Forestry Review - If a Tree Falls...
Transcript
Hello everybody. This is Graeme and today be looking at a game called Forestry. Now in this game, you're tasked with managing and maintaining the balance of needs for wood products through, you know, contracts you're going to be fulfilling with the health and well-being of the forest for its inhabitants and for generations to come. Now, I'm a sucker for real life themes that always have kind of bits of information and explanation of why you're doing things in this game. It just kind of makes the teach that much easier. Now, this game uses an action point allocation mechanism where you have a number of action points to spend during your turn doing kind of various actions. And each action will take a certain number of these points. You'll be cutting down trees, replanting them, processing the wood you've just cut down at factories, and fulfilling contracts. So, will this game flourish like a great oak tree, or will it be more like an annoying weed? Let's get it to the table, see how it's played, and I'll come back with my final thoughts on forestry. Here's forestry set up. There are two random contract cards placed in the three areas of the board. The green, dark green, and orange section. The rest are beside the board. The shuffled spawn cards and the shuffled task cards are placed beside the board. Each area has its own three buildings placed on it with a random HQ tile placed at the front. Wood processing tokens are placed on the board and all the harvest tokens are placed on their spots with three randomly flipped out based on the spawn deck. Clearing tokens are randomly placed in their spots as are the river tokens. Make a stack of 10 game round tokens. And finally, draw three spawn cards and place a different Forester token on each of the spaces and shuffle all the cards again. For each player, they take all their pieces and place
them on their board along with random starting contract card. This will also show you which HQ your manager starts at and which starting wood token you receive. Each player receives one wood token and money based on player order. Before the first round of the game, the top round token is revealed and its effects are applied to all players. And then reverse player order, players will place out their harvester somewhere on the board. The game is played over 10 or nine rounds for beginner or advanced games. At the start of each round, the top round token is flipped and applied to all players. Then in player order, you're going to spend your action points. At the beginning of the game, each player starts with three action points. Now, your player board is split up into different areas to track various things that you're going to be doing throughout the game. You have storage across the top and only one piece of lumber per spot, and you can open up more during the game. The development track is a way to get more actions during the game. As you progress on the reward wheel, you're going to move your token, and when it reaches or passes the zero space, move your cube to a different section to receive that reward. Buildings will be built into the game board and will offer end of game scoring. The forestry token section.
You'll be placing forestry tokens here to get a bonus when you place them and a bonus when you complete a row. The restoration area is where you'll be placing seedlings and receive reward points to advance on the reward wheel. And finally, the water structure track while you advance to increase the end of game scoring multiplier and two water structures that can be built during the game. The main game board is split into the forest area, which is in the interior, and the sawmill area, which is around the edge. The forest area is split into three sections, the green, dark green, and orange. and it's where you're going to be moving a harvester to clear trees and to plant new ones. The sawmill area is where you're going to be sending your manager to perform various actions. On your turn, you're going to be spending your action points. There are two main ways to spend them. First are the harvester actions. For an action point, you can move your harvester up to two spaces. If you cross a river, you must also pay a coin. You cannot end your movement on a space with another harvester, but you can move through them. All the other harvester actions are always done where your harvester currently is located. Next is harvesting. If a tree is on its white side, it can be harvested. The number of dots is going to be the number of action points you have to spend to fell it.
Spend the action points and collect a number of matching trees to place near storage. If there is a reward star, move your reward token that many steps. Finally, flip the tree token to its dark side. The reforestation action is the exact opposite. If the token is on the dark side, spend action points equal to the dot tiles plus a number of seedlings from your supply. If there's a star symbol, again, move your reward marker. The spent ceilings do not go back to the supply. They go on your reforestation table in the area you just reforested, and you gain that reward movement. Finally, flip the tile back over to its white side. To tend to the forest costs one action point. Take the forester token and place it in your forestry table. Each column has to have the same type of forester tile in it. Gain the reward you just covered up. If you complete a row, gain that bonus as well.
Forestry buildings are built at the corners of hex's. For one action point, one construction material, and one worker, you can place your leftmost building and replace the bonus token from the board. The last action on the forest board are the water structures. Spend one action and the appropriate materials listed on the structure to replace water token on the board next to your harvester and place the water token on your player board. So, that's all the actions in the forest area. The other place to spend your action points is in the sawmill manager actions. For one action point, you can move your managers to a different HQ. Managers only ever go HQ to HQ, never on the buildings. When you move to a new HQ, depending on how many managers there are, you're going to be getting a reward. For an action point, activate any building in the section that your manager is in. Each section will have three types of buildings. One for wood processing, where you add the appropriate wood processing tokens to a piece of wood in your storage, and each wood can have a maximum of two processing tokens below it. Resource buildings will just give you the indicated resources and contracts which will allow you to take new contracts. Instead of using a building, you can spend one action point and pay the upgrade cost to flip the building over. The upgrade cost on the bottom left of the card. Place your leftmost building on the newly upgraded card and you immediately get to use that building. From now on, whenever another opponent uses your building, you're going to receive a coin from the supply.
