Catherine Review
Transcript
thank you this video is sponsored by game Toppers turn your own kitchen or dining room table into a premium portable game solution at a fraction of the cost hey everybody Welcome to drive through review 761. today we're going to talk about Catherine the cities of the tsarina and so what this is is a two to four player abstract game set during kind of the time of sort of the sort of the tail end of the Russian Empire before uh became Soviet Union and so what players are going to be doing is playing cards into a tableau in front of them and using kind of these different Combos and interactions which I'll show you down on the board here to kind of spread out different kind of routes collect little resource tokens get kind of favors and different tracks and things like that and then kind of re-interact and combo with some of the cards that they have in front of them and then try to score the most points over the course of a couple of rounds so let's go down to the table explain to you how it works and I'll come back and tell you what I think okay so here is the game board which I set up for four players although nothing really changes too much based on player count in terms of the setup for this game so a couple things to note here is you have these different various cities here out on the board and then you will have a number of these resource tokens on each City equal to the number of players so in a four player game you have one for each player and you'll notice there are spots here around these different cities for
players to put their little houses here which we'll talk about how that happens but you'll never put more than one house in a city and when you put a house out here when you do a building there you take one of those resource tokens and put it in front of you and you kind of collect these for different sort of things that you can combo with as well as for in-game scoring but again you'll never take more than one and there's other ones out here that you'll score points for during little scoring rounds and then here you will have places to build to go up the favor track which we'll look at now so whenever you build a building out there or maybe activate some action here that shows that you will start to move your little marker up here up the favor track and there's a couple things to note about that so you can see there's kind of like three numbers so we'll zoom in there so here the left number will show you your maximum hand size normally you have a hand size of three but in this case the yellow players moved up to here so they now have a maximum hand size of five the next number is the amount of points you will score during some of the scoring rounds so this is just a flat number of points that you score and then the right hand number which in this case is still zero is going to be a big multiplier at the end of the game for your largest contiguous route of buildings there so as you can see as you move up to the top there it starts to go up quite a bit so two three and four so basically at the end the game multiply this number wherever you're at on the track with your largest route and that's add some points to the game and of course there's a score tracker on the side which will score points and little bonuses for every time you do a
loop around the track so other than all of this stuff out here the game largely takes place in front of the players with their display of cards now over the course of the game and even to start the game you're going to have two rows of cards here you've got your action row on top and your activation row on the bottom and if I forget to mention this in the review I'm going to mention it now I really hate how they call this the action row and then the activation row those words are too close to each other they should have come up with some other term because if you're trying to explain the game they're like which one is the action row which one's the activation row so the way that to remember it is you activate with the cards that you play on the bottom and they're activating and taking the action of the one on top okay so what you're going to do is you're going to get a hand of six of these cards to start you also will get two of these cards and you'll choose one here and these it's going to give you some in-game bonuses here so you can see these resources here match those resource tiles which I showed you on the board earlier and so if you collect over the course of the game a certain number so five six or seven of the resources shown here you will score five eight or twelve points and so they're just the different ones there and these are just a little End Game bonus scoring there so you get one of those start the game and then six cards you'll take three cards and decide to put those in your top row you're acting your action row this is the actions you're trying to take the actions on this card and then activate them with cards underneath so then
you'll have three cards left in your hand and then you're gonna play three rounds with four sort of action rounds in between so three larger rounds each with four actions you're always going to end up with seven cards here right and so because over the course of the different action rounds you're going to take you're always going to play one card up here and then one card down here into the activation room okay so you're gonna do that so over the course of four these will have seven across the top and then you're going to delete some cards and you'll be back down to three and you're going to do it again you do that three times so a total of just basically 12 turns over the course of the game so the way that it's going to work is you're always going to draw start with three cards draw two put them into your hand and all of these things happen simultaneously everybody does each of these kind of phases simultaneously so simultaneously everybody's going to draw two cards and then everybody's going to take and put you know let's say I'll just do this randomly two cards like this face down everybody kind of decides that when everybody's done we're going to reveal the cards because you always will put one on the top row and one on the bottom row and if the card that you played in your bottom row in your activation row is the same color as the one above it in your action Row the bottom card will activate the action on your top card and so everybody can take that action simultaneously because like I said there's no you know erasing of somebody's position here everybody has a
