A Place for All My Books Review - Are You Tired of the People Yet?
Transcript
Hey, I'm Alex Radcliffe from Board Game Co, and today I'm reviewing A Place for All My Books from Smirk & Dagger Games. [snorts] A Place for All My Books is a one-to-four player worker placement game of trying to arrange your books as nicely as possible in your little apartment over here in order to get as many points as possible through fulfilling your little projects and honestly just having a lot of books and other neat stuff. No, that's that's literally what it's called. It's literally called other neat stuff. But with that said, before we dive into the review, this channel is sponsored by All Play more about that at the end of the video. And in A Place for All My Books, what you're going to be doing is trying to gather books and organize them as efficiently as possible. You're doing that primarily to fulfill your little projects over here, which we'll show you in a second, as well as your major accomplishments, which you're going to lay out before the game begins. On your turn, you're going to take your little uh workers, so to speak, and then place them on one of the little spots in your apartment trying to basically organize your books through the actions. Let's first take a look at these little projects. Little projects will have various requirements of things you're trying to do, and they're worth two points each plus a little bonus. So, for example, this one wants to have four green books among the apartment's four corner spaces. Now, I have four green books in my apartment. The problem is right now only one of them is on a corner space. So, I'd have to rearrange my books over here. We have one over here, we have one there, and then we have two on this stack here. I'd have to somehow rearrange those to get those into my corners. We also have the bedroom. Have three plus tall stacks in your bedroom. My bedroom location is going to be over here. I have one tall stack. Again, not three yet. We have a den. Have three plus tall stacks in my den. I have none over here. And we have have three plus tall stacks that have no red books. I have one tall stack that
has no red books. And then we have three plus tall stacks amongst your four central spaces. So, we basically want to get our hands on a lot of books in order to fulfill a lot of these projects over here. So, let's take a look and see what we can do. We're going to go ahead and take a gather action. I'll take a sort action. We're going to gain one social battery. In the game, social battery is a currency that you're going to gain while you take actions at home before you go out into the village over here into the town in order to go ahead and spend your social battery, very thematic. So, we gain one social battery. You can pick up a stack of books and distribute them to the top of any stacks or empty spaces, maximum two per stack. So, I'm going to pick up this stack over here, and what I can try to do is I can try to go ahead Ooh, this is actually interesting. How do I want to do this over here? Maybe I should, you know, I'm on I'm going to try and to min-max it too much. I'm not I'm not going to look at worry too much about it. Let's just go ahead and take this, and we're going to put one down over here, let's say. We'll put two down over here, and then we'll put one down over over here. No particular reason. That's going to be our little placement. So, again, we picked up a stack, we gained a social battery, and we put them down at other spaces, maximum two per space. When it comes back to us, cuz everyone on your turn you take a single action, when it comes back to us, I will take one more action.
Maybe I go ahead and rest. Rest is not the worst right now. I can't really accomplish as efficiently as I like. I'm actually going to go into read a book. I'll gain two social battery, and then I'm going to take one book and put it on my nightstand. I didn't get to take it from anywhere. In fact, actually, I'm going to have to say that I put that over there. You'll see why in a second. So, my last turn, I'll have sorted there. So, then I will take one book, I'll take that red book out of the stack, and put it into my nightstand. You can take a book from absolutely anywhere, even in the middle of a stack. And your nightstand is particularly helpful because you can actually take books from your nightstand and trade them in when you get to town, more on that later. So, that was two actions. Comes back to my turn, and now I'll take an admire action. If I was playing the game, I'd probably take a few more organizations, but we can go ahead and take an admire action. So, an admire action is going to be how you accomplish your various little projects over here. So, I'm going to take a look right now. Do I have Oh, no, no, I wanted to do one more thing that I wanted to do. No, I could do Honestly, we're fine. We're fine. We're just going to stick with it.
