Skip to main content
Loading video...

Board Games I Love But Never Want to Play Again!

Transcript 29:50

do all board games need to be forever games you know those types of games that that sit on your bookshelves and impress your friends when they come over to look at it and hit your table maybe once a week like it's some sort of religious experience maybe it's okay to buy a game with the understanding that you may only want to play it a dozen times and then maybe never again we understand that there are video games like that and certainly movies why the hell not board games gr with the fireflies is a brilliant movie but do you really want to be emotionally destroyed more than once if a game was able to provide me an immense amount of joy and a wonderful shared experience with my friends for let's say a dozen hours or so that's what I would consider a really good purchase even if I never want to play the damn thing again and that is what this list is about so I'm going to throw 10 board games at you that I think are super brilliant and that I think you should play that I'll never want to see on my table again I really hate myself for putting it on this list and and starting with this game but it's the reason I made the list Mage War is is absolutely brilliant and it's actually my top 100 and you know what it might stay there despite being on this list because I have so many awesome memories associated with it which of course was the theme of the top 100 Mage Wars is a tactical two-player pseudo miniature game where instead of Miniatures you use cards from a spell book in Mage Wars players play as battling Mages duking it out on the battlefield summoning awesome creatures casting devastating spells or just straight up turning into a werewolf and beating a living hell of your

opponent I love all the in this game seriously I think at this point right now I own like four base sets no no maybe five and all the expansions some multiples and despite all that junk the game never felt like it was too much for me it feels cool like building your spell book it feels cool finding the exact spell to use for every situation in the game and it feels cool having that spell sort of manifest into a creature and actually getting like I said to move it around and kill your opponent's creatures the damn game just drips cool and it is oozing with so much theme and everything in my opinion feels tightly balanced despite there being a proverbial ton of different Mages creatures and Magic types but I think it's that endless amount of customization that leads me to one of the reasons I don't want to play it again the game just takes so freaking long and in 3 hours I I think I'd much rather just play a real miniature game rather than a card game sort of masquerading as a miniature game seriously every miniature game I own I I think plays in less time than this game the other issue I have is that there is no element of terrain so the the map you sort of move around on it doesn't really matter that much and for a game that's sort of trying to emulate a battlefield even if it is incredibly abstract to not incorporate the terrain it's just it's a little wonky and again this is something traditional miniature gaming does beautifully and this game is just a bear to te in my top 100 I mentioned I make

everybody play this game at some point if they're my friend and while that was true for a really long time the veil has sort of been lifted from my eyes and now you know I see that maybe maybe that wasn't the best idea I would teach this game which is super complex to people whose only experience with gaming was like Ticket to Ride I was so blinded by how much I love the game that I just assumed I just assumed that they would fall in love just as hard and sadly the death of any miniature game even a pseudo miniature game is the inability to find people to play with I want to keep thinking I I'll play it again like it's still sitting in my shelves right now but now I'm starting to think I'm I'm just lying to myself you know I made this video for this exact game as a sort of Love Letter to the games that I hold so close to my heart and that I now know I have to leave I kept merchants and Marauders in my collection for years not because I'd ever play it again but because I loved looking at it and remembering all the good times with my friends that I had with this amazing game and I remembered that board games are not meant to be photos in a photo album merchants and Marauders sees players take on the role of an influential Merchant wheeling and dealing across the Caribbean or a dirty stinky pirate sinking their best friends for a few Del blums and some laughs whoever you seek go Glory the first of 10 is the winner so set sail and let's move some plastic the beautiful thing about this game is that it truly tells a story and it's one that every everyone at the table gets to share and be involved with it's not the typical

