Skip to main content
Loading video...

London Review - Chairman of the Board

Transcript 17:37

hey everybody today I'm talking about London by Martin Wallace now London is a card-based board game for two to four players takes about an hour to an hour and a half to play the game was originally released in 2010 but there was a second edition released in I believe it was 2017 by Osprey games which is the version I'm going to be reviewing and I've not played the original version so I can't really comment on that one and the idea of the game is that we are trying to rebuild the city of London after the Great Fire of 1666 every player is going to basically build their own tableau of cards and which are different buildings and stuff like that trying to get the most points as possible the game is as I said kind of focused on cards mainly as you were trying to manage your hand and stuff like that and mechanically the game is boiled down into four pretty simple actions which is um or each player's turn is going to consist of selecting one of those four actions and doing the appropriate thing so the first action is very simple simply drawing three cards into your hand the second one is to buy a borough card and these borough cards are kind of lingering abilities or they kind of give you one off benefits such as points or drawing more kite into your hand or losing poverty which I'll cover in a second the other action is to play cards from your hand because you've got three different basically suits of cars all made up of different colors and in order to play a card you not only have to and pay the

cost associated to that car so everything can cost money but you also have to discard a card of the light color of that card so if I wanted to play a brown card I'd have to discard another brown card in order to play it I don't see that's a weighted decision because you have to factor in what you are dismissing in order to use what you want to use and as I said it also has each cards can have a cost associated to them as well in terms of pounds when cards are played and some have kind of actions associated to them which you know give instant abilities but most of them will just sit there until you choose to select the other kind of action you can take you know term which is activate your city so when you do act city you will basically trigger all the abilities that go or from the cards you've played by um you know discarding these other cards and you're going to basically choose to either when you play this card you're going to choose to either put them on new kind of stacks or or kind of lay them on top of an existing stack because a lot of the cards when you activate the cities when you reap the rewards which can give you points or money or let you get rid of poverty or they can do all different kind of things you're going to have to flip them facedown which kind of means that cards done but the stack of cards will still remain there which can be very important because every time you run your city you have to take a amount of poverty which are these kind of accumulating negative points in kind of into your pool and you're going to get a poverty point for each stack of cards

you've got in front of you in your tableau and you're also going to get a poverty for each card remaining in your hand so when you've got an absolutely full hand of cards it's probably not the ideal time to to be running your poverty is quite interesting because the yet will amount you have isn't overly important as long as the other players have a similar amount because at the end of the game you are go to score negative points based on the difference between yourself and the player with the least amount of poverty so as long as you guys are pretty much on a path throughout the game it's not going to be that drastic but if you completely disregard the idea of poverty then you know you're going to get hit hard at the end of the game and it's probably going to cost you the game ultimately there is when you also when you run your city sometimes you have to pay additional costs so some might say discard another card from your hand some might say you know pay pay money each time you do it some might not even have to might not even have to be dipped over at all so they're going to be permanent abilities that you can use again and again and again and they might be things such as maybe take a pound for each each brown card you've got in your in your city or all stuff like that so the symbology and the different things that the cards do though it's actually not that much going on there is simply get your points get money I think it's maybe draw cards or stuff like that and stop and yeah there's not actually a lot of text-based card abilities or anything like that so I mean terms what the cards

do is very easy to digest and the another factor in the game is the discarding of the cards because as I said when you play those cards you do have to put them or you have to discard one of the matching colors but a cool thing about that is that when you discard them they they just go on a generic pile will never be seen again they'll go on a basically a communal discard board which means that they'll go face-up and when other players draw cards they will not only be able to draw from the kind of facedown stack of cards as you normally would in most board games you can actually draw from the face-up pile of discard cards that other players have already gotten rid of so there's another wrinkle there that the game has factored in I do really like that idea and it's a great way to kind of inject a bit of strategy into the game because you not only the way if your decision is going and what card you want to play you've also got a factor in what you're going to discard because you might be advantaging other players because they might want those class you discuss so a nice touch there and you know every time these cards are discarded the bud the board is kind of flushed and I make he keeps rotating so sometimes they will be you know taking out the game for good so there's not an overwhelming amount of cards I'm available on that discard board the game also includes this idea of taking loans so when you can when you run out of money because money is a fairly tight resource in this game and you can optionally take a loan and the loans come in kind of denominations of ten pounds and when you choose to take a loan you're going to take not only that

