Wingspan: Discussion
Transcript
viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome to the discussion for wingspan so if this game has any testament to it first of all I do I mean II do a shadow for Elizabeth Hargrave because I understand that this is her very first game and still Myers you know back today and you know I helped her helped her create it so I mean I mean it's phenomenal game like I think like right I'm just gonna come alright come out right now and say it so it Elizabeth keep making games i you you did everything top notch and we'll explain why the last cat doesn't like this game I think you did everything top notch but a testament to this game that I think anyway is that cat usually doesn't like to play games anyway it doesn't play any games with me or push like ask to play any games and she actually asked if she we could play this one again so I thought that was awesome and I was like wow okay yeah that works for me so let's talk about there's two things that come out to me about this game what do you think of the theme the one thing the
birds have going for him is that some of them are just super precious looking however the vast majority are small tiny half dinosaur half rage machine so I like birds I have a reason to hate them they're detrimental to our ecosystem all of them not all of them that's not true most of them are adorable and cool I would never own one because I'm not a weirdo but I don't know I like birds there's something something majestic about them I've always dreamed for its gum little [ __ ] anyway so the theme of wingspan I mean still the theme does not like great birds all right it's kind of like the Oh trees from photosynthesis like it's not a you know attention-grabbing theme unless your birds unless you're like super into birds and if you're like a an avid bird watcher or bird enthusiast then I think this game does does it justice like not only do they have these beautiful illustrations that they got from an actual source yeah yeah no good good point at the very end of the rule book which the rule book material is phenomenal like here you're just like you've held other rulebook it
just feels nicer but anyway they gave credit like and did their research so burnt information comes from the all about Birds website from the Cornell Lab of Ornithology the Autobahn guide to the North American birds in a Sibley field guides to birds eastern North American and Western North American by David Allen Sibley tower Rex designed the bird bird feeder diced our photographic sources for the birds came from Glenn Bart Bartley Allan Murphy Roman tea brew qey Rob Palmer and Peter Green prints of the birds and other illustrations can be found at the net net net Natalie Rio just sorry sorry it's on the back of the rule book common and Anna Martinez dot-com so they they got their research these are beautifully illustrated birds like that kind of depict what their ability do and the little snippet of information about these birds like if you've ever actually seen like a bird-watching book my wife hasn't it's like I said she's really into it her brother's really into it so I grew up with a bird-watching book in the house and like the artist spot-on for how they're animated really ripped Iran has you're their mom always been in the birds for as long as I always thought I always seller was recent so just top notch on eicha coming I mean the iconography is very simple you know okay this is how many points are worth this is what its nest this is
how many eggs I can hold that's pretty much it and then the things for the you know resources that's that's pretty much it they didn't try and do I cannot raphy for abilities oh what the [ __ ] does this mean today they wrote it all out you have like I said beautiful artwork what which leads into what do you think of the production value this game was like 50 bucks what 50 or 60 bucks maybe 70 was shipping I would not cost think it was like 55 yeah I would not put shipping them to cause because right but um I would say for if it was 55 even if it was 60 I would say yeah yeah hey it's it's just amazing because it might it doesn't feel like it's not a lot you know you don't get like a huge sprawling board or anything but like quality quality quality quality right quality quality quality the dice yeah it's it's just outstanding like the way this game is produced and this is the way the board games are now you would think this came off Kickstarter and that was like a pledge and this was all stretch goals it wasn't and it was actually weirdly enough a dying breed of board games that was produced by the company and released it not through six years of Kickstarter you had they didn't have to do any of this they didn't to make a diced and that also doubles as
the cardholder not a diced and white like a card like like this lid pops off and all the cards go in it oh it's right okay yeah yeah and then ya dice Wow card tray and then a card holder for the display they didn't have to make different colored eggs these could have been tokens they didn't have to make a dice Tower that's a bird feeder which is completely adorable that's easy to put together small complaint it doesn't like it will fit back in the box we kind of have to Jimmy it or you have to take it apart you have to take the bottom part off but that's it um but anything like that it'd be nice if you can just you know pop it into the into the thing they didn't have to give you did like this deck of birds that we went through this game that was that's half the cards mm-hmm so there's another full deck of bird cards that are in here I think it was I can remember where it said it but I think this game has a hundred and seventy birds in the game so now the number of doubles so some of the abilities are doubles like we had hummingbirds the hummingbirds were like oh everyone you know gifts that gets a die from the dice trade and you get to pick but that doesn't bother me one because the birds that look different and they're probably worth different
points yeah your your hummingbird no no I mean words were the exact same but it was a different type of hummingbird but what I like about than having the same ability is because there are so many it would kind of suck to play this engine building game and you're like well that would be perfect if I could get that in my hinging but you happen to draw the card you know so I don't mind that there's duplicate abilities because it's only fair to utilize the engine so that's enough about how raving about the quality of this game um let's see is there anything that you don't like about this game how the artwork on that on the boards are really cool what makes us all so awesome is that your player board that you're playing on doubles as like a journal like or the back looks like it's like a bird-watching journal so I thought that's nice but you have any negatives about the game I'm trying to think of some and I can't I can really I can't really think of any I guess in it's super super dumb but like a small one would be like it really really won't run away because the more you put your goals down all of a sudden you're like oh [ __ ] I don't have like five actions this time like oh you don't like that I can just