It's fine. So, we don't have three stacks in my bedroom yet. We don't have three stacks in my den yet. We do have three tall stacks that have no reds because I removed the red from the stack, and so we have one, two, three tall stacks that have no red books. I can go ahead and put this face down, and I'll gain two points at the end of the game, and I'll get an other neat stuff card right now. So, I have this. Ooh, we got a game of Boop. Look at that, a little bonus game over here. If we collect four games, we'll get at points. Let's put that there, and let's put this in my face down pile to show that I've completed a little project. Then over here, I have three plus small stacks among my central spaces. I don't. So, I don't believe I gotten any of those. But the other thing I do have is every time you admire, you gain three social battery. One, two, three. If your green, in my case it's green, if green is the most common color in my apartment. Every player is going to have a different preferred color. So, everyone's going to basically say if your most preferred color is the one in your apartment, you can go ahead and get an extra three social battery. The game is going to start off with everyone having your most preferred color in your apartment. But as you go to town, that distribution might change. Speaking of town, once you've done enough over here, and maybe I take a few more turns, maybe not, maybe I'd go down to rest where you can go ahead and gain two social battery, plus draw two little projects before discarding down to five. There's a few of these various actions, but eventually, you're going to want to head to town because that's where you get more books, which will make accomplishing little projects easier, plus every book is worth an extra point at the end of the game. So, I'm going to take the leave the house action. I'm going to lose five social battery. So, whenever you leave the house, you immediately lose five social battery just because you have to work up the anxiety and nerve to actually go out and go to town. But from there,
you still are going to be spending social battery while in town. So, for example, maybe I'm going to go ahead and go to the bookstore. Bookstore's a good place to get a bunch of books. So, I'll go ahead and spend three social battery. One, two, three over here. Spend an additional three, plus that five, and I'll take the medium stack of books from the bookstore, putting them into my backpack while I'm able to take them home, plus the specific little project card in that space. Whenever you do that, you're going to refill the little project card, as well as adding a book to each of the spots. So, one, two, three, making sure there's always going to be more books being added to the bookstore. Additionally, when you go to town for the first time, you're going to advance the sun tracker by one, which is going to be the round counter for the game. So, at any time anyone goes to town, that advances the sun tracker. When it comes back to my turn, maybe I'll go ahead and go to the library over here. I'll draw four books from the bag.
One, two, three, four over here, and then I'll pick one of them to add to my backpack, and then the others, in fact, if I want green, maybe I'll take that green to make sure my distribution works out, and the others will go to the various stacks over here, again, adding more books to the bookstore. At the exchange, you could return any number of books from your nightstand space, and then take that many books plus one of any colors you want from the bag. So, you get to go ahead and trade one for two or three for four, but you really get color selection, which is one of the main advantages of that spot. At the village shop, you can spend social battery to take any of the neat stuff, either randomly from the top, either of these or paying nine to get both of these in order to have more neat stuff, which is worth points and often gives abilities as well. And then lastly, the town park isn't a spot you go to, but rather the town park is a spot you get bumped to. If a player wants to go to a spot that you're in, they can bump you, you'll go into the park, but you will get two social battery for being bumped to go ahead and go to the park. It is a shame you can't visit the park of your own free will, but I understand why you can't, because you'd have an unlimited pool of social battery, and the game will kind of wants you to go back home to get more social battery.
