Thorgal Review: By Tjahzi's Tears and Pajitnov's Polyominos!
Transcript
Hey everybody, welcome back to the Dice Tower. My name is Z Garcia
and I'm Camila.
Today we're taking a look at Thorgal the board game. This is based on a graphic novel from many years ago from what I understand which is very popular around the world. I did not know of it here in in the US and I don't think it's as well known here in this part of the world. Okay. Uh, but the game is going to follow some of the adventures of Thorgo and the other characters in the uh in the graphic novels in the comics as you go around and try to achieve objectives. You are trying to manage your resources, do some action selection, ultimately try to win as a group or fail, lose. Let me go ahead and show you how it works. There's a lot of moving parts in this, so this is not going to be comprehensive in any way. I'm just showing you a little bit of what's going on. We'll come on back after that. We'll tell you what we think of it. The game comes with this Atlas of Adventure which is going to have multiple scenarios in it. So, you'll need to decide which scenario you'd like to play at the beginning of the game. Uh they are going to share a few different pieces of information, mainly areas that the players will be able to inhabit with their pieces, locations they can interact with, and then a pin with resources you might be able to gather beneath that, and a number in there that generally ties to what round in the game you are able to go into that region. In this case, we cannot inhabit this region until the second round of the game. And so, you'll be selecting one. They recommend you start with this first one here, which is a Torans's temple. And you see also a a
board here that goes on the side that ties to that scenario. You're going to track rounds across the bottom. It tells you how you win and how you lose, a few pieces of information, and then over here if any special rules are in play. Plus, above this, you'll put a couple of decks of events that you will draw from when playing this scenario. You see it is the green deck listed right there and the purple deck right here. Uh so we're going to go ahead and set this up. The book of tales is also going to explain any further setup you have to do as listed right here. The decks you need and then the initial action row where you take actions in the game. Besides that, every time you interact with a location and it tells you to read an entry, such as here, it tells you to read entry six and then gain that token, you'll go into the book here and you will read entry six listed right there.
It'll tell you something that happens in the game. I'm not going to be showing you too much more of that to avoid spoilers. Let's go ahead and set this up. In the game, the players will alternate between an action phase and an event phase, and they will continue doing this until they win or lose together. During the action phase, you'll be taking one of these actions, and that happens four times, no matter the amount of players, and then we do the event phase where you draw one of these two events based on whether you qualify for that or that. And then you deal with that thing. So, I'm going to be explaining move, journey, collect, assign, sacrifice. I'll be skipping because it's a little more rare. combat and crafting that happens with these cards down here. Okay. And so you have these four tokens that you are going to be assigning to one of these cards, triggering that ability at a variable strength based on usually where these other chips are. And so starting from the start player, you will take one of these and you will place it on one of the cards, flip it over to that side, activate that ability. uh from one round to the next, these will be placed in various locations. Then at the beginning of the next round, we'll flip all these over again, leave them where they are, and you will simply when you choose to take an action, take it from somewhere, flip it, and move it to that action. If I want to do that, I'll do this one. The next player will move one of the three that hasn't been moved yet, and so on.
Now, let me explain these starting from uh the beginning, and I'll work my way over. Okay, the first one here is your journey ability. This is going to allow you to take a polyomino, place it on the journey cards that are going to be forming that way and gain resources, various bonuses. This card here says you are going to gain plus one food matching an icon that you cover if there are extra of these chips that way of this card, which is impossible right now because it's the one on the far left. A lot of things in this game are going to be happening with these polyominos. And so you would take one of these matching where your exploration track is. In this case, I'm still here at the very bottom of my exploration track. So I only get one of these two polyominos, but as I level this up, I'll have access to better shapes, larger shapes generally.
And so I would take one of these. I'm going to put it somewhere on the board. I'm going to gain a bonus if I cover up anything. I'll also have to deal with a penalty if I cover any red spaces or yellow spaces as listed at the bottom of the card. So, this is what you are doing. This is going to continue as you cross this threshold with a later placement such as placing this right here. Then you reveal a new card and that goes next to it. And this continues with you exploring. The new pieces, by the way, must always go into the active column, the one farthest to the right or past it. And so this would be fine for a next placement and this would be fine for an upcoming placement and so on. Always on the last column or after never on a previous column. So that is uh the journey action. Here we've got collect where you're going to take a collect token and you're going to put it on any of the collect symbols and take goodies that can go anywhere. In fact, previous locations are okay. If you place it on one of these symbols, that means you collect the resources of where you are.