see how it can be a negative huh I see it as an extra challenge but like if you're trying to think right right if you're really reaching yeah um personally I much like that mechanic hi well you're right right because I mean it would it only makes sense that you would be able to do less because at that point your engines built more or less and you're trying to get more birds and just try and get especially by the fourth round you're just trying to get the most points it's like get some some high-end birds played and utilize the engine from from where your birds are giving you that I I think it would be too much if you always had eight action right by the end of the game so I like that I think like you said it gives necks for challenge that yeah the game goes on I like the fact that each round has a round objective that would be different these are double-sided so you might not always have this so not only do you have your main goal to go for you also have round goals and this actually this tile is double-sided the one that we've done is the this is the non-competitive side of it that everyone gets points based on how well they did the backside is whoever is in first place like oh hey whoever had the most Birds I get four points you get one like or hey you had more eggs in your hatcheries
great you know you get six points I get three and then so it goes it you know there's more competition so just alright yeah we all did well so I like the fact that they give you the option of being passive or not really aggressive but more points are are to be had the better you do so I like that um you mentioned the last time you played I like the fact I'm not every egg does something like they're all different colors just for the sake of being different colors it's not like oh man I need a bunch of react right right it says hey eggs there you go points you get for that feathers everything is like this game is so streamlined that the rulebook is 11 pages and in all reality like that's probably more than it actually needs to be like I think this game is very very simple but it has it's one of those games that and Brad and I have talked about this a lot with some games it's simple to learn and but it has a depth to it right as well right so what do you think of the engine building well I think this is my first time doing an engine builder um no you play terraforming Mars terraforming Mars is an engine builder basically that would be from the one that comes off the top of my head is terraforming Mars because
that's that's the most popular one right now and ever and then now everyone's attention is on wingspan right well I think the engine building is pretty neat because it's not overwhelming I can see how it easily could be because you're given a lot of potential with something like that and I can see how if you get a little too maybe excited in your design when you're making games that I can just go kind of haywire where it just spirals out of control and everybody is like I don't want to [ __ ] listen to your turn because and so people just started to get like irritated with each other I think that was so simple and sometimes helped everybody else sometimes it was like well I sure could use a fish right now and you had an engine that would eventually pop off yeah eventually she couldn't rely on it but but it didn't hurt right like what makes this game great is it's not cutthroat so I'm gonna compare this to terraforming Mars because that's probably the most recent besides this one engine building game that we've played in terraforming Mars that I mean that's that's a brilliant game as well and I love it however it is a lot of okay I'm gonna do this Bam Bam Bam Bam Bam Bam Bam Bam and all this stuff is gonna trigger and like you said it's like I'm gonna give a [ __ ] yeah like it's like you were just talking right now yeah all this stuff benefits me however in wingspan you have your engine but and how I originally thought this game was going to be was you do something and it all your burns trigger but in this one it's not you have three
rows of where your birds can go with the the forest the the field and then the water and you do each row action and you do only birds in that row only if they're brown birds so once again how I mentioned this game a stream line is you have essentially four types of birds you have birds that are just pretty much hi a lot of points and they do nothing you have which I still haven't seen any uh there's white birds there they are oh no there are some wind plate birds like that they activate when you play them and that's it you have your brown birds which are going to be your engine birds that trigger based on where they're at you have your pink birds that are once between turds that go off with other people do stuff and then you have your just one that's the ones that don't do anything so those are your four it's it's simply color-coded and so when you look at your turn like I might get some food okay I'll take these dice and then you just move your action cube over okay that's not Brown move okay now it is well whenever I I gain uh food from the hatch or from there and then you just it's so simple and a lot of times you other people are engaged with they're like oh oh wait did you or did you lay eggs oh great I also get to lay eggs well I love about this game is there's no did you lay eggs actually this ability allows me to take those or oh this actually removes your birds terraforming Mars has fuck-you cards in it that completely demonic it's almost
