Agra Review - JonGetsGames
Transcript
welcome to John gets games today I'll be reviewing Agra this game was designed by Mike Keller and it is set in India in the year 1570 to where the whole country is getting ready for the 30th birthday party of Akbar the Great who was the current ruler now this means that dignitaries and notables from all around the country are heading to the great city of Agra and all of the players around the table are taking on the role of small landowners who are trying to cut down some would grow tumeric and cotton in order to create two nice goods to give as birthday presents to the ruler as well as all of the notables coming down the river first I'll explain how the game works and then I'll jump into my review out here in the middle of the table I have the game fully set up for three players and as you can see there is such a large board it doesn't quite fit on the screen we also have this slanted Imperial board right here and lastly each player is going to have their own little tableau just like this when we come down here and take a closer look at the player board we can notice some rather important sections to it the first is this area right here which shows us the amount of the sandstone cotton tumeric and wood that we can gather when we try to do those actions over here we have some favored action options down here we have a meditation track and lastly this is a little guide to show you how any turn works so the first thing that's going to happen is a meditation phase and I'm going to come back to that in just a little bit and skip ahead right now here to the main action phase in order to do this what you're gonna do is take one of your numerous workers over here and you're going to place them out onto the main board and activate the spot at the beginning of the game there are
essentially eight different locations we can put this worker down onto there are the four special actions along the top with the architect sailor trader and botanist and then over here on the left hand side we have the four basic resources that are in the game and we already saw these over on our player board with the sandstone wood tumeric and cotton so if we want to for instance go over here and make some wood then the first thing we'd have to do is look back at our player board in a particular we need to focus on the little piece of forest on our land area so now we do is we look at these little gathering farmer workers and we're going to count the number of empty spaces that are between those workers and the resource that we are trying to generate out on the board and then we'll take that number in this case one or two of these little cylinders here which can be used to show it several different things in this case both of these are now gonna become wood and we go ahead and put them right over here so that in the future we know that these are wood and this also means that if instead of going to the forest area we had gone up to the sandstone quarry we would then put these up here and now they would stand for sand instead of wood next up I'm gonna try to briefly go over the four main characters along the top of the board but keep in mind I'm not gonna make this an exhaustive how to play video I'm just gonna show you the general vibe of what they do so let's go ahead and start up here with the architect now up here you can either bump up your influence marker over here on one of these tracks which will be very good not explaining these later or you can build a building that is out here on the board I mentioned that at the beginning of the game we only have access to these four basic resources and all the better ones that
have these little construction tiles on them and the architect is how you can actually get these to be pulled off the board and you're gonna do that by spending building resources which are the sand over here the wood we've got the planks and then I guess better sand or cement right here and we would just need to discard stuff to match the three and if you combine two different types of resources then you actually get a bonus so we could take this one for one this one for one and then we get a bonus one and that gets us to three and that means this is now constructed which is really nice for us we're now gonna take one of these bonus tokens over here on these are for the first level buildings these four over the second and these are for the third so we could for instance crab this and it will give us a couple of victory points right here as well as a bump on the red influence track and then lastly we would get to go ahead and put another worker out onto the spot we just cleared out and we now get to upgrade resources now in this case I just pulled these off but let's just say we had some sand over here every time you build a building I'm sorry every time you activate a spot like this you can upgrade up to three resources following this little arrow on the board pulling them from the sand area over here into the cement area so that now in the future you know that these are cement instead of sand when we go ahead and look farther out to the board we can see that this arrow not only goes to cement but it also goes all the way over here to the brick location and from the brick location there is a little arrow that goes through it arch all the way up here to these little statues that can be built later on the game as you pull the resources from the left-hand side all the way over to the