you know you sort of read a card and then concoct some sort of false narrative from the text no it's telling a story through its mechanics and the actions you take in the game and and how others respond you decide if you want to become a pirate you decide uh you know where you'll be taking your goods as a merchant you decide if you want to you know mess with your friends after you know 3 hours of investment and and and burn that friendship bridge to the bloody ground it is all within your choice and the player Powers they're they're good enough to sort of guide you down a particular path without making you feel like you're being sort of railroaded and that's sort of destroying the whole sandbox feel of the game because I think at its heart that that is what the game is it's this sort of big old golden age of pirating sandbox game that you get to play in and shed buckets and buckets of blood in and honestly isn't that what we're all looking for when we sit down with our family on a Sunday board game night and our Sunday best I think so but sadly my family can't play this with me anymore because I I I did inevitably sell it it is no longer the the piece of art on my shelves I point to and say things like hey hey Mark you remember that time I I I ruined your entire game after like 4 hours of solid investment by sinking one of your ships wasn't that amazing cave can be very emotionally taxing if you're playing with the type of people I play with or mostly if you're you're just playing with me but it's it's it's not just me my friends

and I can be a little mean and we will beat down on people with no mercy and getting killed in this game is a huge detriment that is almost sometimes impossible to come back from you know so tension can get a little high when you invested hours and hours into a game only for it to come crashing down on you and the worst part is that when that happens you probably still have another hour or so to play the game and while that gut-wrenching experience May excite me I know damn well it's it's ruining everyone else at the table emotionally and I I don't I don't want my game nights to end in everyone hating me I save that for the game of unfair that's when I let to get dirty and have everybody leave the table just just absolutely loathing me regardless it's a game worth experiencing as it really does capture the the sort of Romanticism and freedom of being a pirate taking these sort of huge risks and getting massive rewards with a wonderful variety of paths to take to victory that make each game interesting and and and thrilling like this is the type of game you want to play along with with a pirate soundtrack you know you put on Pirates of the Caribbean you know you you attack your friends and then sink the boats and just have a blast singing sea shanties and and and never ever bathing ever again have you ever laid awake at night you know sort of tormented by the vastest of the universe and marveled at your absolute insignificance when faced with with such Eternal depth and then ask yourself where the hell is Planet X anyway and and and why the hell do I give a in

the search for Planet X your were scientist tasked with attempting to locate the dark and mysterious planet by asking a variety of questions and making observations with logical deduction the more objects you're able to locate the closer you get to locating the planet and scoring a bunch of victory points for your findings at the end of the game there is a lot to like about this game and despite the fact that I'll never play it again it is a wonderfully clever game that I praise out loud every single time might play it the setup is easy and fast explaining the game is relatively quick and simple the app integrates amazingly and just it makes perfect sense every game provides me with the same fulfillment as finishing a sodoku while sitting on the and that is a beautiful thing what's cool is that the game never leaves you feeling overwhelmed most Clues you gather throughout the game typically feel somewhat connected as if you're following this like intricately crafted breadcrumb Trail and yeah you might once or twice in the game game follow the the wrong path but you'll never feel completely lost and and that's an incredibly well-designed accomplishment it's easily the best pure deduction game I've ever played a truly satisfying puzzle that I appreciate and yet I I I never want to see it again in my entire life when I sit down to play a board game I'm not sitting down to engage in pure deductive reasoning you know I'm not Sherlock Holmes okay I want to throw some dice I want to make some cool moves you know play over powered cards and and push some plastic around and and mess other people's up whenever possible

I'm not sitting down to solve a whle and then after solving you know message my friends in a group chat to see if I solved it faster than them just so I can feel better about myself I solve today's in two guesses I'd much rather play something like like crypted or awkward guested because both of those games scratch that sort of deductive reasoning itch but both are able to provide me something a bit more something more gamified like a way to interact with other people at the table uh aside from Simply listening to what they're asking you know I want I want to feel like I'm playing a board game this is kept in my collection because it's on Kim's top 10 gam she absolutely loves it you know but I make sure never to mention it again so I I don't have to play it and I hope she just kind of forgets about it and and doesn't doesn't watch this video because I'm I'm I'm a bad person and I'm selfish I don't care what Planet X is anymore I you know I found it once or twice and now now I'm done I don't I don't want to know I never never want to know I don't don't even tell me where it is because I'll I'll just ignore you remember that show with the sexy robot lady in the red dress well with the game Battlestar Galactica you get to be her and perform a series of mundane tasks all while accusing Everyone by yourself of being a less sexy killer robot in Battle Star Galactica players take on the role of their favorite TV characters each with their own unique part to play working together to keep Humanity alive they do this by solving little puzzles around the board and putting out constant fires all while trying to determine who the trader is among them Battlestar

