The Hobbit: There And Back Again Review - We've Had 1 LOTR Game Yes, But What About Seconds?
Transcript
Hello everyone. I'm Tally. This is Farrell and we're bored of it. And today we're going to be reviewing The Hobbit. There and back again, which is a semi campaign chapter-driven roll and right for one to four players.
Exactly. So it takes you through the story of The Hobbit. And each scenario is going to be something different that happens in that book, something exciting, and you're going to be rolling dice and kind of drawing lines and shapes. Yeah. Exactly. So, it lives up to the name. So, before we get into how to play and what we think, please note this was a review copy sent by the publisher.
the Hobbit there and back again being a rollite. You're of course going to roll dice and then use whatever comes on those dice to input onto your map or board or whatever you have in front of you. So in this case, you have eight scenarios in this book and each one is going to be a kind of unique combination of mechanics. Although mostly you will have the same core mechanisms. For example, the most common way you'll play is you're going to roll all the white dice and then players are going to draft those dice one at a time and basically use whatever is on the dice they drafted. Some will let you mark off things on your board. Some will let you take tokens, but most are going to let you draw lines on your map because a lot of the scenarios have you connecting things by drawing lines a little bit like railroad ink in some ways, except you're trying to get things from here to there and do it the most efficiently. I guess other scenarios will have you playing Tetris in a sense where you roll a 12-sided die, the number will relate to a shape, and you'll put that shape in your grid. you'll be trying to enclose spaces. Uh, and then there's all kind of other different things, but generally the way the game works is that it's a bit point salady that you get points from a variety of different things in each scenario. And so you're kind of competing with the other players uh in some sense who does things first because you get some small points, but also
who's maxing out what essentially as you draft these dice. And there'll kind of always be an end condition, which is when one player does all this or one player reaches the end of the map first by drawing their lines or so on. If you've played a rolling right before, you'll know what to expect here. There's not really any surprises to this. It's in some sense by the numbers. You're drafting dice. You're using the input. You could say the twist here would be that it's chapter specific. So you get eight different maps or conditions and each one have their own little things. But they, as I was saying in the explanation, they fall into two categories. One that's kind of Tetris, one that's
drawing lines and maps and a race to the end essentially. But what I do really like about it and I would say to me it's unique selling point is this pushpull because the games will end if you we take the ones where you're drawing the lines and kind of making a map across the the board you have in front of you. There's this end condition that when a player gets to the end point, the game ends immediately. But what you can do is you can wallow and kind of accumulate a lot of points by maxing out certain point conditions, which obviously means then you're not moving as far. So there becomes this interesting pushpull of is one player kind of wallowing and getting a lot of points but not going for the end. is another player pushing straight for the end and trying to end it early and balancing what you should do when because it can very much be it can be very tough when you get points cut out from you because someone's ended it one turn early.
So I just really like that lowlevel tension that was always present in the game and made you kind of want to look over the table at what other players were doing.
Yeah, I totally agree. That would be the highlight here for me. the individual games in themselves, I still found them very interesting in terms of the puzzles that they give you and then the different routes that you could go down in different routes of scoring,
but it wasn't um how to say there are different things that you could try out and lean into with regards to scoring, but it wasn't so much that you could go back again and do something completely different.
Yeah. So, you're still going to be trying to draw the right paths and use the dice in the right way.
Maybe you lean into this type of scoring over that type, but you still need to be doing a little bit of everything, I would say.
So, yeah, really, really enjoyed it. Enjoyed each of the different puzzles individually. Agree with you that the main highlight would be this pushpull of when to end it. I think I was usually the one who was
going to end it. Yeah, it's very interesting the different ways that we did approach that because actually you were winning a lot more when you didn't push to end it, but I was trying to go fast and get some of the points that you can
Yeah. You were kind of smashing and grabbed as you went along and hoping to cut it off before I really got going.
Yes, exactly. And there are certain points that you only one player gets if they kind of get their first say. So I was sort of
and you got those a lot of time to go after that. But yeah, the detriment was you managed to lean into some of the scoring a little bit more than me. But it was always a very interesting decision as to should I push a hook forward and try to be the first or not. So yeah, and it's very cute, wholesome gang, I would say.
Yeah, as you can see, it has kind of a a big production. So it's actually probably one of the biggest boxes we have for a roll and right because you have these booklets basically that are dry erase. Um, all Yeah. So, the production is really nice. I think the thing where it lands for me is it's almost very middle of the road because
yeah, there's not so many sharp edges over other rolling rights. And I also think the fact that it's scenario based is is fun in one sense, but also to me it harms it long term in the other because
like you either I think would play it through from the beginning.
Like I don't think any of these stood out enough for me to be like, "Oh, let's play scenario again."
One again. Yeah.
And I think that hurts it because then you've seen all it has to offer. Like you say, there's not so much different you can do. Yeah,
each time if you go back to them.
Uh, so I'd make it more one that I would say definitely play it if you have the chance, but then I think we would end up giving it to a friend or something. I don't think
yeah,
it has anything that would make it stay in our collection over the other roll and rights we have.
Especially I think again a great production, but the size of the box really hurts it cuz who wants a roll and right this big?
Yeah, it's actually pretty heavy as well. We like to take right
and I think speaking on that the other biggest roller ride we have is Hrien's Wall which is a complex game and we like complex games. So then it's fine that that's big.
Yeah.
Because it's very complex but this is you know it's reminiscent in many ways of Railroad Inc. or something like that with
drawing the paths or mind space with the Tetris element.
Yeah.
So, yeah. So, no, it's a really nice grab bag. If if the theme and the production are speaking to you, then you can't you won't go wrong with it. But I just don't think it's exciting enough for us to really recommend it essentially.
Yeah.
H over anything else.
Yeah. Yeah. Any final thoughts?
How do you feel about it as a big LOTR fan? Uh, well, I was never actually really a fan of The Hobbit. I think I've read it two or three times and I always found it really boring to read.
Uh, and then they dragged out the movies way too long. So,
it's kind of like the poisoned part of Lord of the Rings for me.
Okay.
But in in that sense, it's fun to relive the scenarios and I think they incorporate them in
in interesting ways and like funny ways.
Yeah.
But yeah, I mean, if you're a fan, then there it's not that you'd be annoyed by the element. No,
but yeah,
fair.
Yeah. All right. Thank you.
So, yeah, that's our review of The Hobbit. There and back again.
Let us know if you have any thoughts on this game. Please consider subscribing if you found it helpful. And we'll see you next time. Thanks for watching. Bye.