It's this pin right here. So, if I'm standing in this region there and I cover up that location, then I am getting one scroll. You make different things. Uh the stone, that purple flame there, the scrolls, wood is one of the things you can collect as seen there. So, various things you can gather in the game. This one over here is going to let you take one of these resources at the top. It's a card with a special ability. You keep it until you spend it. This one over here lets you assign resources to where you are. And you'll notice these locations here can have goods assigned to them. Sometimes the locations have uh enemies and you cannot assign to a location if there are enemies there. You cannot interact with that location. Uh so that is what that's uh going to let you do. This one over here lets you move crossing one of these green dashed borders to another one. And again, you cannot go into an area until the round matches or exceeds the number in that area. And then lastly, you have combat over here where you are going to fight uh one of the enemies in your region. You'll pick if there are multiples and they have levels, levels one, two, you see a level three there and there's even level fours. You'll take a card from that deck. So, for example, if I want to fight this enemy, I would draw this card. I'm going to roll dice equal to my combat, which is over here. Right now, pointing at one, meaning I roll two green dice. And then
I am trying to using these shapes cover all of the hearts. If I manage to do that, I win. If I don't, I get hurt a little bit. And this enemy persists. And that is how that's going to work. Now, various things in the game will let you level up this and let you level up that track there. Once the players have placed all four of the action tokens, then we go to the event phase. We check and read here. If there are at least three of these symbols combined, uncovered on the journey path, we're going to draw one of these. If that's not the case, we draw one of these. And this is going to have some action that's going to happen. Place a token below an action. uh when placing a token below an action rather, you have to discard one stone for each used token to its left. And then down here, it tells you something that happens during the next event phase, mainly resolving one of these bad things listed on the card.
Okay, so that's how that's going to happen. And then we go right back to the top where we ready all of these and we do it again. And I'll point out once more, this symbol here means when you choose to activate that card. So if my first activation is placing this here, this says I am going to uh gain one wound to roll dice equal to the number of tokens that way. In this case, two. So I can do that twice. Speaking of taking wounds, uh like I said, many things in this game are done with polyominos, traveling, attacking, but also taking wounds. Whenever you take wounds in this game, you have to place polyominos into this grid right here. And if you ever cannot place one, which has to go adjacent to a previously placed one, by the way, then you perish and the game is lost. That's how the whole thing generally works. I'm glossing over quite a bit of it. But if you achieve one of your objectives, uh, leading to an uprising or destroying the temple in this case, then you win. If you run out of time because the rounds have ended or somebody perishes, then you lose. So, I know both you and I have been fans of the the bigger games from Portal in the past. I'm thinking specifically of Robinson Cruso.
Yeah, that's one of my favorite games. Yeah.
Yeah. And I like it. I've cooled on it, but I know you like it quite a bit still. Uh and I think in some ways this reminded me of that. Yeah, it definitely had the similar feels where you have goals and objectives and you're planning out where do you go to try to create what, sequencing your turns and um um putting your eggs in a basket kind of thing is what it feels like. All right, we're going to try this strategy this time.
And there's a lot of puzzly moments in the games in both of them. You know, this idea of
there's a lot of moving parts, there's a lot of spinning plates, you're hoping things come to fruition. Uh to me they're not from the same designers even. I believe Ignasi Trevichek who runs Portal Games is a developer on this game. He designed Robinson Crusoe. But they do feel in some ways like they have similar sensibilities.
I think so. And I think um if I had to kind of put this game think of two ones that it feels like or the feelings it evokes when you're playing, it'd be Robinson Crusoe and Legends of Andor. um because they're both going to be cooperative games where you feel like you have this story element to it and you're you're going out and making your story and your adventure, but that's not actually how you're playing. You're playing a puzzle and you're trying it's an efficiency puzzle of making choices, sticking with those choices and seeing them to the end and hopefully completing an objective.
And I think that's hitting the nail on the head right there that if you're someone who is intrigued by this game, um it is important, I think, for your own enjoyment to know what you're getting into. Basically, this is not They even say it at the beginning of the rule, but they're like, "This is not choose your own adventure game. Don't go don't don't come in here thinking this is a choose your own adventure game." This is a puzzle game. I think it's a puzzle game first and foremost. There's some story you'll be reading from the book of tales there, and that's neat. They give you little blurbs as to what's happening, but it is that is supplementary material to what you are really doing in the game, which is very much being careful and meticulous with the action selection you are doing and being like, I mean, you're up to here in water at all given times, thinking constantly, I'm supposed to do this in eight, nine rounds. How am I supposed to do this in nine rounds? this is impossible. Oh yeah, you might might be able to barely scrape out and and get it done, but you can't just sort of go, "Well, I wonder what's down there. I'm going to go look." Unless that's furthering your story and your plan, I should say. It's you're probably going to lose. Like those mistakes are very, very much punished in this game.