spot at the table in each of the Cities everybody has a spot at the table to grab one of the each of the resources there and then you know there might be some other actions here to draw cards but you can kind of just do that simultaneously so you're going to do that four times and then at the end here let's just kind of zoom out so we're going to have let's say one here I'm just going to do this randomly so we're on the second one and then one here the third one and then finally again there so we'll have done our four rounds anything that we have a card underneath and again you do not have to match if you don't want to then you're going to take and discard all of these right so these are all the ones theoretically we've activated so we have three left we suck these back down to the left here and then we go again so we're going to keep playing top and bottom top and bottom four times then we're going to do that whole process three times and then score now each time you do that after you've played your fourth turn there there is going to be interim scoring so you're going to play four turns score four turn score four turn score and then have some final score so now I'm going to talk about how you score and then we're going to work through some of the cards and how what the actions are that those cards do to help you score because one thing is it's a pretty icon heavy game that's not too bad you know there's a lot of different kind of things there's a nice kind of Aid here at the back of the rulebook here kind of this one and a half pages that really covers all the icons it's not a lot but it's a little bit to take in you know on your first couple of
turns in the game so let's look at how you actually score so the first thing you're going to score in the first interim scoring round is you're going to compare cannons so you're going to look at all the Cannons on the tops of these cards right so the tops of these cards that are in your top row if it's in your bottom row ignore that card it completely other than the color when you played it to activate the top one again if this matches the color then you get to do whatever action is on here we'll talk about that in a minute but otherwise completely ignore the card so when we get to scoring we're going to compare cannons with our neighbors now two player game you're just going to compare with each other in a multiplayer game you're going to compare with your neighbor to the left and to the right and so if the neighbor to my left has fewer cannons than me I will get four points if the neighbor to my right has more cannons than me they'll get four points and if I'm tied with either of them they will each get two points so it's kind of like seven wonders if you play that with the military you're kind of comparing your military in this case and so if you have more than the person to your left or right you get four points in both cases if you're tied two and if you're less zero next thing you're going to compare are these books here and so when you're going to compare those books you're going to compare to all of the players on the board and the player that has the most books is going to be able to build one of these cities out here anywhere that they want for free and again you're trying to kind of build a contiguous route and then also again collect the resources out there that match up with the End
Game bonus card that you selected so you're kind of considering those two things the routes and then the bonuses so maybe I'll just throw this out here if I was the most had the most books I'll collect that resource just put it off to the side next to me and then I built this building and started my route a little bit now if multiple players are tied for most then all of us get to do that if you have the least amount of books you don't get anything but if you're somewhere in between the least and the most then you get this sort of Joker token this wild card token which can count as a resource only at the end of the game for this card so it doesn't count as a resource for anything else that I'm going to show you just for this so if you don't quite get the first place on the books then you at least get kind of a consolation uh sort of wild card to use at the end of the game and then the next thing you're going to do is anybody that has little houses on any of these cities that have the little one point thing they're going to score a point for each one that they have you're then going to score the points here for moving up this track so again this is very important for increasing your hand size scoring more points during these interim scorings and again for the largest kind of Route thing that you have at the end of the game and then once you've scored that then again you're going to go down to your display here clean those up and then at the end of the first and the second rounds everybody's going to draw two cards and then at the of course at the end of the third round you're going to do final scoring now it's worth noting that in this case when you draw these two cards at the end of the interim scoring if you
go above your hand limit you don't draw any extra cards but you get a victory Point immediately on the victory Point track for each card that you hit draw that goes above your hand limit and that goes for all card drawing during the course of the game except for one instance and again that's the thing where everybody draws two to start each turn and then we'll decide two to play from our hand those two there you can go above your hand limit for that instant because immediately you're going to play two but anytime any card effects down here or the interim scoring or anything like that where you draw cards and it goes above your hand limit you actually get victory points which can be part of your strategy which we'll talk about in a minute now before we get into some more specifics with the cards I just want to talk about end of game scoring so you will score points for each card in your hand you get one point for that you score for your your end game order card here again which like I showed you based on the number of goods you've collected and then again you take your largest route multiply that by the number on the right of the favor track here and then you add that to whatever victory points you have accrued during the game and then whoever has the most points is the winner so let's just take a couple of examples of cards speak because there's a lot of variety in terms of what the cards do because there's a just a large stack of cards and just little nuances of how these work but there's not a lot of icons like I said it's basically like a page and a half maybe just over a page of these explanations here and it gets pretty self-explanatory once you go so again when you reveal your two cards here Bam