right next up we have the Sailor right here and as you can see there is a lot of iconography on the bottom of their area but the rough idea for this character is you can't go ahead and deliver goods to the Guild's as well as delivering them to notables as they come down the river first let's go ahead and talk about completing orders for the guilds now you'll notice there are these little silver pawns in these three areas that are associated with the red blue and green guilds and the icons right next to this pawn or the ones that that kill'd currently wants so if we wanted to deliver over here to the red guild we would need to give up a cotton as well as a statue that I just showed as being one of the far right harder to get resources on the board and if we were to be able to discard both of those then we would fulfill this and we would actually take our pawn and put it on the spot that this silver thing was that and then scoot this down so that in the future now this is what this guild is looking for however in order to actually deliver to the red guild we have to make sure that we have at least one influence you'll see that little symbol right there says that we cannot currently deliver to the red guild so I'll just cheat a little bit and pretend like our influence was right there and now once we do this delivery we look up to the level of our influence and we're going to take it that number of victory points and put it into our bag the other thing that the Sailor lets us do is deliver goods to the notables as they travel down the river heading towards Akbar's birthday and if you look at these specific cards you'll see we have resources in the top left so that means we could use this action to deliver a brick or a wood or maybe both to this character and when you actually do this
you are going to mark these spots with these markers once again and you're gonna generate victory points for the number of spots that have already been occupied on these given cards and once every one of the resources has been filled in either with yourself or potentially with somebody else then that card is going to be taken and given to the person who delivered the most valuable resources so since we did the brick in this hypothetical situation we would go ahead and grab this card it's also worth noting that whenever you go ahead and put a marker down onto that card you are going to generate another guild bump in that given color so this is a red card so by putting a token down and on this turn we would get to bump up on the red guild once if we win ahead two deliveries on this card in one turn we still only get the one bump but it definitely is a nice thing for us and then down on the bottom we are now gonna get some sort of benefit it might be a one-shot thing or maybe an ongoing thing like this one says that when we do a construct action we automatically have plus one to build and we're gonna generate an extra victory point so once we have this card we're probably gonna want to try and do even more of the construction actions at this point I do think it's worth mentioning that when you deliver to notables you can only access the ones that are behind this little boat icon so at the beginning of the game we would only have access to these four in a three player game and a four player game we would have some more notables going out and once two of these level 1 notables get pulled off the board then this boat is going to move down the river and unlock these as options for us and more things happen as the boat goes down the river including giving you some bonuses if you have some cotton on a couple different spots as well as unlocking these little tokens right here
which are going to lift off and a restriction on at the beginning of the game only three orders can be delivered to the guild board that I just talked about well once the boat crosses over here now we could do four and then five and then finally six as the boat gets farther and farther down the river the third main character is the trader and as the name implies this character allows us to manipulate our resources and you see these three little flag tokens that are down in front of them what this means is they can take one of these and replace the flags that are already on some of the icons for instance we have this cement right here which is that normally two flags but with that there it is now one flag or we could go the opposite direction and make it worth three flags once we have done one of these modifications we can then manipulate some of these around and on the number of flags is going to dictate just how that manipulation goes so I probably would do this so that now by using both of these cements I would have it six flags worth of manipulation whereas before it would have just been that two four Flags total if I hadn't put that marker down this means that even early in the game with good use of these flags you could hypothetically turn a whole bunch of these basic resources into one of these really fancy resources over here in that case you would not necessarily need to build this building you could just put a token over here to demarcate that you have a book by potentially getting rid of a bunch of sand if perhaps you put to this double flag down on there the last of the main characters is the botanist and this is likely the simplest there are three different options and you need to pick two of them and then evaluate them the first is you can bump up your meditation track the second is
you can remove these little boxes from your farmer area and the third is you can move two of your farmers all three of these options are represented over here on our player board one of them is taking off this box and that means that in the future if we generate wood we now have an extra empty spot here so we'd make three wood instead of the two before the other one with moving the farmers means that we can move this down one and this one up there and that means now if we went and did the wood then we would have one two three four empty slots and if we combine that with taking this off right here we could potentially make a five wood on our next turn which would be a really nice action and the last of the options is this meditation track down here you'll notice that it costs one two mics to go from one to two and then eight American and oil to go farther up including some other costs and I think now it's probably a good