Skip to main content
Loading video...

Rate My Shelf - Keep or Cull - Board Games - Episode III

Transcript 19:58

thank you hi everyone I'm Luke Hector and you're watching the broken meeple this is a YouTube channel about board games where I give reviews top tens and my honest opinions regardless of the consequences we'll get on with the show in just a minute but first a quick word for my sponsor as a fellow gamer you'll understand this is unacceptable the solution head down to my new sponsor kiander.co.uk kielder stocks many of the hot new releases as well as some old hidden gems free delivery on ultra's over 30 pound further discounts on bulk purchases and even five percent of your spending refunded bacteria's points to be used for further discounts down the line if you use the referral Link in the description below and sign up for a new account you'll get five percent discount on your first order over 60 pounds so let's make gaps in your collection a thing of the past get down to kinder and start saving today thank you for listening and enjoy the rest of the video get on with it you didn't think I've begun about this series do you now the UK games expo's just been taking up a lot of time with those reviews but I want to keep this going and this is for the calyx square right there this is the top left corner of my calyx shelf which is I think just slightly out of shot and the start of my fantasy flight games section the entire column is devoted to Giant Fantasy Flight games for the most part like boxes of this size or bigger and that's not even including Arkham Horror CG Lord of the Rings lcg and marble Champions suffice to say I have quite a bit of their stuff they make the themes and IPS that I like they tend to do for manic games and yeah granted they're having things that they've been really met a game lately other than their lcgs and even then I'm getting to

the point where I'm actually debating not to buy any more of their lcg content because I feel like I've got enough of them I don't need more content but these games from before you know some of them a bit more recent than others could they still find a place in my collection for all time well we'll have to see so we're gonna have to put a bunch of these on the floor because unfortunately it's impossible to put them anywhere else without them being off in the camera so let's start off with chaos in the old world so this one oh blimey does anybody remember this uh big Beastie this was essentially my blood Rage of the day because everyone sort of leapt onto blood Rage with the big Viking Miniatures and that and I found blood rage to be just kind of yeah it was all right but I didn't think it deserved anywhere near the hype it does and uh flashing and much because who talks about that game anymore but you know chaos in your world was my one this is essentially a giant Warhammer fantasy themed dudes on the map game where everybody plays one of the four chaos God factions and it is essentially beat each other up and you know dish out the damage in it I pimped this one up quite a bit with some like you know proper felt bags and stuff in fact this almost feels a little bit Nostalgia because it's been so long since I've taken this game out of the box I just haven't had the chance to relearn the rules and play it I've even got the skaven horned rat expansion you know even more stuff in here but this one had a board that had all dials and stuff made out of skin not literally but that was just essentially the theme of it everybody had their own special dial with their own sort of

Victory conditions that they had to do you had a bunch of oh let's get a bunch of this stuff out yeah so everybody had their little goddy Miniatures a bunch of cards and everybody played a very asymmetrically so you know your idea was that the corn were Heavy Hitters and they wanted to kill as many people as possible therefore getting points whereas uh pestilence nurgal wanted to spread out where the zenich ones had all the magic stuff and they wanted to you know get the power I forget what the skaven wanted to do but everybody had an asymmetric way of playing and winning this is a great fun game a really solid game but I haven't brought it out in ages because it is just you know it's a decent amount of rules and it's just been ages since I've played it and there's been too many other games to note the question is though can this stay in my collection there's a big thing about this um you want to find a copy of this game anywhere good freaking luck this thing is ridiculously rare now you know on second edition sorry second edition on second hand sales people will scalp you and for every last hair follicle on your head in order to sell this to you like ridiculous prices and as much as I say the game is great doesn't deserve that kind of price tag this bloke by an angle whoa whoa wiggle and sadly you know people might go well I've got blood rage I don't need this this is superior to blood rage I'm sorry it just is and you know those are those Cthulhu Wars which is the kind of the sequel to this where you've got a similar concept but it's