The last action you can do is to fulfill a contract for a single action point. Contract cards are split into single and double contracts. A single contract must be completed fully. If it is a double contract, then the top box must be done and the bottom one is optional. You cannot only fill the bottom section of a double contract. Return the required wood and processing tokens to the supply to receive the reward on the right side of the card. Tuck the card into the left side of your player board. There are a couple of free actions you can do. You can spend one coin to refresh the contracts card where your manager is. This can be done any number of times. Once per turn, you can evaluate a task card. That is, take the immediate effect of one of your task cards and discard it. Up to twice in your turn, you can spend four coins to get another action point for this turn. And finally, up to three times, you can buy new storage, pay the price, gain the reward from it, and then remove that tile. When the last game round token is flipped over, it signals the final round of the game.
Then we go into scoring. Score your buildings by seeing the highest number uncovered along that row. Next is the water structures. for your built water structures. See how many instances of the contract cards, buildings, forestry tokens, and seedling tokens match the structure you've built. Then multiply that water structure by its multiplier. Next, match up your task cards with your depicted requirement. Then look at the reference card to see how many points you get for those completed task cards. Next, the forester table is evaluated. The player with the most tokens here gets 10 points. Second gets six, and two points for third place. All of your unused resources are added up and divided by three. And finally, each wood token you have left over is a point. And the player with the most points is the winner. Let's get back to see what I thought about forestry. On to theme and components. I really enjoyed the theme in this one from kind of an educational point of view. It's nice having kind of little aides in the rule book, these green sections here, which kind of explain why you're doing the mechanisms of the game, kind of where it fits into the real life. It makes the teach a little easier when the mechanisms kind of make sense from a theme point of view. Now, it's not an overly exciting theme, but it's definitely an interesting one. The components were good as well. The art in the game and on the cards, and that's the other thing I like about the cards is again, there's a little kind of thematic tie in here why what this structure is and why you're building using the wood for this. I also like that the tree tokens actually kind of look like the trees they represent.
It's not a big thing, but it's nice these nice little touches. The rule book does a good, as it should, job of of teaching the game. So, overall, the components are nicely done. Now, on to the gameplay. The action point allowance is always an interesting mechanism to me. Many things in this game only cost one action point. Really, beyond felling and kind of replanting the trees, everything is one action point. So, is it useful to get more action points? Of course, but it doesn't feel as critical here as it does in other games where you're kind of fighting for that extra mele or extra action point. There is a nice gameplay loop if a bit repetitive in the long run. You know, getting resources to f fulfill contracts, get new contracts, and repeat. and fulfilling contracts is not overly laborious either, which means you're going to be completing several during the game, which of course gives that nice sort of um adrenaline rush. Giving up on one because maybe a juicier one comes up doesn't feel as punishing in this game as it does in others. I also like that there are several ways to get bonuses during the game and points at the end of the game. And of course, you can't get everything. You will always be doing contracts, but will you go after maybe water structures or forestry tiles or planted ceiling tokens or the buildings? They're all good avenues and you realize that you can't maximize all of them. The game does tend to drag in later stages because players naturally turns get longer and you can also do that additional purchasing of additional action points. And on your turn, you're really not invested in whether other players are doing as there's little to no interaction. About the only interaction points are when there's a particular hex you want to stop on and now their player doesn't move. And I
have seen instances where people have intentionally not moved to block other players, but it's never been a major part of the game. Beyond that, little to no interaction, and I think the game probably plays best around three. Four just makes the game kind of go on too long. The game is smooth, but really doesn't offer anything new. You've seen all the pieces before, but they do fit nicely together. Players looking for that next new exciting thing may be a little disappointed in this game in that matter anyway. So, would I recommend this game? I would. I enjoyed my plays of this one. It's not what I would call cozy, but I'd call it maybe a pleasant game. I really like the theme and kind of the theme integration they've done with the components. I enjoy the look of the game overall and the thematic touches in the rule book and on the cards. I appreciate that there seem to be many paths to victory. Although fulfilling contract is always going to be a major part, making sure you're getting the right contracts to work with your water buildings or your cards is going to be beneficial. The water buildings and the other tracks can be worth a lot of points, but it does take a lot of work to maximize that one little area, and there's lots of things you want to do, but you soon realize you can't do everything. And maybe next time you'll try something different, and that's definitely a plus for me. I like that there are asymmetrical player boards, and you can play slightly different to change up your your approach to the game, but you can still get enjoyment from just playing the base game without those. For the negatives though, I felt the downtime, especially at four players, was almost too high for me. And although the gameplay is smooth, it doesn't bring anything new to the table. And beyond the theme, it's kind
of hard to say why you'd pick this one over other games as, you know, as well as this one works. I also felt that there was a little very little tension in the game where that's where my pleasant moniker comes in. There's lots of ways to get points and you're not racing to get that last resource on the board or corner the market on oak trees. It was more that you played the game with little to no interaction just added up your points at the end of the game as it's hard to judge during the game who's leading. That's definitely a negative for me, but it may be a positive for you. Overall, I'm going to give forestry a 7.5 out of 10. I enjoyed the game and the theme did a lot of heavy lifting for that and I would happily play this again, but I do think in a year or two this one unfortunately may be forgotten. But that's it for the moment. Until next time, thanks for watching.
Hey, uh, thanks for watching another video here on the Dice Tower. Uh, we really appreciate you stopping by and checking our things out. Thanks so much for joining us today. And hey, if you really like what we're doing here at the Dice Tower, then there are different ways to support the Dice Tower. One of those ways is through Patreon. And we have links in the description to this video and we have links to lots of other things we do down there. So definitely check it out. But either way, we're glad you watched us. Tell your friends about the Dice Tower. Until next time though, I'm Tom Vassel and I hope you enjoyed this video.