Skip to main content
Loading video...

5 Cards That Define The Path to Carcosa (Arkham Path to Carcosa Week 2025)

Transcript 45:19

Hello everybody and welcome to our list video here for Path of Carosa week. I'm joined once again by Daniel. Daniel, have you been enjoying Path of Carosa week?

It's so good. My favorite video was the one yesterday.

It was a good video.

Yeah, I really liked what happened about 5 minutes in. That was like really surprising.

So, make sure you watch at least that far in.

Yeah, you have to see at least the first five. Maybe the first seven. That would be good, too. Get the watch time going.

There we go. Um last uh for our last one of these we did the five cards that define the Dunage Legacy and we're continuing that here today with the five cards that define the path to Carcosa. Um so we're going to just dive in, get this going, uh talk about all these cards here. Notably, these cards aren't in like a specific order. They're kind of just uh the order that we put them on the list here. So uh at least it was for me. I don't know about for you, but

I don't know. You put them in on the slides. I have no idea what order they're in. I I actually put them in the order you gave me so with the numbers on that one. So yeah. All right.

So I'm going to throw this one to you first to start us off here with our first card for the path to Carcosa and that is

the man of the palad mask. So thematically this is just obviously the the card that defines Path of Carosa the most. It is the recurring enemy in this campaign. A lot of campaigns have something like that, but this one's even more special because it's a weakness that goes into your deck. And boy howdy, Carcosa likes to put weaknesses in your deck. So, this to me is more than just the cool thematic uh enemy that shows up and you have to keep chasing him throughout the entire campaign, which I think is really cool and there's a, you know, slightly interesting payoff for that in the very last scenario. But I just like that through line. But yeah, you get this guy if you're a lead investigator potentially. You get another weakness in Echoes the past. You for sure get a weakness at the beginning of Phantom of Truth, I think,

and then there's another one given to you before Black Stars Rise. So, you can end up with a crap ton of weaknesses in your deck, and that's something we haven't seen since this campaign. Yeah, it's it's very interesting uh because you get a lot of weaknesses and you actually in in all my recent plays of both Carcosa and Dunich where I was keeping track of XP, Carcosa actually gives out less XP than Dunich, but it doesn't have the same sort of uh uh like identity that Dunich has in the community. And it's like it's that onetwo punch of like less XP but more uh and more weaknesses makes it so that it's a pretty hard finale especially as we get later in this video talking about what is kind of the mechanical identity of this campaign. And as prepping and recording all these videos for Carcosa week, it's really made me realize what that identity is. And I think the man in the pallet mask kind of showcases that.

And it's all about restrictions. It's identity. The mechanical identity for your path carcosa is to try to slow you down or restrict you as much as possible. While there is a lot of horror, which we're going to be talking about coming up, I think that this guy is kind of here to show that this guy is in the first scenario, he impedes uh your progress. He stops you from ending the scenario. You need to get rid of him. And then later on, this guy, he asks you to go out of your way to try to get a better result for the final scenario. And then he comes back uh for one last story beat before the finale. And once again is kind of gating your progress through the scenario. And it's kind of this is his identity for the campaign, which is just like it is all about stopping you from doing what you want to do or slowing you down in that process.

So, in the palad mask, which is that one last story beat I think you're referring to before the finale, he has a little bit of a connection to the doubt convection routes as well, right? You can either do the clue spending or you can defeat him

in order to progress that scenario and that corresponds to uh marking doubt or conviction. So, it's a nice story beat with that. Um, I think that's the only time that really matters in in that respect. But otherwise, I think it also has this investigate action on an encounter card theme that we might see show up later in this list, too.

Mhm. Mhm. Mhm.

Do you ever What do you think you do with this guy most often? Do you ignore him? Do you do the investigate? Do you try to kill him? Does

If I'm playing two player, I usually just ignore him because it's hard to find the time. Um, with Travis and Bren, we're playing three player. they like to go out of their way to get rid of him to mark as many chasing the stranger as we possibly can. Uh so that's something that I al I'll strive for in three player. But in two-player, which I've played in the majority of my Carosa recently, it's a lot harder to find the time if I don't have to go out of my way. Um but this guy's spawn location kind of makes it so that generally you have to go out of your way. What about you?

Yeah. Um, I think the investigate is just easier, but sometimes it's not. Obviously, that first scenario it can be pretty tough because he might show up in a high shroud location, then you're dealing with like a

a six or something. Um, the the fight is like kind of difficult. It's a fouright enemy. He's got a lof. He's got three health. So, that's like conveniently right out of range of a spectral razor.

