Arcs: Leder's Bold Move into 4X Space Strategy
Transcript
arcs is not the kind of game I would normally play I'm not a huge fan of 4X style games and in general I'll avoid games if they have a lot of player-to-player combat however in this case a friend invited me to play so in this video I'll share with you my initial impression I'm not going to talk about how to play in this video but I can summarize it for you uh though the game is from later games unlike other popular hits from the company this one is not asymmetrical that was a surprise for me what they've done though is pretty uh Innovative they've taken a Forex Style game and Forex is short for explore expand exploit and exterminate and they've applied a trick taking inspired card play there are a few elements of this that I really really like like other trick-taking games in arcs there's a lot of exciting Str strategy in deciding which card to choose in order to lead the hand so in the game the cards have a value and a suit the suit is associated with the action and the value is associated with a number of Pips the thing is the higher the value of the card the fewer the Pips and Pips describe the strength of the action so if you want to do a lot with your turn you play a low card that has a lot of Pips but if you want to make it difficult for other people to to surpass
you you play a high card and you have fewer Pips now that idea has nothing to do with Forex style gameplay but it is a very interesting mechanic to play and I personally love it uh the thing about being surpassed by your opponents is that at the end of the hand the player who plays the highest valued card in the lead suit takes an initiative now initiative would be equivalent to winning a trick and that means you get to lead the next team but it also puts you in a position to declare an ambition that's another Innovative thing about this game uh at the end of every round meaning when everyone's played all of their cards different scoring criteria are going to take effect but the scoring criteria that are activated are the ones that the players chose and only three criteria are going to be chosen every round so it isn't enough that you dominate the Galaxy or you take lots of captives or you have an inventory of all kinds of symbols it doesn't matter unless you also declare that ambition so you have to take initiative at some point in order to make that happen or you have to hope that other players will will uh choose it for you but why why would somebody choose it for you if you were going to benefit more than they would right so stealing initiative meaning surpassing the lead card really matters in this game however if you cannot uh follow suit there's there's another way to steal initiative which is by playing
two cards playing two cards effectively sacrifices an action later in the game because you will have fewer cards than everybody else but it's critical for taking control of how the round is going to get scored and that is again fantastic decision making it's I thought it was very engaging one decision that the designers had to make that I think makes a lot of sense and is less conventional for trick- taking is that following suit is optional so that means you can really be strategic about their timing of when you play your best card perhaps no one's going to force it or Draw it out of you and it also lets you pick an action other than what the the lead LED with which kind of gives you more flexibility although when you play off suit you only get one pip value so it is a little bit uh less than ideal but I think it's absolutely necessary for gameplay now those are the elements of the game that I really enjoy that come directly over from this kind of trick-taking type mechanic there is one more piece of the game that I really enjoyed and that is the court cards so the court cards are cards that players will influence with an action and then can later claim with another action and they have all types of powers they can let you attack other players they can let you steal from players they can give you um immunity against an outrage which is a bad thing that happens in the game um and they can really really mix up how the game goes uh to a degree I kind of
thought that the court cards added a degree of chaos that is typically not what I like about a good Euro game but if I'm playing a game that is it's Forex and it's combat and it's all Madness anyway then I thought that the court cards add a great deal of interaction which really complimented this game well so those that's what I really like about this game in short what I find is brilliant about about it is the idea of applying a trick- ticking mechanic to a 4X Style game there are some things that I did not like about it however and I'm going to talk about that next number one I I just don't like games that have a lot of battling and I don't like games that have dice resolution however this one comes with a silver lining because I will say that whereas in other games that have dice rolling It's usually the attacker who rolls some dice and then the defender rolls some dice in this game the dice rolling is handled by the player who does the attacking the faces of the dice that do the most damage also include the best the the greatest degree of response from defense so you're not going to have a situation where you just do devastating damage to the defense and then they don't do anything at all they don't hurt you because they roll so bad there's balance on the dice faces that's cool the other thing that's really cool is that there are three colors of dice and players can choose what kind of aggression they want to go for and what kinds of risk they want to take so the
more aggressive they are the the the higher the risk is that something might happen to hurt them back such an elegant way to handle dice uh battle resolution I I don't I don't really like attacking players I don't like teaming up with players however I also felt myself playing the game and thinking you know what this reminds me of it reminds me of how I actually like Cosmic Encounter which is an old game and you might not know it but if you haven't it's just a crazy like like everyone's just attacking everyone there's tons of interaction and you know what I like that I like just having fun and sort of just enjoying the interaction the level of interaction I'm talk I'm telling you what I don't like it sounds like I like it anyway like in general I I Was Won over by this game but nevertheless that is I'm on the fence about it I don't like dice I like how it's done here uh things that I really don't like though but do I do I really not like it you're going to feel limitation in this game uh because it's a card card driven game play you could be dealt a hand of cards and none of the cards are helpful for what you want to accomplish but that's also the kind of situation a where you need to steal initiative by playing two cards and you need to kind of figure out how you can take a hand
that is dominant in one suit and play it towards your advantage again leaning on the trick-taking gameplay mechanic that's that's how it works out in trick taking games and that's what works in this game too nevertheless I think you're not going to play this game and not complain about your hand from time to time it's a hand of six cards so you're not going to have what you want um all the time and then another thing that was just a kind of weird for me like I don't know why this was even necessary may I don't know I guess I have to think about it maybe it just seems like it's not necessary and they should have just allowed you to have more flexibility but the thing is when you declare an ambition Ambitions once again that's how you want things to be scored at the end of the round you can only declare the ambition matching the icon on your played card so let's suppose you want captives to be scored you need to have a card with a captive icon on it now you could have a ton of captives but if you don't have any cards with a captive icon then you can't declare the captive ambition you have to hopefully somebody else will maybe because they want their captives back they go back after captives get scored or in some cases you might have have a seven the SE the card the highest card the seven is a wild for ambition so if you play your seven you can declare captiv if you want
to I think that it is inevitable you will play this game and there will be a time when you will want to declare an ambition and you're just not going to be able to do it because you don't have the icon on your cards uh that happened to me twice in the game that I played so I guess in general I don't I don't really know if I if I would say don't like the game uh or I don't like these things but they tighten your choices it's a little bit tighter than a game play where you can kind of just do whatever you want and that is why the game leans so much heavier towards the mechanic if you enjoy this mechanic and if you if you like the problem space of this type of mechanic you're going to really like the game if you want to play a 4X game you will hate this because it doesn't play like a 4X game it plays a trick taking game which I love and other people should hate uh I love it but then you have to attack people and I don't like attacking people so what am I saying in general for me because I don't like 4X games I don't think I will ever own this game I don't want to buy this game I don't want to lead this game when my friend invites me to play this game I will enthusiastically join in because I want to do the campaign and because I really like the mechanic because I like games that have great mechanics and I like games that have bold choices so yeah yes I liked ARS quite a bit it is not a game for my channel but it doesn't change the fact that it has won me over that is my opinion on ARS thank you for
watching this video