done with the Cthulhu gods I I mean that's got an even higher price tag and I haven't been tempted by that one the models kind of look a bit generic with the fancy colors that they use and and I don't know we've got enough Cthulhu stuff I don't need everything to be Cthulhu this worked better with the chaos Gods going against each other because I feel that they are far more differentiated from each other than the Cthulhu gods and Cthulhu Wars are it leaves in terms of feel so if I keep this I obviously want to get it back to the table at some point so definitely it'll be in my wheelhouse to do that you know I don't tend to go much for Eric Lang stuff this is probably one of the better ones he's done alongside I guess x-com for me but if I sell this I will never see it again and it will be gone for good and I won't know what to price it at because everybody else tries to scalp on it and it's got the expansion in it which is probably rarer than the game itself this is one that if I sell it it's gone for good and I don't think I want it to be gone for good I think I want to put in the effort to get this out again this one's a keeper for me you know as much as it could if it was more widely available it could potentially be a car just because I haven't played in ages but I keep thinking I want to and I must get it back to the table again and have some good fun with it but it's just going to take me a while to get back into the rules be able to teach it and of course find another four other players willing to play it because obviously this is now a five player game probably one of the few big sprawling games that I want to play as a five player but it's it's just really solid

it's really cool really encapsulates the theme of the Warhammer fantasy Universe you know all the different play styles are great but yeah so rare but for that reason above a lot at the moment I want to keep this rather than cut it alright next up something a little bit smaller Mission red planet Mission red planet people like to call this citadels 2.0 it's got some similarity the citadels but I think Colleen at citadel's 2.0 is a little bit misleading yes it has the roll selection but in citadels you draft the roles here you have a hand of nine cards you play them and then you have to play a card to get them back into your hand there are many more games like care I think even Concordia I hate the fact I even had to say that you know you know games like that where you have a hand of cards and you have to play you want to get them all back that is more similar to than citadels to be frank but this one is another one of these games actually that I would put in that rare box that with five or six players it works pretty well so Mission red planet is about getting all your people on to Mars it's area control through and through you're controlling areas they produce resources they're worth different numbers of points and you're trying to collect the most points at the end but the idea is is that everybody has got these roll cards that do different things regarding moving on Mars and putting your astronauts into these little spaceships to go to Mars they will have destinations which may or may not be the same destination you want to go to by the end of the round but essentially once the spaceship is filled up it then flies off it goes to Mars drops your astronauts off and then

you're lying for straight up area control different resources different value points get the most points win nice and straightforward but the the most of the game is simultaneous and proper simultaneous you know you all select a role at the same time which doesn't take a lot of thinking power they resolve and then in turn order you go from you know nine to one counting down and you resolve the various people but it's pretty quick the turns are Snappy and the game doesn't take that long before you realize it you're already on the end game section it's like oh right so I need to actually start controlling some areas ah what do I do and it really doesn't feel like it outstays its welcome you can play with three or four players fine I don't think it can even play it two can you even play it too it can play it too I can't think of any reason why I would want to this is definitely a three plus player game but it works at five and six it's certainly a bit of a mean uh you know a mean vest for trying to control Mars I do believe you are right but this works at the higher player counts and very few Euros manage it this one is a keeper for me a lot for that regard you know I prefer citadels as a game if we're gonna compare the two if you really must get worked on that I'd rather play citadels but this one is still one of my favorite area control games and area control is not a theme I tend to go for although we've just had chaos in the old world I guess Fantasy Flight is the the publisher who tends to make area control games for me but the fact that this can so easily you know so easily play five and six players without a ton of rules with still a bit of laughter with how

