Fields of Arle: Tea and Trade Expansion Review (Rosenblog February 2024 Part 1)
Transcript
hello everyone and welcome to the board gaming doctor my name is Phil and I'll be your board game doctor today in this Rosen blog for February 2024 I wanted to go through some quick news take you through the expansion to fields of ARL the tea and trade expansion how it plays and my thoughts on it and then finally discuss a topic that has been on my mind which is board game recommendations for folks who enjoy some of the more classic and popular games out there right now focusing on both Rosenberg games and non Rosenberg games to recommend for the first bit of news the 10th anniversary edition of Patchwork is coming out later this year it will feature new art and the automa deck for solo play I know that through the years different editions have come out not only with new art but with rebalancing of the tiles as with the Halloween edition in particular I don't think this new 10th anniversary edition will contain the balance tiles I think they will go with the original ones but time will tell and more details are to come you can play the original Edition the the Halloween edition and the two other editions on board game arena which I believe are the Americana and the uh polish versions for what it's worth but if you don't own Patchwork physically or want to grab it for the automo deck officially then I think this 10th anniversary edition may be a good option for you in other news we've had some more information about when some of rosenberg's games are coming out this year Capstone recently announced that tangram City the Essen release of Rosenberg from last year in to plantan
nuo of course but I think this was his only solo design that was announced and released at Essen anyway this game will be shipping from Capstone and arriving in April of later this year and finally Clash of magic schools which is a reimplementation of rosenberg's Babel will be set to release in June of this year according to the publisher Yello and distributor Flat River group let's talk about te and trade the first expansion to fields of ARL this expansion was published in 2017 and designed primarily by Tito lawen there are some major changes that this expansion makes to the base game so let's briefly talk about what those changes are and then I'll conclude with some of my thoughts first this expansion adds a third player to the game to accommodate this there are additional worker placement spots and building displays that are added to the game creating more options for you to place workers at of course but also creates more of a diversity of buildings to choose from during the game there are additional spots and displays for the one to two player game to because of the additional buildings that this game comes with there are 23 buildings added to the game and just like with the base game some buildings are included in every single game like the orange buildings which have their name printed on the board that you have to play with with every game but some are randomly mixed in with the original buildings like the green buildings and so forth to create a more diverse playthrough every
game and in between games in addition as the name of the expansion implies a new resource in T is added to the game not only does t give you points at the end of the game but they can also be used to give you more powerful actions when taking an action that includes a tool tracker like the shovel pairs action for example you may discard one t to take the action as if your tool marker is one space to the right thus creating a more powerful action when you upgrade your tea to his backside the East frisan Te You may discard it to treat the tool marker as having move two spaces to the right increasing the strength further finally if you discard two East frian tea tokens you may take one action twice in a row to acquire tea additional vehicles have been added to the game in the form of ships not only can these two types of ships give you additional food during the game but also serve as spots for you to upgrade your resources with and in addition with the trading ship in particular you may pay a price that is included on the Harbor board which goes into your individual Tableau and it tells you what price to pay to gain certain resources on those trading ships you don't have to place a resource from your own Supply into the ship to flip it over or to trade for it for example you can pay three food to place te onto every spot of your trading ship and so forth and so that comes directly from the supply finally the last addition to this game
is with the ditches these are little wooden tokens that kind of look like the fences from agrica but you can take an action on the new action board to dig ditches and some buildings allow you to do so as well but this leads you to placing these wooden tokens onto your farm board in between the land spaces you start at the D line which is that starting more tile that has four Pat on it at the beginning of the game and you build out the ditches is in whichever direction from that in between these land spaces the benefit of doing so is that if you surround a land space or not completely surrounded but have at least two ditches touching a land space and if there's no building on it it becomes what is called dehydrated so it allows you to do certain things first you can keep three sheep on that tile and if there are two sheep there at the end of wintertime those sheep if you have two on them may breed as if they were in side of a stall or stable giving you that third sheep on that tile also if you take the farmer action when you get to place the farming tiles such as the uh grain or the flax tiles onto your space using a plow if the land spaces are surrounded by at least two ditches you can place two plows or two Fields with one plow instead of just one field per plow finally if you surround one of the more spaces the elongated spaces that you need to flip over for more Pete if you have two ditches touching one of