Yep.

To completely kill him cuz he's elite. Although I think the new whispers of doom card will solve him, right? Because that does three damage to an elite enemy.

But it's tough test will be at four at least. Um I mean you can use him for other stuff too, but he does impede progress. He could potentially in the unspeakable oath spawn in the garden and now he's a ready enemy that you have to deal with before you can get out. And that's like that's like the ultimate him running defense is like what the heck is this guy doing that doesn't he he's a very uh welldesigned I mean that's like uh what Pat Carcosa is. It's just a very welldesigned campaign from top to bottom right. Like there's a few blips but like Echo of the Past's biggest sin is kind of just that it's boring not that it's like bad right?

Yeah. But this guy is just like he is just perfectly fits with what everything that whole campaign is about and it's kind of just incredible.

Yeah, it's so smart. I mean, we're going to see I think the next card is also related to him.

So, there's an encounter set that goes into the into several scenarios, not all of them, that is literally all about the man the palad mask, too. So, whether he gets summoned from your deck or other things happen,

he's he's present in every scenario. It's crazy how well that works for a card that is in your deck and they've never tried that before or after rather and you know they may not need to repeat things but it's such an interesting design.

Um when I played Carcosa for Iron Man a month ago plus um playing Norman Withers meant that you draw this guy a lot.

Yeah. just naturally, which is both good because you're not drawing spending actions drawing uh cards. You're not getting an upkeep, uh, you know, bled out from this draw. Uh, and that's true of all the weaknesses for him, but you just see him a lot. So, there's more opportunity to have to deal with him in some way. So, it's really cool.

I'll throw my card up here because mine is directly related to the man in the paladin mask. This is the mark by the sign where it's a brain test. If you fail, take two horror. But if the man in the paladin mask is in play, it's plus two difficulty and it's considered direct horror. This is actually probably from the patron game days, the Carcosa card that has caused us the most grief and has threatened to kill the most players whenever we're playing the path to Carcosa or or like a scenario where the man in the pallet mask can show up, which he usually is included in a lot of the standalone scenarios when you play that campaign. But this kind of just like shows the threat where this card as it own is basically just a slightly it's it's it's like a rotting remains type of thing. It's adjacent, right? Where if you fail by two, you're taking two horror. Downside is if you fail by one, you're still taking two horror. But two horror is very soakable.

Like a lot of people have that. Like a Peter Sylvester just says, "That's me, baby. I'll I'll I'll hold this for you." But the man of the paladin mask is kind of like what this card showcases I think in a way that's very obvious to see that a lot of these other cards uh treacheries don't show is the combo potential that the game can bring you. This card is uh giving you its combo on the actual card here. It's saying hey this card by itself pretty plain. However, if you are not if you if this man of the palad mask is in play this is now a fourbrain test with two direct horror which is a very scary encounter card. with peril, too. So, often, maybe this happens in the patron game days, but you're relying on other people because it's like three or four player, right? Oh, someone's got a guts to throw out.

Nope. Now, it's a four test that no one else can help with. Yikes.

Yes. Yep. And and it always finds its way to the investigator with the least uh sanity to take it to. It just the game knows that that's the best person to throw that at. Um,

and we'll talk more about the horror later, but I think this is just a a really interesting card, too. And I'm glad you brought up the the combo part of this because actually I think a lot of at the Carcosa, the encounter sets are designed around these sorts of combos that you don't see as much with the lower player counts, but in the higher player counts you do. Um, we might see at least one of those cards later, but a lot of them are just like you draw it and it looks in in a vacuum like nothing, but the reality is a lot of things can change in between uh one phase and the next and you're suddenly saying, "Wait a minute, Shroud is a lot higher or there's more doom in play or in this case, the man of the palad mask is in play." So things can get out of hand in ways that I don't think the other campaigns take advantage of as much the sort of combo between the encounter cards themselves. But yeah, we'll see some more here and talk about it again.

Yeah. Uh, so I don't have much more to say about this one uh because it's was directly related to the man in the palad mask. So I think we can just move on to your next card here which is So there's this whole hidden card mechanic which this is the first time we've ever seen it came. It was there was a repreeze I suppose in Dream Eaters and I don't remember if they've used it anywhere else uh in official campaigns, but the idea is that you secretly add this card to your hand and then you do some weird things like not being able to move more than once each turn and all your teammates are looking at you saying, "Come on, let's go. We need to leave the asylum already." And you're like, "Uh, I can't."