time to switch gears and go back to the first phase of the turn so I can explain how meditation works let's now look up to the top of the board where we find the meditation area now you'll notice that we've been putting these workers out and they've been standing up and in the meditation phase you can take as many of your workers that are currently sending up and you can lay them down and for each one of them who lays down you're gonna get a certain amount of meditation points and it's going to depend on how far up you are on the meditation track that I just showed you and then you could spend those points in order to do the bonuses that are visible on this area we have this one which is very straightforward it just lets you move the farmers on your little plots really well this one you can spend to meditation in order to remove another one of those boxes this one will allow you to spend meditation points to upgrade the actions going from likes and
it to cement or bricks into statues and lastly this one up here is gonna allow you to turn resources of one flag type into another resource of that same flag type and it is worth noting that once you're done with the meditation phase you're gonna take this medallion and move it on to the last one that you did so actually just lied that wasn't the last one that this is the last one it was covered up at the beginning of the game and you could spend three meditation points to do yet another delivery down to the notables down on the river on the map so as you can see you can do all of these actions before you get into the main action and it is a way that you can get a activation out of workers you already have out in the board up to this point this rules demonstration has been very solitary with me putting my workers onto all these spots but this is a multiplayer game so I think it's now time to talk about what happens when your opponents want to activate spots that you already have workers down on well the first thing they could do is maybe go over to a location where you have a worker who's already laying down because they have meditated well in this case you're simply gonna remove your worker and that's it you get no particular bonuses but instead if this blue player had decided to come over here to the sand area maybe make a couple sand for themselves and that we have a standing up worker then we will still remove this the blue player can still activate that spot but since this worker is standing up we're gonna generate a favor which looks mysteriously a lot like a whole bunch of other tokens in the game in order to show that this multi-purpose marker is indeed favored I usually put it right here in the middle of the area and this leads me to the favor section of our board now much like meditation gives us some special actions we can do before we do our main action with the favor
actions we can activate one of each of these on each turn and we just have to discard at that number of favor sometimes you have to prove you have a certain number but then actually discard less in order to activate that spot so if I had to favor right now for instance as essentially a free action I could put both of these over here and then generate one of the basic resources there's also this option right here to do a resource upgrade as well as this is yet another way to bump your influence up on the tracks at this point I also think it's worth mentioning that at the beginning of the game every player has the same favor options but they also have these three empty spots and as they get their influence marker up to the yellow lines over here on this board they will gain the ability to grab a new favorite tokens put them onto their board which are now options that only they have available to themselves and their opponent's argument to choose from different ones from this rather large stack right here the next two things that I'd like to briefly point out are the merchants and builder tokens that you have probably noticed in this video already and I've been wondering what they do well if we you go ahead and go to a spot with this merchants then the first thing that happens is you're gonna generate two favor onto your board which is nice the next thing we'll do is roll this die and then we're gonna move the bursh into that number of spaces forward they're only going to go to unlocked spots so it would go one
and then three four five in this case and then what you do is go ahead and put these money tokens down onto the spots that they actually walk through and that means that in the future if somebody goes to one of those locations they will actually get this money which is also victory points for doing that action so it's gonna incentivize all those spots the other one is the Builder and for this one you can actually go and activate a spot that the Builder is at even though it is not yet built because what happens is that the Builder immediately constructs that location and you can do the upgrade action if you had some of your resources over here just like that but you are not going to get any of these bonuses and then we're gonna go ahead and roll this die and in this case the worker the Builder is only going to move on to construction slots according to that number so we go one two three and in the future if somebody who wants to go over here and make brick they can do that again the Builder just lets you get these buildings constructed without bonuses but also without having to actually spend the building materials the last thing that I'd like to point out on the board are the special actions associated with the four luxury goods now you can of course spend these goods to cash in the guild things as well as the notables down in the river but you can also use this good in order to do the bonus action associated with it if you use a statue then you can get an entire another worker placement action down onto the board by discarding that the book right here is gonna allow you to raise back up and wake up three people that you have laid down from annotation and give you some favor the painting is gonna allow you to bump up
