Bonfire - Do you like Stefan Feld's Board Games?
Transcript
one of stefan feld's newest games bonfire what we think of it coming up
hi it's tyrone and stella from nipple university welcome to our should you play video where we let you know the overview and what you think of the game and then you decide for yourself whether this game is for you or not now today we are going to talk about bonfire this is not brand brand new but this is one of the newest one as 2020s online release i think from uh from pegasus spieler and stefan phelps seven fell which is a very famous designer and you all probably have played one of his schemes once in the past yes so what is it about count so this is this is the this is the board setup and it's got kind of a i'm not certain what the lore of this game is but it's got kind of a druidic sort of feel oh um can you explain what it is we're creating we're creating pathways and gateways and bonfires essentially we've got uh spaces here for bonfires which will be these tiles when we get them and flip them over we've got portals that will go into these slots we've got a path that will come around the outside and ultimately if i grab one of these here so there's the there's the gated gate there's a bonfire this gnome goes off to the higher council when you complete that and this is a guardian and the guardians will move around and ultimately a lot of your points come from lining up
everything in this row here so you get points for the bonfire you get points for a guardian being on this gate you get points for the portal and you get points if the path crystal matches the bonfire what i've shown here is not allowed because you have to well firstly i put the wrong shape in by mistake where's the match this one's the right shape it's so sad it fit it just wasn't there yeah um so that one's the right shape you also have to produce the paths from left to right but produce the portals from right to left so there's a portable path there's a couple things i didn't show there just to just to simplify that side of it so that's what you're trying to do um in a classic stefan feld way it's got an interesting action selection mechanic yeah it probably bears the most similarities to amerigo there's elements of it that remind me of amerigo and carpe diem a little bit as well it's got a it's got a carpe diem element to it not in the action selection but i think you know in the resources it reminds me of that um so what will happen is each player has this board starts with a tile in the middle and each time you're out of tiles or down to only one action tile because these are the action tiles here you take one of the top two from your board so each player has a fully uh separate version of this you take one of these you add it to your
board in whatever configuration you want and then you gain action tiles you have to use this you place in at least one or orthogonal side and so here i would be gaining one red action so i place this one here i get a red action a blue action and a a brown action but where you line up multiple icons in a cluster you get extra tiles so this one gives me one red and one brown but it gives me two of the ships because you line up the ships ships there yeah and i'd have to then spend these on their actions and when i was down to either one or zero i could come back and place another one and let's say i took this one this time i could there's a couple of ways i could put it i could put it here without the theft of shape i would get a bonus for covering that gold if i put that there or i could put it down here and now i would get one of the pale blue guardian actions i would get two of the brown and three of the ship card actions and three of the ship actions and so these give you all the different types of action tiles there's also question marks which serve as wild and then when on your next subsequent sets of turns you'll spend one or more of these at a time
in order to do its associated action with the number of action points or with the strength according to the number of tiles you spend so the ship action for example this is very merry goey that's that's probably what reminds me of it the most but you can spend one of these to move your ship and start anywhere but then you can move your ship along one path to another island or you can spend two to move it along two oops i forgot to put bonfires there sorry that's all right or you can spend three to move anywhere on the board when you spend the green one which is to buy the paths that go around the outside of your board your first three parts will cost one your second three parts will cost two tokens from here so that's where you're buying these path tiles to to build them around the outside um what else can you do you can gain guardians so you know we spoke about the guardians ending up on these paths there are four other different colors of guardians that you can go and get from the islands when you're at those islands spending this one yep and you can spend those guardians to move them around the path it's a way of getting resources as well as advancing towards points and well while in here you can get bonfire surrender these ones to get a task i mean yeah a task here which is one of these uh you have to pay uh you have to pay some resources to get
them so you would pay the resource on the island and the resource on one of your offering tiles you start with some at the start as well yep speaking about resources down on its uncomplete side and then when you can incomplete is an actual word and then when you complete that you get to flip it over and you score the points for it for some reason uh we we were missing one type of resource which is the clams actually yeah the shells didn't come in so these are these are the the wooden resources here we did have to substitute something for the shells that's not a it's not a widespread issue it's my understanding i looked to see if that was common but i think we just uh just missed the bag for us yeah that's right um so what else we doing we're building the paths we're getting the tasks which we can complete so there's lots of different tasks out here you can it's the purple one i think rotates the great bonfire and so you rotate this one two or anywhere and then take two of the three bonuses you can get a gate a resource or an action tile or some points potentially um there are these cards here so these ones will give you some level up abilities they make you make your other actions stronger these ones are worth immediate victory points and you'll tend to get them towards the end of the game that's the idea anyway yep i didn't get it last time i got a few of them yeah that's good that's what you want