Yep.

Now, um this is cool thematically, right? the fact that this campaign is all about something going on your head maybe and having something that you cannot speak of um is a really cool way to do this. I think unfortunately having played these campaigns too many times now or maybe not enough times, who knows? But so many times that we just know

what the cards are like someone has you can see that it's in your someone else's hand, right? back of the card is an encounter card. And obviously, you know, when someone drew the card and they didn't just resolve it, right? Then, it must be one of these encounter cards. There's four of these guys, right? There's the can't commit skill cards, the skill tests, can't play events,

uh can't move more than once each turn, and then can't uh do free triggered abilities, I believe, is the last one.

Yeah. And if you know that that's the deal, which at least we do, then you can tell what people have. And it starts to lose a little bit of that uh coolness, I think, that you get the first few times you play. So, it's less hidden and more just like now it has a different ability, which is junking up your hand, which can matter for other cards,

and then it takes these two actions to get rid of. And that is actually painful.

Yes. the two actions on this one where you're thinking, okay, I can space out my moves and just hope that that's going to get me there and leave this in my hand or I take two actions now just to get rid of this

and then you only have one action left and you move anyway. I don't know. It It is a bad

uh deal drawing most of these. This one's probably the most annoying one because this campaign has a lot of backtracking.

Yeah. And also like pivotal backtracking as well where it could be like the matter of life or death as we know for a lot of stuff with this one.

Yeah, a lot of dead locations right in the first scenario, the curtain call, there's the I forget what it is. Well, there's a lobby, then there's the

backstage,

whichever one is the center location. Oh, yeah.

Then there's the backstage doorways. Like there's a lot of places where you're just moving through because there's nothing there for you to do.

Yep. And it sucks to just only be able to move once. And obviously Unspeakable Oath, you need to to move quite a bit.

Yeah. Uh this is continuing the thread from the last one, which is the identity for this campaign is kind of just restrictions. And this is I think one of the biggest versions of this. There are alternative versions to these hidden cards. There is the gift of madness ones that exist in unspeakable oath. Uh the pity one is especially flavorful. Uh and a big shout out to that one. Um, but the other ones in the finale are not as bad as these ones. I think that these the whispers in your head are kind of just crazy for how um oppressive they are for just like the smallest card. Like sometimes, yeah, you get the can't play events and you're just holding it for the team, right? But like sometimes you are playing events and you have to solve that right now. Or the whispers in your head dread is always present. It's always kind of a thing, right? Because a few things to note about this one is it's not you can't take more you can't take more than one move action each turn. You can only move once each turn, right? So you can't even like follow someone twice with a safeguard, right?

You can only follow them once, right? Like that's where the restrictions for these things lie. And

with safeguard, right? Maybe you're doing a move on your turn and move on their turn.

Yeah. Or if you have two safeguards and three players, a move on one player's turn, a move on another player's turn, then a move on your turn. That's how you get around the whispers in your head. you can outsmart it, right?

Um

that that's just like that's what this card is doing. It's making you do some really crazy things, that is not optimal, right?

Especially cuz if they don't know and they like move twice with a safeguard and you're like, I'm only going to follow once and they're like, "What the heck? Come on." And you're like, "No, no, no. You must understand." Um when we did our blind play of this, Travis made us sleeve our decks with the same cards he sleeves his encounter cards with. So, while we knew when they initially happened, uh, like when someone just drew a hidden card, um, we had to, if we we lost track of who drew what hidden card when, we would like have, uh, some like we would lose the player advantage of knowing who had what, and that was a very fun on our blind play.

Like that. That's very cool.

Yeah. Yeah. All right, let's hop over to my next card here, which is the straight jacket. Hey, remember what I said about this whole campaign is about restrictions. Get ready cuz they're still coming. Um, this card is only in one scenario. The cards we've seen so far have been shown multiple times or in your own player deck, but this is the first one here that lives in only a single scenario, which is unspeakable oath. But I feel like if there's a co if there's a scenario that defines path to carcosa, it would be the unspeakable oath. I think that's like the defining um c scenario in the campaign. And one of the things that I think about most in that scenario, apart from a card we're going to be talking about right away that's a bit more ubiquitous, but also the straight jacket, how it's again um merging a lot of things wonderfully together in a way that is so I think unique and pivotal to Path of Carosa. As you said, the kind of the theme of this campaign is that maybe it's all in your head. Maybe we are the ones who are crazy, right? So maybe we came into the um this the sanitarium, right? Like the um Arkham Asylum on our own accord, right, to in identify something. Or maybe we were like supposed to be there the whole time. So maybe the staff are just vindictive and

they're putting us in this straight jacket. Or maybe we broke out of our straight jacket that we were supposed to be in in the first place. Why do we have a flamethrower inside of Arkham Asylum, right? Maybe we are having some sort of issue that the staff is trying to correct, right? Like that's kind of the thing that I think is really cool about this card where it's yes a treachery that creates problems, but it's also a treachery that tells a story in the scenario, but it's also a treachery that tells a story in regards to the entire campaign. And I think that's very impressive to kind of have in such a very simple card.

