Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 25:37

hello everyone this is Joannes and this is C and you are watching board gaming ramblings and today we are taking a look at Luther the art of the instruments this is a new game from Pon games designed by Dave Beck and ab Bon it plays from one to four players in 90 to 150 minutes yes luier the new game from the publisher game was distilled which was a game we enjoyed this is a prototype so obviously we got it sent from the publisher we even got this NICE T-Shirts so we we thought we should wear them because that's what you do with t-shirts you have them on your body I would say that this is the perfect occasion for wearing this t-t this t-shirt yes maybe to a concert like a classical music that would also be kind of like meta but today we are talking about the game and as always as you know it's a prototype we are going to talk a bit about the different aspects of the game we going to see hopefully it will give you a sense if this is something that you're going to back because it is going to CR funding yes when you see this it's going to be probably already on crowdfunding so hopefully this will be helpful for you to decide if you want to back the game or not before we go into anything else we have to say one thing M that's where are we going we're going to Gen Con and please if you're also there come and say hi to us and show us the secret sign if you're not there we will do vlogs and also a a live stream from when we at home with all the games and if you are not there and you

want to give us a secret sign you could do it it's just that we probably won't do it back oh yeah you can send us a picture no I was thinking like at the screen oh yeah while they're watching this video that's true you could do that but today we are talking about Lu so let's just get jet lag into it are you ready yes we are as always going to do a brief overview so that hopefully the rest of the video makes sense in this game you are a family making instruments you're trying to get the best patrons to tell them that you are the best at making the instruments trying to make the instruments for them trying to impress them by performing with your instrument repairing other instruments and as I said building instruments for them they will then give you bonuses points and and and and things throughout the game but if you don't make them happy they will be sad and give you negative points which is bad bad that was the word I was looking for you are going to play six rounds each round is going to be the same you're going to get some bonuses in the beginning you're going to move the patron cubes getting some income if they move all the way to the to the end they're going to be sad and they're going to leave you and give you negative points as we already said and that is bad yes then you're going to place your workers it's a worker placement game you're going to in the beginning of the game have your one three and five worker these are going to be placed you're going to place the face down so nobody knows what you are placing and then when everybody has placed there's five spots on the board and two spots on your player board we are going to go through the rounds if I'm the star player I will choose somewhere to a trigger I have to beater

let's say I trigger this we're going to flip over all the Ts that are here and the player with highest number is going to go first there's ways to up your number with apprentices and then you're going to do that action in the order of the numbers you're going to continue doing that until everybody has triggered all their actions and also probably gone to the market to get some resources and sell some resources and done a couple of different things after you done that you're going to do that six more times and you're trying to be the person who has the most Rory points because Rory points are life yes and that is what you're going to do it is a prototype and everything is prototype components the real book is prototype there is a Rob book spoiler alert all of that but we're going to talk a little bit about the things we always talk about which is the artwork and the components that you can see with your eyes yeah and I think the artwork and components in this game are great the artwork is by V Vincent trait that we really enjoy his artwork from before and I think all the symbols are very easy to understand it is also explained in in detail in the rule book but all everything looks nice um the artwork is fantastic there is like a um a piece that's supposed to be like at the top here which has which makes it like a whole board I like it like it's a long board and then you have like this at the top to make it like a little bit different and I read in the rule book that it's based on a real place which I don't remember the name of no it's basically an Orchestra Hall yes like where you have the salon you have the guild you have to repair like all of this and it's kind of as as I said it taken Liberties to make it work as a

board game but it's kind of based everything is based in theme there is as I said a rule book there's actually two rule books and the rule book is as we said prototype but it's looking very good it's very clear very easy to understand there's quite a few Concepts in the game but mostly Concepts that I've seen before so it wasn't that hard couple of the things like a small nuances was hard to get my brain around but mostly that was a me problem and not a rulebook problem there is also I'm going to note a the rehearsal rule book which is basically a teaching Aid I don't usually find this teaching Aid well very helpful because I'm used to my way of teaching rules but this is going to be a great way for people who this might be a heavier game for you for example it's going to be an easier way to teach the rule with this so one player can read a rule book and then use this to teach the game so I'm want to say Great rule book great thing yes the game also comes with play raids which are double-sided with the sequence of the round the icon glossery uh some for the rehear and also the final scoring I found these super helpful during the game I'm I'm fan of these and there's two for each player which is great so two thumbs up for the player I'm going to give the player Aid a natural trumpet in the sky that's good and the rule book a heart nice yes that is my rating