Galactica at this point is an absolute classic it's a really really well done Cooperative game where each member feels impactful to to the overall mission everyone will usually have their task that they sort of like hyperfocus on and then once they're done everyone comes together to discuss who did their job the worst and therefore is obviously a a killer robot and you know not just an incompetent boob actually that's that's kind of what I enjoy the most about any of these sort of Trader games is the fact that there was always one person who everyone thinks is the trader but he he has to do his absolute best to convince them of the truth which is that he he he's not the trader he just sucks that happens in every Trader game I have ever played I can safely say that that there are a few other games that incorporate the theme so amazingly as Battlestar in the early days of first playing this game it it really did feel uh as if you were on the ship sort of being bombarded by by life and death events while simultaneously trying to deal with the fact that someone on your ship is a giant and is ruining everything it really captures that sort of dread and paranoia that's that slowly builds up over time as starts hitting the fan and you're left wondering you know if Mark wasn't wasn't able to kill that syon ship because of bad luck or because he's the syon and how even on the start of a game I'm having fun like there wasn't a single game where my heart didn't skip a beat just a little in excitement when I flipped over the card to see what role I'd be playing for the next you know 3 hours it's just it's fun during the game

to try to play the detective you know sort of determining you know who's pulling their weight and who seems to be actively working against the group as it is fun to sort of deceive others into thinking you're contributing uh when really you're you're sort of that like you're that guy uh on the group project who isn't doing a damn thing uh but you're still going to put your name on that bristle board and stay styland during the presentation and you get all the same marks this game is really really long and it's one hell of a time investment and and the older I get the less likely I am to play a game that's going to take three hours and so perhaps perhaps just loving it as I do Battle Star is it's not enough I need to consider the game like the second coming for it to hit to my table when I know it's going to be the only game I play for that night and battl star it it just doesn't it doesn't do it for me like that I guess over time I I stop finding the stuff you have to do on the ship particularly interesting you know whether that's as a sylon or or or one of the humans the tasks they're rather tedious and they're not they're not fully engaging um but I what I find funny is that I wouldn't suggest this is a bad game because of that it really only puts more emphasis on the fun and excitement of a hidden Trader right because if you put too much into the other mechanics you may inadvertently take away from what essentially is the heart of the the game and if you really like that Dynamic this game is a must play because it really is brilliant I'm super happy that it did at one point really excite me to play this game every single time and just spend you know

endless hours playing with friends how my friends hate the fact that I sold it but with Battle Star I I was honest with myself and I I knew that while I did love it I I just didn't want to see it on my table again you know it had its impact it was it was just time to say goodbye and um I'm not just saying that because selling the game helped me fun a down payment for a home now on to the game I've never owned because my friend makes me play it every time I go to his house the quacks of quelling BG in quacks of quelling Burg players take on the role of charlatans mixing their own secret bruise by drawing ingredients from their bag and adding it to their pot utilizing special powers and doing their best to avoid spoiling the whole mixture by drying too many bad ingredients I think qua is a wonderfully fun and engaging experience despite the relatively non-existent interaction between other players however most turns you are you are looking at other people pulling tiles from their bags in anticipation you know sort of secretly hoping they'll fail or or or openly hoping that they'll fail because because like I said at the start I am an hell I'm I'm generally in suspense on my own turn you know sort of like agonizing over over whether I should pull just just one more tile from my bag and risk going Bust or or just push it to get more victory points and money because if you bust in this game you you can't have both you you have to pick which can make for a fun little agonizing decision and there was enough variety there between games provided by the the special powers that I mentioned to make every game feel really different hell even the catch a mechanic while typically I'm I'm not a big fan of it