Yeah. Why were you in the historical society stealing stuff, right? Yep.

Um, this is a clothing and item. Can you attach hidden pocket to this? Probably not. It's not an asset.

No. Yeah, probably it's not an asset because it doesn't say Oh, no. As an asset. Put it into play as an asset that takes up a body slot and two hand slots.

I got to look what what that says exactly cuz I I I never noticed the clothing thing. A hidden pocket attached to a clothing or armor asset you control.

Yep. There's no there's nothing stopping you. I don't see there's anything stopping you. You can have an additional hand slot that can only be used to hold an elicit asset. That seems thematically appropriate. Honestly, I like it.

Um,

good card. There's three of these in the encounter deck, so that is bad.

You get rid of one and then you immediately draw another one and you're like, come on, man.

Yeah,

but the the story is great, right? You try to take off the straight jacket. Like, what are you doing? Yeah. Here it is a gun.

Yep. Um, also it's such an action task because not only do you need to spend two actions to remove it, you also have to like if you have to place something in those slots again, you have to spend the time like you get the cards back. They don't get rid of them, which is actually kind of like a really nice part of the card. But it's also kind of mean because they're tricking you to just play them again to only get them like confiscated from you again, which I think is really really neat.

Yeah. Um, I played this missin about a year or two ago and I was like, "Perfect alter fate target." And then I read the card and it says, "This card cannot leave play except for by ability below." I was like,

"Whoops."

Yeah. Uhoh. Yep. That can't alter your fate.

Straight jacket.

No, that's actually really That's a That's a a dirty little trick.

Yeah. All right, let's go to your next card here, which is

Yeah, it's Corrosion. Um, I'm surprised you didn't pick it. Maybe you did and then you uh remove it from the list after I

added it here. But it's a it's a Justin Special.

Mhm.

We don't have to go down that route. I think it's an interesting card uh in of itself. This is in multiple scenarios. It is in the very same scenario we just talked about, Unspeakable Oath. And this one actually makes you get rid of the items anyways that are in your hand or in play with a total printed resource cost of at least X where X is a shroud value. It's a tough card. Items are good. Expensive items are usually better. And if you're not careful, and you probably shouldn't be cuz it's hard to make these things work, but if you're standing on a location that is a five shroud or something or other things show up to add shroud to locations, there's like that other card in this encounter set, I believe, that every location gets plus one shroud, which is usually like nothing. But then suddenly you draw this afterwards and you're saying,

"Man, that's not fair. I wanted to discard my one cost thing and now I got to discard a twocost thing." Yep.

It's never usually two cost. It's usually four or five.

Yes. Yeah.

Yeah.

It's kind of a bad time. So, combo this with the with the one we just saw, but also in uh so this is just in I think the two scenarios in Last King and in uh Unspeakable Oath. But this idea of asset hate comes back in a different version with event hate in the finale where it tells you to discard events with the total cost of the amount of horror that's on you, which makes sense for that scenario, but it's kind of a mirror to this one. So, I think it's cool that it came back. So, that's why this is one of the ones that defines the campaign for me. Not just because it's memorable in the scenarios it shows up in and sometimes on people's birthdays, but also it it has a little bit of a thematic uh resurgence back at the end.

Yeah. And also there's the walls closing in and also in a um Unspeakable Oath, which also cares about shroud values and scales with that.

I think it's a neat little mechanical identity that exists within the campaign for it, which like the shrouds value matter. Uh because corrosion is always it's like uh it's like uh chill. It's always in the back of my mind if it's uh going to show up.

Yeah, there's no test. When I played this with uh Nathaniel Cho losing both copies of boxing gloves.

Yikes.

Yikes.