Thematically, I don't know about that one part. But anyways, that's basically what's going on at town. So, the game in general, just to kind of recap things, is you're going to spend time organizing your apartment. You're going to move around books and configure them, primarily in a goal of getting little projects completed, because it'll award you with various other neat stuff, but it'll also award you with social battery and many of these cards, which will help you ramp up quicker in order to go back to town, where you can acquire more books, as well as acquiring more neat stuff, and hopefully along the way you'll be accomplishing a bunch of little projects, filling up with books, as well as accomplishing these major accomplishments, which will vary game to game. But things like have six matching books on your nightstand, have three plus stacks at maximum height, or maybe have four other neat stuff from the village shop. There's a bunch of these options you'll take your little markers and put them on there whenever you achieve them. The person who achieves them first gets the higher value, and people who achieve them later in the game get the lower value, although multiple people can, it's not limited to one. That is basically how you play A Place for All My Books. There may be a few small things that I missed, but that's the general overarching goal. The last thing to cover though, is at the end of the game, when this go to the end, every other player will get one more turn, you finish the round, and every player gets one more turn, but this is effectively the clock on the game, giving every player on average two and a bit trips to town. That's kind of how it works out, depends on the player count, but usually looking at two and a bit, you know, one player might get three, although it could vary depending on how the players play the game. With that, let's go ahead and dive into my reviews, thoughts and opinions on A Place for My Books of what I like, don't like, and can see others not liking, starting off with what I like.
To begin with, the game is incredibly charming. Before anything else, this game wins on charm alone. The game is incredibly like thematic as far as the uh the book aspect of things, the organizations of like putting books around your apartment for a variety of goals is a lot of fun. The idea that you're increasing your social battery while you stay home before going out into town and spending the social battery, and the balance of trying to make that work, especially early game, cuz early game you kind of need to get more books, but you also need to build up your social battery. So, maybe you rest a bit more, maybe you make sure to read a few more books. There's a bunch of ways you can bump that up while preparing yourself for that first trip to town. Subsequent rounds you have a lot more books in your apartment, giving you a lot more room to manage those little projects and accomplish a bunch of them at once. If you can accomplish a bunch of these at once, that is incredibly satisfying to do so, because they can be very hard, but you can try to organize. Have a full column where the top stack of each book is the same color. You can do that, and you can also do that along with having four of the green books in the corner, and a bunch of tall stacks in the bedroom, and the den, and the little things over here.
This already this one have three plus tall stacks among the central spaces. Well, one's already in the bedroom and the den, so you're already working your way towards those other ones. You can try to make as much as of books from town. In town there is a degree of bumping and competition. You didn't really see it cuz I'm just kind of doing my own little solo thing over here while I show you how to play the game, but if you're playing this game, especially if you're playing at three or four players, but even at two players, you will find yourselves being in town at the same time, and you want players out of your way. Oh, wait a second, look how many books you can get over here. I'm going to pop over there, but then eventually I need to go ahead and get books as well. So, maybe I'll go ahead and bump you out. But then meanwhile you go back to the library where I go to the shop, and now you need something in the shop, you can constantly find yourself being bumped around in town, which is both satisfying from a strategic aspect, making sure you're in the right place at the right time, making sure you get to the desired spots, but also just fun to visit the park and get a little social battery restored as you do that.
Overall, the game gives you a nice puzzle as far as the little projects. That's going to be the main strategic hook of the game, getting those little projects in play and trying to accomplish as many as possible with as few actions. And then the game also gives you a bunch of neat stuff. There's a lot of neat stuff in this deck. Tons of little things you can go pin collecting. Well, I think actually that might be a crowdfunding extra, so uh you can possibly go pin pin collecting depending on your copy. But in general, there's a ton of stuff that are both fun to have, but also give you a lot of abilities. Do you want to score extra points for having a certain color of books in your room? Get a little lucky kitty and put it on the board getting those. There's wild books. There's all these kinds of abilities, and the neat stuff are very fun to add to your to your to your game. As far as what I don't like in the game, first of all, there is a degree of over over optimization analysis paralysis going on here. This is one of those games where the weight class of what the game is giving you versus the amount of thinkingness to try to accomplish. When you have a handful of five little projects and you're trying to accomplish them at once, you can have players dragged down in trying to really just optimize. Well, I have to take a sort then a gather. By the way, you can't take the same action two turns in a row.