Bam so we revealed that one and then this one then if the card under here matches then you get to activate that card now on the tops of the cards you don't really worry too much about that during the action phase again that's usually for counting these icons like the books the canons some of these resources which will come into play which I'll talk about in a second the bottom part of the card is what you're usually considered for the action and so you kind of like two parts to some of these actions so you can have like the main action and then the bonus part now for some reason if you play the card here and you don't want to do the action or you place it under a card that doesn't match instead you can draw a card uh because I don't know that didn't happen very often but sometimes but most of the time you're able to perform the action and the real Crux of the game is trying to look at the kind of the hand of cards you have and figure out you know do I want to use this to activate something else do I want to activate it or what or maybe I can let it sleep over here and then hopefully draw another yellow card to activate later because I really want to activate this one and so on so that's the real kind of the Crux of the game so for example here let's do this one so we do this and say we look at the tokens that we have so if we have one of each token we can get four points and we can do this as many times as we have a set of each token now when you go to look at like what you have to satisfy an action like do I have other requirements to satisfy this you look at again only the top cards in your row because again the bottom ones you totally ignore other than the color you can see okay I've already got two three of these different tokens but maybe
I have the other one that I've collected from building a city on the board so in this case oh bang Four Points easy now if I had multiple sets the top parts of these are considered like the main action if I can satisfy that multiple times uh which is you can see it with a little Black Arrow there then I can score you know 4 8 12 points theoretically then because I was able to do the action I chose the deduction then I can do the bonus the bonuses you can only do once so in this case it's discard a card for my hands and then I can go up here you know on the favor track one step so here I could draw two cards if I have three books that again only you only look at the top cards so if I counted the books here which I don't have three books so I'm looking at two then I can go up two spaces here I can score three points and then one time I can discard a card and score four here I can go and actually build in one of these green cities so I can go to St Petersburg Revel or Novgorod and build there and so they're kind of color coded so that's another way you can get buildings out and you go look there and then the bonus I can do once I can have two books and then go up on the favorite track and just a couple other examples like this one here I can just discard two cards this means I can do it once and then I can build uh building in one of the yellow spaces on the board and then if I have two of these I can go up there or like this one here this one can kind of compound on so you can say if I have for each one of either of these I had I can draw a card so you can theoretically have a lot of cards this card already
has two on there and I've got some more here and then maybe this one here so I could draw a couple of cards that way well you might want to do that because if you discard three cards again you can do this once you get 10 points if those three cards match color you can also go up on that and so you can get some card generating card draw generating cards in here and again for each card that you draw over your hand limit that gets you points and so I've played games where I've gotten a lot of points doing that but that's really kind of the basics of the rules of the game is everybody's kind of simultaneously playing these cards activating their actions getting you know buildings out here on their outs going up to favor track to try to combo that stuff up collecting the different resources from the different places again which will interact with some of the cards and their actions on there and give you bonuses at the end of the game and it's just a real quick kind of game in that regard you play that three turns three rounds and then you score it up and see one okay so that is Catherine let's go through my three pillars of review first we'll talk about player count I've only played this two and three player haven't had a chance to play it before I would say I don't really have a preference with two or three player I can kind of lean two player I don't really know why but it just it has a kind of a nice back and forth with two players but that's just like just under three players and I don't see why I would have a problem with the four players because let's look at the play time this is 30 to 45 minutes and that is definitely true I think you know four
players new players and stuff it might take about an hour but because all the turns are basically simultaneous not basically they are simultaneous uh it shouldn't really matter the difference in play time between two and four players that much I mean you have extra heads at the table so there's somebody's going to be doing some extra thinking you know so it's going to take a little bit extra time I would say that's tricky because the first two player game I would say I played took about as long as this first three player game but the second two player game that I played was way quick I mean it was like definitely like a half an hour so that's not it's not really going to matter the play count doesn't really matter there's not like any stealing from people like it's a low interaction game for sure the only real kind of direct interaction is it's kind of a race to you know to do different things so there's interaction there for sure I mean you can't just undersell that and then you have like the canon in book comparison which is like a seven wonders style sort of neighbor Left Right comparison of the military and uh you know science or whatever and that is interactive like there there that is that does factor into some of the decision making uh that you have to do because you're trying to you know worm your way through all the possible things that these cards can do and so let's get to my third pillars like what is this game like well superficially it's very like a San Juan race for the Galaxy whatever kind of multi-use card game like on a superficial level uh it