two out of the three influence tracks before the guilds and lastly the shirts down here well you can just turn them into quite a bit of victory points alrighty let's now come back to our player board and it is worth mentioning that you can spend some of the other resources in order to wake up some people that have done some meditation and I think I now like to go over here so I can explain the final part of a turn so just to reiterate the first thing we get to do is meditation actions and then we can do a main or complaisant action and lastly down here you can see that we can do a guild cache in action which I explained to earlier on that you could also do with the Sailor and the other option you have for free on your turn is you can deliver a birthday gift to Akbar the great when we look up to the top of the imperial board we can see that there are all these slots that are associated with all of the non-standard resources in the game and what this means is we can essentially donate one resource for instance this is a cement from the board and we can put that into one of the slots as long as nobody else is there already in a three player game we block a couple of slots with the non player character and this is going to do nothing for us right now but at the end of the game we're gonna get a increasing number of entry points based on the number of gifts that we give to the ruler at this point you should have a good general idea for how all of the different mechanics work I've of course glossed over lots of the details and so now let's talk about how the game ends well if this little boat gets all the way down over to here or if any of the three guilds has all of their slots filled in from people cashing in or if one of the influence markers makes it all the way to the top of one of these
areas then you're gonna keep playing until you get back to the starting player and then you're gonna do one more round and at that point you are gonna calculate all of the points that you should have lying away in this little bag that you've been stuffing it throughout the game you are gonna get a couple extra bonus points for a variety of things including if you are highest up on the three given guilds then you'll get even more bonus points for the number of cash ins that you've done and you get a little bit less points if you are second highest so there is definitely a reason to go higher on these not only just to get more victory points for cashing lives in but also for beating your opponents out too and not giving them with those bonuses and of course once you add all this stuff together whoever has the most coins which are victory points is going to be the winner of the game let's now begin the review for Agra by starting with a few positive points the first of these has to do with the action selection mechanism that is central to the game now on the face of it it looks like a standard worker bumping style mechanism and just to give a little bit of context and in my opinion there are essentially three different types of worker placement games you have the type where when you put a worker down and then nobody else can go to that spot the second type is when you put a worker down other people can go there they just have to pay more resources in order to do that and the third type is worker bumping where you can go to a spot where your porn is and it will just kick their pawn off and then they have access to that pawn again and Agra is certainly in that third camp but it does something a bit different than all other games like this and that you start with so many workers that you literally never run out of them it's theoretically possible but I've never seen it happen in too many games that I played and what that means is
this is a different style thing than what I've seen in the past cuz usually with worker bumping and the perk of getting bumped is that you gain access to that worker again and usually you run out of workers and you have to like lose a whole turn to get them back but agri says no you just have so many workers that inevitably they will be bumped back before you need to get them back and what that means is that when they get bumped they actually give you another currency which is favor and I'm actually going to talk about that in the second positive point but I just think that's one particular aspect of just giving each player more workers than they could ever do with is a pretty neat take on this overall idea and then the other aspect to it is that you cannot activate a spot that you are at unless you pay victory points so you only block yourself which means you are definitely incentivized to try and go on to places that are good for you right now but also that will be good for your opponents so they will kick you out because if you want to go back over there you certainly don't want to be spending two points to do that every time because that is a costly effect to you so I really like this overall system with all those workers and the way the bumping works out it's been a very pleasant thing to plan through especially considering the only people that are going to be blocking you realistically is yourself in the past so you better plan well next up we have positive point number two and for this I'd like to talk about the favor currency and the meditation currency and both of them I see as coming from kind of the same source because if you remember the way meditation works is at the beginning of your turn you can lay down as many of your workers as you'd like who are already out on the table and they will generate meditation points that you can then use to do a wide variety of things