does work really well here and it makes you feel like you have a shot but at the same time not making the leader feel like he just had his ass handed to him by a blue shell while you may not get hit by that that blue shell you can have some bad luck and I mean I mean really bad luck having bad luck in this game just plants this like a ever growing hatred seed inside my soul that just like gets bigger and bigger with every play you start looking over at other people taking risks that that make no logical sense and just getting rewarded over and over again and meanwhile you're using your your one time potion to negate the you just pulled only to pull something else that's just as even though you have 20 other non- tiles in your bag that you could have pulled it's it's it's it's damn near furiating and the game just doesn't give me that adequate control that I like over my fate you know I'm fine with some luck I really am but give me more to feel like I'm not at the mercy of some some Alchemist luck demon just just on my very Soul just with every turn the game drives me absolutely nuts and and while funny enough I'd recommend it to people new to the Hobby I never want to play it again I never want to play it again so Mark I I know you're watching you know don't don't don't ask me to play this game again I I love it I love it I really do I just I don't want to see it again my sanity needs a break from this game because honestly I I I can't afford a therapist Bells you know inflation it's a killer now for the game that ends up in 100% of content creators

games for Halloween list that that pop up in droves every October Mansions of Madness Mansions of Madness is a fully Cooperative game of horror and mystery where players team up to explore the Haunted Mansion to collect important items solve heads scratching puzzles talk to sketchy NPCs and solve the mystery before perishing or going completely insane it really does feel like you're in this sort of haunted house uncovering a mystery and and that's an amazing feat for a board game to to to Really capture this really is one of the definitive Halloween games for a very good reason it's a thematic as hell and just a ton of fun with the right atmosphere and the right player group and what's cool is that there is enough Variety in the starter box to keep you entertained for many hours my issue with the game although I love it is that the turns themselves they're relatively simple and straightforward you know over time you you really don't feel like you're making important decisions that you know you can look back on after you failed and think man if I just would have done this this other thing instead oh we would have won you know that that would have won us the game turns typically feel pretty obvious and I think I think that type of experience at least in my opinion has a very limited shelf life it's fun while it lasts you know but but that fun won't last forever so the reason I don't want to to play this game again is the same reason I don't want to do you know the same escape room again even though there is still more content out there that I have not tried the general feeling Remains the Same from expansion to expansion it really is a brilliant game

and remember that after you've liked and subscribed to the channel donate a dollar to me every time you see it on someone's top 10 Halloween games list if if if I got a dollar for every time that appeared I I I'd be on mil in a week for sure do you remember Nations this the game that's ranked like 237 on board game geek and yet I I never hear anyone discuss this game anymore which I I think is a damn shame because it truly is one of the best Civilization games out there in Nations players take on the role of a civilization and guide them through the historical ages providing your people with food and stability while progressing economically and militarily to amaze the world through your achievements and build your heritage as the greatest nation in human history I've always been attracted to civilization style games I I just love them whether it's video games like like Civ or Age of Empires or board games like Through the Ages or mosaic I love the idea of taking this sort of like fledgling civilization and then building them up ever so slowly you know morphing them into the perfect you know economic or or military Powerhouse by picking the perfect Technologies and and making the best moves Nations lets me do that in less time than Through the Ages and for that I love it and while we are comparing the two Nations is definitely it's definitely the cuddlier version of Through the Ages Through the Ages can be very mean when you when you want it to be with an abundance of military Cards Wars skirmishes and soldiers instead Nations conflict comes primarily from the scarcity of the resources available in the game you know sometimes you want

