Red Rising Review: Quite Enjoyable, My Goodman - By Board Of It
Transcript
hi everyone tally and farrell here from budavir and welcome to our review of red rising the newest game from publisher stone meyer games this game will transport you to the world of red rising a popular dystopian book series where society is built on a cast system of colors red rising the game is a hand management and combo builder in this game you'll be cycling through cards in an attempt to create the perfect symbiotic hand and outscore your opponents for 1-6 players and usually playing in under an hour red rising has provided us with a short snappy challenge that we've thoroughly enjoyed it's important to note that we were sent this collector's edition review copy by stone meyer games you begin the game with a randomized house tile and five cards the turn structure is pretty simple because you can only do two things you can either lead or you can scout and most of the time you will be leading to lead you'll take a card from your hand and you'll put it on a location on the board then you trigger any when played ability of those cards and deal with those after that's done you will take a card from another location than the one you placed your card on so in this case i'll take a card from mars and then every location has a bonus
associated with it and you'll get that bonus mars will give me helium alternatively if i didn't want to take a card from another location i could draw one randomly from the top of the deck and instead of getting a pre-determined reward i roll the dice and get what it gives me if i wanted to scout this is something you only do when you're happy with your hand and the combos you've made and you just want to get specific resources or bonuses so to do a scout you'll just take the top card of the deck put it on any of the four locations and gain the reward associated with where you put it like so so why would you do either of these well each card has a core value which is at the top and at the bottom there are conditions which if you fulfill them are going to score you more points for example if orion is with her ship the pax that will score you more points others might have you scoring more based on what's on the board or where you are on various tracks you'll be cycling through cars to create a super hand to have your cards interlinking and scoring hundreds of points that's not all though each location has a bonus associated with it jupiter will let you move up the fleet track and you'll gain the printed vp mars will get you helium and each one of these is worth 3vp luna lets you take the sovereign token and then you can activate your house's ability and the institute will let you place
influence cubes on the institute where you'll score for how many cubes you have there compared to the other players the game will end when three conditions are met by any combination of players or one player has met two of the conditions these conditions being have seven or more helium be at seven or higher on the fleet track and have seven or more influence with the institute when the game is over you will complete the round and you will score up all scoring is done at the end and the player with the most points wins before we played red rising everything we'd read or seen had led us to have low expectations which then meant it was a very pleasant surprise when we discovered how much we're enjoying our time with the game we actually played it back to back three times in a row the first time we played which is not a common occurrence for any game in our house this was facilitated by red rising having the perfect length of play if you're playing at lower play accounts the feel of the game reminds us of playing classic card games with the family it's chilled out relaxing easy to pick up but with the semblance of strategy to the gameplay you feel really engaged with your own personal hand of cards and how best to optimize them with the various location bonuses adding a further level of game play to consider now it is a rather light game much lighter than most other stone mire games pretty easy to teach you can have someone up and playing in under five minutes because the turn structure is just so simple place a card take a card get reward
simples it's also really intuitive because you can just look at your cards and they will tell you what they need so this provides guidance to less experienced players making this a great experience for all types of gamers and in keeping with it being a lighter game this is a game you want to play because you enjoy playing it not to show off your strategic intelligence or have a battle of the wits because this game is entirely card based the core of the game is then randomness and what worsens this is that the game is asking you to pair specific cards together from a unique deck and in any given game you won't see much of that deck which then means you're only seeing a very small percentage of the 112 unique cards in this game we don't mean there's no strategy here because you can make some quite smart plays and combos plus you certainly need to be tactical and ruthless to win what we mean is that certain cards require very specific things and whether those cars appear in your games is completely out of your control you could start the game with a perfect hand of cards where they all boost each other or a hand which provides negative points by being together this is further exacerbated by all colors not being spread evenly throughout the deck in part because there are 14 colors but in the books some colours are hardly discussed at all so in keeping with the ip certain colours are over represented in the deck you can easily go an entire game without seeing a specific colour which then negates many of the bonus
scoring and when played aspects of cards the game does make an attempt to negate this by having orange cards act as any other main character and grey cards act as an additional colour to grey but the same issue remains in obtaining them this issue aside thankfully red rising is full of engaging gameplay you see all the cards have a when played ability and you'll need to take advantage of these to come out ahead in the game but of course playing it means that you no longer have that card and this is where red rising constantly presents you with interesting decisions and dilemmas first off do you play a card for its win played ability knowing that you might not see it again and at worst an opponent could use it against you in the future or do you keep it for the points and the combos it provides and then you know where do you play it can you play it anywhere that will impede an opponent where should you take the card you get from is it better to take a card that is best for you but getting a resource that you maybe don't care so much about or is it better to get the resource you need at that moment or move up the track or whatever but get a car that doesn't really do anything for your engine it can be quite tactical with where you play which cars in an attempt to interrupt other players and line up future players for yourself we've found ourselves getting really into this puzzle red rising has you spending all your time in between turns assessing the state of the board what's your next move figuring out which cards you should keep or play one of the reasons it's so engaging is
