the killing two gold coins if the opponent did right a lot of these genies do reward quite nefarious activities you know i mean so you've also got the opportunity to flog a few other resources that you don't really want and then you'll do a bit of cleanup you replenish the wildcards and do some other crap like aren't they asked to talk about it not me so go men's when somebody has dumped their last camel on a tile or if no more legal movements are possible and then you'll add up your victory points on one of those really irritating school pads that everybody hates so much so you'll get one point for each gold coin you own you'll get one point for each vizier yellow meatball that you own plus ten victory points if you have the majority of meeples you'll get two victory points for every white maple you've got you'll get a summer victory points from your gins you'll get a of the two points from all the tiles three victory points for a palm tree on your top five richard points for each palace on your tile and you'll also get the summer fishing points for each bit of merchandise that is different from all the other ones that you own so once you've gone through that really exhaustive list that i didn't quite manage to say in one breath and you i've got the most victory point said you will be the winner of five tribes so what do we like about five tribes so the first thing that we really like about 512s is the amount of variety in the gentiles there are a couple of expansions for this i can't remember what they're called now but they had extra bits and pieces we haven't got any of them because we thought that this was enough for us so there's 22 gin cards at box and they all do different things i've already said that a lot of these do reward

doing a little bit of stitch up and if these gin cards didn't have that aspect to them then this game would be just sort of one of them multiplayer solitaire games so fact that you could call upon these ancient mythological beasts does spice the game up and allow you to put the boot in on at least one occasion you know i mean so the second thing that we really like about five trials is the randomization of the setup not only are you gonna be randomizing the tiles every round so you're gonna end up with a different board but you're also gonna be throwing out a random load of meeples onto the board so no two games are going to be exactly the same obviously the mechanics and the way the game works is going to be the same but you're not going to be able to lock down a strategy that works continually you can have this overriding strategy that you could develop right but in each game the way that the randomization works and also something else we're going to talk about later on prevents you from finding out a best path for this game and then following that path every time you play it so the next thing we really like about this game is the bid for turn order mechanism is really quite novel in it it's not as good as the turn order mechanisms in say a game like cyclades but it has that same sort of thing it's the same designer funny thing right so we really do find it interesting is that if you bid zero then you might be pushed back even further so saving your money and bidding the least amount possible it still may be detrimental to your intended purpose right so that's

really really interesting and it's sort of a case of the only way you can really guarantee your place on the eternal board is by bidding a stupid amount of money and that is really really interesting thing about this game yeah maybe you don't think so but i do right so the final thing that we really like about five tribes is again days of one that i've knocked the ball at the park with the component quality of this one it is absolutely amazing the the phallic turn all the markers are top-notch it's wonderful wonderful artwork and loads of meeples big chunky palm trees and all that sort of thing and it does look absolutely fantastic on the table so yeah you can't fault days of one day i mean maybe this was one of the last big hitting games that they produced after this one hasn't really been that many days of wonder games that make you sit up and think bloody oh that looks really really good done it i mean now since as bidet bought this lot out it's really sort of gone downhill from here on so yeah this is sort of like the last days of wonder game that really made me sit up and stop watching eastenders not that i watch his danders you know what i mean so what don't we like about five tribes it's the first thing we don't like what i keep looking over about five tribes is the fiddliness of picking up the meeples so every time we play this someone always scoops up the meatballs in their pincer like grip and they fly at the end and then they end up knocking meeples over and knocking meeples on other tiles and then you can't remember which maple went where and where it came from right so that is a major problem with this game you've got to be very

very careful that you're not going to be playing a really chaotic dexterity game with the old meeples because it could screw the game up completely yeah second thing that we don't like about five tribes is the downtime is really really excruciating not because it takes a long time to take your turn ordinarily but because there's so many different paths that mipples could take through the tiles it takes a billion and one years for people to analyze the board and then decide where they're going to be dropping their meat pools people used to call this thing analysis paralysis you don't really see much of this these days because maybe designers have sort of come down to the fact that people don't like it but this game is really guilty of forcing you to analyse the board or shoot yourself in the foot in a later turn you know so the next thing we don't like about five tribes is that this game may not suit people that are color blind right because the color of the meeples you've got red and green there and a lot of people who are color blind really really struggle with differentiating between these two shades yeah so because we said those wonder make really wonderful components why didn't they just turn each meatball into a different shape i mean the assassins could have had a sword for instance or the viziers could have not been wearing some kind of hat or something like that or whatever but no they just dumped in a load of carcassonne meatballs not thinking about people that are suffering with the colorblind affliction right so totally unforgivable in this day and age and if it ever gets a reprint or a reframe there'd be no question that they would have to think about that sort of thing you know so the

final thing that we don't like about 5 12 is that because the board changes every turn it's really really impossible to plan a coherent strategy there's no real opportunity to say i'm going to look at that tile and i'm going to move these there in a couple of rounds time i'm going to maybe get that genie to help me do that because by the time your turn comes around and you get to implement that the board has shifted and that strategy has gone it's a bit like pissing in the wind you know so to summarize is five tribes still worth your time and bother seven years after it's first released and we're going to say maybe it's a take it or leave it going for us we do enjoy it don't get me wrong it's just the case of one of them games where the theme doesn't translate into the mechanics that well there is a variety of paths to victory like you could concentrate on maybe getting the majority in the viziers or you could maybe concentrate on getting loads of different resources or maybe just double down on your camels maybe hope a few oases come your way right but this is a curse as well as a blessing because where the board shifts so often during the game your strategy is going to be changing and you're gonna have to analyse the board every term because it changes all the time add to this some questionable content with the old slaves you know i mean for goodness sake bruno what on earth were you thinking did you not think that people weren't gonna have a problem with this i think that content has been removed from a subsequent printer but even so come on man it's a pretty poor design decision i

haven't said that five tribes is it's an average game at the end of day i mean i much prefer istanbul for this sort of thing you know picking something up dropping off stuff along the way and then doing what it says on a tile istanbul is is a bit better than this one so you go that's five tribes remember if you're new and please consider subscribing to this channel leave a comment in that section down below we'll see you next time

you

Progress saved