for yourself but once they have laid down then in the future if they ever get bumped then you will not get any favored bonus so realistically you can consider that every time you put a worker out onto the board they will generate you either meditation points or favor when they ultimately get used up and I really like both of these different aspects because was meditation it allows you to set some certain combo we type things up before you get into your main action also you can upgrade that meditation track so that you will get more and more value out of the workers when you lay them down out on the board and the opposite signed with the favors well you're gonna be getting these when your opponents bump you out you don't activate those people and right at the beginning of the game you have three different options that you can spend favors on which are pretty nice honestly like spending favors to get based resources or doing resource upgrades can really get yourself out of a bind but as you go deeper into the game you'll have opportunities to get your own specialized favor actions that you can then use to do even more powerful stuff and I just think having these two extra currencies that are kind of like secondary activations of the workers that you're doing as your primary activation is a really neat idea and I have enjoyed the way they worked for positive number three let's now discuss the immense number of options that the game gives each player on every one of their turns as they're trying to figure out what their plans gonna be to get to their ultimate destination you know their main goal that they have for that one given turn and by this I'm kind of talking about all the stuff I've already mentioned because you have it the fact that you can put your worker down onto any location on the entire map including where you've been you just have to spend
some victory points there so you're never going to be blocked in any of those spots the second thing is the meditation points that you can activate before that main action so you can use those to set up an even better main action when you put that worker down you can spend those favorite tokens in order to get that one resource that you need or that one upgrade that's going to allow you to chain into some several other things and then you of course also have the really nice Goods at the end of the tracks they can all be consumed to do a variety of things from taking an entire extra main action or bumping yourself up on some of those agent rows and a couple other things as well so when you add all of these different things together it's kind of like you're sitting in a cockpit with tons of buttons and wheels and levers and strings and all that kind of stuff and you're just like well if I do this this this and I put my foot down over there then I can get there but instead I could do that that and then you know press this button on there and I get to that same location and well that same end goal and the question is which way is more efficient and which way maybe it's you to the goal you want to do best to also help yourself out in future turns and I for my planning perspective I love this wide variety of options that I can really find the right path and it seems like almost every time I've sat down on a turn and I'm like I want to do this I can usually figure out a way to actually get it done it just again a matter of how much is gonna particularly cost me and not every turn is this crazy set of combos that you're gonna be doing you will very often not very often but somewhat often have a turn where you just don't do a
meditation and you put it worker down make it what's tumeric and your turn is over and that is fine because those kind of things set you up for later because you need those resources on the board it's actually activate all this stuff for my fourth and final positive point I'd like to briefly talk about the building mechanic and by this I mean you have at the beginning of the game only access to the four basic resources and the rest of the spots on the board have a little under construction tile on top of them and you are allowed to make those resources like the medium and even the best resources right from the very beginning of the game by doing some of the more creative actions that are available to you but when it comes to actually activating those spots by putting a worker down you have to get the resources the building materials together and actually construct that building and the game gives you some pretty nice bonuses for doing that so you are incentivized to open that up but once it's open then it's a new worker placement spot for people for the rest of the game and I just like the kind of unveiling tempo of this at the beginning you start out with just those and as the game goes on you have more and more more options that are available to you which means the game is less overwhelming right at the very beginning and I think the way they get in the veil just works out very well for the overall tempo of the game okay let's now move into a couple neutral points and the first of these should be pretty obvious and that is that with such a wide variety of options available to the players I have noticed that for people who are susceptible to announce this process this game will actively press that button and I have seen downtown can be a bit of an issue when it comes to you especially the larger player counts and as I mentioned before there are so