everything goes wrong and just a good bit of bant around the table it's simplistic rules it's just a really solid game I was so glad when this came out in second edition because I kept hearing a dice tower talk about it on first edition back in the days of Sam Healey Sam and Tom you know the good old days and ah yeah man you know I really wanted to get this and when it was announced that there was this version snapped up immediately haven't regretted it since it's a real keeper all right now let's go for probably a more obvious One Star Wars outer rim this one actually if the expansion had not come out this would have been a guaranteed Carl definitely a guaranteed call if the expansion had not come out unfinished business Star Wars outer rim though is now packed with a decent amount of content the expansion essentially fixed a lot of the problems that were in the base game so when you had like lack of cards or an inability to travel in places and maybe just one or two mechanics that needed a refreshing Outer Rim unfinished business solved all that and I pimped this one out nicely so this one has got the folded space insert which is mandatory you need this insert for outer rim because otherwise your setup is going to be an absolute chore but now you get to be a bounty hunter and go around the go around the Galaxy doing missions getting items upgrading your spaceship hunting down other people which could be other players at times I want them alive no disintegration As You

Wish ah Shack and you know trying to be the most nefarious in the Galaxy but with unfinished business you can now traveling easier there's more cards more stuff to find but what I particularly like are these sort of they're kind of like a I say objective cards in the sense they basically give you like an R overarching story like hero of the Rebellion Galactic Explorer crime Lord the private Monarch and they have different things that you have to do in order to um you know unlock part of this objective and once you get to the end it gives you like a finale thing that you have to do so you have to have enough Fame but you also have to complete this little goal like take out Star Destroyer or you know get to a particular encounter and stuff like that and these just add a nice amount of theme to The Game while also I think in a way slightly speeding the game up because it is a relatively longish game but this one before the expansion I was thinking of culling it because it didn't have enough variety some of these things were a little bit niggles it's hard to get to the table because it is like you know that it is quite a long game and the solo mode wasn't quite there yet but it wasn't too bad here though the solo mode has been improved the content has been expanded the rule sets have been improved it is now complete with unfinished business to the point where that expansion is basically essential for this game and as such Outer Rim is a keeper this is one of my favorite Star Wars games now you know I love playing this with two free players max four is just a bit long I think four goes on way too long but two to three players or playing this solo is just great fun it

really has a lot of that Star Wars theme wrapped in here you feel like you're doing all the Bounty Hunter stuff you tell a story as it is of your character and yeah there's not a huge amount of player interaction and the expansion try to help with that but it doesn't really quite add too much there but that's why I kind of prefer it solo than two or three players but it's just a really solid Star Wars game wonderfully fanatic and just I don't know it's wonderfully cool but the expansion was definitely needed because beforehand it was a curl but right now keeper definitely a keeper this is the way how many of you have heard of this game because I've touted the Praises of it and I suspect I'm the only one who's counted the Praises of it but seriously give this one a look it's called new Angeles I'm not sure if you will even be able to find a copy anymore but this is a game for four to six players unusual count because this is a negotiation game set in the Android Netrunner universe so you know the corporations that you had in Netrunner that uh the C the lcg where they were the bad guys and you had to go infiltrate their servers and do nasty stuff well now you play as one of the corporations in here and the idea is is that the whole city is going to pot so everything is like ah it's all falling apart and the government's thinking of stepping in and like going hey you guys aren't running this place very well there's too much corruption we're gonna intervene you don't want that to happen so what you're doing is you're working sort of cooperatively with the other people the other corpse in order to keep

the city going but you have your secret Rivals that you have to have more money than them in the end of the game in order to actually win while the city thrives quite a few reference AIDS so you saw the print here I believe this is from the uh the esoteric order of games uh you know by all means check out their their website and that and get some really cool reference sheets but these are very useful to help teach the game but the rules are not that complicated I mean I've seen larger rule books and when you get into it it's really not that complex of a game in fact that's the reference one the actual learn to play document you'd be surprised how easy it is to kind of comprehend a lot of the stuff in here but it looks gorgeous you know it's got all that Netrunner artwork everywhere it's well produced yeah okay Fantasy Flight style trench box there's only so many components in that but what this is is just a really cool negotiation game because you have a Twist on top one of you could be a federalist the government's given them a sweet deal out of it you know if you let us take over you get to run the show and we'll take you the head Corp one of you is tempted by that and so secretly you want the city to tank but you can't let everybody else know about it because each round you all have to vote on these different like projects that you're going to do like I want we want more security here well I want to sort out this outage here but we better sort out this unrest over here I want more Health Care you know bits and Bobs like that you're trying to sort it out like completing a global objective as a group but the Federalist is trying to make it so that the players fail that kind of objective and make