You have to move from top spot. So, I'm taking a sort then a gather. Maybe then I go and read a book, and I'm going to try to accomplish those. There can be a lot of thinkingness to getting your little projects got done, which can be a little out of proportion to the weight class that the game is in. It's one of those things where the overall decision space is decent, but not huge, but the min-maxing on your little projects can certainly slow things down. I'll say that my bigger issue is probably I'm unsure on the replayability that the game provides. Outside of the major accomplishments being slightly different, which doesn't provide a major gameplay difference because you're already balancing your little projects. These are already going to be slightly different configurations, so the accomplishments don't really feel like they change your game in any meaningful way so much as just being another little project that happens to be public to try to balance. The neat stuff is probably the main thing that I enjoy every time I dive into this again. It's more like, "Oh, I didn't see that card. Oh, that's a new card." So, that charm of trying to uncover new neat stuff is I think where the game keeps giving. But, outside of that, I'd say the replayability does feel a little bit on the lower end.
While there is strategic reward to trying to organize the books in your in your I was going to say bedroom, but your apartment in general. I think the general puzzle, the feeling of that puzzle is similar game to game. So, for me, the replayability, the neat stuff is the main thing that I enjoy seeing each time I dive back into it. As far as I can see others not liking, only trips only having only two trips to go to town can definitely feel on the low end. I think that the game does a good job as far as not feeling too long or too short for what it is. So, while I personally do feel like getting a third trip to town could be nice, it also would inherently make the game longer, and I feel the game is an appropriate length for where it is right now. So, it's that weird balance where I both understand why you'd want to have a a third trip there. And again, someone could have a third trip, but I I understand why you'd want more, but I think it would just change the game ratio, so I'm fine with it as it is. I'll also say the randomness of the neat stuff is something that can be a little frustrating. Over here, you're going to go ahead and get points if you get extra games. That pin collecting, you need extra pins. Some of these neat stuff come in sets or combos, and if you don't get those sets and combos, there's not a lot of control. Like, you're top decking a lot of the time. You can't really clear the board over here, so you're kind of limited to whatever selection is available with minimum amount of choice and a lot more top decking in order to get what you want, and that can be a little less satisfying experience, especially if you are looking for those sets. Having players get incredibly helpful cards, and you're like, well, I got one book out of a set, you know, one, you know, game out of a set, or one pin out of a set, that can be a more frustrating experience. As far as final thoughts on A Place for My Books, this game is incredibly charming. It's incredibly charming. Although, I will say that the charm is probably its strongest asset. The gameplay is good,
make no mistake. I enjoy the gameplay, but I think the gameplay is good, and the charm is amazing. So, for me, the biggest concern with that is that the replayability factor primarily so far comes from the other neat stuff. I think that I'm lacking a little bit more of a reason to continuously dive into this one because the strategic element is present, the charm is top-notch, and finding other new stuff is the main area where I enjoy that. Combine that with a little bit of analysis paralysis in a game that's a little bit on the lighter side, and I definitely enjoyed this one. Rating-wise, I'd give this a 3.5 out of 5, but I do think it falls into that category where I'm always happy to play it and a little bit less likely to suggest it myself. As far as other game recommendations, if you're looking for other book-themed game book-themed games, definitely check out Ex Libris from Renegade Games, I think Renegade Games, if I'm not mistaken. That's a game about sorting books, but this time you're doing it alphabetically, as well as Astounding Mystic Library. That's another one. Both those are going to be other games where you're sorting books, but in an entirely different way. And did I mention that All Play is a channel sponsor? If you're interested in checking out games out of from All Play, you can go ahead and check out games both from them as well as their partner publishers. And regardless of where you are, there going to be a flat-rate shipping. For instance, in the US, it's going to be $4 flat-rate shipping. Check out Fiction if you're looking for another book-themed games. This one more late more leading into deduction and a Wordle-style gameplay, but if you want another book game but in a different variant, check out Fiction or Fiction: Banned Books. In any case, until next time, I'm Alex Radcliffe from Board Game Co. Hope you found this review helpful, and as always, I hope you have a good one.