Halls of Hegra | First Impressions | My 2023 Solo Board Game of the Year Frontrunner
Transcript
hello everybody Welcome to Tully table my name is Shaggy and today I'm going to be running down my quick first impressions of Halls of hegra I've done a full playthrough on my channel so if you haven't watched that please go check it out because in this video I'm gonna assume you've either watched that play through or you know how Halls of hegra plays now I think I might have spoiled this in the thumbnail of this video but yes Halls of hegura is my current front runner for solo game of the year I still have quite a few big titles to play but for right now I've just really had a great time with this game I'm not really a war gamer and I don't really like War as a theme for a game it's just not something I'm very interested in you know you start throwing in some dragons and some robots or something and then you got my interest so typically this game would have just flown under my radar and you know completely passed me by but somehow I heard and I can't even remember where I heard this but I heard that some of the mechanisms in the game were inspired by Robinson cruso and this war of mine well okay now you've got my attention your game was inspired by what I consider to be the best solo game of all time all right I'm going to take a closer look so when this finally hit my table for the first time Robinson Crusoe was in my mind but so was another game and that game is frostpunk frostpunk is my game of the year of 2022. it's a game I absolutely adore and it was also
inspired by Robinson Crusoe and this war of mine so much so that it's almost like a spiritual successor or if Robinson Crusoe in this war of mine had a baby that you know grew up to be a city planner right that would be frostpunk so I had that in my mind and really the long and short of what I'm trying to say here is this really isn't like Robinson Crusoe or this war mine there's certainly some individual mechanisms that you can tell were you know maybe inspired like you know the suspicion track feels a lot like the noise track from this war of mine you know you have worker place man you have a morale track back you know there's these Echoes from from Robinson Crusoe but the worker placement doesn't work like Robinson crusos in fact it really reminded me more in a weird way of of an acronym it's not a perfect comparison but you know the idea of having different types of workers some of them can't do certain actions and some do certain actions even better and when you use them they get tired you have to spend resources to refresh them yeah it was giving me an anacrony kind of vibe minus all the mechs but what this doesn't have is some of the core features of those games which is you know an emphasis on storytelling right we're not getting any of that like you get in this war of mine and you're not getting sort of the scenario based gameplay and the emergent storytelling like you're getting from Robinson Crusoe Halls of hegra is trying to tell one story you are playing
through a story things are going to happen slightly differently you can choose to focus on slightly different things and there will definitely be surprises right I mean if you saw the playthrough there were things that happened in the playthrough that I hadn't seen before in other games and they added some nice narrative and they definitely affected the strategy and stuff but for the most part you're kind of playing through the same story so this game has nowhere near the variability of a game like Robinson cruso for some people that might mean that it lacks a little bit of replayability those two things aren't necessarily the same you know for me having the slightly different events come out having different collections of workers who do different things having the different modules come out drawing different stuff from the hit bag and all that adds enough for me to make it exciting and makes me want to play again and again I find the game to be pretty addictive but I think for some people that might feel like a lack of replayability and so I want to put that out there if that's something that you think might bother you then you may want to be careful of that for this game I'd tend to not be someone who you know plays a game 50 times in a row so it's not a concern for me the other thing to note is that this isn't a traditional war game right this is much more of a Euro game with uh worker placement and bag building and ultimately a really fun Tower Defense core to the game you're managing resources and you're managing your workers and their morale it all
comes together and works together really great but my favorite thing about the game by far is just the way that it really ratchets up the tension you know you start in that mobilization phase you're getting some more workers you're building up and then boom once that first attack starts suddenly you have more things to worry about you have more difficult decisions you can't do everything you want to do you're doing a little bit of push your luck then as soon as those sieges start happening man it gets tough the tension just skyrockets things start going wrong and you really start hanging on on holding on as best as you can I find this game to be extremely difficult survival is tough it has one of those endings where it's just about really trying to hang on right just trying to wait out the clock as everything is just falling apart not everyone is gonna like that kind of Arc right it's got that survival Arc and that's something that I really love it's the same thing that you have in those other survival games that we keep talking about I enjoy that immensely and there's definitely luck involved you're rolling dice a lot you're pulling things out of a bag you know it doesn't matter how much good stuff you seed into those bags sometimes you're just pulling out the bad things and you're just getting unlucky that sort of stuff's gonna happen I never felt like it was unfair you'll have good luck and bad luck it seems to even out overall you know you're gonna have easier games or harder games depending on how things go but to me that just adds to the tension adds to
the excitement and again I never it never felt under Fair there's just one little tiny exception to that and that is when you're drawing from that recruit bag there's a bit of a push your luck mechanism involved in that but honestly it's just possible to just get super unlucky and at the very beginning of the game just draw one of those doubt tokens and the difference between getting just one new recruit and four new recruits right there at the beginning is pretty drastic that can be a pretty big swing of luck and it doesn't feel that great I do kind of wish that that recruit bag was handled a little bit differently my personal opinion and look I'm not a game designer so me throwing out game design ideas is completely meaningless but I would have liked it to have been something a little bit more like we always draw four tokens out of the bag but sometimes you might draw those doubt tokens you know you would just toss those away so it means like you're recruiting less because of those doubt that would probably feel a little bit more fair because then you would usually be drawing at least two to four maybe have more doubt tokens in there at the beginning and then when you draw them you actually get to discard them so it doesn't feel so bad to you draw you know the fact that you draw one okay I'm only gonna get one recruit this time and then I gotta put the doubt back in the bag it's just it feels pretty punishing at times and that feels real swingy especially early in the game but other
than that I love the idea of building the bag up especially the hit bag throwing in Miss tokens in there right having the decision to attack the airport so you can get rid of some of those tokens that are going to be filling up that hit bag in this playthrough I completely ignore those planes and you saw in part three what happened those things are incredibly punishing but then the fact that you can take out the Cannons so that you're drawing fewer chits out of that hit bag those are great decisions and I love the idea that when you repair some of the damage from you know the guns or the walls or whatever it goes into the hitback so you might draw back out and those things might get re-damaged that is really cool it just works so well and I also love sending out your workers onto that map to do the Supply runs how the weather can change their movement and how you can attack the different patrols or you can try to sneak goodbye to you know grab the stuff and bring it back to get your supplies that you desperately need oh man it's just a blast I think this is the type of game that could really appeal to a lot of Gamers I mean if you like work replacement games or if you like Tower Defense games or maybe you're into traditional war games and you want something a little bit different even if you're not a solo gamer I think this could really be a game for you know Gamers who don't typically play solo this might be a solo game that really appeals to them and if you are a solo
gamer then you really gotta check this one out it is long keep that in mind it's long and you know there's a lot going on but I think the rule book is terrific everything makes sense everything flows just perfectly so I really hope that this gets the attention that it deserves and I'm trying to do my part but check out Halls of hegra it gets my highest recommendation that's it for me thank you so much for watching and goodbye