That hurts. All right, next one we got here. My number three is Descent into Madness. Hey, remember what I said about this whole campaign is about restricting you? Well, here's another example of that. I promised they were going to be there. Uh, but this one kind of merges the two identities that the campaign has for this one, which is one, horror is bad. Horror hurts. Horror is a little bit spooky in this campaign. Uh, and then this one is nothing until it's everything. People often ask why I'm not scared of uh ancient evils, but I'm scared of Descendant of Madness. Because people say you still get a turn with Descendant of Madness, but you don't get a turn with Ancient Evils. But neither does the Encounter deck, right? So like the game kind of exists in the state where you can assume that you in the encounter deck it gets one action for every three actions you get right so when you get ancient evils yes you're losing your three actions but the game is losing its one action right as well with the sentence of madness you now only have two actions to deal with or for some god forbid way you've drawn backtoback descendant of madness which has happened uh it's now you only have one action to the game's action and That's not a rate that is going to probably lead to great success. So cards like this one and then Frozen and Fear, which actually also shows up as a card in an encounter set in this one. It's actually in like a a a c a scenario set for the campaign, which is really neat when they do that. Uh those things always hurt really well.

But I think the Descendant of Madness is a great example of merging the two identities of this campaign in terms of horror and restriction in a very elegant way.

So this one is part of the encounter set with the hidden cards, right?

Yes. Yeah.

So there's two of these and four of those. Well, one of each of the hidden cards and those cost you two actions to get rid of. It's very likely that you have one of those in your hand and you draw this and now you're deciding how to actually run your turn. You just get rid of the hidden card and that's your whole turn. A lot of this game is built around three actions is like standard and also useful. Like you do something, you move, you do something else. And just shaving off one action with surge so something else bad is going to happen too is problematic. So it's a tough card. The return to version of this I think is interesting too. I think that one asks if you have a hidden card in your hand and if you do you take a which is also bad because it surges but also and you're more likely to have them in your hand in uh in that campaign but losing an action I just don't want to do that.

No, please don't.

No. It feel it feels it's it's never nice when that happens.

And this is why healing is good, right? you want to keep from that three horror threshold. And I've said that taking in the thick of it in this campaign, if you're taking mental trauma is a bit of a tough gamble because the skulls in the very first scenario scale with amount of horror on you, this card shows up right away.

Um, there's other things that care about that too. And do you really want to just have that from the get-go or do you want to find another way to get your XP?

Yep. 100%. All right. Our your number two card here is none other than

Spawn of Holly. This guy has caused me so much grief.

Um he shows up in three scenarios. So first in unspeakable oath if you're unlucky.

Mhm.

He could be part of that monster deck that

or or alternatively lucky too cuz he's probably one of the n he's tough as hell but he's also one of the nicer monsters in it. That monster deck does not freick around.

That's true. But sometimes you want those victory points just

they're they're the the real the real treasure in there.

Exactly. I like that. It's kind of a treasure deck. Okay. Um let's just look at the numbers here. Four health is demands your attention, right?

You can't just get rid of him in one action unless you have a bunch of good stuff in play or you know upgraded skills and things. So it's possible but to fight him you got to take a fouright test and that's not easy. And you know what happens in Black Stars Rise? These guys get plus one fight.

Yeah.

For probably most of the scenario, and if you're unlucky, basically the entire scenario,

it is not an easy thing to fight something that has a four or five. And with retaliate.

Mhm.

And the retaliate is not messing around. One damage and two You can try to evade, but you better successfully evade by enough to not take a anyway, which can be a problem. Um, I just think that this is a a package of yikes.

However,

the two is nice if you want to be something behind,

our our favorite card without a trait in the game

because it's a monster.

You kill him, everyone heals, too. Uh what I like about this guy is he kind of traps you. Uh where it's like one of those things where um he doesn't have hunter, right? So you could just leave him where he is. And that's why I think the little like the little twist on the evade mechanic is really neat for this guy where it's one of those things where you can evade him um get two or less you're taking a You're still getting punished for the process and then you move out. Uh, however, for some reason, this guy is one of the hardest mfers to evade. I've had multiple times where I've seen someone try to evade him and be like, I'm going to evade and move, and then they like fail the test, and they're like, oh well, um, I guess I'll evade again, and then they still fail that one, and then they somehow evade the on the third one, take a horror, but they haven't actually moved out of the location, right? Um because yeah, this guy is he's kind of um Black Stars Rise is interesting because the monsters get tougher and they like that's how like the scenario scales with you as you go.