because you're essentially always gambling on certain cards coming out or what your opponents might do the relief you feel when you play a card that you would very much like to get back and it remains untouched on the board when your next turn rolls around is palpable coming to the negatives these house tiles that everyone is randomly given at the beginning of the game can feel quite unbalanced you see some of them are linked with gaining vp so they'll let you move up the fleet track or gain helium or gain influence with the institute so in return for getting the sovereign token you're gaining cold hard vp and you can visually see that whereas other houses like you do things like place a card on the board discard a card from the board it's just like and the thing is i'm sure there's a tactical advantage to this but i can also tell you that any player would much rather get one of the houses that just gives them cold hard vp because that is the point of the game and it's never a great thing when you're playing a game you shuffle these out at the start and you hear players groaning when they see what they've got and another quibble which is maybe a personal one these houses are a small part of the game and they've assigned the player colors of components to these houses which then means that players cannot choose the color they want to play as and i just think let people be the color that they want to be it makes them happy and it's just like a nice thing that you enjoy when you play a game to have your personal color and it's also a bit annoying
in a game where you can play multiple times in one session and it just means that you're having to swap components around get them out of the box put them in swap with other players and it's just a little more tedious than it needed to be otherwise some sort of mechanic that would allow players to add new cars to the board more often could help players create combos more easily perhaps it could be that if no new cards have been added to the board at the end of the round the sovereign could draw one from the deck and decide where to place it because the game can get a little bit slow and stagnant if nobody is drawing from the deck and risking the role of the dice also in keeping with the negatives but moving on to the components we were sent in the collector's edition which is different to the retail version the card rails in the collector's edition are kind of a bit rubbish as they are neither long enough nor deep enough so either you can't see all of your cards or they just keep falling over and echoing almost everyone else the colors of the player tokens in the collector's edition are incredibly similar and really difficult to tell apart sometimes and that's this has led to gameplay issues in our games that said whilst you shouldn't get the collector's edition over the retail version because the price difference simply isn't worth it we do really love the metal cubes and metal ships they're a joy to hold and feel incredibly weighty the gold cards in this edition also have gold foil and look beautiful we're big fans of the graphic design and art direction and find this a really pleasing game to look at we do much prefer what's here when compared with the retail version
i.e plastic cubes and ships which we hated in pendulum and hate here go wood or go home moving on to the play account this unfortunately isn't a game that we've had the chance to play at the higher play accounts so five or six people and we also just aren't sure that we'd want to see it's such a light quick game that it thrives on having a sub one hour playtime it also has fast and simple turns which just generally lends itself quite well to playing with less people if you play with more people then you're going to have more down time and the game's going to be longer and we're not sure this is a game would enjoy playing as much if it took 90 minutes to play it particularly because as we said before the cards are random and what comes up is random and the combos you can make is a little bit chance so if you're just having one of those bad games it's not something you want to drag on for 90 minutes we're just not sure that having more players adds anything to the gameplay experience we were surprised by how little the game changed at 3 or 4 compared with playing at 2.
that said props to stonemeyer for always striving to allow people to include as many friends as possible it's better to have it and not use it than not have it at all finally the theme due to our high level of journalistic integrity i decided to read the red rising series so we could give the best review possible and now i have jamie stegmeier to thank for having had no spare time for two weeks because every second i've had spare i've been reading the red rising series being on book four now i have to be honest and say that the theme is really just set dressing if you've read the books you'll get a kick out of it if you haven't read the books i'll tell you it won't really matter and you'll still have fun what they have done with the characters and their when played powers and what cards they want to be with and why the characters they want to be with it's all in keeping with the novels and interesting and they've done it quite well but it just never really evokes the feel of red rising a very dramatic brutal tense strategic series really you just don't get any of that it's quite abstract in some ways here and that's very much not what red rising is but don't worry because this also isn't the type of game where someone who's read the books will have any kind of advantage over someone that hasn't read the books you might know what you're looking for but i don't think it's going to matter because the cards you get dealt at the start of the game almost matter more than what you know
about the game so in summary red rising is a wonderful hand management game it's not for everyone and it's not without its issues but it is a game that we've really enjoyed every play of if you're looking for a lighter card game with some bells and whistles that's accessible for most and plays in under an hour then look no further just be aware that in a game with so much randomness with a unique deck of cards where you have to pair certain cards together can cause frustration also whilst we do really like the collector's edition it's not without its issues and it's not worth the difference in price for another recommendation the game that red rising took its inspiration from fantasy realms is supposed to be quite good if you enjoyed this video we'd really appreciate it if you could give it a thumbs up subscribe to our channel if you're not already for regular board game reviews other content always with a little hint of these two doggos and feel free to let us know in the comments if you have any questions about it see you next time