Knitting Circle vs Calico — Which One Should You Buy?
Transcript
Calico and Knitting Circle, both are beautiful puzzly games from AEG for one to four players. Same artist, different designer. Is one better? Calico, first published in 2020, is a tile-placing game where players draft one tile at a time, turn after turn, and try to meet multiple overlapping objectives involving pattern and color. For example, this pattern will help me satisfy the objective shown in the middle, as it requires four tiles in one pattern and two of the other. I also have three indigo tiles, so I'll earn a button. Later, when I place this third tile with the matching pattern, I'll attract the cat, Millie. That's what I mean by overlapping objectives, and it's enough to make you dizzy. This game ends once the entire quilt is complete. Let's look at Knitting Circle, published in 2025. Here, tiles are taken from a rondel. What are we building? Not a quilt. We're making numerous different garments, as many as we can make in six rounds. Each garment can satisfy as many or as few objectives as determined by the player. Players do not have to place their tiles as they take them. During the crafting phase, all players simultaneously place all of the tiles they drafted that round. Players get extra points for the size of the garment they create, but if you're in a tight spot, filling the entire card is not required. Yet another degree of flexibility Knitting Circle offers that Calico does not. Entirely unlike Calico, placing a tile can sometimes grant a bonus, like taking a tile of your choice. This is perhaps the most
forgiving difference between the two games. If you look at the profile for these two games, they're largely the same, except in complexity and luck. Knitting Circle gives players more agency for a simpler game, while Calico is more challenging and can often put players in a tight spot due to nothing other than bad luck and unfortunate tile options. If you'd like to see more games compared according to attributes like this, check out my web app at the perfectboardgame.com.