and then on your turn if you if you do meet what is required on the task then you can flip that over and not only does it trigger these points but it lets you put one of your little meeples into the higher council which gives you a bonus action or some bonus resources you can't go into a into a high council space more than once so it forces you to diversify and really that's the game it it goes through in this process and you're trying to be efficient because it's actually a relatively short game all things easy yeah you don't get to the point of having achieved everything you want to because once i think it's in two players once there's seven total meeples in this area so seven total tasks completed uh i think it's 10 and then 13 depending on your player count that triggers the start of the end of the game yeah and each player has seven potential task spots so if only in a two player game there's four you're only going to feel half of these yeah even slightly less because these guys count and they yeah mechanism once the end is triggered and this is a you don't see this that often but it's got quite a countdown so there'll be five rounds left once the end is triggered and you work your way down and at any point you can pass to get points but essentially at the end of the game you are trying to line up your final
turn yeah and as we said before you get all your points by having guardians bonfires gates and crystals all in the same line so really your last action is likely to be getting a bunch of these guardian tokens together doing the last move of your guardians and slotting them into online major major actions yeah which still wasn't enough for me at the end anyway you had a couple yeah i think you needed one more bonfire because the bonfire the guardians are worth a lot more points if they're around the other yeah the other end so that's that's probably a more detailed summary than than most but there's a few things going on here but ultimately it comes down to finding tasks that that work with each other or that work with the strategy you're doing getting them into the appropriate slots getting enough guardians and moving them around to unlock the points because that's where 60 70 of your points will come from i think yeah it's not quite that much i might have been about half of my points right i can't remember exactly the points bonfire is like campfire right but one one much better much bigger much bigger tends to be more of a celebratory um or uh i guess rituals sort of i guess so we watched a movie recently right and with the bonfire like people just throwing stuff in the series that we just started to watch yeah it tends to be a celebratory or ritual sort of thing all right what was
that oh how to get away with murder we just started yeah interesting anyways this is not review about the movie the video about bonfire yep so what do you what do you think of the game um compared to the amerigo i think amerigo is slightly i don't know from the start this seems a little bit more complex complicated than america i think it is a little bit complex in america as well uh they were like more complex than uh carpe diem yeah so i do like this mechanics reminder of carpe diem you take tiles you put it somewhere and you get bonus maybe maybe not i think um for us i haven't actually played all of stephen feld game i haven't played for them trijanum and there's another one that i haven't played oh oracle yeah and then i think there's one more that is more recent than this even or even coming out there is a brand new one which we don't have yet yeah yeah so for a seven felt game this is i think it's kind of like okay not the best but not not not bad either for compared to carpe diem i like happy dmv the simplicity and the straightforward action but also this one um what i like about it i say earlier which is this area um action although i'm not really that good at tetris and special rotation i think this fine i still find it interesting um and i got a card that lets me get the tiles before i finish the tile which means that i can essentially get a more
efficient action and spend you know more action tiles and get more things yeah so yeah so this um there's a lot a few interconnecting actions that i think is pretty good to um as i make you think and then okay which one i need to do first you have hey i have to definitely plan your action first a few steps ahead which is i'm not really that good at and i think i fell at that part and i didn't really count backwards properly and then i was short of action so i i think it was it was not bad it's not like wow it's it's okay for me how about you yeah um there was an element which reminded me of carpe diem as well which was the scarcity of resources because you start the game with with six i think six of these resources and it's one of each type you actually find as the game goes on it's quite difficult to get oh yes new resources and you know that's not what you're used to in euros you're used to being able to get big chunks of um big chunks of resources there's actually there's only really a couple of ways of getting them which is bonuses on when you move guardians and bonuses from the great bonfire actually i ended up with a few resources i wasn't able to manage my resources efficiency efficiently actually yeah and i guess that's a big part of the game as well you don't want to
uh spend time gaining resources yeah i spend at least a lot of time there yeah um you spend resources when you gain tasks and when you gain these cards so it's not the game is much more about the action tile economy than it is about the resource economy that's actually true that said i did a lot of actions that just got me lots of the wilds so i didn't have to think that hard about it oh that's not good well okay um uh just quickly add i'm saying that compared to other steps seven fields game so i'm actually putting the standard higher than usual so compared to just a normal game it's actually higher than the first standard does that make sense so it's actually a fun game like there's nothing wrong with that um i'll play it again for me i found it when you com when you compare it with some of those other games i found it very independent i'm working from my own set of fake tiles here i'm building my own little grid here and what was going on out here wasn't that competitive because there's a guardian for everyone there's a gate for everyone um the paths yeah sometimes it gave you the resource you wanted really the most competitive uh you know interdependently competitive part was these cards and particularly these cards they ended up being the game is actually very restrictive until you have some of these known cards
and these are actually quite powerful they let you break quite restrictive rules like and we've got one here which is spending a wild action as two action tiles this one lets you move your boat further so that's quite handy uh this one you get three benefits instead of two when you move this bonfire i had one which i think was it was the cornerstone of my strategy in the end which was you can place more than one worker of your color on one of these spaces in a minute oh that's good it meant that i was able to just keep loading people into here which was a useful um it gave me resources that meant i didn't have to find other ways of chasing resources whereas usually you can only go to each of these once and they give you sort of a nuanced action so i went a little bit off i guess i went a little bit off the point there but i found i wasn't really watching what you were doing very much at all and i like yeah i like to have a bit more interaction even if i'm building my own engine i like the draft to be to have some tension to it or to be more um maybe in a higher play account because we only play two players though in the lockdown thing so we've only played two players have you played with more than two players let us know in the comments as well because maybe it would be you know it might be a different experience right