amount of money that the ten pounds but you're also going to take one of these loan these loan tiles and they're going to basically cost you a lot of money if you have any outstanding loads at the end of the game but you could pay them back at any time but you have to pay them back at fifteen pounds so if you've got cash flow problems you know taking loans is going to be an option but you could you have to factor in that you've got to have to pay that interest in order to in order to get rid of those loans and not have to sacrifice the points at the end of the game so again just another little wrinkle there just to make it a little bit more you know a little bit more to think about and something to factor in when you are choosing which cards to play and whether that that is worth the you know the risk of not being able to pay the loan back in order to do what you want to do I try to cover a bit about the borough cards as well so these borough cards are these kind of larger cards which as I said earlier you do have to pay money for in order to get them and they're pretty you know they're generally pretty much more expensive than the average College you'll pay and they'll as I said they'll give you either more cards to draw they'll give you you know the ability to get rid of poverty and I'll simply give you straight-up points as well and not only that some of them give you ongoing benefits which is really cool because I think this is one of the factors of the game I did find the most interesting where some of them will let you do things such as you know when you're playing the cards you normally have to discard a card of the same color some might say you know you don't have to do that anymore you can discard any color to play any card but you'd have to pay a

pound in order to do so some might say you know when you do run your city you don't have to take a poverty for each card in your hand so again really powerful abilities there but the thing about this is that obviously you're going to get a lot of points for taking these Baroque art so you're going to want to do them quite regularly but when you do take a new one you have to replace the ability of the existing one which can be quite a big sacrifice to make and not only that so the the young the burro cards are divided into kind of a few different sets so you've got the ones north of the River Thames and the ones south of the River Thames and some of the cards you play when you activate your city and kind of synergize with those you know those different sets it might say take an X amount of points for each northern borough card you've got or something like that so that's that's where the synergies come in and the the deck of cards that you're going to play through is um layered so you've got like the a set card and the B sets and the C sets and each so as the game progresses they're going to get gradually more powerful and more expensive so it does have a bit of progression that way and but ultimately I think the cards generally do work in the same way throughout they're just kind of ramped up in their abilities so mechanically this game is is very simple as I boil down into the and four easy steps or four easy choices that you've got to have to make on your turn but I think where the main decisions go into is when to activate your city because I said you you do want the rewards all the time obviously to

get your points and to get more money but just that poverty is such a difficult thing to balance and you know you said you don't want to play it when you've got loads of cards in your hand you know you got to be careful about how many stacks you're making because you know you could end up just having facedown stacks which not doing anything for you but they're still going to give you the poverty so yeah there's a lot of factor in the onus come on we've got this kind of economic feel to it which is quite hard to wrap your head around at times balance of the game the player balance of the game in terms of the different strategies you can take being you know being equal in their kind of opportunity is I think it's very well done because so the guy noticed is that if people to be completely you know ballsy and make a huge Pablo of cars and run their city to get really powerful benefits obviously you going to take a lot of poverty to counteract that so if someone has got a really streamline City that they want to they want to run they're all she's not going to be taking as much poverty but they're not going to be getting as much reward as well so those two things really do kind of you know counteract each other very well and at the end of the game your scoring will reflect that which is really nice the game takes about an hour to an hour and a half to play for me personally I think it did out States welcome I'm a bit because as I said the the cards aren't hugely varied and it did feel like you're pretty much doing the same thing throughout obviously you're getting your bigger your bigger tableau as the game goes on and you're going to be getting you know managing your poverty and stuff is going to really ramp up but I did

think it would have been nicer for it to take maybe about 45 minutes because I did I really did feel like it did start to run drag on a bit longer than it should have because I said there's a very big stack of cards you've got to get through up time of the game is really good to be fair there is I said the actions are very simple and very snappy and there's not really a huge amount to you know to to brain burn yourself or to give you analysis paralysis because mostly the cards are you know are pretty similar in their feel and you know if you need money you know gonna have to take you know actually it's to get money if you need to get rid of poverty you know you've got to do so there's not a huge amount of things pulling you in different directions which is which is quite nice replayability wise personally this is where I had a bit of an issue with the game I think there's not a whole lot to explore in terms of different things to do ultimately a lot of the games are going to feel very similar because there is not lots of different kind of things that mesh together there's not very um ultra powerful synergies that you need to explore or somebody there's not a lot of different things to you know things to go after this are the points the money you know the poverty that's pretty much what this game is about so there's not kind of you know out the box thinking that you can go explore time and time again most of that comes from the Burrow cards but as I said that that's a one-off thing and you're going to keep replacing that so you've not got that real strong engine building feel the player interaction mainly comes from