system for today we played the game and it took time yeah it it did indeed we have played the game with two and three player as and it has taken us between 2 hours and two and a half hours yes and it's a bit longer than the ru book says I'm unsure like 90 minutes seems like a stretch maybe for one person you can play the 90 minutes when we played uh three players the last time we played it then our turns begin going pretty Snappy we had some moments of AP but most of the time I don't see us being a lot faster than we were so I'm unsure if you can get it down to 90 minutes and one of the player counts is way better than the other player count but we're going to talk about that soon before going into the gameplay section I'm going to say something okay to make you stay here the game is fun yay yes the game is fantastic and if you stay around and hang with us you can understand why we feel that way do you like my my segue yeah I like that it's very good I like it's more than the ads that you've done and here it's an ad no Hello Cinema hi do you like instruments yes I do do you like classical music yes I do do you like board games yes then there's a new board game in town it's called luier oh ni art of the instrument I have to buy that you can't you can back it on on on Crow fing then I will do that and you will then get it but you shouldn't because I'm

doing it so we don't need two puppies that's true and now back to the video this game has work replacement kind of blind bidding talk to me about what do you feel about that do you like it do you like it do you like it yeah I like it we've seen this um mechanism in other games before and I think this game implements that mechanism nicely so you all get to do the action but the the person with a higher number get first pick and as you can see the cars has a lot of symbols on them and they work together or or not so being able to pick what you're actually looking for is very valuable in this game yes I will say that this is as you said like it's something we've seen before but I really like it there for a couple of reasons for the first thing you always want to have the higher numbers because all the different actions are giving you a bonus if you have like a four or higher in the beginning of the game you have have a one and a three and a five so having more than you're probably going to have one five you could have like an apprentice that makes this into a four that's going to be able case of choosing which do I want to have that bonus on but also where is it important for me to go first and where it is important for me just to go because there are many cards that you can choose from in each each action but there are different tires so you have to pay for the action like let's say over here there's two that are free to take but in the beginning you're going to have to pay a lot of coins or in um inspiration if you

want them if you haven't moved it far enough on the balcony track yes and I think that is very interesting another highly interesting part about the game is the triggering order of the actions yes tell me all about that not all but just like tell me the things about it here is the details well I think that is what makes this mechanism more unique than in other games that we see before because if I'm here for example I just have a one here I know that I don't know what you have but for example I need to know which one of these patr pattern that I will get before I for example dropped an instrument for them then it's super important for me for this to trigger first so I will try to do that but if I'm not the first in turn order you might go ahead and Trigger some other place that you are first so it's very important with the order that you do stuff in could really work to your benefit or the the opposite yeah and and this is basically the reason uh that this game is better with more people yes we played two players a couple times in the beginning and there is like a dummy setup you will fill in some of these and some of the scoring opportunities are going to be blocked other than that it's kind of like a static thing and they're not placing any tiles H you could play to play with an atoma there's some Poss to do that we would never do that because we don't we and don't enjoy like playing with an Ultima or a dummy if we don't have to so adding that third

player cuz I like the game a lot with two but after playing it with three I don't know if I want to play it with two again I agree the the there are basically four kind of markets and they get more stale with two and more like the randomness is hurting you more with two as well and also the the music pit here is more open in the beginning with more play is I I really enjoyed the interaction more with tree and I absolutely agree with you that it's a better game so I'm going to say if you like interactions in games or if that's something that you need in your game to enjoy it this might be for you because there's interaction in every step like you want to go here first we haven't spoken about it but basically when you come to a place first you will get a better bonus and of you stay there at the end you're going to score points at the end of the game but the triggering of these actions in two players it was most of the time maybe there was one space where it was super important for me and you also were there but most of the time it wasn't that big of a deal with three players it really was yes it was like that was maybe what elevated it from like a good game to a great game for me yeah and I think it's cool that you have some personal actions on your player board as well and those you are always in control of when is triggering I enjoy that and the market action that you can do like isn't triggering an action so you are in control of something so most of the time I'm trying to make a plan where okay as long as I get to do the market action before I do that I'm fine and it doesn't really matter because if I then use to