to build that Wonder quickly but there will only be a set of number of Architects available at the start of Any Given round so in that way it becomes a a fairly tight race and while it may stress some people out I find that to be a very enjoyable experience it's funny I I actually picked this up because I was playing so much Through the Ages that I wanted a game that was similar but different you would think I'd play something that's entirely different altogether but no I wanted something a bit quicker to play in between the times that I played Through the Ages but that sort of brings me to the reason I I won't play this game again it's not Through the Ages it's it I mean I would actually recommend this game to most Gamers over Through the Ages I I really would but for me the game just hits so much harder and is so much more enjoyable than Nations even though I I I like I said I really love Nations and I'm really grateful I was able to find something that played a little shorter but in my opinion it just couldn't stand next to the the beauty and Grandeur that is Through the Ages face it you've never played Rome Wars you know it's one of those like games you've seen on in the big coffin box your local game stores and you you thought to yourself no I I don't think I want that taking up space on my bookshelf but that's that is your loss because Rune Wars is an amazing game Rune Wars is an epic board game of Conquest adventure and fantasy that sees players fighting for key territory through battle and area control where

they must gather resources raise distinct and powerful armies and lay Siege to heavily fortified cities they do all this in the race to collect 10 Dragon Stones this is like one of those epic video games like like Heroes might magic where you strap in and you get ready to play for hours and hours moving your plastic dudes around and doing just tons and tons of cool it is exactly something I would have loved to play as a child I mean I granted I would have got almost all the rules wrong but but honestly I probably get tons of rules wrong already in this game every single time I play because there are there are a lot of rules in this game to start you pick your faction and then do whatever it takes to acquire as many Dragon runes as possible whether that's you know taking over enemy territory uh setting Your Heroes on a sort of like stealth mission to fulfill Epic Quest or just manipulating key events to your advantage run Wars feels like this this weird and scary Frankenstein monster with just a sleo like Stitch together parts from other board games it it's it's an adventure game and it's a war game and it's it's it's a goddamn beautiful and it's a horrifying monstrosity everything in the game just comes together to make this sort of crazy fantasy world come alive being able to recruit the neutrals on the map is is is always a mechanic that makes me excited because it it's just Heroes of M magic the problem is this is one of those games you can really only play maybe once a year if if that and the difficulty with that is that unlike something like say Twilight Imperium the rules here are not intuitive at all and the rule book is a bloody nightmare I

have difficulty keeping that like giant to of guidelines in my head between plays uh so in order to play again I sort of have to go back and reread the whole damn thing and I just I I don't have time for that this game more than any other game truly feels like that cones of dunshire joke from Parks direct like half the time I'm explaining it to people I'm not even sure I understand what the hell I'm saying but the funny thing is that's sort of what I love for it you know I I love the fact that it's it's a bloated mess of mechanics I said this many times in this Channel that I embrace an overabundance of of rules and mechanics and things to keep track of but I I do need those mechanics and rules to be mildly intuitive you know I like being overwhelmed my choices in mechanics but I don't like pouring through one of the worst written manuals in human history maybe this was a game that I got to enjoy so much because I was younger I had a bit more energy and more time to really appreciate you know the sort of the the beauty of this mechanical monstrosity maybe I'm just Danny Glover now you know like maybe I'm just I'm too old for this regardless I have awesome memories associated with this game and while it will never be a game I recommend to almost anybody I I do still think it's an amazing game and it's a brilliant experience ever watch Scooby-Doo and thought to yourself man what if instead of using reasoning and and insan hings to solve the mystery you just used abstract paintings on cards and suppressed your urge to yell at your friends for not understanding your Clues well now you can do that in Mysterio Mysterio is an asymmetric Cooperative game where you either play as the

vengeful ghost trying to lead other players toward your killer or one of the psychics using the clues that the ghost provides them to solve the murder mystery trying to communicate to people on your team using very abstract images is it's it's a lot of fun and every one playing this game always has a good time at my table you know it's nice to have a game in your collection that's a little outside the box in regards to its mechanics and its overall theme the artwork is of course beautiful and the amount of detail in every picture is exactly what you want in a game like this the funniest moments in this game are when you hand someone that the what you think is the most obvious clue imaginable but they're looking so deeply at all the on the card that they're ignoring you know sort of like the forest from the trees and thinking that that the little object in the background is something how symbolic of of something bigger it's like it's like no Kim that's that's not even art on theard that's just a coffee stain it's frustrating but it's a hell of a lot of fun and the game does deliver on that sort of Cooperative aspect because you are encouraged to help others to try to guess their Clues when you guess right you really do feel like you've worked together and solved a pretty unique and fun puzzle the thing I really dislike about this game though is that token you place on someone else's guess when you think uh they got their guess wrong it seems counterintuitive to The Cooperative nature of the of the experience it's like the game expects you to just like jump up after someone gets it wrong and yell aha I told you you are an idiot guess better you like it's it's a weird experience and sadly now the game feels just a little