many ways to get to where you want to go there's so many things that you can think about why you get there there is the feeling that there's just one better way to do it like you're like these there's these three ways to do a turn but maybe there's a fourth it's just better than all those other three and if you allow your friends or allow yourself to really tunnel down on that thought process the game can definitely start to drag and so I think it's important to remind people that this is the kind of game where you can't do a lot of planning in fact almost all of your planning wouldn't start your term because the game is so open like if somebody goes where you want to go well you can also go there it does mean that you're gonna bump them off and probably give them a favor but at the end of the day you have to do the things that you have to do and so I don't think that analysis process is like a crippling issue with this game but I have noticed with myself I sometimes need to kind of crack the mental what can be like nope just do that turn it's good enough and when I played this especially at the four player count it did seem like sometimes it took longer to get around the table than I would have liked now for my other neutral point I'd like to talk about the guild tracks that are on that biggest slanted Imperial board and specifically I'd like to speak to how strategically opaque they can seem for the first couple games and I am mostly talking about myself here when I'm saying like for people as they're trying to play this game but I have seen other people really not have this clique for several plays and so just for a little bit of a reminder the way this works is there are three different guilds and for each of the guild there are six sets of two resources you can cash in in order to generate victory points but you're only going to get points equal to the
place where your influence marker is on that track and for the first couple games of this that I played I noticed that not just myself but everyone around the table was that not really cashing in those resources they were primarily focusing on doing other things and their area but also trying to push their influence marker really far up on that track before they cashed in anything because at the beginning I think you get like three victory points for doing cash ins when your influence is low and all the way up near the top you can get like seven or a bit repoint so it's like well I'll just wait and then push it all the way as far up as I can and then near the end of the game do those cash ins but then I look down and it has this mechanic where you cannot players in general cannot fulfill a certain number of these things before you hit these thresholds on the river it's like you know until you get to the certain point only three out of the six can actually be turned in and I remember thinking like whatever you're gonna get even close to Mac man maxing that out I don't really understand and it just seemed like that's that whole area of the game when the game ended we count up the points just nobody was really getting it and it took I guess four full plays for me to finally see it actually click and make sense where suddenly we had players trying to turn in the goods early in the game to maybe get some extra bumps because if you're not the person with the most influence when you cash in you get a little bit less points but you get a free bump up so you have more influence in the area so you make more points when you do future cash ins and it seems like there's a bit of a groupthink situation with this part of the board within a specific game if nobody's really going for those spots then nobody really cares about it but
the moment somebody cash in one of them early in the game everyone's like oh no there's only three of those available and now there's only two available in that one spot I'm gonna try to get in there as soon as I can as well and I think a big part of this is understanding all of the other buttons and levers that I've talked about in this game and figuring out how you can actually get some of those really valuable resources on like the third turn of the game you can't do that but it's not inherently obvious to players the first time or two that they sit down to play this game and so this is not gonna affect everybody but I figured it was worth mentioning that from my personal experience it took me three full plays where I guess the starting of the fourth play before us finally like okay I think I understand how that's supposed to work I think you really are supposed to get in there as soon as you can because these spaces are quite limited in there and the jockeying for those spaces and for our pawns on the influence board became so much more relevant and interesting in that fourth game that I finally played all right it's now time to cover a couple negative points to the game and the first of these you will probably know about already if you paid any attention to some of the feedback that this game has gotten and that is that the board is beautifully illustrated but kind of a nightmare to actually play on especially when you are considering the the resources you know you have the basic resources and then the middle resources and the final ones and the way you track these resources is you have the tokens go down on to the basic ones when they're created and you kind of passed them along these lines from location to location on the board and the board is so focused on being beautifully illustrated that the lines that go from thing to thing are obscured
in various ways and do not really follow a consistent path and there have been that several times where we have had a confusion as to where this one line goes to especially for the first game or two by the time I was into the fourth game I hadn't totally mapped out but it doesn't mean it wasn't annoying the way all of these things are positioned now because if they were like imperfect lines but then still beautifully illustrated that would make more sense but just sometimes you have a resource on the spot you're like wait is that a sand or is that a brick it's really close I'm pretty sure that was the sand stone and you know trying to consider these things is a frustrating thing and I really think they should have given a lot more attention to the graphical design as opposed to the artistic design of the overall board and then a couple other things are pretty annoying as well like several of the resources to look very similar when it comes to the little icons on the maps you have like a bowl of soup and you have a bowl of die and then you have a pile of sand and Oliv and several these have scoops in them and when there are tiny little icons and they're all kind of orange to yellowish I have seen people have trouble trying to parse the difference between those and then lastly you have that big slanted Imperial board with those really tall skinny influence markers and I think on three occasions now I've seen it where we have had several of them fall down usually when somebody cashes in one of the birthday presents on the top of the board if it doesn't quite sit in it falls down I've seen that little thing like roll down and knock out multiple of the little influence markers I'm like ah like I'm pretty sure I was here and I was pretty sure you were there and it's never caused us to like you know I need to restart the game or like you know