repair and use actions or resources for that I can buy them before I need them to build their instruments and let's talk a bit about the more a couple of different things in the game there are so many Concepts and so many things so we not going to have time to go deep into all of them let's talk a bit about the patrons because the patrons are going to have a different uh it's basically like a a contract so this person wants you to build a piano it's not a piano but it's like it's the one thing I don't know what is it's like a three different kind of instruments I I don't know what it is in percussions and keyboards keyboards percussion keyboard thank you so much H and other channels would maybe cut this out but we won't because we're not perfect and We Know It uh I don't know if somebody cast it out it's just we are weird uh and I like myself that's very important you should enjoy the company of yourself before enjoying the company of others and so this person San he wants a keyboard and percussion you you have to build that instrument and then you can build other instruments but most of the time you probably going to do a repair or a performance action and when you finish this when you finish one of them you're going to reset the cube the patient Cube so that you are not losing the patron and then when you finish all of them you're going to score some points and it's is going to turn over and give you a bonus so this for example is going to tell you to get five coins at the beginning of each round so I think that's going to be forming your strategy a bit about which of these you

go for for different actions yeah absolutely having those patrons is a big part of the game and managing when to fulfill their their needs is also a big part of it and seeing up here okay what types of instruments do they need do some of these patn fulfill them things I need for my final scoring and what bonuses do they give me or towards the end of the game what final scoring do they give let's talk a bit about the performance and the repair um the repair is pretty simple you're going to choose one you're going to pay the resources you're going to get some points and you're going to be able to place a repair token out here let's say this one wants to be on the it's not on the play rate winds the wins and you have to play it somewhere here and you're going to get a bonus if you are first here or you're going to get a smaller bonus and this will help you to to solve the patrons very straightforward but it costs resources but you know what you're going to have to pay this is kind of different yeah these are performances and you then here have a die mechanism because here you have in the beginning two basic dieses and together with the skill level that you put in here to do the action you summarize the Pips yeah the notes yeah so let's say you chose this one yeah now you got I have seven and I can fulfill the Tet two here which gives me two

coins and I can put out this uh performance token that works the same way that here I can place in the this area right here you have three three areas that are a little different these are different musical areas basically so this is more luck based but you have inspiration tiles that you can use to basically mitigate that luck so it not doesn't never felt like oh Super Lucky or unlucky to me yes and I have to say that both making the instruments doing the repairs and doing the performances you a lot of times do the things that benefits your patn but you can also do these things to just get the points that is also a valid thing to do but it's good to do the thing where you get the points and you get the and it helps you P so you're trying to do that making the instrument is kind of straightforward you're going to do the action here to like make the instrument paying the resources and moving it over here to the finishing bench then you're going to have to do here to finish the instrument paying that you're going to score some points and you might give it to a patron if they need it um you're going to put the instrument out here in the musical bit and get so this was the timony you're going to place it here and get the different bonuses for that as well there are different tracks which makes you better at performing this one doesn't really make you better at repairing uh but this one makes you better at working on your workbench basically and and and those are kind of different things you can do you have a

market that's going to change each round so sometimes say the wood is going to be very uh expensive sometimes it's going to be cheap all of these things one thing I want to talk about or I'm going to ask you about okay is how do you feel about the luck level in this game I'm asking because many people's going to wonder because especially in dis still there was a couple of luck elements that some people didn't like and it is the same designer or one of them so people probably going to ask about that yeah the luck is definitely present in this game which would be weird if it wasn't with four stacks of cards and I and Ice I think that this luck didn't bother me and you have ways to mitigate that the cards sometimes you can feel more unlucky because you've set yourself up to get a specific thing because for example let's say that here a lot of these patn need the wind uh instrument to to be happy and you could have a scenario here where there wasn't a single wind instrument uh available then you could pay a lot of resources to go through the deck and find an instrument but most of the time yeah that that could affect you so I would say that yeah there is luck in the game but and most of the time you just have to deal with playing the best you can out of the things that are available to you I'm going to say that for me it didn't really bother me at all because there's only three different

things there's three different kind of instruments and there's not one it would have been a horrible game if it was like uh lombardini needs a natural trumpet oh yeah that would have been horrible so it's like it's it's it's it's only three different kind of instruments and only three different eras so like when you need a specific era there's a high chance it's going to be there and if it's not there's a high chance it's going to be the next round and most of the time before these things you're going to have like some leeway because you can do it can be here and you can trigger one of them so now you have two more rounds to be able to do the next one so it could be a possibility we haven't had a time where one of these were going to leave no but that is a concept in the game so it is there for a reason that you might okay so I have to go and get another one H so know that it's there but it hasn't bother me at all I'm going to talk a little bit or I'm going to ask you uh this is something that we don't talk about but this feels like a very thematic game mhm yes I was going to ask you do you it sounded like you were going to say something more yes I also think it's a very thematic game um I know that sometimes I don't know the words for things but I probably would know them in Norwegian in my defense and I think it's the art looks amazing amazing and also all the things in the game have names that make sense to the theme so we usually when we talk about the resources for example you have actually said the names of the resources that never