But this guy, I mean like he's he is kind of a tank. Like five fight is a big number to overcome. Plus the token bag in this campaign does get tougher. You get an extra minus three the first time this guy shows up which is in standard anyway um in Unspeakable Oath and then you get a minus five in Black Stars Rise. So, it's you're using a lot of resources to avoid that, especially on that retaliate

to try to get to 10 to avoid the minus five. Uh, you know, that that is not easy. It's maybe your deck should be that good by scenario 7, but sometimes he shows up really early.

Yeah. And also like if you fail one of the attacks and he retaliates you, you kind of fall right into his evade trap too where like I guess I kind of have to evade him and suddenly this guy's dealt you three horror in one turn. Yeah.

So, I find the enemies in this uh campaign to be pretty chunky.

Yep.

Some of them can be tougher than others. Uh the very first enemy that you that's memorable, of course, is in the first scenario with the emissary, the royal emissary who kind of has that same retaliate business that this guy has where if you fail the attack on him, he hits you for two damage and you have the I think he's got the same stats. I think he's 442,

I think. So, yeah.

Um and he's just a bit squirly. You're like, "How do I deal with this problem without suddenly being almost dead?"

Mhm.

And this guy, I think, is a good emblematic version of that.

I agree. All right. Well, let's continue mine with another enemy here, which is the maniac, or as he's known today, what's his new name?

I had it up earlier.

He is Sear of the sign. if you have the re the rebox. Yeah. For when they've changed from lunatics to possess and all that.

Uh so this guy

uh I think like the whole um that like the possessed uh encounter set does a lot of heavy lifting in this campaign. This could also be exchanged with young psychopath. I think young psychopath is a very also a really good design to showcase um the kind of like chip damage that this set that this set brings you. Um, but I chose Maniac instead because I feel like to me he's just a bit more of what I think about in Carcosa, which is an enemy that is only a like re in reality a 331, right? But

yeah,

as we know from Inmouth chip like when you get poked by an enemy when you draw it, it's really it's just really annoying, right? However, unlike in Smmith, people don't really tech for these guys because they only show up in like what, three scenarios, I think. Um,

two maybe.

Two, maybe. Yeah, even just two. And that's how memorable they are that they're only Yeah, they're only in um Last King and Unspeakable Oath, right? Um, but that these guys are that relevant for just that whole that those two scenarios that they're in. But this guy, you draw the first one, you're like, "Ow, that sucks." You draw the second one, you're like, "Please stop hitting me." Um, and it's one of those things that he's only a 331 when you're fighting him because he has really no way to heal that horror. But if you're failing, kind of like with the Spawn of Halley, you're kind of fall right into that same evade trap that the Spawn of Halley has where you could evade this guy because if you just if you try to punch him and miss, he's going to deal you damage in the enemy phase, but if you evade him, he's going to take a damage. You were going to take a damage anyway. So, it's kind of better to evade him, but you're still just getting like slowly chipped down because of that.

Unlike Also, Young Psychopath and Maniac do a very interesting thing. And I wonder if this was on purpose or if this was just like a happy design uh kind of discovery that the players have over time. But the maniac and the young psychopath, they both do something that is very in flavor for the campaign, which is they don't want they don't want you to engage off of the person holding them. So, in Path of Carosa, you're more likely to attack into your teammates than you are in other campaigns, which means you're more likely to accidentally hurt or kill your teammates, which kind of fits into the whole flavor mechan flavor of the campaign, which is wait a minute, are we actually like the bad guys losing our mind here?

That's brilliant. Yeah. The other enemy that comes to mind that doesn't do that is the mad patient. I think it's called in unspeakable oath that makes you take a for attacking it.

Which is very very bad.

Yeah, it's very bad. Yeah. Um, yeah, that that is just a because that one spawns in locations that you need to get through and then suddenly you're like, I need to figure out a way to get rid of these guys without dying. And

it's just more chip damage like the maniac and the young psychopath have, but it's great design. It's really interesting and makes your fighters think about how they're going to deal with these problems on a replay because it's probably not uncommon for a Mark Herrian to not know that you need to tank that much horror in Unspeakable Oath in particular and everyone's like, "Well, you're the fighter, right?" And you're like, "But

yeah,

I don't want to fight all three of these things, you know, twice. That's just way too much horror for me." So, makes you really have to consider these guys as being not just an easy threat to to get rid of. Like the fights are pretty low in all of them. Of course, you take the plus three on the young spyopath, but yeah, it's making you take damage or horror for for uh engaging or fighting, so it's tough.

I think the the mad patients also do a really good job of showcasing kind of what you were talking about earlier with the dead ends. And I think this campaign is a campaign of dead ends and choke points, right?