I think so. And I think that's one thing that uh this game shines at is knowing that it is a very punishing game, which means you have to figure out what you want to do, figure out how you're going to do it, and kind of stick with that plan, you know? So, it's not what I would call a very tactical experience. It does feel more more strategic where all right, let's talk about the story. What's our plan? Maybe something will happen and a story will unlock and you'll shift a little bit, but you don't really work on two or three things to see which one works,
right? you know, you do have to
pick your pick your path forward.
Yeah. Now, mechanically, let's uh pivot and talk about that a little bit. I It's interesting because I think most designers uh would, you know, when asked say you don't want to put too many original ideas in a single game because then it becomes weird. It becomes obtuse.
You want one original idea, something that's like your hook and that's wrapped in familiar things so that there's something that's like a shining beacon and the rest is like comfortable. This doesn't feel like that to me. There's a lot of weird ideas in this one box. There is the idea that this action selection system is pretty original and it's it's a little strange. Um,
the action selection locations will change throughout the game. So, you'll have some that will swap other ones in and rearrange the line and stuff.
The positioning of the tokens and you having to pick one and move it to a new place, flip it, you know, and where they are in relation to each other. And then on top of that, the polyomino heart of this game in which you're using these shapes to take wounds, to deal damage, to progress
on the journey.
On the journey. Um, it's so it's just very str. You got to like polyomino games if you want to like this game. And I don't think that's obvious from the outset. I I agree that I do think that there's a big polyomino uh part of this game because it is used in so many different things. But I think with that though there are so many polyomino games that were already comfortable with that. So it doesn't feel to me as
unique. It's a unique implementation of something we're comfortable with. Um but it's not like the action selection. I feel like that's very unique. That is kind of the standout to me that puts this game in a different category than almost anything else.
Yeah. Yeah. And I think it's just again my part of it is also for me in my head I don't know if I can draw a relationship between Thoral this pseudo Viking character and his stories and his you know adventures and these these shapes these polyomino shapes it's a leap thematically it's a leap and and my point being you better like puzzle games you better not be too attached to this theme. Um, speaking of the theme, did you find not knowing this theme, did that detract from the experience for you?
I think it detracted a little bit and that's probably my biggest negative on the game is the the theme, but I think that I don't know if that's a me issue because I don't know the theme, you know, but or is it a disconnect with the theme? I don't know. And I don't know the answer to that because sometimes following the stories, it's like, wait, who is the good guy again? Okay, there's I mean in the in the the one of the scenarios there's a ship that comes down and multiple kind of factions are are vying interest in this and so it's like okay
who's the good one is it the sister or the queen that's good I don't remember what's this are they both bad who is it we're partnering with I'm not really understanding this and so I found it a little bit hard to follow which then as we're trying to deduce from the board where to go in order to complete an objective I found that to be a little difficult I had to reread the passages and try to bring that out now is that because it's disconnected from the theme or because I don't know the theme. I don't have an answer to that. Um, so for me personally, that was a little bit did bring it down a little bit. On the flip side of that though, it did make me want to find out about the theme. I want to know the answer to that. You know, I've uh gotten a copy of the comics and I look forward to reading them to kind of pursue this. So, in that way, it was a huge benefit because hopefully it's helping me discover something new, you know, and intriguing me about this this comic series. So I I it's yes, it detracted, but that might just be a me and my experience.
Well, it's also I mean it inspired you to go seek out the the source material. That's a win right there. I think you know that means it's doing a good enough job
that you're intrigued by the things that are happening.
Yes. Yeah.
And I think this game does manage to give you a lot of moments of intrigue. It does intrigue you. You know what's going on? Why are we going here? Oh no, a bad guy showed up there. Now I got to fight this guy. Oh, wait a second. they're dispersing because an an event you trigger that that kind of stuff is is good. Um, my biggest negative is that I do have a hard time sort of finding based on any, you know, whatever scenario I'm playing, I I usually have a hard time sort of knowing where to hang my hat as far as like what does that mean? They're explaining to me this person is upset with Thoral because of the thing you did when you showed up on my shores. And I'm like, okay, that's a great little piece of writing. I like that a lot. What does that mean? Do I go there or do I not go there? Is that going to upset him or alleviate our relationship? I don't like I I have a hard time therefore um reconciling the puzzle, the the game play, the mechanisms to the blurbs they are writing.
Mhm.
Sometimes I have a hard time going, "Oh, oh, this lines up with this. Got it. Okay, I see. So, I shouldn't go there if I don't want to upset this guy. I have a hard time making that connection. Those those two things, you know, I have a hard time connecting. Um, but mechanically, the the moment to moment I do find to be engaging. And this game moves along at a nice clip and it is I think lighter than you would think.
Yes.
It just feels heavier because of that thing I was talking about. It's a very original game. I don't know that I would say it it feels heavier
like to understand it. Sorry. To like break in.