really hurt the overall impact but it's kind of a scary silly thing I just think overall all of these different artistic and component quality things should have been looked into considering how big and expensive this game is when it comes in the box for negative number two I have something I want to discuss this is gonna sound a little bit vague and a little bit nitpicky but that is that for a game with so many wonderful levers and buttons and things going on I feel like it could have been streamlined to a certain extent and still had a wonderful gaming experience in there I mentioned as a positive that I love having all of these buttons and levers in order to put together some really nice combo turns and trying to have multiple avenues to get to the thing that I want to do but I feel like even saying that this game has just a few too many little outliers which makes teaching this game take longer than it could otherwise and I just think in general from a design perspective they could have streamlined some stuff a couple of examples are like you can spend certain goods to refresh your workers that have already laid down to meditate on the board and now maybe you're watching this and you play dagger before and you say John that's an amazing action it lets you do amazing combos with your meditation track and I would agree that yes I've seen that action be rather nice but I also feel like it probably could have been designed out of the game so that's not one more rule that you have to learn you also have the boat as it goes down the river at certain points it does special activations based off of the amount of cotton that you have and that makes me feel like the designer felt like cotton was a bit weak and so you need to have this extra reason to just kind of be
sitting around with a bunch of cotton when the boat hit certain spots on the river and maybe the things that are made from cotton could have been just made a little bit more nice so that the cotton in general is not underpowered and perhaps I'm putting words into somebody else's mouth maybe that's not the reason why and they just loved the idea of cotton being somewhat special in that aspect and again I don't think it's a bad mechanic I just feel like maybe that one also could have been cut out so it's just one less thing to consider as you're doing all your planning and a one less thing to teach because this game is definitely a beast to teach to new people and there are many other little examples like this that I could go on and on about for a longer than I probably should but I just feel like this game would be a little bit better if some of these little sharp edges around the outside of this thing we're taking off because if you're sitting in a cockpit with like 20 buttons verses or 40 buttons I feel like 20 buttons is still more than enough when it comes to actually trying to get to where you want to go and like I said I like the fact that there are so many of them just maybe a few of them could have been called out to streamline the overall gaming experience all right let's now discuss it the variability for Agra and I think considering the size and weight of this game it's about what I expected going in and the main thing that is going to make one game play differently for the next or those notable cards that come in on the river at the bottom half of that humungous board and there are only 24 of them in the game which at first seemed like a relatively low amount but then you do the math and you realize that for a two or three player game you only use eleven out of those 24 and for the four
player game you use 14 out of the 24 which means even have the highest player count there's still 10 of those cards that will be in the box and every single time you play the game so the way you shuffle these up is going to vary the game States primarily because of the legis for two reasons the first is because of the colors of those cards if you have a lot of green cards come out in that specific shuffle then that means that the green guild with the infamous track is probably gonna be much more contested because it's so much easier to get those influenced bumps by delivering goods to those notables and the other thing comes into play with the abilities down the bottom sometimes the synergize really well with each other and you could try to find those good combos and try to snipe out those specific cards and that's a kind of variability in the game is that and what I look for with a game of this particular weight so I think that it could probably be more variable if some other aspects of the game were different from one plate to the next and who knows maybe expansions will do that in the future but as I said I have no problems with the amount of variability that came in the box when it comes to player count Agra supports two to four players and I've been fortunate enough to trying all of those player counts and I'm happy to say that three players is easily the best way to play this game now I think that four players works fine as well but the reason three players get such a big edge really comes down to the downtime that I mentioned earlier that analysis paralysis is definitely a factor that can come into play with this game and when you have one less person around the table then that means it's going to come back around and you'll get to take your turn faster than if you were in a four-player setting and I would play this game at