the you know the the relationship between how much poverty you have with the other players because I said you want to keep at least on a level playing field and not have to not overwhelm yourself of poverty because that's going to be a very difficult position to come back from I'm also the discard board as I mentioned is something to accounting to the player interaction aesthetically the game is absolutely stunning I love the art direction in this game I think it is absolutely you know wonderfully Illustrated it has this very charming feel to it the borough cards are look incredible the building illustrations are great and the characters are really kind of you know welcoming and they just look at it from a visual aspect I think the game is beryllium component quality as well you know the cards of a really good stock has a very clean iconography just a very slick looking game and I'm very impressed with the with the component quality and just the the visual appeal of the game and the theme of the game well as well as is really nice I mean I'm obviously from England so I've been to a lot these places which obviously does it does fact

rim and but I think the theme is this game almost feels like would be a great like souvenir because there is so much different artwork of all the different regions and London all the different you know the iconic landmarks and stuff like that and they're almost all the castles like postcards it's just a fantastic package in terms of its theme and its artwork and it's just I can really see this game appealing to like you know to tourists and stuff like that because this would make a really great souvenir and not only that I mean the games itself is solid so it would act as a almost as a kind of a great tool to get people into the Hobby because you know you're more kind of civilian people who aren't you know as nerdy as we are would pick up this game because it looks so nice and maybe give it a go and think oh you know what this game isn't as you know brainless as a lot of the games we used to play when we were kids so this is some really nice touch there set up as head our time is really nice to be fair you've got the three different layers of cars give them a shuffle and you're pretty much good to go the the scalability of the game works well I mean I think it's going to work equally as well as two three or four so yeah no issues there at all and if I had to compare this game to anything I'm not really sure what I would give it to I mean I think there'd be a lot of kind of gateway level gamers who would you know really liked this game and enjoyed this game I see players who would play games like wingspan would enjoy this because

it's got a very similar waiting it's got that almost similar feel to it where you're building stuff up and then running your engine so I would recommend to play this game to players who like games of that of that waiting but over for me and this is a really solid design I mean Martin Wallace is a game as a game designer who's you know hugely acclaimed this is actually the first game of his I've ever played I've never played brass or anything like that but I must have met a my my expectations that this game was going to be a lot heavier than what it was and would have a lot more going on than what it was and maybe that's where the you know the the grinding of my expectations in the game came together and I was a bit a bit underwhelmed with our how the game was I that's not in terms of its design it's just in terms of its complexity yeah there wasn't a lot for me to really you know to get me excited I couldn't see some really powerful combinations that being said I did like the the different kind of feel of the game where you've got to constantly worry about your poverty rather than just you know keep building up and building up and just smashing your own tableau through again and again and again so I like the way that the game did factor that in that you can't just do that you do have to think about when you're going to use it you're going to have to manage your hand quite carefully think about what cards you can get rid of my stuff at that so there is some decisions to go into this but ultimately for me there wasn't enough you know variability in what the cards did know some of them might be you know take you know don't pay anything but get to points so they might say you know pay a pound but get four points some might say you know discard a card

but get three points so they're very they're very similar in their field but just have a kind of a relative cost associated to that and for me that just wasn't enough for me to keep coming back to this game now that being said I did enjoy my player there it's not going to stay in my collection or anything like that and but yeah I said I can really see this game appealing to Gateway gamers or players who don't want to go you know take that next step beyond you know games of the weight of of wingspan and stuff at that you know this family weighted games this is something they can really check out and enjoy and as I said the game is just beautiful to look at which is um you know is is a great thing so yeah that's my thoughts on London a solid game but one that I personally you know wasn't mad about but yeah objectively the game is very solid and well put together and it gets a decent verdict for me I've put it a six point six which again is is certainly not a negative review whatsoever it just isn't quite for me or what I'm looking for and so that concludes my review of London if you have enjoyed the review please hit like and subscribe to my channel I check out my other reviews too you can also support me by following me on Instagram and and patreon as well so I'll put the links below for those after everyone else I'll see you next time I'm chairman of the board bye

Progress saved