Chu Han Review with Ryan Guerra - 2 Player Trick Taking
Transcript
Miniature Market has thousands of board games at discounted prices. Click the direct link below to see all those discounted games. Long before Marvel versus DC, Messi versus Ronaldo, Android versus Apple, or even Kendrick versus Drake, there was Chu versus Han. One of history's OG rivalries. No internet beef, just swords, politics, and a lot of ambition. Basically, it was the original Clash of Clans, just with fewer gems and a lot more beheadings. Today, I'm looking at Chuhan, a two-player game that has you and your rival battling for dominance in the ashes of an empire. One of you is a ruthless general, the other a cunning politician, and both of you are probably wishing your cards were just a lot better. Designed by Tom Leman, yes, the race for the galaxy dude, Chuhan aims to deliver fast turns and clever card play in a compact 30inute package. Let me show you how it plays and I'll see you at the end with some final thoughts. Chuhan drops two players into the middle of one of China's most pivotal civil wars. You'll take on the roles of Yu or Lu Bang, the leaders of the Chu and Han clans, as you duke it out through a series of tricks until one of you hits 31 points and seizes the dynasty. Each round starts with players getting a third of the deck with the rest going into a central supply.
Whoever has fewer points goes first. The lead player may start by playing a card with a lead power followed by a set of cards. A set just being any group of the same number. After this, players take turns responding with the same number of cards but of a progressively higher value. Can't do it? Then you pass. The winner takes the trick and becomes the new lead. Tricks keep going until one player runs out of cards. that player scores up to five points based on how many cards the other player is stuck with, plus one point for each Rit token their opponent has on your turn. You can also play a single card value three or six for its unique ability, or spend a RIT token to draw two more cards. It's all about pushing your luck, reading your opponent, and playing your powers at the right time. Rounds go by quickly until someone hits 31 points and claims victory as the new head of the 3rd century BCE Chinese dynasty. The loser?
Well, maybe go try your luck founding a new empire elsewhere. I hear the Americas may have some openings. So, would I h this game off to someone else or would I choose to keep it in my collection? I know that was a stretch. Let's just get on to some pros and cons. Pros. First, some of the card abilities are definitely clever. Turning your opponent's power into your own game feels really great. Next, the historical guide in the box surprisingly detailed and very well done. If you like games that lean into theme and context like that, even if it doesn't really affect gameplay, it's a pretty awesome touch. Now, the cons. First, there really just wasn't much of a wow factor here. There's so many inventive trick takers out now, and this one felt fine. Like, honestly, it mainly reminded me of that old card game, President. You know, that one that you would play in high school study hall while pretending to do school work. Secondly, the pacing definitely can stall. a few bad draws and suddenly you're just watching your opponent play solitire while you sit there hoping for some kind of miracle. And finally, the rule book. Maybe others aren't as passionate about rule books as I am, but this matters to me a lot. For such a simple game, this should have been a breeze to learn, but this rule book was pretty rough in the 2020s with tools like chat GPT around that I just don't think there's much of an excuse for a clunky teach like this. Here's the thing. I really admire Tom Leman as a designer. Race for the Galaxy, Roll for the Galaxy, St. Petersburg, Jump Drive, The City, all solid hits. Pachuhan just doesn't land in the same league for me,
unfortunately. That being said, it might be for you. I would recommend you check this out if you like games like Scout, but maybe you want more of a two-player experience, Fox in the Forest, but would like a different theme, or even if you're into The Cat in the Box, or the card game President, or if you just want a light, fast two-player trick taker that you can travel with, this might be your gem. But if you're like me and you want a little more depth and engagement and less, I hope I don't just draw all ones, then this one's probably not going to stick. Thanks so much for watching. Being part of the Game Boy Geek has been such an awesome experience, and I really appreciate all the feedback from you guys so far. Let me know in the comments which new or upcoming games you'd love to see covered next. But for now, I'm going to hop back to an epic rivalry that's more my speed and go binge some Clash of Clans.