four players again I just go into it knowing that this is probably gonna be like a three three-and-a-half hour long game or something like that and also it kind of depends on specific people that I playing with and fortunately for my design perspective the game does a good job of accounting for the fact that you are missing that fourth player when it comes to tightening up some of the tracks in some of the locations out there on the board so three has worked really well but unfortunately my one play had two players did leave me a little bit cold and in the game's defense it was only my second play and with so many things going on I can absolutely say that I did not really understand fully how this game was supposed to work when I play to add to players but that being said it doesn't take away the fact that it just did not feel like it clicked or really flowed that well at - mostly because with only one person around the table or across the table from me that was just one opponent to buff out my workers which meant I had so many my workers out there on the table at any given time that I was oftentimes in my own way and you could say that that's my fault but I also think that if it was three players then that would happen a lot less often and of course it's happening to my opponent too so it's not like an unfair advantage but it just seemed like it did not flow and play the way it really was supposed to at that two-player count and maybe some people are gonna love it at that one but for me personally that one play of it at two means that that I probably won't play it at that player count again but unfortunately the three player game works really really well and hopefully you can apply yourself in a situation where you can get three player people around the table to play this one when you can in conclusion I've played agri four times at this point and I can safely say that this is one of the best
strategic games that I have ever played this comes from a couple different areas but the biggest has to do with the fact that this game is so wide open and friendly to players when it comes to the options that they have available to themselves there are so many things that they can do and all of them are available to them all the time like you can go to that spot and you will kick out your opponent you can reactivate that spot even though you are there and it is gonna cost you a couple victory points but that doesn't mean that you don't have that option and I did mention that it does feel like maybe this game has a couple more options and buttons and labors to press then it realistically needs and I kind of wish maybe a few of them had been streamlined out to make the teach of this game and the overall process of thinking through all the options a little bit more streamlined because it's kind of like an embarrassment of riches when it comes to the number of options and ways you can manipulate things as you are trying to plan through your turns but all that being said that act of planning in this game is intensely satisfying and it's wonderful that you can be figuring out all of these different options for yourself even when it's not your turn because again there's only so much that your opponent's can do that will alter your plans because you can always go everywhere on the board I did mention that there were some kind of frustrating elements to the graphical and artistic layout of the board and with some of the icons but fortunately I've been able to kind of get my mind around them now that I've played the game a few times but that doesn't take away from the fact that there was active confusion for those first couple games and whenever I've taught this game to a new person it seems like that act of confusion comes back into play so I do
wish that the board had been designed in such a way maybe they'd have this beautiful sign on one side and you can flip it over and have a more utilitarian mechanics base side that you can kind of choose which one you wanted to go with but that's not something that actually came in the box maybe for a second edition I don't know but I do think that in the future if they do more print runs they really should actively look at trying to make now specifically the lines of the upgrades of the resources a little bit clearer but I don't want to harp on that stuff too much because in the end this has been a wonderful game to play I've really enjoyed every play of it I was like breathlessly excited at certain moments during my first play of this and even on the fourth play that I did about a week ago or so I was still just loving it and talking about how I just wanted to play it again in just a couple days and that hasn't happened because unfortunately this game is long especially for our play group it seems like even a three player game it usually clocks in at close to three hours which means it's not gonna fit into many of the board gaming settings that I have but I am hoping to play this one well into the future and to continue to enjoy all of the super satisfying planning that planning options that it provides me each time I sit down to actually play it as always I'd like to thank everyone who's been supporting this channel through patreon including all of these producer level pledges if you two would like to directly support the channel you could do so at patreon.com slash junkets games and I would really appreciate it also if you'd like to see more in depth board game reviews like this one as well as full game playthroughs and vlogs please subscribe to the channel thanks for watching