those tiles you may flip it over for free without having to take the respective actions from the worker placement board so those are the changes and now for my thoughts on the expansion as a disclaimer I've only played the expansions solo and have not discovered the three-player game yet for the base game I'm a big fan of fields of ARL first of all I like the Cozy nature of the theme in the game and although it seemingly feels like an open sandbox type of uh Point salad game meaning that whenever you you know whatever you do you will get roughly the same amount of points as another player albe it for some slight efficiency decisions during the game fields of ARL the more I play feels more like a Cutthroat game than I had previously imagined my goal is to eventually write and publish a more in-depth strategy guide to this game which I think would be beneficial to those to people in general because this game is playable for free on yucata.de the more I see gameplay from that website of high-ranked individuals The more I've come to a conclusion that there is a right way to play this game or in other words a more correct way to play this game and that some strategies are better than others I feel that the base game is somewhat close to being quote unquote solvable because there is a relative lack of variability to the game it feels more like a chess like type of game than other Euro games currently published and are out there and I feel like fields of ARL more closely resembles other Rosenberg games like or at laora and even A Feast for
Odin in my personal opinion feeling more chess-like in nature in some I felt like there was a lack of variability with the building tiles and Fields of ARL although there is a little bit of diversity there and each game can be potentially different and with my preliminary data it seemed like collecting animals and doing a more focused husbandry strategy seemed to be the most successful Avenue of play the expansion I feel tackles these two facts about fields of ARL the animal strategy being predominant as well as the lack of variability the added 23 buildings not only deal with the new components of the game but they add diversity to some of the other strategies that you may explore as you play the game that are inherent in the base game in particular there are a lot of buildings that interact with the new ditches and I think that ditches are a great way to efficiently turn over Moors as well as serve as a cheap way to have sheep reproduce as if it were a stall or stable in other words I feel like if you're trying to accomplish these things which you're normally trying to do in a base game of fields of ARL flipping over those Mor tiles to remove those negative points as well as get more Pete which you need anyway as well as creating if if you're going for the more predominant strategy of animals and building out stalls and Stables if if that is your goal then ditches are a great way to I feel like accomplish those in a more efficient and even cheaper way in The Limited play time that I've had with the expansion it it does feel like it
strengthens what is already present with having an animal- based strategy there are not only the ditches but some buildings that help you along with the strategy but I I feel like it makes it easier for all who are playing to enable that same strategy meaning there are more options for players to pursue animals you may have one player who is able to build the Stalls and the stables and you know they get the points for that but they do pay the price and the cost in resources perhaps while that Avenue is closed down for another player they may be able to pursue ditches and take that action and allow for you to reproduce animals uh sheep in particular at the same rate as the first player and so on and perhaps the third player could for example get a building that can allow you to do so so I I do feel like it opens up that strategy uh that is predominant and makes it more widely available for players but I think it does open up the floor for other strategies to pursue as well and other predominant ways to gain points I think the T resource is really fun it helps you build up to a combo play that could really put you forward in the game in my experience using the tea that you start with which is three uh resources of tea to give some actions a boost that could really benefit you through the game such as the shovel pair action creating more space early on in the game to enable ditches and spaces for your sheep to grow into uh and so on and so forth that felt really strong to
do so early on taking actions twice in a row was really fun and for example when you built up the enough resources and pulled off a double building action in the same turn denying other players those buildings and adding them to your own Tableau that felt really fun to me the weakest portion of the expansion was the Harbor Tile in ships they don't allow you to travel to other places from what I understand so you can't really uh you know diversify your vehicles and ships to be able to travel faster and getting those points and food but having a trading ship came in handy when I needed extra wood for example or needed some tea to build up to those combo plays later on in the game but other than that it didn't seem like it benefited the strategies that I pursued and that I had internalized from playing the base game perhaps in a three-player game like I've mentioned before where things become a little bit more Cutthroat and you need extra options to accomplish what you want to do they the ships may play more of a role as a secondary option to gaining those resources and uh when other spots on the board are taken regardless resources were tight and I felt like I couldn't quite on a solo play get into the ship business and utilize them towards my strategies on top of everything else that I had assumed would give me more points at the end of the game needless to say I do need to play this expansion more to be more familiar with the building tiles and to see how other strategies become more viable because of
those buildings however I really like the sense of variability they provide creating a diverse experience to the Casual fields of ARL players who do not go into it more competitively and just want something more variable out of the box I feel like it makes the game less solvable and more of a discovery every time which approximates how I feel about Agricola with the variable amount of cards and expansions that it has to offer and some of the other Rosenberg games boasting a more out of the boox variability like newsford for example this expansion I feel adds a lot of good things for the veteran fields of ARL player to enjoy about the game without tacking on too much complexity as well to me this is a step down from what farmers of the Moore did to agrica or frantic fiends did for caverna which entirely renovated the game and is this expansion I feel is more similar to what Norwegians did For A Feast for Odin which added minor tweaks to the game and added a few things here and there to make the game feel different yet Tighter and more of an enjoyable experience perhaps patching up some of the weaknesses from the base game in some I highly recommend this expansion to those who want first of all a three-player experience with a field with fields of ARL or who just want to explore more from this game with the additional components and modules and buildings Etc and I personally can't wait to play it more and really want to