convoluted for what it is I just want to go I just want to go back to Dixit the extra bits that I have to set up and the extra components and mechanics I need to explain to new players and I I do typically just play this with newcomers it's just it's just not worth it for myself in the long run because I can have pretty similar level of fun with a much simpler game like Dixit despite all that I really do feel like this is a brilliant game that's worth owning even if it does have a limited amount of time to provide that enjoyment uh before it inevitably dies and then leaves you colorful Clues as to who killed it do you like The History Channel do you do you like battle do you like gluing hundreds upon hundreds of tiny little stickers to wooden blocks well you should play command and colors ancients cuz you can do just those things and and colors ancients players face off against one another on Ancient battlefields using a unique historical war game system driven by perfectly played cards that dictate how you should move your tight formations of soldiers to battle across a wide variety of fun and historical scenarios the game has far more depth than Memoir 44 or or battlecry or battle or uh once you understand the basic card mechanics there is there's just so much more room for strategic decision- making uh that I find very satisfying you know it's my favorite of the whole bunch for sure sure plus it feels it feels more grown up you know like you're playing you're playing with silly plastic well I'm moving around wooden blocks because I'm cultured it does a brilliant job at simulating that sort of tight Rank and file of of historical battles you know I I say this like I know a damn thing about them I mean Beyond every other

dude who obviously thinks about Rome you know 10 to 12 times a day do you remember that Meme topical but it does generally feel like I'm I'm I'm a general moving around these very tightly formed battle lines and and doing my absolute best to outthink and outmaneuver my opponent and the leader cards are great because they force you to sort of keep this cohesive units under the command of the leader in order to properly you know utilize the cards the whole experience just makes the game play an empowering Endeavor where you feel like you're always provided meaningful and impactful choices where you constantly have to adapt to both what your opponent is doing and the choices in a in in movement on a given turn due to your cards now unfortunately much like the game that I started this list with CNC makes me want to play a miniature game and that you know that's no no fault to the game itself it is an amazing amazing game but every time I play it I typically think to myself like man I own a lot of shorter miniature games that I could probably be playing uh that I think simulate battle maybe a little better and I'm know I'm not saying that because I'm a plastic uh who loves painting my little army men to make guests come to my house uh and and sort of Praise me when they see my my little dudes that that I justplay in the dining room uh like the classy gentleman I am you know like when my grandparents pass I will inherit precious heirlooms when I pass my grandchilden will inherit colorful plastic men and I I think I think we know who the real winner here is and the scenarios themselves don't feel entirely unique enough for me because you know that could be because I'm coming from a miniature gaming

background where things can take a little bit more Liberty and get a bit more wild with the with the objectives that you have to complete for the match regardless I do highly highly recommend this game if you're a board gameer everyone everyone should own a copy despite the Dreadful commitment of putting on those goddamn stickers it's it's this beautiful mid-ground between miniature gaming and board gaming plus it gives you something to talk about with those weird war game freaks uh and their tiny little cardboard tokens when they start talking about like you know how cool Combat Commander Europe is you can be like well I play CNC ancients so I am also cool too I'm I'm just kidding of course none of us none of us are cool so to wrap it up you know do I regret purchasing any of these games hell no hell no every game on this list is one that provided me an incredible amount of fun albe it uh for a relatively small time frame and you know what that's perfectly okay not every game needs to last forever so that's it for today I hope you enjoyed this video hit like And subscribe and all that stuff and I'll see you in the next one bye

Progress saved