Yes.

Like it's it's very interesting um because Unspeakable Oath has a lot of dead ends that you're just going to have to either go to to clear out or like just to progress the scenario and then a lot of choke points that you're going to have to move through that are now loaded with enemies. Both the basement halls and the patient wings, right?

Even Neko's the past has this, right? Y

where you're going to these dead ends for the most part on every floor, although some of them are connected if you are lucky.

And then there's I mean even the map that seems like it is connected all the way around, the Paris map in Phantom of Truth has a couple locations that say if you go in here then you can't leave.

Yeah.

So, um especially with the chasing around that that scenario requires, it's not as simple as it as it might look. And then Palad Mask also potentially has very narrow corridors.

Yes.

Like really narrow corridors where you're just going down one straight line for forever.

That happened to us on when we just played it this week. And it's just like Yeah. You're just straight line and you're like

we have no ways to kind of like kite these enemies. They're coming for us. Man, the more I talk about Carcosa and like the more we you could do this deep dive, it's really just like a phenomenally designed campaign. Like it doesn't have to be your favorite because everyone's different, but man, the design is just like insanely tight for this campaign.

Very tight. All right, let's go to our final ones here with your number one, which is

Black Stars Rise. It's the name of of a scenario. Yeah,

this one's interesting because it's actually not that bad of a card, but it makes you think a little bit. And I talked earlier about the combos that the game can throw at you. And Doom in this campaign works differently than usual for good and for bad. Now, in the very first scenario where this one shows up, you have a little bit of a doom clock, but it's a doom clock that is compared to how quickly can you kill the royal emissary.

So, testing this pretty difficult test, which is intellect, which by the way, we'll see in a second, you do get tested on in this uh campaign. um you could just place a deal on the current agenda and just say we've got that many fewer turns to deal with the problems and probably that's fine. Now there are other cards that care about how much doom is in play which can get out of control. There's other doom in play that uh just shows up and you have to think about that more carefully. Um but if you fail and and take four horror instead that's awful. just I mean it it can be just brutal.

Um so I picked this one because it does a few things that's interesting. It's obviously not a bad card. I'm I'm happy to take this as of course Norman Withers. I'm like sure whatever I can take this test.

Um but if you're running low on sanity and you're just going to fail this test cuz you're Mark Harrian and extra ancient evils in the scenario is not really what you want all the time.

Nope. Um, this one shows up in Phantom of Truth, but has a different version of it, too, which is why I wanted to bring it up because it has the one that removes Doom from the agenda because that one works differently in that campaign, which can be tough. Like, you sometimes are uh trying to get through those agendas as quickly as possible. And removing Doom is at the uh risk of your own like survivability or the number of clues that are on the board. you can't always evade the organist forever, so it can be bad. Um, it's not a tough card, but I think it's part of an interesting piece of uh the puzzle.

Yeah. Uh, so I think I'm actually going to transition into my card because they're from the exact same set and they represent the kind of exact same thing. And mine is Spires of Carcosa. So, same set here, which is uh this one's two ancient evils in a way. like it doesn't trigger this turn, but it's like cutting two turns away from you, but you're able to as an action investigate off of this to remove the doom from it. This one and Black Stars Rise only show up in three scenarios, uh, which is Curtain Call, which is then, uh, Phantom of Truth, and then Black Stars Rise. Fittingly enough, it's in that scenario. Thank god it is. But what that what how this works is that these scenarios, man, again, the majesty of Carcosa, they all work with Doom a little bit differently where um they're not traditional agendas, which is just like a set number of time. In current, as you said, you can defeat Big Bud Baby to reset it, right? Or alternatively, it means that Big Bud Baby, the royal emissary, is going to come out a little bit sooner, right? But then

which can be really bad

which can be very bad but you're able to still kind of reset it. Phantom of Truth there's two versions of this one and the Spires Carcosa can impact it depending on the version you're playing which is that it's a traditional Arkham Arkham scenario and fires of carrosa becomes a bigger thing but more commonly spy carcosa is just a scenario extender cuz doom and play redu increases the amount of time you have to play and then there's black stars rise which has two doom thresholds. So likewise with both Spyro's Carcosa and the card Black Stars Rise, the value of and threat of those cards can change depending on the situation you're in, which gives you as a player a lot of control while still being bodied by the scenario. And if these cards show up at the right time, like Gpire's Carcosa can sometimes just mean nothing or you need to rush to get it done. But it's the card that I think about like the most when I think about this campaign as a whole. It's like the card that to me that defines it the most just because I think it's one of the most interesting threats on a treachery and it requires a lot of focus to get it done and it still has some of that early arkham where you need to be able to use your book to get things done right because it's actually printed on the card. But there's still also a lot of power that you have a player have in terms of getting through that especially with a bigger collection. But also at the time I think it does showcases a good identity of how players dealt with threats, right? So like if this was just

like an ancient evils that showed a temporary set, we'd have a problem. But this is a treachery that is manageable with various uh classes handling it different ways. But it's also in scenarios where the doom works differently. And I think it's just again a perfect example of why Patrickosa is the way that it is.