Yeah. I think what was intimidating to me from this game at first is seeing it set up actually at convention stuff and stuff like that. It looks a lot more complicated than it is, you know. When I we finally got our hands on a copy here, I read the rule book and I had a oh that's it. Yeah. You know, and then there are a little lot a lot of kind of little minutia almost, I think, that you have to go and and figure out, you know, do if there's a stack of baddies, do you fight all at one time and line them up or do you do just do one if there's multiple in a stack? Do you pick the one or just do the top? Little questions like that that I think uh would benefit from an FAQ or something like that. But I just don't necessarily think that that's increasing the weight. I still think this is a, you know, at most a medium game.
Right. Right. It's It's much simpler than I think based on looking at it set up on a table.
Yeah. And there is, by the way, a small FAQ here, but you're talking about better rules ultimately.
Um, all right. So, I'm going to come down on this one at a seven out of 10. I like it. Um, I do find myself a little frustrated sometimes when I'm playing it to understand why I'm doing a thing I'm doing. And also that time pressure of how are we on the fifth round already? I feel like I've done nothing in this game. And then it still might win, mind you. It just has that feeling of [screaming and groaning] I'm running out of time. Same exact feeling I used to get, you know, when I would play uh Robinson Cruso sometimes. That feeling of I'm this. No, this is impossible. Who made this? This is it's well put together. It's welldesigned. I just have a hard time connect finding connective tissue between thematically why I'm doing something and mechanically how I'm doing that thing. Um but then I you know I play the thing and enjoy the moment to moment even if I find some frustration when I look at the overall arc of my experience with the game. So a lot of complex feelings with this one because it is a game that does a lot of things for me. Seven out of 10. I enjoy it. I want to keep exploring it and that's a sign of a good game. a game that has its hooks in me and I can't distance myself from it. I want to keep coming back. I want to try another. I want to have a go at that that scenario.
Now, let's try that again. Couldn't quite do it, but maybe we can this time. Those things uh are a sign of an engaging game.
Yeah, I I actually have a hard time picking a scenario to play when we pull this game out because I'm like, "Oh, that one sounds interesting. Oh, I like that. Oh, I want to try that again." Um to to the credit of the game, I like this quite a bit more. I'm coming in at a eight and a half, 8.5 on this. And I think that that definitely has room to improve as I learn the theme. And I'm if I hope to be able to make those connections. I'm just not there um even after multiple
multiple plays of this. The game doesn't teach you the theme. You know, I feel like I I think that you're going to need some background there um in order to to get that, you know, nine nine and a half um you know, that I think that this game could potentially be for me. But eight and a half. Absolutely very much enjoy this puzzle. Uh I'm really enjoying the world. I love the polyomino effect. I love how simple it is that there's these polyominos and you're leveling up your character in different ways. You know that as you journey you're going to get bigger polyominos. The wounds you take are different size of polyominos that you're trying to fit into your own little grid on your your character board. I find that very engaging and intriguing. just as you're trying to map it out, you're like, "Okay, well, that did take the wind out of me, but how can I place this together?" Um, I just I love all the little puzzles of this. I love the discovery as the the as you go and you further the story and stuff like that. I just find this very intriguing.
I love what you're describing of the how are we all how are we already on round five? I love that tension. It does very much remind me of, like I said, Legends of Andor, very much reminds me of Robinson Crusoe. It has that tension. It has that there's no way that this is possible. even Spirit Island in that, you know, in the middle of a game where you're like, "There's no way possible." And then you see that little shred of light and you're like, "Oh, wait. We could do this if we just focus our effort on this one thing, right?"
I will say I think that this is a two-player only game, period. Um, any more than that, you always have four actions that you're going to be taking like you saw in the overview there. So, if you have more or less, those actions are just distributed differently, right? And I think in a four-player game to only have one turn each round is very limp feeling, you know. So I think in a two-player game where you get two actions each round really leads to some strategic planning back and forth that I just find I'm extremely not even just engaged like and engrossed in when I'm playing this game. Very much like it. An 8.5 for me.
Well, there you go folks. That is high praise indeed for Thoral the board game. That is a seal of excellence from us here at the Dice Tower. Thank you everybody for tuning in and checking this out with us. My name is Ze Garcia
and I'm Camila and
we'll see you on the next one. Go explore.
Hey, uh thanks for watching another video here on the Dice Tower. Uh we really appreciate you stopping by and checking our things out. Thanks so much for joining us today. And hey, if you really like what we're doing here at the Dice Tower, then there are different ways to support the Dice Tower. One of those ways is through Patreon. We have links in the description to this video, and we have links to lots of other things we do down there. So, definitely check it out. But either way, we're glad you watched us. Tell your friends about the Dice Tower. Until next time though, I'm Tom Vassel, and I hope you enjoyed this video.