life harder vote for the wrong things you know a little bit of corruption here and there a little bit to see a little bit descent and because everybody's got their secret Rivals it just works to keep yourself hidden I have never had such fun in some negotiation games before particularly when I'm the Federalist in this I will happily play a normal faction in here but if I'm the Federalist oh man it's so much fun uh it's a long game this is gonna take you a good three hours to play you have to play the long game in this you've got to think ahead and as the Federalist I've done exactly that the last one I played I think at gridcon I taught five new players this and you know we had a blast I was Jin techy the healthcare one and throughout the whole game I started off on everybody's side and slowly started trying to grab a few things for myself a little bit of manipulation social manipulation here and there and then we got to the last penultimate turn sorry the penultimate term from the end we were hoped we were going to succeed providing we put these Androids in specific places to get the resources we need perfect hey guys I got the exact card though let's do that boom let's do it they didn't have a reason to suspect I was a federalist and so they voted with my card it's like right look put the free Androids where they need to go okay over there over there over there oh the looks on their faces when they saw me do that it's like uh what are you doing what are you doing Luke uh smug mode and they realized it they twigged it and they had one turn left in the game and they couldn't undo the damage I had done critical hit yes and

that sort of stuff is just so juicy I love it but this game is underrated as I'll get out nobody talked about this nobody sort of hyped it up granted a three-hour Euro negotiation game that ideally wants to Full Count of six players works well with five I don't think four is enough five or six players preferably six if you can get it but it's a long game it's definitely one for a convention and honestly I like to bring this to a lot of conventions because it doesn't take much longer than a typical convention game if anything it takes less time because some heavy you know convention games can take four hours plus but this one's done and dusted in three and you feel knackered afterwards because you're doing so much in it I love this it's just always a blast every time it comes out it just doesn't come out very often it's a keeper for me though because again if I get rid of this I'd probably never gonna see it again I can't donate this to a library because nobody's ever going to pick it up and play it in a library so this has to be my copy but honestly it's one of if not one of my favorite I don't know can I think of a better negotiation game a straight up negotiation game than this one I do like negotiation games I don't own very many though this is definitely one of my favorites if not my favorite I really do enjoy it new Angeles seriously if you get the chance to play this with me at a convention jump in on it because I'll be more than happy to teach it and you will have a blast so there there you go four Keepers this is a shelf that isn't shifting anytime soon and like I say you know there were a couple there that I was considering to Carl at one

point or another chaos in your world was definitely a little bit like hmm I don't know but Rarity is a big deal and that's probably what this episode is emphasizing more than anything else if a game is easily available or you can get it at a library you're less inclined to need to keep it yourself but when it's one of those little treasure troves those hidden gems that is a rare gem like this is a gem that will never be found anywhere else on the planet it's been mined out you have the only one well that makes you want to keep things a little bit longer than usual and maybe that could be considered a bad thing because you might be keeping a game that's actually not that good for you because it's rare and no other reason but I know I'll get chaos in your world out to the table again I know I will play new Angeles and it's easy to get Mission red planet out and Star Wars outer room is still a really cool game so yeah all four of these are Keepers no doubt about it so that's it for me on this episode of the broken people if you like what you see then please remember thumbs up on YouTube and get your comments down below about these games do you like them do you love them if you never tried them did you once have them and then call them if so why I want to hear your thoughts and so does everybody else until next time you can check out all the reviews I've been doing lately such as your moon Planet unknown uh mind bug uh what did I do recently uh the oh the Isle of trains yes I've got quite a few reviews out already and there's plenty more to come my God am I working overtime at this point but hopefully you're enjoying them until next time remember regardless of whether you want to keep yourself away it is or not it's still only a game bye for now

Progress saved