they're kind of like they're for the sake of being they're kind of like however Dell kind of had some of those cards where it's like the majority of the deck is nice nice and let me build my thing and then there's like five that are like a big middle finger yeah this game doesn't have any of that it's it's either okay this kind of helps me a little bit I'm just gonna gain points for it or I mean really the only thing you could think of is okay well hmm I really don't want them to get more eggs so I guess I won't lay eggs but you have to lay eggs so it's like all right well I've gained three eggs and yeah you can have one I never once wanted to like hurt you throughout this game right I was always excited to just play and see what kind of birds I can get and just be like oh man and there was some you get to see some really good combos like one of mine my birds were backwards and it was like okay well one that allowed me to discard a fish to be able to tuck two cards and then the bird literally right next to that gave me a fish and I'm like man it'd be really nice if those were full slob because then I gained a fish and I can use that same fish to tuck cards and then you can just do that over and over and over and over and just keep tucking and getting a lot of points so there's like you said there's a lot of potential here with with these cards and it's just it's not me right it's not me at all this is a very very wholesome game and I love the secret objectives there are birds in here that can give you more like more secret objective
cards so you're not just kind of hosed on well the entire game because some of them are difficult well I'm I'd say they're difficult but another thing that I love is they give you a percentage of what like the one I took for example the water one which I can't find it was 18 percent of cards out of the whole hundred and seventy eighteen percent which is what do math do that math love the table you're in I mean let's see let's see that is 30 cards there any total cards that that could have given me the fish icon and all Rio and that's why I took it because I was like if I can get four then I get eight points and that's a lot I only got three and so it got me three points okay five-point difference but so these aren't like I like how these aren't like super easy to get and you're just okay well I guess I just got that like some of them really like you have to work like you actually end up taking a fish I would have gotten four but you end up drawing cards and I'm like oh yes and there's one in there oh no no there was one I don't think it was then it was whenever the vulture was there and you took everything but the vault covered the ground nesters and I was like well yeah this is becoming increasingly difficult anyway we've only played this
as a two-player game I think this works really well at - I like it like I don't feel like anything's missing from playing this is a two-player game right like we didn't come away being like yeah we need like four people like I asked yesterday how many I could play up to the news curiosity one two five yeah yeah and it's it's just one of those things that like the more people you have that I mean there's probably you probably have less birds in your thing well no not even then because it always refreshes at the end of their turn so you would just have more competition for the birds that you potentially want yeah I mean but even then and then actually probably help you because you have more people triggering yeah your cards and then them triggering yours or you triggering there so but once again there's no coupler like terraforming Mars can be pretty cut through trying to draft these cards and and play them to you know corporate over this it's just wholesome this made me like birds like they did a good job the other thing some that some people might not like is while I think the abilities of the birds very lightly relate to their their snippet of info which I love how they have the info I think it's phenomenal it just brings a little more life into the game um there are some things it is at its core a gyro engine builder so like tucking cards is why I
am i tucking cards I mean but if you read the thing it's like oh this like but then one of the birds I had looks like it made it it can make like till it dies or whatever and that was a tuck card it's like okay it's kind of its mating some cards like allow you to put a whole bunch of eggs down that's because it's like ability was or its little snippet was yeah the cowbird lets you put an egg on to a different nest it's because the cowbird that's what it does is it lays its eggs in a host nests and if it gets really host yes yep um the only thing that I can think of is I need that I can't find it but I do remember that it reading this this game has 170 birds that are around the North America so what I think could be cool if they just wanted to support this maybe a little bit more which I don't think they have to I think the art illustrations and the amount of cards you get anyway is already talked knowledge but let's say it's something that could be cool is they can do an expansion of a different region you know come up with with some different maybe if people want it to be a little bit more cutthroat or competitive you can add in some more some more competitive Birds or some cards like that from a different region of the world cuz you have like I said most of it I believe those North America you could do you right right but but I think all of them are North America the majority of yeah so I think if they
could do Asia or Australia Australia there's the cutthroat expansion they dissolve 13-foot bird yeah uh uh so I think they could do stuff like that maybe add a little bit more objectives no maybe not Qarth objectives but round objectives maybe different variants on on how to play but that's just me just asking for a little bit more because I really like the game so that's that's pretty much all I got you got anything else no scale one to ten dang all eight I expected that to be higher I'm a giver than nine I I really like this game stone Meyer is it might be my favorite company I don't think I've played the game by them that I haven't liked so stone Meyer is just fantastic also just got a shout out that one of my one of my little cup things came came busted and they replaced it with like it within like two days so just talk knowledge quality service hole of the game everything's phenomenal like I just I love it so that is wingspan everyone let us know what you think of wingspan in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe for wonderful with every time of day just for you hey everyone thanks so much for watching this and if you like this video then click the subscribe button below to
enjoy any video that I put out and right next to that subscribe button it's a little bell click that so you get notified of whenever I actually upload these videos if you want to support the channel you can definitely visit my patreon page the link is in the description below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful with every time of day this for you