Yeah. And this one is like man the palad mask himself because it the threat level does change depending on what location it's attached to. So the shroud value changes. So where black stars rise says it's a tough test of four. This could just be a one shroud location and you're just eating a couple actions and that's okay. But it could land on a location with a four or five shroud. And you're thinking, hm, can we just let this ride out until the agenda advances? Cuz there's not a really good way to to cheese this. You can use moonlight ritual, too. But alter fate doesn't work on this since the uh doom is on the location, not on this. So, it's kind of a tough it it it begs questions, right? Which I love that about Arkham Treacheries. have to think. It's not just press button and things happen, but you have to think about, hey, how can I um deal with this? Is it worth dealing with or not? You talk about it with the team. If you're Rex Murphy, you can succeed by two and get clues anyway, which is

pretty hype. Yeah.

Um but it's it's an interesting part for sure. And I I do like, especially in Black Stars Rise, um that it's more manageable. The other two, it really depends. it it's just you're at the mercy of where it attaches and when it comes out. It's not that you have no options, but it's it can get interesting. And the other card in the set, by the way, is um Twisted to His will, I believe. That's the one where you're taking a a willpower test that scales with the amount of doom in play, and then if you fail, you uh discard two random cards. It you draw this one first, then that one, and suddenly you're taking tests that are kind of absurd, and you're just you're losing two random cards, and that's just the way it is. But it's interesting how the uh game these encounter cards are going to combo with each other in really interesting ways.

Yep. And likewise how like in other campaigns you have a little bit more time to uh if there was a card like this card was in other campaigns like like circle undone or uh inmouth or edge of the earth where it was like uh places of the doom on your location. Investigate that location this exact card right. You have a little bit more time and space in those campaigns to move to the right location at the right time. But because everything in Carcosa is about choking you out, getting rid of your actions, getting rid of your cards, getting rid of your choices, you have less time and space to be able to move around to position in the perfect place. So, you kind of just have to hope that it works the right way. And this kind of continues as well going to corrosion as well. In a perfect world, you'd love to be on a two shroud location, but you might not have the action to get there, and you kind of just have to hope maybe I can get out of this. Okay, so I'm going to be on this three shroud location, but then ooze and filth comes out, it's a four shroud location, and now you're suddenly discarding your Cyclopian Hammer, right? Like that's like what Path of Carosa does. It It's a very um punishing treachery deck because it targets uh things that not a lot of other campaigns target.

Yeah, it's true. I'm actually really curious now to look at some of those newer campaigns, even the next one, Forgotten Age, and think about do those encounter sets combo with each other in the ways that we're seeing pretty uh I mean, this is happening in almost every encounter set. Does does it happen in those? And I feel like the answer is not as prevalent. Yeah,

I think sometimes it has happens, but something that wastes your time in Forgotten Age, for example, is um you can't explore from this location or you can't move, but it's really just the power is in that card alone. It makes you, you know, move around or something, but it's not saying, hey, if you draw this one and then this one, things become really tricky. Yeah,

it's just bad.

Yep. 100%. I'm curious to see it, too. So, when when Forgotten Age week comes, we'll definitely be doing another one of these. So you can look forward to that. But you do have three more videos for Carcosa week to look forward to as well. So you should definitely check those out. Um, and remember, watch yesterday if you didn't watch yesterday's video for the first five minutes, make sure you do that cuz I'm it's something great happens. Uh, otherwise, thanks for watching. Thanks for joining me, Daniel. Again, it's always fun to talk Arkham with you in these videos. Uh, but if you want to support the channel, you can do so by liking, comment, and subscribing. Or if you want to go above and beyond, you can join our patrons, which you find down in the video description. Uh, otherwise let us know what are cards that define Pat Carosa for you. I would love to hear them in the comments below. Thanks for watching. Have a good one. And as always, a GG's.

Progress saved