and i suppose the other thing i felt was ultimately so many of your points come from guardian and bonfire that there was you didn't really i'm not going to go so far as to say there's only one pathway to victory but there's one but there's one very specific thing that everyone has to do well actually you won you didn't even have this properly done while i tried to well try my best not doing it very well at the end to start filling up the gauge remember yeah and then start getting this but then the position of this in the middle was just not right i have to do it one by one from right to left and i keep having to you know reach out a little bit further that was the other thing i got one of these cards that let me put them in any order and that let me just um yeah that's really good let me bypass a whole big part of this and that's where these you know if i were we didn't really figure that out until we played it but definitely if i were teaching i was i would say that you know these these are going to drive your game because these take something that is very restrictive and prescriptive and gives you the flexibility and you realize that during the game does that mean that it's your fault i lost i'm kidding i'm kidding never never your fault um so yeah look overall it doesn't it didn't hit the it didn't hit what i wanted out of this sort of game um so very nice it was it was okay for me it was an
interesting mind puzzle but it felt way too solitary for me right right that's fair enough who knows maybe we'll one day we'll play three players or four players and then it i can see that it would be tighter with a rotation with the boat movement with the draft but yeah i did not invest on this and for me at the end i was trying to gun it for this but then it's just not enough action i wish i did even this is an interesting part the um the countdown it's it gives you it gives everyone a fair chance to catch up and play to make the last set of things that one that part i like that part i like and the tile placement part i like this this part is necessary yeah i think if you had a if you had a game that ended instantly um the whole game would be about who can get the guardians in at exactly the right time yeah whereas this it basically gives you a countdown to like there's no reason in five rounds that you can't get the guardians where you need them to be unless you've uh stuff up your used all of your guardian actions yeah so i think it's necessary but i also think it takes some of the tension out of the end game trigger i see because once one of these what certain numbers of meeples are out an angular trigger now i would prefer to yeah yeah it's necessary the game wouldn't work if you didn't have this opportunity to
close up your engine um yeah but it means that the end game trigger isn't the tense part of the game isn't as tense a part of the game is it i was like oh somebody you have to like watch out everybody see who's going to end it and then you're going to have to all like like get it from like right now right now run yeah because you know because you get a handful a point like if you if you've got everything set up and you finish three rounds early you get three points yeah in a game where 50 is the winning score that's true so that's it so have you played bonfire have you played other stefan phelps game um do you recommend any to us let us know in the comments anything else aaron um i think if the if there's one other thing i'll say about this game there are a lot of icons it's that's half of the half of the rule book is what does this card mean what does that task mean uh it does make your first game uh you know you get the the gist of it pretty quickly but it makes the first game very information overload as well all right so that's just something to watch out for when you first play it it's not a yeah it's not a bad thing we're all used to having a lot of icons and being able to interpret what they mean but there is a lot when you first play it it is um it's language independent though true this which is a good thing uh yeah so let us know again what you think of it in the comments it's not like newly released i'm sure a lot of people have played this
um and let us know maybe your strategy maybe i can be tan as well i keep losing to taryn the last couple games so you know and i thought you were and i thought you were going to win because you had the whole path set up i think ultimately when it comes down to it it was you were one bonfire short i was one by yeah i was like just right like right you got a bonfire there which would have been six points plus the bonfire score plus the gate um possibly plus the path if it had matched one of these is worth a lot of and didn't have like even a cheap this much like this much resources no i have like like a lot of resources yeah and they don't worth a lot of points i think yeah they're pretty weak at the end yeah like this it's unused i should have like maybe i played the tiles too often and to get resources i can't remember where i got the resources you would have got them from your path because every time a guardian stops on a space you get uh resources i've got the one that gives me double the resources as well you get two of those right i have two others two of them now i have to like two of those and then i because of that i keep oh yeah that's what happened i keeps letting them stop rather than advancing where they need to be yeah because of the resources which meant which meant you would have spent a couple of actions there that could have been spent on a task yeah or like getting the bonfire and then do this or something like that yeah so sad rematch rematch pretty much
no maybe maybe yeah yes all right everybody thanks for watching that and uh yeah again let us know in the comments or um if you want to recommend to us and hopefully if you find this useful it will be very helpful if you hit that like button and subscribe to us if you haven't already done so we do this type of video should you play but we also do other types like how to play teach you how to play games my short and sweet video which is only a few minutes i usually try to make it fun i've got a collection of costume over there and i've got what else we have applied through and we do live literal or weekend and thursday evening usa so hopefully you can join join us in our adventure and then meet other cool people in the chat in the live playthrough and so on and i'm also on instagram uh find me there as well hopefully we will see you next time