kind of reminds me of St Petersburg I think some of that has to do with they're both set in Russia um and they both have cards but St Petersburg is this total economic thing this is not really like that this is really cool though I really do like this game because the cards have so much kind of going on with them that you're like you're like oh my God what am I supposed to do here do I want to activate which of these cards do I want to activate first of all and you kind of want to activate all of them and it's like okay I really want to activate this one now but I want to activate this one later so what you can do though is it's a neat kind of thing is you can play you're like okay I'm going to activate this one this other one over here that it's already down and I'll stick this one over on the right and wait for it until I can kind of get some cards and then I can get myself into a better kind of hand position to have a little bit better choice of what I want to do make my choices a little bit more optimal so I can really set myself up to have you know a good choice in either direction that I take and it's just really cool because it's like it's hard to explain because it's very abstract okay I feel like this is a game that probably would have come out like 10 15 years ago and been like really heralded and you know touted and that kind of stuff because it just has this really cool combo-rific kind of stuff nowadays I can almost hear the
voices in my head out there on some of the you know internet critics and some of the other reviewers and stuff like wow there's no interaction really it's a bunch of you know uh icons and Combos and stuff like that and it's it doesn't have this it doesn't have this other like you know check mark that it ticks you know with like you know social interaction or something on a game and I'm like I don't know that this is great because it feels like a breath of like old fresh air that you know like I'm like oh I remember when games were like this and it kind of has it's like a throwback vibe and I really like it for that because sometimes in this is I got to kind of caveat this a little bit because it's it's something that I really particularly personally enjoy I love a good hand of cards I love a good like oh crap like what what order do I play these in you know and if I do this and like invariably you you play something you're like oh that's good and then like five seconds later you're like oh no I should have did that and it's like the whole game is full of that in the game it's definitely a less than an hour game but it somehow feels like a more crunchy kind of full epic kind of game that would you know normally take like two hours or so so it kind of packs a lot into that and there's just a lot of stuff tugging at you you're like okay I'm trying to get the most books get the most canons start to you know I got to work on my route so I got to start building stuff but holy cow I can really generate a lot
of points you know especially towards kind of the end of the game where you have access to a lot more of these different tokens and stuff that will trigger not only in your card row but you gather those tokens to get the end game kind of order bonus card but those tokens will trigger off extra abilities on your car so you really want to do that so in the last one you're like I'm going to draw 10 cards or something it's like and you know your hand limit's gonna be way under that so you just get a bunch of points and so it becomes a real kind of fun Balancing Act to you know figure out where your optimal Point stuff is but it doesn't feel like pointsality or anything it's like okay you get points from extra cards you get points from the routes you know you get points from the cards that say here's some points and that's it you know so it feels like an old school kind of thing where you're just really at home and you just kind of sit in there with that whole multi-use card thing and it's just a fun little juggling act and there's not any like nobody's punching in the face you know no you know in terms of like the gameplay where you're like you're getting stuff taken away from you you're doing this and doing that um so it feels really nice to me uh as somebody who's been playing these games for a while to have a game that kind of like has an old sort of throwback to some of those really clean basic Euro things with some nice card play there's not a lot of components on the you know I didn't have to punch anything you know it's just like
everybody has a little handful of wooden tokens there's a giant deck of cards go and then you got some really good you know stuff to kind of chew on and I'm like this is really cool I'm really glad that somebody made a game like this again because a lot of games which a lot of them which I really enjoy it's like big and sweeping and there's just crap everywhere on the table and there's a lot of complexity and intricacies um but this one is so like just polished down just shave down to it to a very smooth nub and uh it's good it's just a really fun game I I really this is one of those games because of the abstractness it's hard to review and express that because it's all just abstract it's like oh I set these card combos and got some points and built a route I'm not telling you like a thematic story here so it's hard to review that and go this is going to be I think you're really gonna like it but if you're one of those people you're like what is he talking about and you've probably turned it off that's fine but for those of you that have played some of these older games some of these more streamline games and stuff and have been I think you know what I'm talking about here so this is that's who this is kind of for and I think if you're not you know you don't have a good memory of that kind of stuff with some of these older games like a San Juan or something or a St Petersburg or um you know I mean very Loosely and a lot of these games I'm saying are not really like this game because this game is very different with how it kind of works but it's in that same sort of overall kind of larger net of these kind
of older Euros like a Tiger's new phrase Samurai through the desert you know stuff like that um this is it fits in there so it feels good it's like oh it's a new game that somebody lost and then somebody found it and brought it out 15 years later really really cool a definite High recommend for for me and if you love cards and you love the whole multi-use card thing which I do this is easy recommend easy so thanks foreign