happens in Bard games so yeah it's pretty thematic but in real life it happens when you talk about the resources It's s like in BN games we never say that and it's kind of because we played the tree player game we played with my cousin and he knows more about music and he was like oh but this is exactly how in real life and he he was like it it feel it seems like it's very correctly thematic I'm going to touch on one thing which I think is a great concept of the game this kind of out of order but I don't care and this is these you going to have some uh objectives that you can do and there are most games where you have objectives you want to have the highest scoring objective but in this game you're going to try also to raise for the lower scoring objective because when you do an objective you're going to unlock a ability or for example more rooms for resources on your board I just want to note that because I think that's a very clever thing so you might be able in beginning to be like oh but I just want to r that and then I don't really care for that anymore I just want to be able to get that bonus out there there's so many elements there's special workers you can get when you get to the middle of each track all of there there's different ways to go yes I will say for for scoring even though you are going to build instruments and you are going to do patrons but but I I I think it's nice that the what you call them the achievement that the goals the goals and also your own personal final scorings can sometimes you have to see okay I can take that Patron and make this

instrument for them but my final scoring wants me to do something else and then you have to weigh what is more important what will give you the more points and I think like I said the bonuses or the abilities you had one time you played now you had you got four bonus points every time you performed so basically you kind of stopped almost doing instruments and patrons and you just like spamed that because you can do the same action multiple times around and I think that it's fun like there's different paths to go and different strategies to to explore so who do you think this game is for and what do you think is to wait on it I think this is a heavy game for me I think it is and uh this is for people who like work replacement games yes if you hate that you might not like it yes and it also is a game you touched on this already for people who like interaction in this game if you are um not a fan of interaction I don't think you will like this game very much oh it's not like it's not super heavy interaction it's not like for example wild cars I nobody can to be like ha and there's not take that it's like the order the thing it's in that where it's not multiplayer solitare but it's in that where other people do is important but it's not going to most of the time it's not going to be like oh I lost because you chose to do that I haven't been in a position where uh I haven't put myself in a position where if somebody did a thing I would lose yeah like it's okay I'm going to be it's going to be not best for me if somebody do that but it's not going to destroy my whole plan so it's not like super duper

but it is a nicely interactive game for me sorry no it's fine I'm just going to say that for me it's on the lower end of a heavy game it's not like a super brain burning super heavy game but it is more than a medium game yeah it is tight in the the money and the resources that you have but I think the tightness really comes from trying to make these combos work with fulfilling your Patron's needs and seeing if the right cars come up you have to be okay with that kind of inter interaction and that kind of Randomness in my opinion and I think also I wouldn't play this game at two now that I know how good it is at tree and I also would say that this is a longer game experience MH those were kind of your final thoughts oh yeah it was yes before I say my final thoughts I'm going to say that if you're watching this and you've seen it all the way to the end thank you it means a lot and also you can help us out in a very big Way by giving us a victory points and we get victory points when you click that subscribe button down there you can also click the Bell to get notifications every time we post a new video yes do you want to add more things to your final thoughts oh I think actually did you like the game yeah I absolutely did like the game I think this is a fantastic game I think that this basically for all of these crowdfunding games it's hard because I can't tell you that you should back the game but if you enjoy the kind of games we do if you like me your games if you like I will say that one of the reasons I like it more with more people is that even though there's different parts to

go for the strategy you are doing the same kind of things you are building the instruments you are getting the patrons you're doing some repair you can focus heavy on repair you can focus heavy on perform but you're not going to be a gamer oh not going to do instruments this time or I'm not going to do patrons this time because you are going to do at least a little bit of of these because there are only four main things that you will be doing in the game so what elevates it from that fun puzzle to a great game is the interaction between players that you will get when you play three or four or if you play solo of course with otoma or if you want to play with aoma with two people you can do that as well to simulate that third player which I think if I were to play it with two again I would try that out add that uh so for me it's a really really good game I have enjoyed my place of it a lot uh I would have liked to played it more but we we we we don't have time for always playing this games 16 billion times and yeah I don't think I have more to say we not we don't rate prototypes that's just what how we ended up not doing things but hopefully the things we said with our mouths made it clear if this is going to be a game for you or not if you have any questions please let us know in the comments and that's going to be the end yes thank you so much for watching I'm johanes and you've been watching board gaming ramblings and byebye

Progress saved